Kalplata Vivek

SR No.: 032756
Original Sutra Author: N/A
Author: Murari Lal Nagar, Harishankar Shastry
Publisher: L D Indology Ahmedabad
Publication Year: 1968
Total Pages: 550
Language: Hindi, Sanskrit
Classification: Book_Devnagari
File Size: 15 MB

Page 87

sreyan vi udhanusistatva! purve Kita-yuge yatha 1/" Here, the superiority of one who is praised is what is to be proved (sadhya), the reason (hctu) is, "being instructed by the vrddhas," the example (dislanla) is "people of Kita-yuga in the past." (p. 72, 1. 9) Wben the relation of sadhya and sadhana is welknown, the mere mention of the dpstanta may justify the conclusion (sadhja), for the sodhya and sadhana are suggested. But when this relation is not welknown the use of the example (drstanta) alone results in Neyartha dosa. The ill. is (p. 71, 1. 23): Bharatas tvam Dilipas tvam tvam evailah Pururavah / tvam eva vira Pradyumnas tvam eva Nararahanah 1/2 Here the conclusion that a particular king possesses certain qualities is not possible simply on account of the example. Hence it has Neyartha-dosa, (x) (p. 72, 1, 14) Bhamaba's enumeration of dosas contains 'Dustam also- 'pratijna.hetu-dislanta-hinam dustam ca ne spate' 3 Therefore he gives illustrations of dusta-fada, dustartha, dusta-vakya and dusta.vaku artha. (p. 72, 1. 14) According to Viveka B. K. L. v. 62 mentions two dosas; (a) by the word 'unpleasant (ahtdya) Padartha.dosa is meant and (b) by the word 'heart-rending' (asunirbhedam). Pada.dosa is meant. The ill. is (p. 72, 1. 16): prajanana-sresthi-varistha.bhubro churo 'rcitanghreh pithu-kirti.dhisnya / ahighna-padmasya jalari.dhamnas tavaiva nanyasya sutasya vittam// 5 In this verse the first half illustrates unplesantness (ahtdyatva) and the second illustrates heart-rending (asu.nirbheda) phraseology. . 1. यत्र दृष्टान्तमात्रेण व्यज्येते साध्यसाधने। तमाहुः शुद्ध दृष्टान्तं तन्मात्रानिष्कृतेः (यथा)॥ B, K, L. V. 58. 2. (ibid) V. 59. According to Viveka this is a counter illustration of JGTEFA and suffers from Italy (for contrary interpretation cf. 3. 2. P. 126. Prof. Tatacharya takes this to be the ill. of J428-a). Acc. to Viveka, B. K. L. V. 60, which comes after this ill. suggests that faulty expressions are employed by those who are chary of giving details. The remarks are taken to be satirical (5964 & 1-P. 72, 1, 12) 3. B. K. L. 1V. 2 Also sfasiegetragta gas a gola l'B. K. L. V. 1. 4. Etagfave That Stade #18 #PAT 97 fat areRi 31 11 (ibid) V. 62. 5, (ibid) V. 63.