Sanatan Jain Dharm

Author(s): Champat Rai Jain
Publisher: Champat Rai Jain
Catalog link: https://jainqq.org/explore/010829/1

Page #1
Printer Srilai Jain Jain Siddhant Prakashak Press, Bishwakosh Lane, BaghBazar, Calcutta.

Page #2
zrIvItarAgAya nama / sanAtanajainadharma athavA jainadharmakI prAcInanAke jvalanta pramANa / mUla lekhaka aura prakAzakazrImAn campatarAyajI jaina variSTara-eTa-lA, hrdoii| prathamAvRtti / pauSa, vIranirvANa savat 1450 / 1... 5 janavarI 19 ." { nyoTAyara ,

Page #3

Page #4
bhuumikaa| priya pAThakagaNa ! yaha hamAre parama saubhAgyakA avasara hai ki isa aitihAsika aura zAstrIya udyAnake apUrva sumanako lekara maiM Apake samata Aja upasthita hotaaii| yadyapi meM na koI prasiddha lekhaka athavA vidvAna hI hUM, tathApi isa zAstrIya udyAna meM eka sumanakI sucAru gandhane mere hRdayameM eka abhinava ullAsa utpanna kiyA, yaha kRti ujIkI phala svarUpa hai| maiMne ise usa udyAnase cunakara dharma ke prazasta udyAnako susajita karake isako zomA vRddhi karane ke liye prayatna kiyA hai| hAM, susajita karane kI prazaMsanIya praNAlI eka dUsare viNyAta evaM svanAmadhanya vidvAn lekhakakI hai| kevala kuzala kArAgarakI kudaratI karAmAtakI khUbI dikhAnevAlA meM AzA hai, isa sumanake saurabhase zAstrIya udyAbhake rasiyA bhauroMkA mana yatheSTa lagra mugdha hogaa| isa sumanake nava vikAtase jo nUtana sugaMdhi hara ora phailegI, vizvAsa hai ki usakA vinAza aura satya tathA ahiMsA kA yatheccha pracAra hogA aura bhArata-mAtAkI punIta AtmAko divya jyoti bhrama aura zaMkAkI adhiyArI dUra kara degii| maiM nahIM samajhatA kisa sumanako nayA rUpa raMga TenemeM mujhe kahA saka saphalatA hai|

Page #5
(2) antameM maiM jainadharma ke abhyudayake kApyoM tallIna rahanevAle, hindo mAtAke gauravavaddha supUta marane parama priya bhrAtA sva. kumAra devendraprasAda jainakI pavitra AtmAkA smaraNa kiye tathApi anyavAda kI sumanAMjalo samarpaNa kiye binA nahIM raha saktA, jinakI kRpAse aneka sumana ghame ke udyAna meM thAropita aura pala vita hokara vikasita rUpameM prakaTa hue haiN| isa mumanake prakAza kA bhI bahuta kucha zreya unhI ko AtmAko prApta hai| mero AzA hai ki sabhI dhamaniSTha majana ma yatana pramANoM vAlI nirAlI pustakako eka bAra dhyAnapUraka nayA niyatA pUrvaka par3hakara mere parizramako sArthaka kreNge| 7-8-23 ] ke0 pI jaina. PANIm AVAL

Page #6
zuddhAzuddha suucii| satara azuddha vivara vicAra hogI hogA jana ko, mAnagha ko mAnapa isasa isase unakI unake tapa jo manuSya tapa manuSya devatAoMko phala devatAoM ko karIya asambhava hai masambhava hai| mAtmAkA mAtmAke karIba 2 anolog| jenIloga, bhAnavakA mAnava prAcIna haiN| prAcIna hai"

Page #7
(2) satara prANoM azuddha milA milatA nii Izvara bhAjana bhojana asambhava sambhava mAyAta Ayata praNoM kI lahara kI usa lahara ko ke varNana hai. varNana konoM dharmakI hindU dharmakI kali kIla drshaayeNge| darzAyeMge amarako amarake ki aprabala prayala samaya samayavAlI unakI atirikta, atirikta kucha varNana na kareMge, varNana kareMge kUtroM unako 41 15...

Page #8
satara zuddha azuddha zabdoM bril maa hai aura ghAyuma vAyu kama pana ina usa jAjena jo jaina hote haiM, hote haiN| hote haiM rahate haiM sAyA apane dUra nahIM dUra hI nahIM dRzya dikhalAtI dRzya bhI dikhalAtI prAradhokA prArarAdhoM kI umaphI ummako pramANika pramANita tulanA (Gifto) (Gifts ) ( boulble ) ( double ) jAghAtmA jIyAnmA joki goMki vagairaha

Page #9
pRSTha / - satara zuddha azuddha mAikA mAdde ke ziSyoMkA ziSyoMko sakapAla ekavAla tAtiyAkA aMgarejI tAtiyAkA anuvAda prakAza prakAza tatvoM meM tatvoma na zarAra apanAvazyakIya anAvazyakIya zarIra

Page #10
zrIvItarAgAya namaH / jainadharmakI praaciintaa| zrItIrthakarapraNIta mata athavA jainadharmako utpattikA viSaya pUrvI bhApAyoke vidvAnoM ke liye jinhoMne isake vikAza prati aneka manamAnI kalpanAye racI haiM, bhrama aura bhUlakA eka mukhya kAraNa rahA hai| kucha samaya pUrva yaha anumAna kiyA jAtA thA ki mAkI chaThI zatAbdI meM jaina dharma bauddha dharmako zAgvAsapane prasphuTita huA thA aura bhAratIya inihAsameM bhI jo hamAre skUloM meM kucha samaya pUrvataka par3hAyA jAtA thA yahI zikSA dIjAnI thI / parantu naI khojane yaha pUrNatayA pramANina kara diyA hai ki "yaha (jaina) dharma mahAmA buddha se kama se kama tIna 300 sau varSa pUrva vidyamAna thA aura Adhunika pUrvI bhApAmApI vidvAna aba isa bAta para sahamata ho gaye hai ki 23 tIrthakara bhagavAna pArzvanAtha svAmI koI kAlpanika vyakti na the yakki eka aitihAsika puruSa huye haiN|" isa pApyAke masya hone ke

Page #11
(2) hetumeM vizeSa pramANa dene kI AvazyakatA nahIM hai / kevala nimna likhita vidvAnoMke vAkya hI yaha pUrNatayA darzA deMge ki " vauddha dharma jaina dharmakA nikAsasthAna kisI prakAra nahIM ho saktA / u DA0 TI0 ke0 laDDakA kathana hai ki "varddhamAna mahAvIra svAmI se pUrva jaina samayake itihAsa kI koI vizvasanIya khoja hama nahIM kara sakte, parantu yaha nizcaya hai ki jainadharma bauddhadharma se pahalekA hai aura usako mahAvIra svAmI ke pUrva pArzvanAtha yA kisI aura tIrthakarane sthApita kiyA thA, " mahAmahopAdhyAya DA0 satIzacandra vidyAbhUSaNakA + bhI isa viSaya meM hRr3ha vizvAsa hai aura vaha likhate haiM ki yaha nizcita samajhA jA saktA hai ki -F "indrabhUti gautama jo mahAvIra svAmIke gaNadhara the aura jinhoMne unakI zikSAoMko ekatrita kiyA thA, vauddhadharma ke pracAraka gautamabuddha, aura brAhmaNa nyAyasUtroM ke racayitA . akSapAda gautamake samakAlIna the / " yorupIya vidvAnoMkI ora dRSTi DAlate huye insAiklopIDiyA * dekho DAkTara laDDU sAhavakA sapUrNa vyAkhyAna aMgrejI bhASAmeM jisako maMtrI syAdvAda mahAvidyAlaya kAzIne prakAzita kiyA hai / and + aMgarejI jainagajaTa bhAga 10 aMka 1 dekho I

Page #12
(a) aAfa rilIjana pegaDa ithiksa (bhAga 7 pRSTa 4.5) ke nimna likhita vAkyako maryopari antima sammati samajhanI caahiye| " bAvajUda usa pUrNa mata-bhedake jo una ke siddhAntomeM pAyA jAtA hai janamata va vuddhamata jo donoM apane prAramika samayoM meM brAhmaNa dharmakI mImAke bAhara the vAhya svarUpameM kucha kucha eka dUsarese milate haiN| jisake kAraNa bhAratIya lekhaka bhI unake sammadhameM kamI kabhI bhrama meM par3a gaye hai| ataeva yaha koI AzcaryakI bAta nahIM hai ki katipaya pAzcAtya vidvAnoM ne jinakA jaina dharmakA paricaya jaina sAhitya ke apUrNa dRSipAta para hI nirbhara thA svayaM sahajahI meM yaha mata sthira kara liyA ki vaha buddhamata kI zAkhA hai| lekina tavase yaha nissandeha siddha ho. gayA hai ki unakA vivara asatya hai aura jaina mata kama se kama utanA hI prAcIna hai jitanA buddhamata / myoMki buddhamatake zAstra jaina dharma kA ullekha unake prAcIna nAma "nigrantha" se eka samakAlIna vipakSI matake mamAna kara* te haiM ...... .......va unake pracAraka nAtaputra (nAta aura nAtI putra jaina matake antima tIryakara barddhamAna mahAvIrakA upanAma thA )kA varNana karate hai aura vaha jainiyoMke kathanA. nusAra 'pAvA' ko ukta tIrthakarakA nirvANakSatra calAte haiM aura dUsarI ora jainiyoM ke zAna unhIM rAjAoM ko pahA. vIrakA samakAlIna batAte haiM jo unake vipannI manake pracA.

Page #13
(4) raka vuddhake samayameM rAjya karate the| isase yaha siddha hotA hai ki mahAvIra, buddhake samakAlIna the aura anumAnataH buddha se jo unake 'pAvA' purImeM nirvANako prApta hone ke pazcAt bhI jIvita rahA, kucha pahile hue the / parantu mahAvIra buddha kI bhAMti usa matake vyavasthApaka na the jo tIrthakarake samAna unakA sammAna karatA hai aura na usamatake prAraM bhika saMcAlaka the . ...... unake pUrvake pAvaM nAmaka 23 ve tIrthakara jaina dharmako saMsthApaka kahe jAneke adhika yogya jAna par3ate hai...... ........parantu aitihAsika pramANoMke prabhAvameM hama anumAnase Age bar3hanekA sAhasa nahIM kara ske|" hama DAjona jArja vyuhalara C. 1. EL L.B. Ph.D. kA bhI pramANa dete haiM jo apanI 'di jainsa' nAmaka pustaka pRSTha 22-23 para likhate haiM ki "vauddhadharmAvalambI svataH hI jainiyoMke tIrthakarasaMbandhI kathanakI puSTi karate haiM / prAcIna aitihAsika vyAkhyAeM va zilAlekha bhI buddhako mRtyuko pazcAtako prathama pAMca zatAbdiyoMmeM jaina dharmako svatantratAko siddha karate haiM aura zilAlekhoMmeM kucha aise haiM jo jaina purANoMko kevala kapola kalpita gaDhante ( Fraud ) honeke kalajhase hI mukka nahIM kara dete haiM varan unakI satyatAke dRDha sAkSI haiN|" aba isa viSayapara kevala eka dUsare vidvAna, mejara

Page #14
jenaraja je. jI. prAra0 phAralAMga, epha-Ara-esa-I, epha prAra-e-esa ema0 e0 AI ityAdi ko sammati 'korTa sTaDIja ina di sAhanata mAfa kampareTiu relIjansa' ke pRSTa 243244 se udhRta karanA hI paryApta hogii| " anumAnataH IsA pUrvake 1400 me 800 varSa taka balki amAta samayase sarva UparI, pazcimIya, uttarIya madhyamArata, tRrAniyoMkA, jo mAvazyaktAnusAra drAviTa kahalAne the aura jo vRtta, sarpa aura liMgakI pUjA karate the, zAsana thA / ......parantu usa hI samaya meM marca parI bhAratameM paka prAcIna sabhya, dArzanika aura vizeSatayA natika sadAcAra va kaThina tapasyAvAlA dharma arthAt jainadharma bhI vidyamAna thaa| jisameM spaSTatayA brAhmaNa aura bauddhadharmAka prAraMbhika saMnyAsa bhAvoMkI utpatti huii|" "Aryoke gaMgA kyA sarasvatI taka pahu~cane ke bhI bahuna samaya pUrva jainI apane 22 voDoM saMtoM athavA tIrya kareM dvArA jo IsAse pUrva kI 8 vI vI zatAdIke aitihAsika 2veM tIrthaMkara zrIpAzvanAthase pahile hue the, mikSA pA cuke the aura bhopArzva apane se pUrvake sada tIrthakaroMse mAra una dharmAtmA mRpiyose jo dIrgha 2 kAlAntara me huye ge, jAnakArI rakhate the aura unako bahuta se anya jo umasamayameM bhI 'pUrvo' yA purANoM arthAt prAcIna ke taura para pramiddhaye aura jo yugAntaroMse vikhyAta va vANaprasyoM ke dvArA kagaThaspa

Page #15
( 6 ) cale prAte the, mAlUma the / yaha vizeSatayA eka jana saspradAya thA jisako unake samasta bauddhoM aura vizeSakara IsA pUrvako 6 ThI zatAbdIke 24veM aura antima tIrthakara mahAvIrane jo san 568- 526 IsAke pUrva huye, hai niyamabaddha rakkhA thA / yaha tapasviyoM (sAdhu) kA mata dUrasya vaikaTriyA aura DesiyA (Baktia and Dacia ) ke brAhmaNa dhaura vauddha dharmo meM jArI rahA jaise hamArI sTaDI na0 ? aura saikaDa vuksa Apha di IsTa bhAga 22 aura 4, (Smady I and S. Books E. Vols xxII & SLV) se jJAta hotA hai / " ajaina lekhakoMkI, jo prathamake 22 tIrthakaroM ko aitihAsika puruSa nahIM mAnate haiM, uparyukta sammatiyA isa vAtako pUrNa taura se nizcaya kara detI haiM ki jainadharma kamase kama 2800 varSase saMsArameM pracalita hai, arthAt mahAtmA buddha se 300 varSa pUrva se / isase yaha siddha hotA hai ki jainadharma kisI prakAra vauddha dharmakI zAkhA nahIM kahA jA saktA / aba ina ukta siddha kI huI vAtoM se yaha prazna avazya hosaktA hai ki 'zrAyA jainadharmakA nikAsasthAna hindUdharma hai yA nahIM ?" kucha vartamAna lekhakagaNa isa dharmakA, brAhmaNa dharmase usakI varNavyavasthA ke virodha meM putrIrUpase sthApita honA mAnate haiM (dekho di hArTa Apha jainijma pRSTha 5) / . yaha sammati isa vicAra ke pradhAra para hai ki Rgvedako; mAnava jAtike prArambhika zaizava kAla 'ke bhAvakA saMgraha honeke kAraNa, una saba dharmose, jinameM buddhima

Page #16
(7) tAkA adhika aMza hai, adhika prAcIna honA cAhiye / isI vAta ko mAnakara yaha kahA jAtA hai ki prAcIna dharmake virodha jaina dharma sthApita huA aura isa liye isako mUla dharma (prAcIna hindu dharma) kI uddaNDa putrI samajhanA caahiye| jisase usakI va. huta gaharI sadRzatA hai| durbhAgyavaza isa saMbaMdha koI vAhya pramANa upalabdha nahIM kyoMki na to koI prAcIna smAraka hI aura na koI aitihAsika cinha hI milate hai jo isa prazna para prakAza DAla sake / isa bAtakA nirNaya kevala svayama donoM dharmAke zA. stroMko prAtarika sAkSose, vinA kisI bAhya mahAyanAke hI kA ranA hai| ataH hama donoM dharmoka siddhAntoMkA sAtha sAtha adhya. yana kareMge jisase hama yaha jAna sake ki donoMmeM adhika prAcIna kauna hai ? prathama hindU dharmake Upara dRSTi DAlate huye usa zAstroM meM veda, brAhmaNa, upanipada aura purANa zAmila haiN| inameM veda sava se prAcIna haiN| dUsarA nambara prAcInatAmeM brAhmaNa zAstroMkA hai| usake pazcAt kramase upanipadoMkA prauH phira sabase antameM purANokA hai| sava veda bhI eka hI samayake nirmita nahIM haiN| Rgveda sabase prAcIna hai| isa prakAra hindU mata una dharmoM se hai jo samaya samaya para vRddhi va unnatiko prApta hote rahe haiN| ___ yaha vAta svayaM apanI sAkSI hai, aura isasa yaha pariNAma * jaina purANa vAstavameM jainamatakI asIma prAcInatAko siddha karate haiM, lekina cUMki vartamAna itihAsavettA sivAya itihAsika pranyoMke Ara pranthoM para avizvAsake sAtha dRSTipAta karatA hai isa kAraNa hama isa lekha meM unakA pramANa nahIM deNge| -

Page #17
(8) nikalatA hai ki hindU dharma jaisA zrAja hai vaisA sadaiva nahIM rahA aura yaha spaSTa hai ki usameM samaya samaya para vRddhi hotI rahI hai tAki usameM pUrNatAkA vaha dRzya AjAya jo nissandeha vedoMmeM unake pUjya maMtroMkI rahasyamayI bhASAke hote hue bhI nahIM pAyA jAtA hai| jaba yaha vicArate haiM ki vedoke samaya athavA vedoMke pUrva hindU dharmake siddhAnta ( Teachings ) kyA rahe hoMge taba vahI kaThinAI pAkara par3atI hai jisako upanipadake le. khaka bhI pUrNatayA taya nahIM kara sake kyoMki vedoM meM kisI vaizAnika athavA vyavasthita dharmakA varNana nahIM hai. sutarAM kevala devatAoMko samarpitamaMtroMkA saMgraha hai jo aba sabake saba vividha prAkRtika zaktiyoMke hI rUpaka (alaMkAra) mAne jAte haiM / brAhmaNa zAstra to svayaM hI vaijJAnika honekA dAvA nahIM karate balki ve yakSa viSayaka kriyAkANDase paripUrNa hai| aura upaniSadoMkI bAvajUda unakI dArzanika pravRtike bhI samajhane ke lie lambI va bhArI TI. kAoMkI AvazyakatA hai| aura ve aisI kathAoM Adise bhI paripUrNa haiM jaise brahmAke svayaM apanI hI kumArI putrI sadra pAse bArabAra balAtkAra sayoga karanese sRSTi utpanna honA (vRhada zrAraNyaka upaniSad 1 / 4 / 4 / SaTdarzanoM meM bhI jinameM dharma ko kAyadese taratIva denekA prayala hai eka dUsarekA khaNDana hI kiyA gayA hai| tAtparya yaha hai ki prAja bhI koI manuSya isa vAtako nahIM jAnatA ki hindU dharmakA asalI svarUpa kyA hai yadhapi IzvarazUnya sAMkhyamatAvalambI bhI vaisA hI hindU kahalAtA hai jaisA ki viSNukA bhakta yA zItalAkA upAsaka jo cecakakI devI haiM ! yAcasaMvandhI viSayameM, isameM koI

Page #18
/ saMdeha nahIM hai ki RgvedakI vAstavika pavitratAmeM pazu balidAnakA / prativAda hai aura ajamedha azvamedha gomedha aura naramegha jaise sa skAra pIchese kisI dUrasamayameM zAmila huye haiN| yaha vAta caiTika alaMkAroMke vAstavikasvarUpase sApha mAlUma hotI hai| vizeSatayA 'agni ke svarUpase, jo tapakA rUpaka hai kyoMki tapa jo manuSya va pazumedhakA pUrA virodhI hai,| aura vedoMke aise vAkya bhI jese "bhakSakagaNa santAnarahita hoN|" (dekho Rgveda 121.5) aura ve vAkya bhI jinameM rAkSasoM va mAMsabhakSakoMko zrApa diyA gayA (dekho vilakinsa hindu mAithAlojI pRSTha 27 / isa matakI pravala puSTi karate haiM / ina yajJaviSayaka veda vivaraNako pratirUpaka bhI SAntara karanekA jo ghora prayatna hinduoMne svaya pIchese kiyA hai vaha yahI darzAtA hai ki hinduoMkA hRdaya pazuvadhase kisa kadara ghRNA karatA thaa| yaha vAta aMdhakArameM hai ki yajJa saMpandhI (validAna) viSaya vedoM meM kaise milAyA gayA |haaN! kevala yaha vAta spaSTa hai ki yaha viSaya hindU dharmake yathArtha bhAvake viruddha hai| aura isaliye kisI bure prabhAvake kAraNa pIchese milA diyA gayA hai| kyoMki yaha vAta vuddhigamya nahIM hai ki koI pavitra dharma aise hiMsApUrNa aura kumAga kI ora lejAnevAle vAkyoMkA pracAra kre| isa prakAra hamArA hindU dharmakA digdarzana pUrA hotA hai jisase hamako yaha kahane kA adhikAra hai ki vicAra aura bhASA kI spaSTatA ( Precision ) kisI samayameM bhI isa dharmake

Page #19
(10) prasiddha cinha nahIM rahe haiN| bhAvArya-ki yaha vicAroM kI aspaSTatA aura gaDabaDose jo dhArmika kAvyakA mukhya cinha hai, kabhI asaMyukta nahIM rahA aura isakI jaDa eka cindarUpI mantroM ke saMgraha parahI mukhyatayA nirbhara hai, jo vyaktigata mAnI duI zaktiyoM gaNoM Adiko arpita haiM-ataH una kAlpanika devatAoMkA phaja jo bhUtakAlake Rpi kaviyoM kI mAnasika ulajhanoMmeM magana rahane vAlI kalpanA zattise utpanna huye hai| java hama jaina dharmakI ora dekhate haiM to hamako isase eka vilkula vilakSaNa vAna dikhAI par3atI hai / jaina dharma eka kevala vaijJAnika dharma hai aura prAtmA athavA jIvanake siddhAntako pUrNatayA samajhane para asarAra karatA hai| isameM samayAnukUla parivartana na honese yaha hamako apane prAcIna rUpameM milanA hai / yadyapi gata 1800 sau varpomeM isakI sAmAjika vyavasthAmeM kucha matabheda avazya hogayA hai; parantu isake siddhAntoMmeM na to koI pAvazyaka dAta milAI gaI hai aura na koI vAna ghaTAI hI gaI hai jainadharma kI apUrva pUrNatAko samajhaneke liye yaha Avazyaka hai ki isake siddhAntoMkA varNana saMkSepase kiyA jAya / / jaina dharma batAtA hai ki prAtmAkA mukhya uddezya parama sukha arthAt paramAtmApanakI avasthAkA prApta karatA hai yadyapi AtmA pratyeka avasthAmeM isa uddezase abhikSa nahIM rahatA hai| jaina dharma yaha aura bhI batalAtA hai ki AtmA apanI hI kRtise isa paramapadako pA sakA hai, kabhI kisI dUsarekI kRpA

Page #20
(11) yA dayAse nhiiN| isakA mukhya kAraNa yaha hai ki siddhAtmA(paramAsmA kA sarvocca pada AtmAkA hI nija satyasvarUpa hai| jisako vaha azuddha athavA apUrNa avasthA meM vividha karmoka baMdhanoMke kAraNa prakaTa nahIM kara sakatA hai| yaha karma vividha prakArakI zaktiyAM haiM jinakI utpatti AtmA aura mAI ( pudagala) ke melase hotI hai aura jo kevala svayam AtmAkI hI kRtiyoMse nAza bhI kI jA sakatI hai| jaba taka AtmA apane satya svabhAvase anabhijJa rahatA hai taba taka vaha apanA svAbhAvika svarUpa aura sukhako prApta karanekA prayatna nahIM kara saktA hai| ataH AtmAke svabhAva aura anya padArthokA aura una zaktiyokA jJAna jo prAtmAke svAbhAvika guNoM ko ghAta karatI haiM karmoke baMdhanase chuTakArA pAneke liye nitAMta Avazyaka hai| vaha yathArtha athavA satya jJAna hai jo sAta niyamoM yA tatvoM ke satya zraddhAnase utpanna hotA hai| jisakI, AtmA ko usake sukha-sthAna athavA muktidhAmameM pahuMcAneko, AvazyakatA hai| aura isa samyak jJAnake sAtha sAtha samyakcAritra arthAt Thoka mArgapara calanekI bhI nitAMta AvazyakatA hai| jisase karma baMdhanokA nAza hokara saMsArake AvAgamana athavA janma maraNa ke duHkhase nivRtti mile| isa prakAra sAmAnya ronise jaina dharmakI yaha uparyukta zikSA hai| aura yaha pratyakSa hai ki yaha sarva zikSA laDI rUpameM hai jo kAraNa kArya ke siddhAnta para nirbhara hai| athavA yaha eka pUrNa

Page #21
(12) vaijJAnika darzana hai aura isa khalAkI sabase bar3I bAta yaha hai ki isameMse eka kaDIkA nikalanA bhI vinA kulakI kula lar3I ke tor3aneke asambhava hai ataH yaha siddha hotA hai ki jaina dharma koI aisA dharma nahIM hai jisako samayake anusAra sudhAroM athavA unnati prAdikI zrAvazyaktA ho| kyoMki jo prArambhase hI apUrNa hotA hai kevala vaha ho anubhava dvArA unnati pA sakkA vaidika samayake hindadharmako dekhanese hama jaina dharmake sadRza kramavaddha pUrNatA na to RgvedameM hI aura na avazepa tInoM vedoMmeM hI pAte haiM / jinake racayitA kevala agni. indra, sadRza kathA naka devatAoMkI prazaMsA karake santuSTa ho gaye haiN| sutarAM punajanmakA siddhAnta hI jo satya dharmakA mukhya aGga hai vedoMke kathAnakoMmeM kaThinatAse milatA hai aura jaisA ki yorupIya vidvAnoMkA kahanA hai vedoM meM kevala eka sthAnapara hI usakA ullekha pAyA hai, jahAM 'zrAtmAkA jala vanaspatimeM sthAnAMtara hone kA varNana isa prakAra hama sivAya isake apanI aura koI sammati sthira nahIM kara sakte haiM ki prArambhika hindUdharmakA artha yadi usake bAhya (sthUla ) bhAvameM lagAyA jAve to vaha jaina dharmase usI prakAra mitratA rakhatA hai jisa prakAra ki do asahaza aura ninna vastueM rakhatI haiM aura vedoMko jaina dharma kA nikAsasthAna kahanA asambhava ho jAtA hai| yathArthameM vAstavikatA

Page #22
( 13 ) isake bilakula viruddha hai kyoMki yadi hama isa khyAlako dilase nikAla deM ki veda IzvarakRta haiM aura kisI prakAra unake alaMkRta maMtroMmeM chipe huye siddhAntoM ko samajha sake to hama hindU dharmakI guma rahasyamayI zikSAko AsAnIse eka bAharI nikAsa se nikalate huye dekha sake haiM yaha vAta pahile hI siddha ho cukI hai ki na to nirvANakA mahAna uddeza aura na bhAvAgavanakA siddhAnta jisameM karmakA niyama bhI zAmila hai prArambhika hiMdU zAstroM me unako sthUla dRSTise par3hane para pAye jAte haiM / aura yadi yaha niyama vedoMke kathAnakoMmeMse nikAle bhI jA sakeM to bhI unakA varNana vedoMmeM usa vaijJAnika DhaMga para nahIM milatA hai jaisA ki jainazAstroM meM / isa lihAja se prArambhakA hindU mata vauddha matase sadRzatA rakhatA hai jo AvAgamanake siddhAnta aura karma ke filsapheke usUlako to mAnatA hai parantu baMdha aura punarjanmakA varNana usa vaijJAnika taraha para nahIM karatA hai jisa prakAra ki jainamatameM kiyA gayA hai| ina vAtoMse jo artha nikalatA hai vaha pratyakSa hai aura spaSTatayA usakA bhAva yaha ThaharatA hai ki karma, vyAvAgamana aura mokSake siddhAnta hinduoM yA vauddha dArzanikoMne nahIM daryAta kiye the aura na vaha unako kisI sarvana yAnI sarvajJAnI guru yA Izvarake dvArA prApta huye the / isa yukti ( viSaya ) kI zreSThatAko samajhaneke liye yaha yAda rakhanA Avazyaka hai ki karma siddhAnta ruhAnI philsaphe (adhyAmilAna) kA eka bahuta ThIka aura vaijJAnika prakAza hai aura

Page #23
1 ( 14 ) yaha ki vaha jIva aura pudgala [ mAdde ] ke saMyoga ke niyamoM aura kAraNoM para nirbhara haiM jinameMse ekakA abhAva bhI usakI sattAko vilkula naSTa kara dene ke liye kAphI hai kyoMki yaha asambhava hai ki kisI niSedharUpI sattAko kisI prakAra - vAMdhA jA sake aura yaha bhI asambhava hai ki kisI anitya padArthako kalpita, sattA na rakhanevAlI jaMjIroMse bAMdha skeN| vauddha mata AtmAkI sattA ( nityatA ) kA virodhI hai aura - karmoke vandhanakA kisI dravyake AdhAra para honA nahIM mAnatA hai jaba ki prArambhika hindu dharma Atmika pUrNatAke vijJAnake viSaya meM kucha nahIM batAtA hai| yaha vAkya svataH apane bhAvoMko pragaTa karate haiM aura isa vicArakA virodha karate haiM ki jainiyoM ne apane vistRta siddhAnta ko inameMse kisIse liyA ho / yaha bhI saMbhava nahIM hai ki hama aisA kaheM ki jainiyoMne hindu proMke yA kisI aura matake siddhAntoM ke AdhAra para apanI praNAlI sthApita kii| isa kisma ke vicAroMkA pUrNatayA khaNDana insA iklopIDiyA oNpha riz2ojana ainDa pathiksa bhAga 7 sAta pRSTha 472 se uddhRta nimna likhita vAkyoMse hotA hai - SC aba eka praznakA uttara denA zrAvazyakIya hai jo dhyAna pUrvaka paThana karanevAle pratyekake manameM paidA hogA yAnI karma phalAsphIkA siddhAnta jaisA ki Upara usakA varNana kiyA gayA hai jainamatakA prArambhika aura mukhya aMza hai yA nahI ? yaha pratyakSameM itanA gUr3ha aura vanAvaTI jAna par3atA hai

Page #24
(15) ki dila isa ghAtake mAnane para tatpara ho jAtA hai ki yaha eka aisA phalsaphA hai jisako kisI aise prArambhika matake Upara, jisameM saba padArthoMmeM jAna mAnI gaI ho aura jo saba prakArake jIvoMkI rakSA karanepara tulA huA ho, pIchese gar3ha kara lagA diyA gayA ho| parantu aisA vicAra isa vAtase viruddhatAmeM par3egA ki yaha karma siddhAnta agara pUrNatayA vistArapUrvaka nahIM, to bhI vizepatayA apane mukhya svarUpameM purAnese purAne zAstromeM upalabdha hai aura unameM jo bhAva dikhalAye gaye haiM unake uddezya meM pahile hI se sammilita hai| aura na hama yaha anumAna kara sakate hai ki karma siddhAntake viSayameM zAstra prArambhika "kAlake pazcAtko dArzanika unnati ko pragaTa karate hai| isa kAraName ki zrAstrava, savara aura nirjarA Adike yathArtha bhAva isI mAnImeM samajhe jA sakate hai ki karma eka prakArakA sUkSma mAddA hai jo prAtmAmeM AtA hai ( Astra) usakA AnA rokA jA saktA hai arthAt usake Aneke dvAre baMda kiye jA sakte haiM ( savara ) aura jo karmokA mAhA pAtmAmeM sammilita hai vaha usase alaga kiyA jA saktA hai (nirjarA ) jaina loga ina paribhASAoMkA artha zabdArthameM lagAte haiM aura inakA prayoga mokSasiddhAntake samajhAnemeM karate haiM (AsravoMkA saMvara aura nirjarA mokSake kAraNa haiN|) aba yaha paribhASAyeM itanI hI purAnI haiM jitanA

Page #25
(16) ki jaina mata, kyoMki vauddhamata vAloMne jaina matase nihAyata sArthaka zabda prAsravako le liyA hai vaha usakA prayoga karIva usI mAnoMmeM karate haiM jaisA ki jainI log| parantu usake zabdArthameM nahIM, kyoMki vaha karma ko sUkSma mAhA nahIM mAnate haiM aura AtmA kI sattAko nahIM mAnate jisameM karmokA pAstava ho sake / saMvarake sthAna para ve asavakkhaya ( prAsravakSaya ) arthAt prAstravakA nAza, kA vyavahAra karate haiM jisako vaha maga (mArga ) batAte haiN| yaha pratyakSa hai ki unake yahAM Asravake zabdArthakA lopa ho gayA hai aura isa liye unhoMne isa paribhApAko kisI aise matase liyA hogA ki jisameM usake zabdArtha kAyama the| arthAt anya zabdoMmeM, jainiyoMse / bauddha saMvara zabdakA bhI prayoga karate haiM jaise zIla-saMvara (sadAcArake vamojiva apane mana vacana kAyako kAbU meM rakhanA) aura kriyA rUpameM saMvuta arthAt 'vazameM rakkhA ' kA prayoga karate haiM jo aise zabda haiM jinakA brAhmaNa lekhakoM ne isa arthame istemAla nahIM kiyA hai, aura isa kAraNa anumAnataH jaina matase liye gaye haiM jahAM vaha apane zabdArthameM pUrNatayA apane bhAva ko pragaTa karate haiN| isa prakAra eka hI yuti isa vAtake puSTa karaneke liye upayogI hai ki jainiyoMkA karma siddhAnta unake matakA AvazyakIya aura akhaNDa aMza hai| aura sAthahImeM isa bAtake sAvita karaneke liye bhI ki jaina mata, vauddha matake prArambhame bahuta jyAdA prAcIna hai|

Page #26
( 17 ) jaba hama hindU matako ora isa vAtake jAMcaneke liye dRSTi: pAta karate haiM ki cAyA karma siddhAnta hindu RpiyoMkI khoja kA natIjA hai to hamako usakA eka anizcita aura apUrNa bhAva hindU dharma ke prAraMbhika zAstrameM milatA hai| pariNAma yahAM bhI vahI nikalatA hai arthAt yaha karmasiddhAnta hinduoMne kisI anya dharmase liyA hai, kyoki yadi vaha hindU RSiyokI mehanata kA phala hotA to vaha apane racayitAoM ke hAthoMmeM bhI apane usI vaijJAnika DhaMga para hotA jaisA ki vaha niHsandeha jaina matame pAyA jAtA hai| karma, bandhana, mukti aura nirvANa ke svarUpa kyA hai, yaha eka aisA viSaya hai jisakI strita hinduoke vicAra bahuta ho viruddha aura avaijJAnika pAye jAte hai| vAstava meM athava saMbara nijarA aise meM se haiM jinase brAhmaNokA mata karIba karIva vilkula hI anamina hai bAvajUda upaniSadoM ke lekhakoM kI vuddhamattA ke jinhoMne apane pUrvajoMka dharmako dArzanika vicAroMkI puSTa nIva para AdhArita karane kI koziza kI / pasa ! jo pariNAma nikAlaneke aba hama adhikArI haiM vaha yaha hai ki hindU matane aise forest kisI anya nikAsa se prApta kiyA hai jisa ko zrama bAja loga usIkI kRti mAnate hai / dUsarA prazna yaha hai ki hiMduoone karmaka siddhAMtako kahAM ne prApta kiyA? vauddhoMse to nahIM, kyoki bauddhamata pIcheko kAyama huA / taba sivAya jainamata ke aura anya kisI majadavase nahIM, jo AvAgamanake mAnanevAle dharmo meM aura sabase prAcIna dharma hai aura 2

Page #27
jo isa mamaleko vaijJAnika Dhaga para sikhAnevAlA akelA hii| dharma hai| yaha yuktiyAM isa asatya khyAlako dUra karadetI haiM ki jaina mata hiMdU matakI putrI hai, paraMtu cUMki beTokI utpattike vicAra se bahuta prakAza isa vyAkhyA para par3a sakatA hai isaliye saba hama vidhi anukUla veToMke nikAsakI khoja lgaayeNge| vartamAna khojane vedoMko usa kAlake mAnisaka bhAvokA sagraha mAnA hai jaba ki manuSya-vaccepanakI dazAmeM podgalika camatkA. rose bhayabhIta rahatA thA aura saba prakArako prAkRtika zaktiyoM ko devI devatA mAnakara unake prasanna karane ke liye daMDavat karatA thA parantu usa samayakI hindU sabhyatAse, jo svayaM vedoMko prA. ntarika sAkSIse spaSTa hai yaha khyAla jhUThA ThaharatA hai, kyoMki pavitra mantroke racayitA kisI mAne meM bhI prAraMbhika apakka vRddhi vAle manuSya yA jaGgalo na the aura unake bAre meM yaha nahIM kahA jA sakatA hai ki vaha agni aura anya prAkRtika zaktiyoke samakSa AzcaryavAn aura bhayabhIta hokara daDavat karate the| eka yopiyana lekhakake anusAra: 'pAryokA deza aneka vibhinna jAtiyAMkA nivAsasthAna thA ora bahutase prAMtoM meM baMTA thaa| veTome vahutase rAjAoM ke nAma likhe haiM. .. .. purapati, zaharoMke hAkimoM cakledAroM, jamIMdArokA jikra hai| ........suvasadhArI liyoM aura acche bane huye vastroMkA ullekha hai| ina havAloMse

Page #28
( 16 ) 'aura aurole jinameM maNi mANikakA jikra hai yaha natIjA nikAlA jA saktA hai ki usa samayameM bhI zArIrika AbhU. 'ghaNoMkI aura adhika dhyAna diyA jAtA thaa| vastra manumAnataH rUI aura unake vanAe jAte the, aura ve karIba 2 isI prakArake the jaise vartamAna kAla meM haiN| pagaDIkA ullekha hai| suI aura tAgekA varNana isa bAtakA sUcaka hai ke sile hue kapaDe nAmAlUma na the |.......lohese surakSita zaharo aura durgokA varNana hai .... pIne vAle mAdaka padArthokA bhI maMtro me varNana hai| karIva 2 RgvedakA eka kula maMDala somarasakI prazaMsAse bharA huA hai / madirA yA surAkA bhI vyohAra thaa| Aryoke mukhya udyama saMgrAma aura kRpi the / jo yuddha karane me sUra Thahare unhoMne dhIre 2 pratiSThA aura ucca padako prApta kiyA, aura unake mukhiyA rAjA ho gye| jinhoMne raNameM bhAga nahIM liyA vaha viza vA vaizya yA gRhastha khlaaye|" vaidika samaya hiMdU samAjakA varNana karate huye DAkTara vilsana sAhava likhate haiM: "yaha vAta ki Ayya loga kevala eka jagalomeM phiranevAlI jAti na thI bahuta spaSTa hai| unake zatruoMke bhAMti unake gAMva, zahara, aura pazuzAlAyeM thIM, aura unake pAsa bahuta tarahake yanta upayogI sAmigrI, va sukhake sAdhana, durA. cArake upakaraNa jo manuSya jAtikI ekatrita maNDaliyoM meM

Page #29
( 20 ) pAye jAte haiM, the| ve punane va kAtanekI vidhi bhA jAnata tha; jisa para ve mukhyatayA nirbhara the / ve lohele vyohArase bhI anabhijJa na the aura na lohAra, ThaThere, bar3haI va anya zilpakAroMke kaaryose| ve kulhADiyose jaGgaloke vRtta kATate the| aura apanI gAr3iyoMko sApha va cikanA karaneke liye rande kAmameM lAte the / yuddhake liye jisake vAste kabhI 2 ve zaMkhadhvani parapakatrita hote the, vevakhtara,gadA, kamAna, tIra, vI talavAra yA tabara aura cakra banAte the| unhone apane dharelU vyavahAra aura devoMkI pUjAke liye kaTore,kalse, choTevar3e camce banAye the / nAIkA udyama karanevAloMse ve bAla kaTavAte the ve bahumUlya pASANoM va javAhirAtokA upayoga karate the, kyoMki unake pAsa sonekI vAliyoM, sone ke kaTore aura javAhirAtakI mAlAyeM thiiN| unake pAsa yuddha ke liye ratha the aura sAdhAraNa vyohArake liye ghoDo tathA vailokI gAr3iyAM thiiN| unake pAsa jaGgI ghoDe the aura unake vAste sAIsa bhI the| unakI samAjameM khoje hijaDe ) bhI the| ..... *mAti 2 kI nAveM ver3e va jahAja bhI vaha loga banAte the / ve apane nivAsasthAnoMse kucha dUra dezoMmeM ghyApAra bhI kiyA karate the| kahIM 2 ina mantroM meM samudrakA bhI ullekha hai jisa taka ce anumAnataH sindha nadoke kinAre kinAre pahuMce hoMge / unameM se manuSyokI maNDaliyokA arthalAbhake liye jahAjoM para ekatrita hokara jAnA likhA hai

Page #30
(21) 'eka sAmudrika senAkI car3hAI ke bAremeM ullekha hai ki vaha ver3e . ke iva jAneke kAraNa niSphala huii|" - Aryaloga apane manovinodake liye nAcanA, gAnA tathA nATya karanA jAnate the| vedoMme mRdaMgakA bhI ullekha hai aura adharva veDhameM eka maMtra vizeSatayA mRdaMgale liye nirmita hai| aisA varNana una AryokA hai jo vedoMke nirmANa samayameM huye haiN| hama unheM asabhya tabhI kaha sakte haiM jaba hama unake guNoM kI orase, jinakI ki eka yatheSTa sUcI uparyukta donoM lekhomeM dI gaI hai, AMkha mIca leN| to phira usa baccepanakosI upAsanAkA jo agni indra zrAdi devatAokI kI jAtI thI, jinake liye Rgvedake mantra niyamita haiM, kyA abhiprAya hai ? yaha bAta akla ke viparIta hai ki aise ghaDe buddhimAn zrAdamiyoMko, jaise ki vedoMko Antaragika sAkSiyoMse hindu sAvita huye haiM, yaha mAna le kivaha akla ke bAremeM itane kamajora the ki Agako dekhakara Azcarya vAna aura bhayabhIta ho jAte the aura yaha ki unhone eka aisI prAkRtika zaktike prasannArtha, jisako vaha svayaM vaDI hI AsAnI se paidA kara sakte the, bahutase majana banA ddaale| vAta yaha hai ki vedoMke devatA prAkRtika zaktiyoM ke rUpaka nahIM hai balki jIvazI Atmika zaktiyoMke / cUki AtmAke svAbhAvika guNokA bhajanA AtmAko karmoM kI nidrAse jagAne kA eka mukhya kAragA hai| sAniye Rgvedake RSi kaviyone bahutase mantroko zrAtmaka zaktiyoke liye niyata karake bnaayaa| tAki vaha Atmika guNa

Page #31
(22) aise jIvameM jo unake arthako, samajha kara, jApa kare, pragaTa ho jaaveN| unhoMne jIvakI bahutasI kriyAo-jaise svAsocchvAsako bhI alaM-- kRta kara DAlA jaisA hama bhAge dikhaayege| magara isa savameM yaha yAta garmita hai| ki RSiyoko Atmika vidyAkA pragADha bodha thA aura yaha saba vaidika samayake AryokI uccasabhyatAke anukUla hai| parantu java ki Rgvedake mantroke banAnevAlomeM Atmika jJAnake vodhakA honA jarUrI mAnanA par3atA hai to ina Atmika jJAnakA astitva spaTa vaijJAnika DhaMga para honAbhI lAjamI mAnanA paDatA hai| lekina isa satya jJAnako hama agara jainamatameM nahIM to aura kahAM dRr3he, jo hindusthAnake aura saba matoM meM sabase prAcIna haiN| isase yaha natIjA nikalatA hai ki jaina-darzana vAstava meM Rgveda ke pavitra maMtroMkI, jinake racanevAlone jIvakI vividha kriyAo aura svAbhAvika Atmika guNoko kalpita vyaktitva (devI deva. tAoke ) rUpameM vAMdhA, nIva hai| vAkaI yaha khyAla ho sakatA hai ki lAMkhya darzana, na ki kisI dUsare matakA koI aura zAstra RgvedakI nIva hai kyoki vedoke kAlpanika vyaktigaNa eka aise vicArake AdhAra para haiM jo yathArthameM sAMkhya nahIM haiM to bhI vaha sAMkhyamatase itanA milatA hai ki vaha sAMkhyamatase bahuta kama viruddha hogaa| magara satya yaha hai ki vartamAnakA sAkhya darzana vedoM ke bahuta pazcAt kAlakA hai vaha vedoke pramANako mAnatA hai aura samayake lihAjase vedoMke. pahalekA nahIM ho skaa|

Page #32
(23) isaliye yaha vidita hotA hai ki sAMkhya darzaname milA huA koI aura mata rahA hogA jo gupta zikSAkI aspaSTanA ( Inddefiniteness) aura anizcitapanase bharA hogA / yaha vAta ki isa prakArakA eka mata thA jaina purANomeM pAI jAtI hai jinake kathanAnusAra anabhikSa loga jainadharmake prathama tIrthakara zrIRSabha deva bhagavAna ke samayahImeM nAnA prakArakI dharma zikSA saMmAra phailAne lage the aura svayam pUjya tIrthakarakA potA marIci nAmI jisane pariSahajayame asaphalatA prApta hone ke kAraNa apane prApa ko yoga kriyAmeM RddhiyoM siddhiyoMke hetu saMlagna kiyA thA eka aise dharmakA saMsthApaka ho gayA jo sAMkhya aura yoga darzanoke madhya darjekA thA / isa prakAra yaha jAna par3atA hai ki marIcikA sthApita dharma jo pUjya tIrthakaroke matale prAna kiye satyake aMzake AdhAra paragupta rahasavAdake DhaMgakA nirmANa kiyA gayA thA, vedoMkI alaMkRta devamAlA aura pazcAtake purANokI asalI va prArambhika buniyAda hai| isa kathanakI prabalatA ki vedoMkI kalpita devamAlA jaina matase prApta hue satyake aMza para nirdhArita hai, pratyeka vyakiko vidita ho jAyagI, jo AvAgavanake niyama aura usake prAdhArabhUta karmasiddhAntake nikAsa para vicAra karegA / yaha bAta ki yaha niyama, vedoke racayitA yA racayitAyoko *marIci RSikA nAma vaidika maMtroMke banAnevAle Rmi kaviyoMmeM RgvedameM vAkaI diyA huA hai| -

Page #33
( 24 ) mAlUma thA, Rgvedake usa vAkyase vidita hai, jisameM jIvake jala va vanaspatimeM praveza kara jAnekA varNana hai ( dekho DI0 e0 maikyanjI sAhabakA inDiyana mitha ainDa lojyanDa pRSTa 116 / aura vaidika gupta rahasyamayI zikSAke AdhArabhUta siddhAnta ke sAmAnya svarUpase bhI vidita hai| agara hama yAskake sAtha, jo vedoMke TIkAkAroMmeM bahuta prasiddha gujarA hai yadyapi vaha sabase pahilA TIkAkAra na thA, sahamata hokara yaha mAnaleM ki veToMmeM tIna baDe devatA hai, yAnI agni, jisamA sthAna pRthvI hai, vAyu, yA indra jisakA mukAma vAyu hai, aura sUrya, jisakA sthAna prAkAza hai, to yaha vAna mahajahIme samajhameM AjAyagI ki yaha devatA apane vibhinna kartavyoMke kAraNa bhinna bhinna nAmoMse prasiddha hai (dekho Dablu0 je0 klikinna sAhavakI hindU metholojI pRSTha 6) hamane indrakA asalI svarUpa 'di kI aupha noleja meM batAyA hai aura pazcAtameM usakA yahAM bhI varNana kareMge, lekina sUrya kevalajJAna athavA sarvajJatA kA cihna hai aura agnise matalava tapAgnise hai| isa prakAra vaidika RSiyoM ke tIna mukhya devatA prAtmAkI tona dazAproke cinha hai, sUrya usakI svAbhAvika divya chavikA prakAzaka hai, indra usako pudgala dravyake svAmI aura bhogatAke rUpameM darzAtA hai aura agni jo tapase utpanna hotI hai usake pApoMke bhasma karane vAle guNoMkI sUcaka hai| agnike tIna pAMva tapake tIna AdhAroM, arthAt mana, vacana aura kAyako jAhira karate haiM aura

Page #34
( 25 ), usake sAta 7 hAtha sAta prakArakI RddhiyoMke sUcaka hai| jo zarIrake sAta mukhya cakroMmeM supupti avasthAmeM par3I hai| meMr3hA jo isa devatAkA masUtra (priya ) vAhana hai, vAhya AtmAkA cihna hai ( dekho di kI aupha nAleja, adhyAya A48) jisakA validAna astI vyaktikI unnatike liye karanA hotA hai| lakaDIke takhte jinase prati paidA hotI hai vaha paulika zarIra aura dravya mana haiM jo dono mokSake, pahile masma ( AtmAse pRthak ) ho jAte haiN| cUMki AtmAke zuddha paramAtmika guNa tapasyA karanese arthAt tapake dvArA pragaTa hote haiM, isaliye agni ko devatAokA purohita kahA gaya hai jisake nimantraNa para vaha Ate hai / antataH tapAni AtmAko pUrvajoke sthAna (nirvANa kSetra) para pahuMcAtA hai jahAM vaha sadaivake liye zAnti, jJAna aura Anandako bhogatA hai| ___ devatAoM ke yuvaka purohita agnikA aisA svarUpa hai| yaha koI puruSa nahIM hai balki eka kAlpanika vyakti hai aura kAlpa"nika vyakti bhI AgakA sUcaka nahIM hai jaisA ki vedoMke yoropiyana anuvAda karanevAloMne khyAna kiyA hai valki prAtmAke karmoM ke bhasma karanevAlI agnikA jo tapazcaraNameM pragaTa hotI hai| eka yahI rUpaka isa ghAtake jAhira karaneke liye yatheSTa hai ki jisa buddhine usako janma diyA vaha prAtrAgamana aura karmake siddhAMta se jarUra jAnakArI rakhatI thI, aura yaha bAta ki isa masaleko (alaMkArakI bhASAmeM chipAkara nyAna kiyA hai isakI sUcaka

Page #35
hai ki yAnI isa zAsanika nika racanevAlene apane prApako ina zinAka gAnika Dhaga para vana karane ke yogya nahIM samajhA yA kama vajana yaha ki unko biganika daMga para khojatrane kI iccA yA vAvazyakatA na yo ima niyai nAvina hai ki unane isa siddhAMtako kisI aura jariyele prAna kiyA thA, jo jaina mata bAhara duniyA meM kahIM nahIM milatA hai| yahAM yaha bAta bhI kahane yogya hai ki hindU mata sava jaina ma aura usake nAyaka bhagavAna zrI RSamaThevajIko jinane unhoMne vingukA avatAra mAnA hai, prAcInatAko nvIkAra diyA hai aura kama umra vinddha nahIM kahA gahapurA aura nipugaNa meM zrI RSabhadevajInA barIna hai jinhoMne unake aitihAlera vyakti honeko sarakI lImAjhe para pahuMcA diyA hai aura jo unakI mA nadevI aura una pura bharanA, jina ke nAma para hindulAna bhAratavarSa nantAyA. varNana karate haiN| bhAgavata pugaga bhI para nAyarakA varNana hai aura unako jaina natakA saMsthApaka mAna hai ! isa antima ullikhita pugAke anusAra apamanyajI viSNu ke avatArAmane narve avatAra the, aura vAmana, rAma, kRSNa, buddha se, jinako bhI viprAkA avatAra mAnA hai, pahile durabhava ki gamana avatArakA jo silasinnaM pandrahAM hai, RgvedameM sTa rItine varNana hai isa liye. yaha natIjA nikalatA hai ki vaha usa mantrale jisameM unakA varNana hai. pahile hue hoMge aura

Page #36
(27) cUMki zrI RSabhadevajI vAmana autArase bhI pUrva hue haiN| isa liye vaha Rgvedake mantrase bahuta pahile samaya meM gujare hoMge / isa prakAra yaha bAta saMzayarahita hai ki veToMkI racanA vartamAna kAlameM jaina matake sthApana hone vahuta kAla ke pazcAta huii| hindu loga svabhAvataH vedoko Izvareko kRti mAnate haiM parantu usake mantrose yaha bAta apramANita pAI jAtI hai, yathArtha bhAvame satyajJAnakA prakAza dAhI tarahase hotA hai (a) yA to zrAtmA svayam mAna dvArA satyako jAna letA hai yA (ba) sarvana guru (tIrthakara ) nirvANa prAptika pahile satya sAnA dUsaro ko upadeza dene hai / veTa isa dUsarI saMjJAmeM Ate haiM kyo ki unako zruti, jisakA artha 'tunA gayA hai' hai, kahate haiM / isa liye yaha AvazyakIya huA ki hama aMsalI zruti yA zAstrake * yaha vAta ki vedoMkA bhAva gupta hai isa pramANakI satyatAme bAdhA nahIM DAlatI hai kyoMki rAmAyaNa aura mahAbhAratako padyoM aura purANoM kI bhAti vedoMke rahasyamayI kAlpanika kAjiyoM alakAroM aura kathAnakoke banAne meM, itihAsake mazahUra mArupha, vAkyAta aura ghaTanAoM kA prayoga kiyA gayA hai / jainapurANoMse yaha sAvita hai ki zrIRSabhadeva bhagavAna ora viSNu Rpi, jo vAmana avatArake nAmase prasiddha huye, isa kAraNale ki unhoMne eka daphA tapasyAse prApta huI baiMkriyika Rddhi dvArA apane zArIrako yoneke kadakA banAkara aura phira pazcAtako avizvasanIya vistAra divAkara kucha sAdhuoMkA kaSTa dUra kiyA thA, donoM aitihAsika vyakti the /

Page #37
(28) nikAzakA svarUpa daryAphta kreN| isa lilasilemeM pahilI bAta jo jAnane yogya hai vaha yaha hai ki vacana cAhe vaha kisI rUpameM ho aura cAhe vaha irAdatana bolA gayA ho yA nahIM, eka prakAra kI paudgalika kiyA (aAndolana ) hai jo mAnasika yA jAnulla (kapAya ) vRttiyoke prabhAvake ( eka prakArake ) sUkSma mAdde para par3anese paidA hotI hai| yaha kriyAyeM ( Andolana) phira bAharI havAmeM praveza karatI hai jisake dvArA vaha sunane vAloka kAna taka pahuMca jAtI hai| manakI vRttiyAM jo bacana kI utpattimeM uparyukta mukhya bhAga letI hai sUkSma Andolana hai jo prAtsAke do bhItarI zarIrome utpanna hotI hai aura jo una zarIroke abhAvame asambhava hai| isaliye jisa kisI gatmA meM paudgalika leza nahIM rahA hai usake liye vacana asambhava hai isase yaha pariNAma nikalatA hai ki zarIrahita zrAtmA arthAt sAmAnya rItile zuddha jIva, logoMse vAkya dvArA bacata vyavahAra nahIM kara saktA hai| isake atirikta cUki pudgalake vaMdhatase vAphaI rUpale mukti usI samaya mumakina hai ki jaba sva-prAtmadhyAna pUrNatAko prApta ho isaliye zuddha AtmAke liye asaMbhava hai ki vaha dusareke mAmilAtame dilacaspI le / ataH yaha nizcita hai ki yutikA nikAsa. siddhAramA, jaisA ki dharma"zAstrokA racayitA Izvara kahA jAtA hai, nahIM ho sakatA / 'yaha bAta bhI yAda rakhane yogya hai ki satya devavANI spaSTa bhAvame hI ho 'saktI hai kyoMki tIrthakara bhagavAnako satyake

Page #38
(26) chipAnekI koI AvazyakatA nahIM hai aura isa vajahase unameM yaha icchA nahIM mAnI jA saktI hai ki vaha aisI bhASAkA prayoga kareM jisake arthameM bhUla par3e arthAt jo maTakAnebAlI ho / deva. vANI bar3e pujAriyoM yA purohitoM kA rahasyamaya kaviyoM yA santoM dvArA nahIM ho saktI hai| isa viSayameM vividha matoMke zAstroMkA par3hanA yatheSTa rItise hamako isa bAta ke mApanepara vAdhya kara degA ki vaha vAkya yA hukma yA zrAjJA jo IzvarIya kahI jAtI hai kabhI 2 usI zAlake kisI dusare vAyase khaMDita ho jAtI hai aura bahudhA kisI dUsare matakI AmAse / yaha darAsla / IzvarIya preraNA nahIM hai balki kisI vicAra meM unmAdake darje naka mugdha ho jAnA hai aura isakA bheTa yaha hai ki purohita yA bhaviSyavANI kahanevAlA vyakti apane Apako rojA, dAna, bhani prAdike kAnAntarita abhyAsame eka prakArako aniyamita samAdhi avasthAmeM praveza karane kI Adata DAla letA hai jisameM usake prAtmAkI kucha zaktiyAM thoDI yA bahuta pragaTa ho jAtI haiM / loinako IzvarIya prakAzakA cinha samajha lene haiM aura saba prakArako vAhiyAta dhora kapola kati sammotayAM unake prAcAra para gar3ha DAlate haiN| magara yathAtha yaha hai ki viveka karanevAlI buddhi ke kAryahIna ho jAne ke kAraNa maname upasthita vicAroM se jo sabase adhika prabala (mava) hotA hai usakA bhaviSyat vaktAke citra kSetra para zAsana ho jAtA hai jisase usakI vANI usake vyaktigata vicAroM

Page #39
. (30 ) aura pakSapAtase raMga jAtI hai, tathApi vaha yahI mAnatA hai ki - usakI kriyA (vAkya) IzvarIya pravezakA natIjA hai| eka polineziza bhaviSyavaktAke IzvarIya pravezakA nimnalikhita * varNana par3hane para lAbhadAyaka tthhregaa| (dekho TI0 eca0 haksalI sAhabakI banAI huI sAinsa enDa hoyUTraDIzana, pRSTha 324):, ". . ... eka suara mArA gayA aura pakAkara rAtako rakkhA gayA aura dUsare dina keloM aura yAma (jimIkanda ke sadaza 'pala ) aura TAMgana jAtiko nijI surA 'kAvA' kI ' sAmagrIke sAtha ( jo.unako bahuta priya hai ) pAdarI (syAne) ke pAsa lAyA gyaa| phira sagha loga gerA bAMdha kara jaise mAmUlI kAvA pIne ke liye baiThA karate the, vaiTha gaye, parantu pAdarI, IzvarakA pratirUpaka honeke kAraNa, sabase ucca sthAna "para baiThA jaba ki TAMgiyotA nAra namratApUrvaka Izvara ke prasannArtha ghereke bAhara baiThAina sabake baiThate hI pAdarIkI prerita : avasthA mAnIjAnI hai kyoki usa hI kSaNase IzvarakA praveza usame mAnA gayA hai vaha bahuta dera taka cupacApa hAthoM ko apane * sAmane paDe huye baiThA rahatA hai, unakI akhi nIcekI ora ; hotI haiM aura vaha vilkuna zAnta, kriyArahita honA hai usasamaya java ka bhAjana vaTatA hai aura kAvA taiyAra hotA hai kabhI 2 metAvUla loga usase pUcha tAcha Arambha karate haiM / bAja daphA caha uttara detA hai aura bAja dafA nahIM magara donoMhI dazA: oMmeM usako vinda rahatI haiN| -bahudhA vaha khAne aura

Page #40
( 31 ) 1 zarAvake vanda hone taka eka zabda bhI muhase nahIM nikA jatA hai / jaba vaha bolatA hai to vaha sAdhAraNa rItise dhImI aura vahuta calI huI AvAjameM bolanA Arambha karatA hai jo dhIre dhIre asatI svAbhAvika pitra ( AvAja) taka pahuMca jAtI hai aura kabhI kabhI usale ucca svara bhI ho jAtA hai / jo kucha vaha kahatA hai vaha saba IzvarIya kathana samajhA jAtA hai aura isI liye vaha uttama puruSa sarvanAma meM bolatA hai, mAno vaha svayaM Izvara hai / yaha saba sAdhAraNa rItile vinA kisI Antarika mAkulatA yA - zArIrika hilana julanake hotA hai, lekina kabhI usakA mukha bhayA. -naka rUpa dhAraNa kara letA hai aura bhar3aka uThane marIkhA -hotA hai aura usakA tamAma zarIra mAnasika zokase kampAyamAna ho jAtA hai, usa para kaMpakaMpI car3ha jAtI hai, usake matye para pasInA A jAtA hai, usake hoTha kAle paDha kara eMTha jAte hai, granname usakI AMkho me AMsuoM kI dhA rAye cahane lagatI hai gambhIra kaSAyo se unakI chAtI ubharane laganI hai, usakI AvAja ruka jAtI hai| dhIre dhIre yaha hAlata dUra ho jAtI haiN| isa vegaLe pahile N * aura usake uparAnta jitanA cAra bhUkhe J vaha vahudhA itanA khAnA khA jAtA puruSa sAdhAraNatayA khA sake haiN| " hai isa udAharaNa para vicAra karate hue, prophesara DI0 eca0 iklI sAhava pharamAte haiM -~-~

Page #41
"yaha adabhuta ghaTanAyeM jo aime zandomeM varNana kI gaI hai jinako par3ha kara hara manuSya jo hama logoMkI vilakSaNa mAnasika avasthAghoMse jAnakArI rakhatA hai, turanta unako satya mAna legA. ranaDorakI bhaviSyavaktA strI kI kathA para bahuta bar3I rozanI DAlatI hai| jaisA ki isa strIko kathAmeM pAyA hai vaise yahAM bhI bhUta yA devakA zrAnA ...... .. vANIkA badala jAnA va uttama puruSa sarvanAmameM bolanA pAyA jAtA hai| abhAgyavaza (norakI cillIke atirikta ) panaDorakI usa paigambariyA ( bhaviSyadvakA strI) ke dazAkA kucha varNana nahIM hai / parantu jo kucha hamako dUsare jarAyose ( udAharaNa ke taura para 1--samavela adhyAya 10-prAyana 20 tA 24 ) isarAiloM meM IzvarI pravezakI sahacara zArIrika avasyAosa hAla mAlama hotA hai usakI ThIka samAnatA pAlIneziyAke bhaviSyadavaktAoMkI isa kathA aura dUsarI kathAomeM pAI jAtA hai|" prakArake dRzya mIrAsAhaba ke makvara para hindustAna me amarohAke sthAna para dekhe jAsakte haiM aura mAdhAraNa sthAne bhI isa prakArake kucha na kucha kRtya vinA vizeSa pari zramake dikhA sakta haiN| jaisA ki hamane Upara kahA hai yaha IzvarIya praveza nahIM hai parantu mana para vicArake vizeSa prabhAva kA pariNAma hai| zrutike sacce lakSaNa ratnakaraNDazrAvakAcAra meM varNana kiye gaye haiM aura saMkSepase isa prakAra hai

Page #42
( 33 ) (1) vaha sarvajJa tIrthakara bhagavAna dvArA utpanna hotI hai| (2) vaha tarka vitarka kisI prakAra khaNDana nahIM ho sakkI, arthAt nyAya ( mantaka ) usakA virodha nahIM kara sakA / ( 3 ) vaha pratyakSa, anumAna aura zase ( sAkSI ) mutAvika hotI hai| (4) vaha sarva jIvoM kI hitakArI hotI hai, arthAt vaha kisI prakAra bhI kisI prANoke duHkha yA kaSTakA kAraNa nahIM ho sakI - jAnavaroko bhI duHkha aura kaTakA nahIM / ( 5 ) vaha vastu ke yathArtha svarUpakI sUcaka hai| aura:( 6 ) usameM dhArmika viSayameM bhUta aura bhrama dUra karane kI yogyatA hotI hai / sabai zAstroke uparyukta lakSaNoMko dhyAna meM rakhate hue yaha eka nigAha meM sApha hojAtA hai ki vedoM ke bAremeM yaha dAvA karanA ki vaha ani honeke kAraNa IzvarIya vAkya hai, samajha dAra akalake liye nAmumakina hai / agarne yaha bAta pahile pahila nAgavAra mAlUma hotI hai to bhI usase gurez2a nAmumakina hai, kyoMki svayaM hinduoMne apane vedoMse kaI bAnoMmeM virodha kara liyA hai| udAharaNa ke taura para vaha indra, mitra, varuNA va anya vaidika devatAoM meM se bahutoM kI aba pUjA upAsanA nahIM karate hai isa viruddhatAkA kyA abhiprAya ho sakA hai ? agara yaha nahIM ki 3

Page #43
( 34 ) vaidika devatA bhokA vAstavika bhAva ki unakA vyaktitva kevala kAlpanika hai, logoMko mAlUma ho gayA aura isa kAraNa unakI upAsanAkA pracalita rahanA asambhava pAyA gyaa| isa bAta se bhI ki vartamAna hindu prathA vedoMmeM kahe hue jAnavaroM aura manubyoke validAnako pAzavika aura nIca karma samajhatI hai yahI pariNAma uddhRta hotA hai| vAstavameM validAna ke niyamake sambaMdha meM pocheke lekhakoM ne zAstrIya vAkyakA bhAva badala kara gUr3ha artha lagAne kA prayatna kiyA hai, parantu prAcIna razmo aura ravAoM se jo Aja taka cale Aye haiM yaha bAta spaSTa hai ki ArambhameM usa kA artha aisA na thA / yaha bAta ki usake racayitA mAMsabhakSI RSI hI hoMge vilkula pratyakSa hai, kyoMki koI sabA zuddha AhArI sAdhu kabhI khyAla meM bhI apane lekhako rakta va mAMsake alaMkArase se, jinake kevala arthahI ke bAremeM bhrama nahI hosatA hai vari jo usakI svAbhAvika manovRttiko bho avazya ghRNita mAlUma hoMge, gandA nahIM bnaaygaa| isa liye vedoMkA vaha praGga, jisa meM jIvoMke balidAnakA varNana hai una vyaktiyakA banAyA huA nahIM ho saktA hai jo tapa (agni) ko muktikA kAraNa jAnate the, valki vaha pIchese kisI bure prabhAva se zAmila huA hogA / hindUmata ke vikAsakA bahuta spaSTatA ke sAtha uparyuka yuktiyoMke lihAja se jalda patA cala sakatA hai / alaMkArika zikSAke janmadAtA RSiyoMkI kalpanA zaktimeM Atmika pUrNatA ke prApti ke upAya ke taura para, jo usake daivika guNoM kI prazaMsA (

Page #44
( 35 ) karanese prApta hotI hai, utpanna hokara vaha pazcAskI santAnoM meM eka sundara bhajanoMke saMgrahake samAna calA AyA, jo kucha samaya vyatIta hone para zrutike taura para mAne gaye, aura phira unake bhAvArthake bhulA diye jAne para eka naye matake vIja (mUla ) bana gye| sabase prAcIna mantra anumAnataH ve the jo ava Rgavedame zAmila hai, sivAya unake jo jIvoMko balidAna kI AjJA dete haiM yA kisI prakAra usakA anumodana karate hai| unakA asalI artha anumAnataH, unake racaneke samayameM ghahutase manuSyoMko mAlUma thA aura cUMki vaha kevala lekhakI kuzalatAke lihAjase hI sundara nahIM gine gaye the varan Atmika zuddhatAkI prAptike hetu bhI mukhya kAraNa the, isaliye vaha turanta kaMThastha kara liye gaye the, aura nitya prati pUjApAThameM unakA vyavahAra rahasyamayI zikSAmeM lavalIna RSi kaviyoM dvArA hotA thaa| samaya ke sAtha unakI pratiSThAke bar3hate rahanese kucha kAla pazcAt vaha zrutikI bhAMti pUrNatayA pUjya mAne gaye aura rahasyavAdako uljhana meM par3a kara harSa mAnanevAlI rujhAna (buddhi ) ke dvArA uname sava prakArake adabhuta guNa mAne gye| isa kAraNa pazcAt ke logoM ne una maMtroMko, unake bhAvArthako, pUrNatayA na samajhe huye bhI bhAktapUrvaka svIkAra kiyA, aura inako apane dharmakA IzvarIya pramANa mAnA / IzvarakRta zAstrakI bhAMti kAyama hokara pUjya mantroMkA saMgraha rahasyavAdakA mAdhAra ho gayA aura samaya 2 para usameM hera phera aura vRddhi huii| sabase pahalI vRddhi jo usameM

Page #45
kI gaI, vaha saba saMbaMdha rakhanevAloke liye kisI bure prabhAva vaza huI, kyoMki jaya ki usakA phala una niraparAdha prANiyoM ke liye, jinakA validAna devatAnoko denA usa samaya niyata TumA, dukha aura kaSTa thaa| umane ali car3hAnevAle aura una sabako jo dharmake nAma para prANighAta karane meM tatpara huye, durgati aura narakagAmI ThaharAyA, aura annataH asalI aura satyaveda po pratiSThAko bhI gauravahIna kara diyaa| lekina adhika samajhavAle manuSya jIva hI isa bAtako Ana gaye ki nalidAnakA prabhAva vAstavika nahIM varan asatya hai, aura unhoMne isa vAtako nizcita kara liyA ki raktakA bahAnA napanI yA bali-prANIko mucikA kAraNa kamI nahIM ho saktA / parantu isa prathAko jar3e phaila gaI thIM aura eka dinameM naSTa nahIM ho saktI thoN| yaha bahuta samaya pratIta ho jAneke pazcAt humA ki vajidAnakI prathAke virodha jo lahara uThI thI usameM itanI zakti paidA ho gaI ki zAstrIya lekhakA badalanA aAvazyakAya samajhA gyaa| lekina yaha koI sahaja vAta nahIM thI kyoMkiyadi hama eka zlokake vAremeM bhIzAstrIya akhaNDa satyatAko asvIkAra kara deM to rahasyavAdake siddhAntokI, jinako prAkSAkA prabhAva IzvarIya vAkya para nirbhara hai, nIva vilkula khokhatI ho jAtI hai| isaliye vedoM meM kAMTa chAMTa karanA asambhava thA, aura * deso phuTa noTa na 1 pustakake bhaakhiirmeN|

Page #46
( 37 ) cuddhimAna sudhArakako cinhAdakI, jo kAMTachAMTako choDa kara eka hI upAya IzvarIya pramANa saMvadhI AzAme sudhAra karanekA hai sahAyatA lenI pdd'ii| cunAMce eka cinhAdhina yAnI bhAvArthakA prAdhAra vedavAkyake arthake hetu dRr3hA gayA, aura mukhya jAtike cali pazuoMke lakSaNoM aura unake nAmoMkA yuktisa mAvoMke guptAtha kAyama karane ke liye prayoga kiyA gyaa| isa prakAra mer3hA, vakarA, va sAMDa jo bali pazupro nIna mukhya jAtike jIva haiM, AtmAkI kucha ghAtaka zaktiyoMke, jinakA nAza karanA Atmika zuddhatAko vRddhi va mokSaka hetu zrAvazyakIya hai, cinha ThaharAye gae / yaha yukti saphala huI, kyoki eka pora to usane vedoMkI AjJAko IzvarIya pAkyakI bhAMti akhaNDita choDA aura dUsarI ora balidAnakI amAnupika prathAko banda kara diyA aura manuSyoM ke vicAroMko isa viSaya meM latya mArgakI ora lagA diyaa| lekina pApake vIjama jo boyA gayA thA itanA adhika phUTakara phailane zakti thI ki vaha validAna siddhAntake bhAvArtha ke vadala jAnese naSTa na ho skii| kyoki tamAma gupta zikSAvAle mone, jo jAna paDatA hai ki dhArmika viSayoM meM sadaiva bhAratavarSa meM upasthita rahasyavAdI mUla zikSA para calate the, (yahA usa samaya bhAratavarSakI sImAyeM kitanI kyo na hoM ) valike khUna ** dekho 'di kI Apha nAleja' adhyAya ATha 8 - dekho di phAuTena hyaDa aupha rilIjana vA gaMgAprasAda ema. e. kRt|

Page #47
(38) dvArA svargama jA pahuMcanekI navIna pRthAko svIkAra kara liyA thA aura vaha sahajameMhI eka aisI rItike chor3aneke liye, jisameM unako priya bhojana arthAt jAnavarokA mA~sa khAnekI karIba 2 mApha taurase mAjhA thI, prastuta nahIM kiye jA sake / isa samaya hamAre liye java ki itanA dIrghakAla gujara cukA hai, yaha sadaiva asambhava nahIM hai ki hama pravRtti aura nivRttikI laharoMkA, jo hinduoke vicAroM ke parivartanase vAya saMsArameM utpanna huI, patA lagA sakeM, parantu yaha bhI nahIM hai ki hamAre pAsa vAstava meM usake sadRza koI sabala udAharaNa na ho| yaha udAharaNa yahadiyoke matakI zikSAmeM pAyA jAtA hai jisake validAna saMbaMdhI vicAroM meM jAna par3atA hai ki hinduoke bhAMti parivartana huye| 1 saimavela adhyAya 15 zrAyAta 22: "kyA khudAvandako sokhatanI kuravAniyo aura javIhoM meM utanI hI khuzI hotI hai jitanI ki khudAvandakI AvAjakI sunavAIme ? dekha! pAzA pAlana karanA validAna karanese acchA hai aura zunavA honA meMDhoMkI crviise|" eka pracalita rItikA pravala khaMDana hai| zAstrake bhAvArthake badalanekA prayata isa vAkyase spaSTa ho jAtA hai:"maiM tere gharase koI vaila nahIM lUMgA aura na tere vADemeMse cakarA......... agara maiM bhUkhA hotA to tujhase na kahatA ... .....kyA maiM bailoMkA mAMsa khAUMgA aura cakaroMkA khUna 'pIUMgA?Izvarako dhanyavAda de aura apane prANoMko paramA

Page #48
smAke samakSa pUrA kara" (jadara 5. AyAta 6 tA 25 ) jaromiyA navo isa vicArako aura puSTi karatA hai aura isa prakAra IzvarIya vAkya ghatalAtA hai ki:.......: maiMne tumhAre puruSAoMko nahIM kahA, na unako AzA dI ....... *bhunI huI bali aura javIhoke liye, parantu isa bAtakI maiMne unako AzA dI ki merI vAtako suno...... aura tuma una sava rItiyoM para calo jo ki maiMne tumako batalAyI hai tAki tumhAre liye lAbhadAyaka ho" (jarImiyA navIkI kitAva adhyAya 7 zrAyAta 21 tA 23) / ina vAkyoM meM hindUmatake parivartanase itanI gaharI sahazatA pAI jAtI hai ki yaha Akasmika bAta nahIM ho sakatI aura isa meM usI kartAkA hAtha pAyA jAtA hai jisako prophesara DvAyassanane vRhadArayayako balidAna siddhAMtako dhArmika bhAvameM paridhartana karate huye pAyA ( dekho dI sisTama zrApha ghedAnta pRSTha 8) parantu yaha kurIti ava taka calI AI hai| pariNAma yaha hai ki hindUmata apanI hI santAnako jisakA eka dUrake dezameM pAlana poSaNa dupA hai apane hI sanmukha upasthita aura apanI AkSAkA ullaMghana karate huye pAtA hai, aura apane hI zAstroko gomedhake viSayameM jo aba pUrNatayA ghRNita ho gayA hai apane virodhiyoM ke siddhAMtokI puSTi karate huye pAtA hai| kucha thor3A samaya huA svAmI dayAnanda sarasvatI saMsthApaka AryasamAjane jo vyAka. raNake macchezAtA the, isa bAtase ekakalama (ekadama ) inkAra

Page #49
(40) karake ki vedoM meM pazu badhakA varNana hai aura yorupiyana vidvAnoM ke anuvAdoMkI satyatAko bhI asvIkAra karake isa kaThinAIse cacanA caahaa| parantu isa prakArakA prayatna svayam sAtI denevAlI vAno kI upasthitimeM kAragara nahIM huA karatA hai / prAcIna pracalita gIti rivAja svayaM isa bAtakA pramANa hai ki vedoMke anuyAyo validAna karate the / prAja bhI umra vargIke hindU pAye jAte hai jo pazuprakA balidAna karate haiM aura jiname brAhmaNa yajJa karanevAle (hotA) hote haiM / yaha bAta khullamakhullA zAka bhojI maname sahana nahIM kI jA sakatI thI yora isa amarako siddha karatI hai ki vartamAna samayale pUrvakAlameM balidAnakI rasma adhika pracalita thI / hindUo aura brAhmaNoMmeM mAMma kA khAnA koI asAdhAraNa bAta nahIM hai, aura vaha svataH hI prAmANika vAna hai / yaha bAta nahIM hai ki vaha loga mAsako chipA kara khAne hai, varan jo usako jAte haiM, vaha usake khAne ke kAragA kisI prazame bhI anya hindudhoMle ksa nahIM samajhe jAte haiM, goki vahutame usako apanI icchA me nahIM bhI khAte haiM / isa prakAra gata samayameM sarva sAdhAraNa ke bhojyake taura para mAMsakA svIkAra kiyA jAnA asambhava thA / mukhyatayA sadAcArake niyamoke kaDe pAlana aura saba prakArake hinduo ke jAti vyavahAra ke lihAja se sivAya usa hAlata ke ki vaha kisI pUjya AzA dvArA jo yajJazAstroMke atirikta aura koI nahIM ho sakano, pracalita kiyA gayA ho| hama isaliye natIjA nikAlate haiM ki bhArya

Page #50
( 41) samAjakA nirvAcita artha veDhoMkA savA artha nahIM hai| jahAM taka ki aMgrejI anuvAdoMkA saMbandha hai yaha karIna kayAsa nahIM hai ki caha vilkula hI asatya hoM, kAragA ki ve bhI prasiddha hindu vRttikAro AdhAra para bane haiM aura na sarva sAdhAraNa hinduoMne hI unako asatya mAnA hai| hindUmata ke vikAmano bhora dhyAna dete huye hamAre nigAyoMkI zuddhatA pratyeka vyaktiko vidita ho jAvegI jo nimnalikhita DAkyoM para pUrI tarahase vicAra kregaa| (1) zAme veda pazu va puruSa balidAnakA pracAra karane haiM / 12) hindU loga aba gaU aura manuSyake validAnake sakhna virodhI hai jo donoM unake pUjya zAstroMmeM gomedha va puruSamedhaka pavitra nAmoMse prasiddha haiN| (3) amegha zrava vipula banda ho gayA hai aura aja. medhakA bhI yahI hAla hai goki varekA mAMsa aramI kula mUda vizvAsI manuSyo dvArA devI devatAoM ke pramannArtha armANa kiyA jAtA hai| (4) yAsaMbandhI mana abhI taka hindU zAstroMme zAmila hai goki yaha sApha hai ki unakA bhAva zabdAva vaDhala kara bhAvArtha meM lagA diyA gayA hai| - - * dekho phuTa noTa naM. 2 pustaka atameM / dekho phuTa noTa naM. 3 pustakakai atameM /

Page #51
( 42 ) (5) ina maMtrokI bhApA kisI siddha bhagavAna (zvara) kRta nahIM ho sakatI aura na zuddhAhArI (zAkamakSI) mRpiyoMkI ho sakatI hai kyoMki agrima (Izvara) to kisI pApamayI prathA kI spaSTa yA aspaSTa taurase puSTi nahIM karegA aura na mamamasalane vAlI bhASAkA prayoga karegA aura antima mAMsa aura raktake alaMkArokI racanA kabhI nahIM kreNge| ina vAkyoMke sAtha yaha vAtamI dhyAna rakhanI cAhiye ki vedoMkI bhApAkA artha isI prakAra samajhameM pA sakA hai ki usake zabdoke vAhya pathake nIce chipA huA eka gupta jJAnakA siddhAnta mAnA jAve, goki hama tamAma rUpaka alaGkAroMke bhAvako jinakA RpiyoMne pavina mantromeM prayoga kiyA hai, na samajha paaveN| bahutase rUpaka to purANoM meM diye hurahavA noMkI sahAyatAse samajhameM A jAte hai, aura yadyapi kisI pazcAtake pranya kI vyAkhyAoMkA usame pahilo granthame par3hanA nyAyasaMgata nahIM hai tathApi isa vAtase inakAra nahIM kiyA jA saktA hai ki purANoMkI kathAyeM vedoke devI devatAmokA suvistara varNana * dekho: "jaisA ki nimna lekhase vidita hai, purANoko bhI..."yathAryameM vedoM se pUrvakA kahA jA sakA hai: prathamaM sarvazAstrANA purANaM brahmaNA zrutam , anantaraM ca vaktrebhyo vedAstasya vinimRtAH / agAni dharmazAstraM ca vratAni niyamAstathA // brahmANDapurANam // "

Page #52
(43) hai| yaha bAta bhI dhyAnameM rakhane ke yogya hai ki indra varuNa Adika vaidika devatAoMkI pUjAkA banda ho jAnA isakI dalIla hai ki yaha logoko unake mukhya svarUpake patA laga jAneke kAraNa huzrA, isaliye jaya logoMko yaha mAlUma hogayA ki vaha kevala mAnasika kalpanAke vyaktigata rUpaka haiM to unhoMne usa pUjAko jo unake prasannArtha kiyA karate the, banda kara diyA / anumAnataH vedoMke aura vaidika devatAoMke guptArthakI kuJjI kabhI bilkula naSTa nahIM ho gaI thI, sevaka gaNa, sAdhAraNa brAhmagA aura sAdhu bhI cAhe kitane hI usase anabhitra kyoM na rahe hoN| buddhimattAkI laharake antameM jo brAhmaNoM ke samayake validAnakI nivR. ttike pazcAt uThI, mAlUma hotA hai isa kuJjIkA bahuta adhika prayoga kiyA gayA / isa prakAra mahAbhArata aura rAmAyaNa kI padyoM aura purANoMke race jAneke samayameM devI devatA oMkA eka bar3A samUha jisakI saMkhyA 33 karoDa hai usa prArambhika ora sImita devI devatAoMke kuTumpameM se jinakA varNana hai, vedome hai, nikala par3A / inake atirikta kucha aura kAlpanika vyaktiyo jaise kRSNakIracanAbhI hiMdU purANoM ke racayi (di paramAnenTa hisTrI opha bhAratavarSa jilda ; 2. pR. 8) artha:-"brahmAne sava zAstroMmeM sabase pahile purANako sunAyA aura tatpadhAt unake mukhase veda, maga, dharma, zAstra, vrata aura niyama nikle|"

Page #53
( 44 ) tAmoMne raca ddaalii| magara yaha kahanA nyAyayukta hogA ki yadyapi rAmAyaNa, mahAbhArata aura purANoMne lace aitihAsika 'ghaTanAoMkA rahasyapUrNa aura malaMkRta * pozAka pahanA kara itihAsameM baDI gaDabaDa utpanna kara do to bhI usake sAtha hI unhoMne apane devatAoM ke kalpitasvarUpako dikhA kara dhArmika upAsanAmeM bahuta kucha sudhAra kiyA / yadyapi yaha sudhAra nissandeha gambhIra thA tathApi yaha apane uddezyakI pUrtimeM asaphala rahA, kyoki kevala kalpita devatAsamUhakI ravAnagIne ardha kAlpanika ardha aitihAsika vyaktiyozI pUjA. ke liye dvAra khola diyA, aura sAthame hI kucha nabIma samaya ke magara prAcIna prakArake devatAgaNa bhI pUjA aura pratiSTAke "pAtra mAne gye| rAma aura kRSNa prathama prakArake aura giva pichale prakArake devatA hai| inameM se veTome kilIkA bhI varNana nahIM hai jo eka aisI vAta hai jisase yorupiyana samAlocakoM kI isa rAyasI puSTi hotI hai ki hinduoMne apane devatAo ko badala diyA hai| magara isa dopake hindU itane aparAdhI nahIM hai jitamA vaha rahasyavAdakA rujhAna hai jo unake matameM vyApta hai kyoMki jahAM kula dharma zikSA aisI bhASAmeM dI gaI hai hijisakA zabdArtha to kucha aura hai aura bhAvArtha kucha aura hI "hai, vahAM manuSya cakkara meM paDa sakte hai aura kSamAke pAtra haiM agara unase bhUla ho jaave| upaniSadoMne isa rahasya va andhakAramaI * dekho phuTa voTa naM. 4 pustakake antameM /

Page #54
( 45 ) anizcitapanako apane dharmase dUra karanekI koziza kI aura ajJAna aura mithyA vizvAsa ke prandha kUpako bahuta kucha tor3A, parantu vuddhimattA kI mazAla, jisako unhoMne prajvalita kiyAusakI prabhA, mAlUma hotA hai ki kevala TimaTimAke taura para hI rahI / upaniSad bhI gupta cinhavAdale vilkunta vaJcita nahIM haiM aura unakA prakAza na to unake mata sarva re kuoM meM hI pahuMcatA hai aura na vaha sadaiva andhakAra se bhinna ho pAyA jAtA hai / SaT prasiddha darzana bhI jo upaniSadoM ke kAlake pazcAt bane, paraspara eka dUsareke khaNDana karane meM hI apanI zaktiko naSTa kara dete haiM aura saMsArasambandhI vAtoMkI mukhtalipha aura mukhAlipha vyAkhyA karate haiM / kevala eka vAta, jisameM vaha saba sahamata haiM, vedokI IzvarakRta honeke kAraNa akhaNDa satyatA hai / isa prakAra apane rahasyavAda zAstrako IzvarakRta mAna lenese khoja ke vizAlakSetra se vaJcita rahane aura dRSTikSetra ke saMkucita honeke kAraNa vaha satya dArzanika nayavAdako bhI na samajha sake aura ekaruat marraarth jAlame phaMsa gaye jo sAvadhAnoMko phaMsAneke liye taiyAra rahatA hai / isakA pariNAma yaha huA ki mAnava zakAoM dhaura kaThinAiyoMke dUra karaneke sthAnameM jo tatva jJAnakA saccA uddezya hai unhoMne apane ho dharmako pahilese adhika anizcita * dekho kitAbake aMtameM phuTa noTa naM 0 5 / -

Page #55
(46) -banA diyA, aura unakA vAstavika upayoga usa vyartha vAdavivAda para sImita hai jo vedoMke anuyAiyoM meM yarAvara jArI hai| satya yaha hai ki eka pUrva sthApita vaijJAnika dharmase janma pAneke pazcAt Rgvedake rahasyapUrNa kAvyameM, jo aAdhunika dhamakI nIva hai, bhUta kAlameM itanI vRddhiyAM va tabdIliyAM huI hai ki loga usakI intadAko bhUla gaye haiM jinameMse eka phirke ko jo Aja kala vidyA kortike pAtra ho rahe haiM. usameM eka vAnara jAtise vikasita mastiSkake vicAroke sivAya aura kucha nahIM dekhatA hai aura dUsareko jo dharmake aMdhazraddhAnI hai haraeka akSara aura zabdameM IzvarIya vAkya ho dikhAI detA hai| agara vaha pariNAma jo ina pRSTomeM nikAlA gayA hai, sahI hai to ina donoM vicAroMmase koI bhI satya nahIM hai, kyoMki RSi kavi zikSita bAlaka na the, jaisA ki ve samajhe jAte haiM, aura na vaha kisI daivI vANIse uttejita hI the| janmase hI hinda dharma jainadharmakI eka zAkhA thI, goki usane apane pApako zIghra hI eka svatantra dharmake rUpameM sthApita kara liyaa| samayake vyatIta hone para vaha kisI rAkSamI prabhAvameM aagyaa| jisakA 'virodhIprAndolana upaniSadokI buddhimattA aura jagata prasiddha darzanoM, nyAya, vedAMta zrAdikI kali va kAlakA lakSya hai| apane zrApako eka svatantramata sthApita kara dene ke kAraNa svAbhAvikahI vaha jaina matako apanA virodhI samajhane para vAdhya huA, aura darzanoMmeMse kuchameM jaina siddhAntake khaNDanArtha sUtra bhI likhe gaye haiM, yadyapi

Page #56
(47) jisa vastukA vaha vAkaI khaNDana karate hai vaha vAstava meM jaina sidvAnta nahIM hai jaisA ki jainI loga samajhate haiM balika svayaM unakI manamAnI kalpanAyeM hai jo jainamatake bAremeM unhoMne gar3ha ima isa prakAra yaha pariNAma nikAlate haiM ki dono tharmA meM adhika prAcInatAkA prabha jainamatake haphameM phaisalA honA cAhiye, aura yaha ki pUjya tIrthaMkaroMkA mata hindu matakI putrI yA jhagar3AlU saMtAna hone ke bajAya vAstavameM svayaM una nissa. * yaha AzakA ki vedoMkI bhASA jaina zAstroMkI mApAse zatAbdiyoM pahilekI jAna par3atI hai, vyartha hai kyoMki prAcIna kAlameM manuSya apane zAstroMko kaNThastha karake surakSita rakhate the| jainamata aura hindU matake zAstra bhI prathama isI vidhise surakSita the. aura lekhanakalAkA prayoga abhI kucha kAla pUrva ke aitihAsika samayameM huA hai paratu veda kavitAmeM likhe gaye haiM jisakA abhiprAya yaha hai ki vedoMkI bhASA sadaiva ke liye niyata ho gaI, jisameM parivartana nahIM ho saktA isaliye ve sadaiva apane racaneke samayako hI darzAyeMge / vilA lihAja isa amarako, vaha kara likhe jAyeM / yaha pAta jainamatameM nahIM pAI jAtI hai, jisake zAstroMkI bhASA sadaivake diye niyata nahIM hai| ataeva jisa mApAmeM jainatiddhAta liye gaye haiM vaha vahI bhASA hai jo unake lekhanasamayameM pracalita shrii| jainamatake sambadha meM bhASAkI jAMca isa kAraNa asaphala hotI hai aura usakI prAcInatAkA bhanumAna vipakSI dharmoM ke zAstroMkI AMtarika sAkSI dvArA hI ho sakA hai|

Page #57
(48 ) deha prAcIna dharmakA prAdhAra hai| bunAsA yaha hai ki hiMdU dharma apanI utpatti ke liye una toya kuzalatAbAle kaviyokA kRtajJa hai jinhoMne apanI aparimita uttejanA jAgame prAramA kI apragaTa aura daivI zaktiyoMko kAvyavicArameM vyaktigata caaNdhaa| uha yahazI na the aura na unake lekhoM meM koI penI zAnaNya yA vahaziyAnA besaklIkI bAta pAI jAtI hai jisake kAraNa yaha kahA jAsake ki usa samayake manuSya azo vadhApanameM muntilA the| isake viparIta unakA bAna jenamata ke akhaNDa siddhAnta para nirbhara thA jo tIrthaMkaroM se nikalI huI zutike zrAdhAra para sthApita hai| samayakI gatine mAtA aura putrImeM pUrA viyoga paMdA kara diyaa| yora putro pacAt ko duSToMke hAthameM par3a gii| usakA pariNAma nAnA prakArako pApakI saMtAna (yoMkI rIti) hupa jipsako upane kisI bhayAnaka prabhAvake kAraNa janA / isake bAda vaha upaniSada ke racanevAle RSiyoMkI rakSAmeM jagajoMko tanahAI meM pazcAttApa karatI huI milatI hai, aura phira isake bAda hama usako buddhimattAke vizvavidyAlayameM apane ke naye aura mukhtalifa magara Ill fitting (ayogya) gono (cIroM) ko sambhAlate hue pAte haiN| aura aba jaba ki Adhunika khojakI X-ray prabala buddhimattA usake nihAyata amUlya aura manabhAvane zrAbhUSaNoMko prArambhika manuSya ke hanumAna - jAtise nikalaneke *'saMsArakI prahelikA vikAsavAdiyoMko sadaiva usa samaya taka hato

Page #58
( 4 ) thor3e hI pazcAtkA kAma sAvita kara rahI hai to vaha apane usa tsAha karegI jaba taka ki ve AtmAkI jo apane svabhAvase sarvajJa hai, jaisA ki " kI Apha naoNleja" aura "sAinsa Apha thoTa" meM pUrNa rItise sAvita kiyA gayA haiM zaktiyoM aura guNoM svarUpakA yathocita jJAna prApta na kara leM | isa sampUrNa jJAnakI zaktiko svayaM pUre taurase anubhava meM pragaTa karane ke liye kisI vastuko bAhara se prApta karanekI AvazyakatA nahIM hai, kintu kevala usa bAhya pugalake aMzako jo AtmA ke sAtha lagA huA hai, dUra karanekI hai / isa prakAra jitanA hI sAdA ( vairAgyarUpa ) jIvana hogA, utane hI adhika uca prakAra ke jJAnakI prAptike avasara mileMge / isaliye hamAre pUrvaja jinakA jIvana bahuta sAdA thA aura jinake vicAra bahuta umra ye sacI buddhimattA ke prApta karane ke henu usase adhika yogya the jaisA unakI vartamAna samaya dUrako satAna khyAla karatI hai| yaha bAta ki vAstavameM bhI yahI hAla hai, prAcIna kathAoM ( purANoM Adise ) siddha hai, jisakA anumodana sAmAnya rUpase dharmasabaMdhI vicAroM aura vizeSa rUpale janavidvAtakI adbhuta pUrNatA kI AMtarika sAkSIse hotA hai / isa prakAra vivita hogA ki apane adhikatara vaijJAnika guNoMse apane pUrvajoM ko cakAcauMdha kara denekI bajAya hamane unako chodI huI zikSAnidhiko bhI bahuta kucha naSTa kara diyA hai aura aba garva karaneke liye hamAre pAsa parivartana zIla phaizanoM aura kArya hona paudgalikatA ke atirikta nahIM hai / niH sadeha yaha unnati aura vikAzake mArgakI ora calanA nahIM haiM paraMtu isake viparIta pathapara maga dharanA hai / 4

Page #59
t bhUle hue bhUta kAlako jisake kAraNa usako bahuta du:kha milA hai phira smaraNa karane kI ceSTA kara rahI hai / svayam eka sarva vikhyAta mAtAko saMtAna honeke kAraNa hama usako apane pichale mamayake, jaba ki usake baDe prazaMsaka kavi usa kI tatva zikSA ke bhAvokI prAlaMkArika bhASA meM parivartana karake sahaja banA diyA karate the, kucha kucha sumirana karanese harSase praphullita hote hue dhyAna kara sakte hai / usakI mAtA aba bhI use hAtha pasAre hue vApasa leneko prastuta hai, aura yadyapi vaDa va vRddhA ho gaI hai tathApi vaha prema aura kSamAse Aja bhI vaisI hI pUrNa hai jaisI ki vaha sadaiva rahI hai / nissandeha vaha eka zubha samaya hogA jaba ki hiMdU aura jainadharmakA pAraspa parika saMbaMdha pUrNatayA jAna liyA jAvegA, aura AzA hai ki mAtA aura putrIkA " zubhasammelana sava sambandhiyoMko zAnti aura Ananda pradAna karegA 1 0 ) 000 iti

Page #60
( 51 ) phuTa noTa nambara 1 isa krUratAke navIna parivartanakA ninna vRttAnta jana purANoM kI sahAyatAse isa prakAra pAyA jAtA hai: eka samaya rAjA vasuke rAjameM jisako bahuta kAla vyatIta huA eka zakhsa nArada aura usake guru bhAI parabatameM 'rAja' ke artha para jisakA prayoga deva-pUjAmeM hotA thA, vivAda huaa| isa zabdake vartamAna samayamai do artha haiM, eka no tIna varpake purAne dhAna jiname aMkhupA (aMkurA ) nahIM nikala saktA hai aura dUmarA 'vkraa'| parvanane, jo anumAnataH mAMsa bhakSaNakA vilAsI thA isa bAta para jora diyA ki isa zabda kA artha cakarA hI hai, magara nAradane purAne arthakI puSTi kI / sarva janatAkI sammati, sanAtana rIti aura prativAdIkI yuktiyoMse paravatakI parAjaya huI, magara usane rAjAke samakSa isa ghaTanAko upasthita kiyA, jo svayam usake pitAkA ziSya thaa| rAjAphI sammati paravatake anukUla prApta karaneke hetu parava. -takI mA chipa kara mahaloMmeM gaI aura usase apane patikI gurudakSiNA mAMgI aura isa vAtakI icchuka huI ki muMha-mAMgA para paave| vasune, jisako isa vAtakA kyA gumagna ho sakatA thA ki usase kyA mAMgA jAyagA, apanA pavana de diyaa| tava paravatakI mAMne usako patalAyA ki vaha paravatake anukUla phaisalA kare aura yadyapi vasune apanI pratikSAse haTanekA prayatna kiyaa| magara parvatakI mAne usako aisA karanese rokA aura

Page #61
( 52 ) pratijJA se na haTane diyaa| dUsare dina mAmalA rAjAke sAmane upasthita huA jisane apanI sammati paravata ke anukUja dii| isa para vasu mAra DAlA gayA aura paravata rAjadhAnIse durgatike sAtha nikAla diyA gayA / parantu usane apanI zakti bhara apanI zikSA ke phailAnekA pragA kara liyaa| parvata abhI soca hI rahA thA ki usako kyA karanA cAhiye ki itaneme eka pizAca pAtAla se brAhmagA RSikA bheSa banA kara usa ke pAsa AyA / yaha pizAca, jisane apanA sAMDilya RSike taura para paravatako paricaya diyA / apane pUrva janma meM madhupiGgala nAmI rAjakumAra huA thA jo apane vairI ( rakI) dvArA dhokhA khAkara apanI bhAvI strIse vaJcita rakkhA gayA thA / isakA vivaraNa yo hai ki madhupiMgalako rAjakumArI sulsA ke svayamvara meM varamAlA dvArA svIkAra kiye jAnekA pUrA maukA thA kyoki usakI mAMne usako pahale nijI taura se svIkAra kara liyA thA / usake rakIya sagarako isa gupta pravandhakA hAla mAlUma ho gayA aura sulsAke prema andhA hokara usane apane maMtrI se isa bAta kI icchA pragaTa kI ki vaha koI yakSa rAjakumArIkI prAptikA kare / isa duSTa maMtrIne eka banAvaTI sAmudrika zAstra racA aura usako gupta rItile svayambara maNDapake nIce gADa diyA aura jaba svayambara meM Aye huye rAjakumAroMne apane apane zrAsana grahaNa kara liye' to usane kulapUrvaka jyotiSa dvArA eka prAcIna zAstrakA svayamvarake maNDapake nIce gar3A honA batalAyA / kissA mukhta t

Page #62
( 53 ) sara jAlI dastAveja khoda kara nikAlA gayA aura samAne maMtrI se usake par3hane kA anurodha kiyA / usane zAstra par3hanA prArambha kiyA aura zIghra hI Akhoke varNana para chAyA jisake kAraNa madhupiGgala vizeSatayA prasiddha thA bar3e harpa sahita madhupiGgalake usa zatrune banAvaTI sAmudrika zAstra ke eka eka zabdako, jisameM madhupiMgalake aisI AMkhokI curAI kI gaI thI, jora de de kara par3hA, ki vaha durbhAgyakI sUcaka honI hai aura unakA svAmI karmahIna, abhAgA, mitra ora kuTu striyoMke liye azubha hai / becAre madhupiMgalake AMsU nikala prAye aura vaha samAse uTha gayA / isa kapaTa-kriyA ke dvArA parAsta, duHkhita aura lajita ho kara usane apane kapar3e phAr3a DAle aura saMsArako tyAga sanyAsIkA jIvana vyatIta karanA Arambha kiyaa| isa samaya suhasAne svayambara meM praveza kiyA aura sagara ko apanA pati svIkAra kiyA / isake kucha kAla pazcAt madhupiMgalane eka sAmudrika ke jAnakArase sunA ki usake sAtha chala kiyA gayA aura dhokhA huA tathA anyAya yukta vidhiyoMse usakI bhAvI strI se usako prathak kiyA gayA / usane usI kodhakI hAlatameM jo dhokhe ke hAlake khula jAnese utpanna huA thA, apane prANa taja diye / marakara vaha pAtAla meM pizAca yonimeM utpanna huA jahAM usako apane pUrva janmake dhokhA khAnekA bodha ho gayA aura yaha vahAMse apane zatruose badalA leneko claa| vaha turanta

Page #63
( 54 ) manuSyoMke dezameM AyA aura pazvatase usa samaya usakA samAgama huA jaba ki vaha vasuke rAjyase nikAlA gayA thA aura soca vicAra meM thA ki vaha 'ja' zabdake apane ( navIna ) artha ko kisa prakAra saMsAra meM phailAve / usane paravanako apane zatruse badalA lene meM yogya aura prastuta sahAyaka jAnakara usake duSTa kAryakI pUrti meM sahAyatA dene kI pratijJA kI / manuSya aura pizAca kI isa azubha pratijJAke anusAra yaha nizcaya huA ki paravana sagara ke nagarako Aya jahAM para mahAkAla ( yaha usa pizAcakA vAstavika nAma thA ) saba prakAra ke batrA ( roga ) aura marI phailAyegA jo parvata ke upAyose dUra ho jAyeMgI tAki isa prakAra paravatakI pratiSThA vahAMke logokI nigAhameM ho jAya jina meM vaha apane bhAvoMkA pracAra karanA cAhatA thA / pizAcane apanI pratijJA pUrI kI aura paravanane samasta prANiyo ko bure bure rogoM meM grasita pAyA jinakA vaha mantroM dvArA saphalatA pUrvaka ilAja karane lgaa| parantu usa abhAge rAjyameM hara rogakI jagaha para jo acchA ho jAtA thA, do naye aura roga utpanna ho jAte the / yahAM taka ki logoMko isa bAtakA vizvAsa ho gayA ki una para devatAkA kopa hai aura unhone paravatase, jisako vaha aba apanA mukhya rakSaka samajhane lage the, isa bAre meM sammati lI / isa prakAra kucha samaya vyatIta ho gayA aura antameM yaha vicArA gayA ki aafaaiko navIna prathAke Arambhake liye sataya anukUla hai| Arambha kAlameM prANiyo ke 3 | balidAna hI saMkhta

Page #64
virodha huA, parantu vahuta kAla taka mele huye asA duHkho aura parvatakI atula pratiSThAne jo pUjAke do taka pahuMca gaI thI, aura mukhyataH usa zraddhAne jo usakI adbhuta zaktike kAraNa logoMmeM utpanna ho gaI thI aura jo vAstavamai usakI kArya saphalatAke anubhava para nirdhArita thI, manda sAhasavAle hRdayoMko usako AjJApAlanaka lie prastuta kara diyaa| sabase pahale mAMsa bAz2a vAz2a rogoMme davAIka taura para diyA gayA aura vaha kabhI AzAjanaka pariNAmake utpanna karanemeM niSphala nahIM huaa| jisa pAtako paravata vAdavivAdase sAbita nahIM kara pAyA thA usIko vaha apane pizAca mitrakI sahAyatAse isa kArya pariNita yukti dvArA sAvita karanemeM phalIbhUta huaa| dhIre dhIre usake ziSyoMkI saMkhyA varAvara bar3hatI gaI / yahA taka ki paravata ke isa ghAtake vizvAsa dilAne para ki valise pazuko kaSTa nahIM hotA hai varan vaha sIdhA svargako pahuMca jAtA hai, 'ana'-medha (yaza) kiyA gayo / yahAM bhI mahAkAlakI zaktiyo para bharosA kiyA gayA thA jo kArya hIna nahIM huI, kyoMki jyo hI lipazune pavitra kurIke nIce tar3apanAva karAhanA prArambha kiyA, tyohI mahA. kAlane apanI mAyA-zaktise eka vimAna meM eka bakareko harpita vA prasanna svargakI aura jAte huye banA kara dikhA diyaa| sagarake rAjyake vuddhi bhraSTa logoMko vizvAsa dilAneke liye para kisI cIjakI AvazyakatA nahIM raha gaI / zraja medhake pazcAt gomedha humA, gomedhake zada azvamedha aura antataH puraMyamedha bhI baDe

Page #65
( 56 ) samArohake sAtha manAyA gayA jinamese hara ekane apanA prAjAjanaka phala dikhlaayaa| hara yajJameM pali-pazu yA manuSyako svarga jAte huye bhI dikhAyA gyaa| jaise jaise samaya vyatIta hote gayA logoke hadayose mAMsabhattaNa va jIva hiMsAko ghRNAjo unameM prAraMbhika dhAvasthAmeM thI nikalatI gaI, yahAM taka ki annameM validAna vali-prANIke liye svargake nikaTastha mArga mAnA jAne lagA ! isa prathAkI eka vyAkhyA vAstavameM validAnake zAstromeM jo usa samayameM race gaye the kara dI gaI aura logoMke diloMmeM ina rItiyoM ke liye itanI zraddhA ho gaI ki bahutase AdamI harSapUrvaka yaha vizvAsa karake ki ve isa prakAra turanta svarga pahuMca jAyeMge svayam aranI vali car3hAne ke liye tatpara ho gye| antameM sullA aura usakA kapaTI vAhanevAlA magara bhI devatAoMke prasannArya apanA apanA balidAna karAne pAye aura vedI para kATa DAle gye| pizAcakA praNa aba pUrNa ho gyaa| usane apanA badalA le liyA aura pAtAlalokako calA gyaa| usake cale jAne se balidAnakA dhanAvaTI prabhAva bahuta kucha jAtA rahA parantu cUMki vaha apane sAtha vayAnoM aura mahAmAriyoMkA bhI letA gayA, isa kAraNavaza usakI ora prArambhameM logoMkA dhyAna nahIM gayA / navIna race gaye pAkyake ki 'valiprANI sIdhA vargako pahuMca jAtA hai' apramANita honeko aba loga isa prakAra,samajhAne lage ki yaha pavitra mantroMke uccAraNa yA zuddha

Page #66
( 57 ) anuvAcanameM jo calidAnake samaya par3he jAte the, kisI truTike raha jAneke kAraNase athavA kisI prakArake kisI aura kAraNa hai| isI bIcameM yajJa karAnevAle hotAoMke nimitta yajJakI pUrI vidhi bhI tayAra kara lI gaI thI aura prAcArika paddhatikA eka-sampUrNa nIti zAstra bhI tayyAra ho gayA thA jisameM choTe choTe yimoM para bhI acchI tarahase vicAra kiyA gayA thaa| anumAnataH prAcIna (RgveTake ) samaya ke kucha mantroM meM bhI paravata aura usake mAtahata ziSyoMke anu. sAra parivartana kara diyA gayA thaa| magarakI rAjadhAnIse bar3ha kara yaha naI zikSA dUra taka phena gaI aura pizAbake apane nivAsa sthAnako prasthAna karane ke pazcAt bhI honAoMkI zaktiyAM, jo unako mismarejama, yogavidyA ityAdike abhyAsa se jiname mAlUma honA hai ki unakA bhalI prakAra praveza karAyA gayA thA, prApta huI thI; logoko paravatake duSTa-manakI ora zrAkarSaNa karaneme paryApta rhiiN| isa kathanakI puSTi java hama svayaM hiMdu zAstroke vAkyoMse pAte haiM to hamArA vicAra uparyukta jaina zAstromeM varNita hiMsAke kAraNakI satyatA para dRr3ha ho jAtA hai| dekhiye-bhArata zAMti parvake 336 adhyAyame likhA hai ki caMdravaMzIya kRti rAjAke vasu nAmake putra the jo parama vaiSNava aura svargagaja indra ke parama pyAre mitra the| indrane inheM eka prAkAzagAmI ratha pradAna kiyA thaa| isI

Page #67
(58) para car3ha karake ye prAyaH sarvadA uparideza ( zrAkAza ) ko jAyA karate the| isI kAraNa inakA nAma uparicara huA thaa| satya. yugake kisI samayameM yAjaka Rpi aura devatAyoke vIca eka bhayAnaka vivAda upasthita huaa| vivAda hone kA kAraNa yaha thA ki RSigaNa pazu himAko pApa samajha kevala dhAnyAdi vIja samaha dvArA yAga karate the| devagaNa piyoMke isa vyavahArase santuSTa na ho kara eka dina unake nikaTa A kara bole-"yAjaka mahAzaya ! Apa yaha kyA kara rahe hai ? 'ajena yavyaM isa zAstrAnusAra chAga pazu dvArA yAga karanA ucita hai|" muniyone uttara diyA, "aisA nahIM ho sakatA hai, pazu hiMsA karanese hI pApa hotA hai| 'vIrjayaijJeSu yaSTavya' isa vaidikI zutike anusAra vIja dvArA hI yAga karanA ucita hai| Apa logone jisa zAstra kA vacana kahA usameM bhI aja zabdase vIjahIkA ullekha kiyA gayA hai vaha pazuvAcaka nahIM hai|" kintu devatAoM ne ise svIkAra karanA na caahaa| ve bahutasI yukti aura pramANa dikhA kara apanA hI mata pravala karanekI ceSTA karane lge| Rpi bhI una logoMse kama na the| ve bhI aneka yukti aura pramANake ilase devatAoMkA mata khaNDana karane aura apane matake pratipAdanameM yatnavAn hue| isakA vicAra vahuta dina taka calatA rahA, vAkyayuddha bhI bahuta huA, kintu kaunasA mata uttama hai isakA koI nirNaya na ho skaa| aise samayameM uparicara rAjA jA rahe the| donoM pakSone dono matameM kaunasA mata uttama hai, isake nirNaya

Page #68
( 56 ) karane kA bhAra unhIM para sauNpaa| rAjAne devatAoMkA pakSapAta kara unhIM matakA anumodana kiyaa| isa para RSiyoMne kruddha ho rAjA ko zApa diyA / isa zApase hI mahArAja usI vimAna ke sAtha adhovicAra ( bhUgarbha ) ko jA rahe haiM, aisA dekha devatAoMko vaDI lajA mAlUma huii| unhoMne rAjAko viSNukI ArAdhanA karane kA upadeza diyA aura 'zubha karma meM vasordhArA denA hogA' aimA hI vidhAna kiyA / isIse hI bhUgarbhasthita vasuko proti hotI hai / Ajakala bhI vivAha ityAdi zubhakarmomeM 'vasordhArA' dene kI nIti pracalita hai / kAlakramase viSNune unheM mukta kara diyA / ( hiMdI - vizvakoSa, saptama bhAga, pRSTha 493 ) 3 phuTa noTa naM0 2 unake vedArtha kI uttamatA aura molakA aura bhI ThIka 2. anumAna karaneke liye hama Arya samAjiyoMmeM agni aura indrake svarUpakI jo svAmI dayAnandajIke anuyAyI aura 'TarminAkojI zraupha di vedaja' ke prasiddha racayitA mi0 gurudatta ke kathanAnusAra uSNatA yA ghoDoMke sikhAnekI vidyA aura zAsanakartA jAti kramAnusAra hai, jAMca karege / gi0 gurudatta maiksamUlara Adi pazcimI vidvAnoMkI kuzalatAko caileja ( asvIkAra ) karate hai aura karate haiM ki una logoke anuvAdoM meM sAdhAraNa zabdoM ko vyaktivAcaka manAyeM mAna lene meM azuddhiyAM ho gaI hai / yaha jJAta rahe ki yorupIya vidvAnoMne hindU TonA kAroM, nadIvara, sena, AdikI vRttiyoM kI sahAyatAte hI apane anuvAda race haiM -

Page #69
parantu mi0 gurudatta nirukake kartA yaskake mata para jo hara zabdako kevala usake yogika arthameM prayoga karatA hai, Arada hai| hama yorupIya arthakI yatheSTa samAlocanA kara cuke hai aura isaliye ava mi0 gurudattakI vRttikI kuzalatAkA andAjA usako prophesara maiksamUjarake anuvAdase tulanA karake krge| jina vAkyoko hama tulanAtmaka nirNayake liye tajavIja karate haiM vaha hI hai jisako mi0 gurudattane svataH ho mukAvilAke liye pasanda kiyA hai aura ye Rgvedake 162veM muktake prathamake tIna mantra hai| mi0 gurudatta aura prophesara maiksamUlara donoke artha 'TarminAlojI aupha di vedaz2a meM diye huye hai aura ninna prakAra haiN| mi0 gurudatta pro. maiksamUlara 2-"hama tejasvI guNoMse "pAzAhai ki mitra, varuNa, susajjita phurtIle ghoDeke Arthamana, Ayu, indra, RtuoM vala utpanna karanevAle ke svAmI aura mArata hamako svabhAvokA varNana na kareMge na jhir3akeM kyoMki hama yajJake yA utAkI prabala shkti| samaya devatAoMse utpanna huye kA varNana kareMge jisa teja ghor3oMke guNakA varNana kreNge| ko buddhimAna yA vijJAnameM meM pravINa loga apane - upAyoM meM ( yazameM nahIM) "kAmameM lAte haiN|

Page #70
(61) 2-"vaha loga jo yaha zikSA, 2-"jaba ve ghoDeke Age jo dete haiM ki kepala sata karmoM khalisa sovaraNake AbhU. se upArmita dhana hI saMgraha paNoMle vibhUpita hai valiko aura vyaya karanA cAhiye majabUta pakar3e huye le calate aura vaha jo buddhimattA hai tava citalA (dhanvedAra) praveza ho cuke haiM jo dUsaroM vakarA agAhI calate se padArtha vijJAnake viSaya vakta mimiyAtA huA meM zAstrArtha karane meM aura calatA hai, vaha indra aura mUrkhAko sudhArane meM nipuNa pUpaNake priya mArga para hai, kevala ve aura aise hI calatA hai| zakti aura banake rasako - zAsanArtha pIte haiN| 3--"upakArI guNoM se pUrNa 1-"vaha bakarA jo ki samasta bakarI dUdha detI hai devatAghoMke liye arpita hai pUpaNake bhAgake taura para jo ghADoMke vAste prathama teja ghor3e ke sAtha eka puSTikAraka mojana nikAlA jAtA hai hai; sarvottama anAja kAraNa ki tvastri svata. usI samaya upayogI hI mana bhAvana bheTako jo hotA hai jaba ki catura ghoDeke sAtha lAI jAtI hai rasoiyA dvArA bhojya kIrti pradAna karatI hai|" vastuoMke guNa saMbandhI /

Page #71
( 62 ) jJAnakI rotiyoMke anusAra svAdiSTa bhoja ke rUpameM banAyA jAya / " zabdoko bar3e harUkomeM hamane likhA hai aura unakA prabhAva hara ekako svIkRta hogA jo svAmI dayAnanda ke isa kathanako dhyAna me rakkhegA ki uparokta sukta 'azva vidyA kA varNana hai jo ghor3oMke likhAne aura vijalIkI bhAMti vizvavyApI uSNatA ke vijJAna se saMbaMdha rakhatA hai" ( dekho Tarmi nAlojI Apha di vedz2a pRSTha 38 ) | durbhAgya vaza isa ayakI azva vidyA arthAt bhojana sabaMdhI kuzalatAse prasaga yogyatA kisI prakAra yukti dvArA pragaTa yA prAmANika nahIM kI gaI / vipakSI arthame bhI vAstavame koI kuzalatA nahIM hai yadi usa ko zabdArthameM par3hA jAve / parantu usakI prasaMga yogyatA usake eka vidyamAna cAlU rItile jo niHsandeha bahuta prAcIna kAla se calI AI hai, anukUlatA rakhane ke kAraNa spaSTa hai / 1 nissandeha yaha bAta satya hai ki vaidika paribhASAoMke artha karIva 2 sabhI yogika hai jo rUr3hi se, jisakA bhAva icchAnusAra rakha liyA jAtA hai, bhinna jAtI hai / parantu yaha bhau itanA hI satya haiM ki anumAnataH saMskRta bhASAkA tamAma kopa aise zabdoM se paripUrNa hai jo mUla dhAtuoMse mukhya mukhya niyamoMke anusAra nikalate hai / yaha vizeSata vyakti vAcaka zabdoM taka pahuMca gaI 2. vizeSakara vyaktiSoMke nAmomeM pAI jAtI hai, jaise rAma vaha hai

Page #72
( 63 ) jo harSa pahuMcAye yA jo zrAnanda 'pUrNa aura harSadAyaka ho| isa prakAra hara vRttike viSayameM kisI na kisI dRSTi sandeha karanA sadaiva saMbhava hai parantu yaha vidita hai ki isa tarIke se koI saMtApajanaka phala prApta nahIM ho sakatA hai / bahutasI dazAoMmeM dhAtuvAda zabdoM ke arthako yatheSTa rotise prakAza kara degA, parantu prAyaH yathArtha mAca prApti ke kAraNa zoMkA pracalita yA prasiddha bhAvakA bhI prayoga karanA avazyakIya hogA / yadyapi isa cAtako dRSTigocara rakhanA hogA ki ina prasaMga yogyatAko apanI priya sammatikI puSTike kAraNa haThapUrvaka naSTa na kara deN| isaliye yaha kahanA satya na ThaharegA ki indra sadaiva zAsanakartA jAti hai aura zAsanakartA jAtike atirikta aura kucha bhAva nahIM rakhatA hai, aura agni azva vidyA yA uSNatA ke atirika kabhI aura kucha nahIM hai, ityAdi / uSNatAke bhAva agni aura zAsanakartA jAtike bhAvameM indra bilA zubahA isa bAta ke yogya nahIM hai ki vedake mantromeMse bahuta adhika mantra unake liye niyata kiye jAMya, mukhyatayA jaba unake virodhI kramAnusAra zIta aura aisI jAtiko jisa para dUsarA zAsana jamAye ho vaidika devAlayameM kahIM sthAna nahIM milA hai / bahutasI vidyAyeM, udyama, guNa aura jAnavaroMke sikhAne kI rItiyAM aura bhI haiM jo mi0 gurudattake bhAva ke lihAjame dhagni aura indrase kama Avazyaka yA upayogI nahIM hai, magara hamako vedoMmeM koI mantra unake liye nahIM milatA hai| na to azva vidyA aura na f

Page #73
zAsana vipaya vapayogI padArthoke una chaha vibhAgoM arthAt (1) kAla, (2) sthAna, (3) zakti, (4) manuSya-AtmA, (5) icchA pUrvaka kArya, (6) jIvana kriyAyomeM jo raminAlojI aupha di vedaja ( dekho pRSTha 53-54 me varNana pAyA jAtA hai| bAvajUda isake kimi0 gurudattane yaha vimAga vandI vaidika devatAoM ke nirNaya erane ke liye vizepatarA banAI tho, jo na vaijJAnika Dhaga para na dArzanika vicArase kisI prakAra nirdoSa ho saktI hai / upaNatA vAstavameM zaktiyoMke vibhAgameM sammilita ho saktI hai jaise ki vaha vAkaI hai parantu usakA apanI pAMtikI anya prAkRtika zaktiyoMse agragAmI honekA adhikAra abhI pramANita honeko zeSa hai| isa prakAra hama apane Apako isa bAtake mAnaneke liye vAdhya pAte hai ki vedoke mantromeM devatAmroke taura para varNita agni aura indra uSNatA yA azva vidyA aura zAsanapartA jAti kA artha nahIM rakhate haiM, varan AtmAke katipaya guNoM yA paryAyoMke vAcaka haiN| isI prakAra zrAyu aura pRthvI, zrAphAza aura bhUtala nahIM hai parantu kramAnusAra zrAtmA aura punala hai| puSTi dAtA pUSaNa isI prakAra AyukA (jo jIvana zaktikA niyata karanevAlA hai' ) rUpaka hai / yadvA kabhI 2 vaha prakAzake devatAoM meM bhI ginA jAtA hai kAraNa ki prAyu kamakI sthiti taka hI zArIrika balakA honA saMbhava hai| yaha bAta ki pUSanakA varNana yAtrIke taura para AyA hai usake yathArtha bhAvakA eka aura sUcaka hai,

Page #74
kyoMki Ayu varAvara kama hotI rahatI hai arthAt gujaratI rahatI hai aura aMlakArameM pathika rUpase bAMdhI jA sakatI hai| pUpanake dAMtoMkA giranA jisakA varNana purANoM meM AyA hai anumAnataH isa. liye hai ki usake svarUpako nissandeha sAbita kara de kyoMki yaha vRddhAvasthAkA lakSaNa hai / isaliye balidAnameM pUpaNake mAga kA artha puNya karmose utpanna honevAlA Ayukrama hogaa| yahAM bhI hama jaina siddhAtako isa bAtakI vyAkhyA karate huye pAte hai jo hindU zAstroM meM bhramapUrNa hai kyoki hindU zAstroM meM koI nizcita niyama pAlana aura baMdha saMbaMdhI darja nahIM hai aura isa kAraNavaza vaha vyorA rahita aspaSTa vicAroM para saMtuSTa rahane ke liye vAdhya hai / vAstavamai karma baMdhana cAra dazAomeM pAyA jAnA hai aura isaliye usake samajhane meM nimna likhita vAtoke jAnane kI AvazyakatA hai-(1) 148 karmaprakRtikA svarUra jA jaina siddhAnta andhoMmeM vaNita hai (2) karma prakRtiyoko maryAdA / 3) baMdha kI nIvanA aura (4) mikadAra arthAt puhalakI mikadAra jo AtmA zAmila ho| yaha cAro prakRti, sthiti, anubhAga, aura pradeza baMdha kriyAnusAra kahalAte haiM aura inake jJAna vinA yaha nahIM kahA jA saktA hai ki karma ke niyamale jAnakArI prAta huI / bhava jahA taka zrAyukA saMbaMdha hai vaha zeSake sAta ko isa ghAtane vilakSaNa hai ki usakAdha jIvana paryaMta eka hI daphana hotA hai jabaki aura zeSa karmAkA hara samaya hotA rahatA hai mAnavI jo paudgalika mAdA AtA hai usako yoM kaha sakate hai

Page #75
ki vaha vaMdhanake lihAjase karmake vibhinna bhAgoM meM bhAjita ho jAtA hai aura usame karma pratiyAM banatI haiM aura isa vibhAjita hone meM vidyamAna. Antarika bhAvokA vaDA prabhAva pahatA hai| yaha bhAva ravayam vyaktigata vicAroM para nirbhara hai / puNya aura vairAgya prAtmAkA bala aura vIganAko bar3hAte haiM aura pApa usako nirvala aura adhogati avasthAmeM DAlatA hai| ina uparokta vicAroM ke lihAjase vedoMmeM varNana kiye gaye devatAoMke balidAnakA artha una kRtiyoMse samajhanA cAhiye jinase jIvana kriyAoMkA jo devI devatAoMke rUpameM varNita haiM pAlana poSaNa hotA hai, aura kisI bhAvameM bhI prANiyoMkA rakta. pAta nahIM samajhanA cAhiye / vizeSa karake valiTAnakA saMbaMdha AtmAke svAbhAvika zuddha guNoMse hai jo icchAyoM ke mArane aura tapasyAse pragaTa hote haiN| paudgalika prAsrava jo niHsvArtha karmase hotA hai zubha baMdhanakA kAraNa hai aura isa 'bheMTa' (puNya prAsrava) kA vividha prakArakI zubha karma prakRtiyoM meM vibhAga hotA hai jo devatAoMkA bhAga kahA gayA hai| Rgvedake 1623 suktake prathama tIna mantroMke bhAvArthakA samajhanA ava kaThina nahIM hai| unakA sabaMdha mana (azva ) ke vazameM karane (- naSTa karane prata. eva mAra DAlane vA bali car3hAne ) se hai jisake pUrva kAmavAsana kA (jisakA anurUpaka vakarA hai) svabhAvataH nAza karanA Abazyaka hai| yaha vidita hogA ki. yaha yajJa devatAoMse sIdhA saMbaMdha rakhatA hai aura unakI puTikA tatkAraNa hai jabaki

Page #76
( 67 ) prANiyokA kisI dUravartI devatAke prasannArtha ghAta karanA nyAya va vijJAna donoM meM se kisIke bhI prAzraya nahIM hai / anya devatAoMkI ora dhyAna karane para yugala prazvinI kumAra svAMnakI do nADiyoM, kramAnusAra ir3A va piGgalA ke rUpa rU pratIta hote haiM ) unake bAremeM yaha mAnA gayA hai ki vaha varAvara calate hote haiN| kAraNa ki prANakA svabhAva sadaiva calate rahane kA hai / aura vaha vaidya rUpameM bhI mAne gaye haiM isa kAraNa se ki svAsIcchvAsa nAr3iyoke apavitratAko dUrakara detA hai aura isa kAraNase mo ki yogiyo dvArA yaha bAta mAnI gaI hai ki manuSya ke zarIra ke bahuta se roga jIvanakI mukhya zakti arthAt prANakA jisakA saMbaMdha svAMsa se bahuta ghaniSTa : ucita prayoga karanese dUra ho jAte haiM / sa dhAraNa rUpame svAMsako vyaktigata vAyuke pratirUpa meM jisakA eka nAma anila ( svAMsa ) hai vAdhA hai | parantu devatAoM meM sabase adhika mukhya 33 hai jinameM 11 rudra 8 vasu 12 Aditya, indra aura prajApati zAmila hai / , rudra jIvana ke una kartavyoM ke rUpAntara hai jinakA ruka jAnA mRtyu hai / vaha rudra ( rudra yAno ronA mRtyu samaya rodana hone ke kAraNa kahalAte haiM, isaliye ki mRtaka puruSake mitra aura kuTumbI jana usakI mRtyu para AMsU bahAte huye dekhe jAte haiM / caha AtmAkI bhinna 2 jIvana zaktiyoM ko sUcita karate haiM / 8 vasu anumAnataH zarIrake 8 mukhya bhAgoMke jo aGga kahalAne haiM kartavyoMke cinha haiN| kucha lekhakoMke matAnusAra 8 casuoMkA

Page #77
(68) abhiprAya 8 sthAnoMse hai, arthAt (1) pittaja zarIra (2) graha (3) vAyumaNDala (4) alaukika sthAna (5) sUrya (6) AmAzakI kiraNeM (7) upagraha aura (8) tArAgaNa (dekho di TAminAlojI aupha di veduz2a pRSTha 55) magara yaha adhika saMbhava hai ki zArIrika aGgoM ke vidyamAna kartavya hoM kyoMki ve jIvako zaktiyoM ke vividha svarUpa haiN| athavedake eka vAkyameM (dekho di TarminAlojo aupha di vedaz2a pRSTha 53) unakA ullekha vividha zArIrika katavyoMkI bhAMti kiyA gayA hai ora vRhadAraNyaka upa. niSadake anusAra 33 devatAoMke patalAnevAlA mArga hRdaya. mAMkAzake bhItara hai ( dekho di paramAnyanTa hisTrI aupha bhAratavarSa bhAga 1 pRSTha 532 ) / aba hama AdityoMkI ora dhyAna deMge jinako saMkhyA 12 kahI jAtI hai| magara yaha vidita hai ki vaha sadaiva itane nahIM mAne gaye haiN| iblyU-je vilakija sAhabake matAnusAra dekho di hindu methAlojI pRSTha 18): "yaha nAma ( Aditya ) kevala Adityake vaMzajoMkA ho , vAcaka hai| Rgvedeke eka vAkyameM cha? ke nAma varNita hai| . arthAt (1) mitra (2) mAyamana, (3) bhAga, (4) varuNa (5) dakSa . * CI jaikoliyaTa sAhaca apanI pustaka di aukalTa sAinsa ina iNDiyAke pRSTha 18 para manuke AdhAra para batalAte haiM ki jIva svayam devatAoM kA saMgraha hai|

Page #78
aura (6) aNsh| aura eka dUsare mantra meM unakI saMkhyA sAta kahI gaI hai, yadyapi unake nAma vahAM nahIM diye gaye hai| eka "tIsarI jagaha AThakA varNana hai magara aditi apane pATha putroM meM se jo usake udarame utpanna hue the devatAoM ke samakSa sAtako lekara pAI aura mArtaNDa (AThave ) ko alaga kara diyA ki ina putroMke nAma jo vedoMke minna 2 mAgoMmeM diye huye hai eka dUsarese nahIM milate haiM - isaliye isa vAtakA jAnanA ki prAditya kauna kauna the * kaThina hai / zatapatha brAhmaNa aura purANome AdinyokI saMkhyA 12 vAraha taka bar3hA dI gaI hai|" . bhaviSya-purANakA kayana hai (dekho di parmAnyanTa hisTrI aupha bhAratavarSa, bhAga 1 pRSTha 481 ca 486 ) ki AdityoM ko devatAoM meM sabase pahile hone ke kAraNa prAditya kahate haiN| kucha aura lekhakoMke matAnusAra prAditya zamzI sAla ke bAraha mahIne hai (dekho di TarminAlojI aupha di vedaja pRSTa 55) aura unako zrAditya ima kAraNa kahate haiM ki vaha saMsArameMse pratyeka vastuko strIMca lete hai| isa yAtakA ki isa kathanakA Thoka artha kyA hai samajhanA sahaja nahIM hai, parantu yaha jyAdA karIna kayAsa hai ki Aditya AtmAke, jisakI zuddha avasthA kA rUpapha sUrya, jo jJAnakA eka uttama ciha hai, mukhya ( yA prArambhika ) guNoM ke sUcaka hai| isaliye Aditya jinakI saMjJA cAhe kitanI hIkyoM na ho, kyoMki yaha manupyakI vimAgandI

Page #79
(7 ) para nirbhara hai AtmAkI usake mukhya upayoga arthAt nase sambandha rakhanevAlI kriyAyeM haiN| isa prakAra varuNa jisakA bheSa zamzI varSake mahIneke taura para hAsyajanaka hai karma zakti kA pratirUpaka hai kyoMki yaha manuSyoMke satya aura phaMThako dekhatA hai (hindU metholojI pRSTha 36 ) / eka dUsare sthAname varuNa kA zAsanakSetra vizAla karake samasta saMsArako kAyama kiyA hai, kyoMki yaha AkAzameM pakSiyoM ke ur3ane dUra calane pAlI vAyuphe mArga, samudroMmeM calanevAle ahAjoMke pathako jAnatA hai aura tamAma padArthoko jo huye haiM yA hoMge dekhatA hai| varuNako samudrakA adhipati mAnA hai, anumAnataH isa kAraNa ki samudra saMsAra (AvAgamana) kA cihna hai|| anya Aditya isI prakAra varSake mAsa nahIM ho sake haiM parantu jIvake bhinna bhinna guNa ho sake haiN| ava kevala indra aura prajApatikA ullekha vAkI hai, inameM se pahilekA varNana to 'hama anya sthAna * para kara cuke haiM paraMtu pichalA prajAoM (vaMzoM ata: jIvanake aneka kAryoM ) kA pati arthAt mAlika hai, aura hRdayake prabhAvika kartavyakA cinha hai, (dekho di parmAnyanTa hisTrI aupha bhAratavarSa bhAga 1, pRSTha 462-466) / uparokta varNana samasta hiMdU devAlayoMko vyAkhyAke liye * dekho di kI aupha nAleja aura di kAnaphluensa aupha oppojiTsa "(vA asahamata sNgm)|

Page #80
(71) vastuta: yayeSTa hai, yadvA usake devatAoM kI saMkhyA 33 karoDase kama nahIM mAnI gaI hai kyoMki isa devavaMzake zeSa devatA mukhya 33 tetisako hI, jo tInameM aura antataH eka hI yAnI svayam bhaktakI parama pUjya paramAtmA svarUpa prAtmAmeM hI garmita ho jAte hai, mAnasika santAna haiN| yaha vidita hogA ki hamArI vyAkhyA kerala usa aprasaMgatAko jo mi0 gurudattake arthameM pAI jAtI hai aura usa pratirodhI apaneko jo yorupiyana dArzanikoMke bhAvameM vidita hai, dUra nahIM karatI hai varan hamako apane devatAoM kI janasaMkhyA meM salagna hindU kAlpanika zaktikA pUrA dRzya dikha jAtI hai| ina devatAprokrI vazAvaloke sambandhameM bahutasI ulajhane aura peMca, jinhoMne prAdhunika khojI vidvAnoM ke dAMta khaTTe kara diye hai, unakI kAlpanika utpattike AdhAra para sahajameM hI sulajha jAte haiM, kyoki jIvanakI vividha kriyAoM ke eka prakArale eka dUmarImeM garmita honeke kAraNa yaha samaya samaya para avazya hogA ki unakI utpattike vicAroke pratirUraka apane pArasparika sambandhiyoM aise nAmutAvika lakSaNoM se paripUrNa hoM jo amarmajJa manuSyako asadhya aura isaliye pU~The pratIta hoN| yaha vidana hogA ki kucha devatA svataH apane pitAoMke pitA mAne gaye haiM aura koI apane janmadAtAoMke samakAlIna, isa tarahako dhovemeM DAlane. vAlI kathAyeM kevala hindumatake hI vizeSa lakSaNa nahIM haiM varan maha rahasyavAda aura gupta zitA tamAma manoMmeM pAI jAtI haiM,

Page #81
( 72 ) jaise IsAI mata meM bApa aura beTe ( khudA aura IsU ) kA samakAlIna honaa| inakA bhAva unake svarUpokI dArzanika mUla ( nikAla ) kA patA laga jAne para sulabha aura sahaja hotA hai varanA bhUla meM par3ane aura bhaTakanekA kAraNa hai ! usa manuSyako, jo amarIya zAsana aura devAdhipatyake bhedakA patA lagAnA cAhatA hai, cAhiye ki sabase pahile nayavAdakA prAbhyaJjana ghRta, jisake binA buddhimattAkI kuJjI rahasyavAdake murcA lage huye tAloM meM jo zatAbdiyoM se banda par3e huye haiM nahIM phiratI hai, prApta kare / phira usako cAhiye ki vaha apane nijI vizvAsoM aura priya vicAroMkI gaTharI bAMdha kara apane se dUra pheka de, taba una zaktiyoM ke pUjya sthAnameM praveza kare jo tamAma prANImAlakI prArabdhokA nirmAtA haiN| kevala isI prakAra vaha vAstavika vastusvarUpamaya satyako pA sakegA aura bhrama va pakSapAtakA zikAra honese bcegaa| tIvra buddhivAle pAThaka aba isa vAta ko samajha leMge ki prAtmA jo indriyoM dvArA paudgalika padArthokA bhogatA hai indrake kAlpanika rUpAntara meM dyAyusa aura pRthvI ( jIva dravya aura pudgala ) kI saMtAna hai aura tisa para bhI vaha apane pitAhIkA pitA isa mAnI (artha) meM hai ki siddhAtman svayam apavitra jIvakA apavitratA ra hita zeSabhAga hai / yaha bAta ki yaha vicAra sadaiva - * vividha apekSAoM yA dArzanika dRSTiyoMke dhyAnameM rakhaneko nayavAda kahate haiM / t

Page #82
vilkula ThIka ra vaijJAnika nahIM hai vyAkhyAkI satyatAko kamajora nahIM karatA hai kyoMki hamArA abhiprAya kevala rahasyavAdake bhAvAryake darzAnese hai na ki usakI ghaTanAproke viparIta vaijJAnika satya pramANika krnese| * sAdhAraNa rItise yaha vidita hogA ki rahasyavAdameM virodhatA aura asaMgatikA aza isa vAtakA dRr3ha sUcaka hai ki vividha apekSAoMse prApta kriye huye pariNAmoko nayavAdakI AjJAkA ulaMghana karake mizrita kara diyA hai / isaliye isa kahane meM virodha honA saMbhava nahIM hai ki jo kucha buddhi aura buddhimattA ke viparIta dharmameM pAyA jAtA hai vaha kisI satya vAtakA varNana nahIM hai cAhe vaha satya vAta koI vyakti ho yA prAkRtika ghaTanA parantu yathArtha aura vAstavameM eka mAnasika kalpanA hai jo eka vahu praja kalpanA zakti ke kArakhAneme kitI sAdhAraNa niyamake prAdhAra para gar3hI gaI hai| vedoke pazcAtakI kahAnAoMmeMse vaha karapanA jo aba kevala hinduoMhI meM nahIM ghagn tIna cauthAI mAnava jAtimeM pracalita hai arthAt raka sRSTikatA aura zAsaka Izvarako kalpanA isa niyamakA sarvottama udAharaNa de rahI hai| anumAnataH vicArakA vaha aMza jisake AdhAra para yaha kalpanA sthApita huI hai vizvakarmAko svarUpa hai jo devanAyokA zilAkAra aura RSi kariyoM ke AkAra racanAsabaMdhI vicAroM arthAt vastuoM ke prAkRtika svabhAvakA rUpaka hai / aisA jAna paDatA hai ki hindu mastiSkane dravyoMkI svAbhAvika kriyAke bhedase cakagakara antataH

Page #83
( 18 ) 1 yaha pariNAma nikAlA ki dravya kartavyakA bhI koI kAraNa avazya hogA, aura apanI isa aspaSTa aura dhuMdhalo kalpanAkA koI yuktiyukta AdhAra na pA kara eka naI prakArakI zaki adRSTa ( a nahIM + dRSTa = dRSTigocara, ataH anajAna ) ko jaldo meM kAyama kara diyA | kavi-kalpanAke unI rujhAna vaza jo devAlaya ke aura devatAoM kI utpattikA kAraNa huI, bhaTTae bhI samayAnusAra daivika guNoMse susajita ho gayA aura cUMki vaha Arambha hole aura saba devatAoMke kartavyakA nikAsa aura isaliye una sabase adhika balavAna arthAt Izvara ( Izvara vaha hai, jo aizvarya rakhatA ho arthAt valasAmrAjya yA svAmopana ) mAnA gayA thA, isaliye antataH vaha apragaTa mahezvara ke sadRza saMmAra meM prasiddha ho gayA / hindU devAlaya meM sarvoccasthAna pA kara isa adRSTane apanA rAja hindU duniyA ke Age phailAnA Arambha kiyA aura apane kucha pUrvAdhikArI mitrAdi kI bhAMti zIghra hI anya dezoM meM jahAM vaha saba prakArake acche aura bure padArthakA karttA mAnA gayA, apanA sikkA jamA liyaa| cunAMce 'isIyaha' navI apane Izvarako puNya va pApa donoMkA karttA ThaharAtA hai (dekho ijIlakI isI yaha navIkI kitAba adhyAya 45 AyAta 6 va 7 ) / muhammadane bhI 'isoyaha' kI sammati ke snIkAra karane para saMtoSa kiyA aura isa bAtako kaha diyA ki nekI aura badI donoM Izvara kRta haiM, kyoMki aura koI karttA duniyAme nahIM hai / puNya aura pApake karttAke rUpameM sIdhA sAdA agaSTa jisakI utpatti kadA 1

Page #84
(75) cita eka aise vAna:prastake mastiSkameM huI jo dArzanika vivekake liye vizeSa vikhyAta na thA, aba jaba ki loga usakI mAnasika utpattiko sRSTikartA sampandhI vAdavivAdake tIvra kolAhalake kAraNa bhUla gaye haiM, to vaha saba prakArako virodhatA aura asaMgatikA bhaNDAra ho gayA hai| isakA virodha honA mI asammaSa thA kyoMki manuSyake mastiSkameM samasta kriyA aura kartavya ke eka mAtra kAraNake rUpameM kalpita ho kara isake liye yaha sambhava na thA ki vaha kisI prakArake (karmajanita, svAbhAvika ityAdi) kRtiyoMkI jimmevArIko asvIkAra kara sakatA / adhikAMza nikaTa kAlameM yaha rUpaka AtmAke Adarzasa bhI jo IzvarameM laya honA samajhA gayA hai, saMvadhita ho gayA hai / isa prakAra antima zaki kA prArammika mAnasika vicAra aba kamase kama cAra minna vastuoMko garmita karatA hai, arthAt (1) prakRnikI kArya kAriNI zakti (2) jIva dravya aura anya dravyoMke kartavya (3) kamajanita zakti aura (4) jIvakA antima uddeza, ina hI cAra bhinna asaMdhya kalpanAoMkA saMgraha hai jo eka darzanika vicArame navIna madAkhilata karanevAleke mAstiSkama lAparayAhI sthira hokara adRSTake rUpakake taura para saMsAra zAsaka sambandhI viSaya meM bhUla aura jhagaDejA upajAU kAraNa hai|

Page #85
(76) phuTa noTa naM0 3. tullA liye hunAyassanake di sisTema aupha di vedAMta'kA ninna likhita viSaya par3hiye (vAsa jA~sTana sAhayakA aMga. rejI tarjumA, pRSTha 8): "...... ..yaha vAta ThIka hai ki AraNyakoM meM hamako validAna ke bhAvArthake vadalaneko vilakSaNa dazA bahudhA milatI hai| yajJa saMskAroMke amalI rItise karane ke sthAnameM una para bhAvArthako badalakara vicAra karanA batalAyA hai jo dhIre 2 sarvottama vicAroM para pahuMcA detA hai / udAharaNake liye vRhadAraNyakakA prArambhika viSaya (jo adhodhAyuke liye niyata hai ) misameM azvamedhakA vaNena hai le lIjiye: 'o3m ! prAtaHkAla vAstavameM yajJake azvakA sira hai| sUrya usakA netra hai vAyu usakI svAma hai| usakA mukhya sarvavyApI agni hai| kaNa validAnake ghor3e kA zarIra hai, svargaloka usa ko pITha, AkAza usakA udara aura pRthvI usake pAMva rakhane kI caukI hai| dhruva ( Poles ) usake kaTibhAga haiM, pRthvo kA madhya bhAga usakI paliyAM hai, Rturye usako avayava hai, mahInA aura pakSa usake jor3a haiM, dina aura rAta usake pAtra haiM; tAre usakI haDDiyAM hai, aura meva usakA mAMsa hai / regi stAna usake bhojya haiM jinako vaha khAtA hai| nadiyAM usakI aMtar3iyAM haiM; pahAr3a usake jigara aura phephar3e haiM; vRkSa aura paudhe usake keza haiM; sUrya udaya usake agADIke bhAga

Page #86
haiM; aura sUryAsta usake pocheke bhAga haiM, jaba vaha jamuhAI letA hai to vaha bijalI hotI hai, jaba vaha hinahinAtA hai to vaha gajetA hai| jaba vaha mUnatA hai to vaha barasatA hai; usakA svara vANo hai| Dina vAstavameM usake sAmane rakhe huye yajJake gharatanakI mAMti hai, usakA palanA pUrvI samudra meM hai rAta vAstava meM usake pIche rakkhA huA vartana hai, usakA palanA pazcimI samudra meM hai, yaha donoM yakSake vatana ghor3e ke girda (idhara udhara ) rahate hai| ghur3adaur3ake azvake taura para vaha devatAoM kA vAhana hai| yuddhake ghor3e kI bhAMti vaha gaMdhoMkI savArI hai; turaMgake sadRza vaha asuroM ke liye hai| aura sAdhAraNa ghAr3e ke samAna manuSyoM ke liye hai| samudra upakA mAthI hai, samudra usakA palanA hai|' "yahA~ saMsAra validAnake ghor3e ke sthAnameM pAyA jAtA hai, zAyada isake pIche yaho bhAva hai ki yogIko saMmArakA tyAga kara denA cAhiye (devo vRhadAtyayaka aniSada 31 va 43 ). nisa prakAra kuTumyakA puruSa yantra ke vAstavika pratAdoM (Gifto) ko tyAga detA hai| ThIka usI prakAra chAdogya upaniSada (adhyAyazloka-1) jo udagAnAke liye hai sacce udagAnA samAna zikSA detA hai| o3ma! zabdako jo brahma (paramAtmA pratikrama ) kA vinha hai jananA aura usakA Adara karanA aura maMtra jisakA saMbaMdha hotA' se hai aine AraNyakam (2,1, 2) meM usA prakAra arthakA parivartana kiyA gayA hai| tulanAke liye dekho brahmasUtra

Page #87
( 78 ) 3, 3, 55-56, jahAM isa vicArakI puSTi kI gaI hai, ki isa prakAra ke cinhita alaMkAra (pratyaya) zAkhAmoM meM hI kevala sahI nahI pAye gaye haiM balki sAdhAraNa taura para bho| phuTa moTa naM04 - isa prakArake rUpakoMkA dropadoke rUpale udAharaNa diyA jA sakatA hai jo mahAmAratake anusAra pAMgho pANDava bhrAtAoko strI tho| jainamatake digambara AnAyake purANoM meM isa yAtakA virAdha kiyA gayA hai| aura yaha kahA gayA hai, ki vaha kevala anunakI hI khI thI. jisane usako svayambarameM samAjake samakSa jItA thaa| nissandeha yaha vAta karIna kayAsa nahIM hai ki aise 'puruSa jinakI neka aura badakI vicAra zakti pANDavoMke samAna ucca avasthA kI thI, itane bhraSTAcaraNa ho ki vaha usako eka hI samayameM pAMca patiyoMse saMbaMdha karane para bAdhya kreN| satya yaha hai ki mahAna upAkhyAna ke racayitAne aitihAsika ghaTanAoMko toDa maroDa kara apane alaGkazika AvazyakAoMke yogya banA liyA hai, aura satyArthaka hUMDha lene kA bhAra pAThakoMkI buddhi para chor3a 'diyA hai| navayauvanA dropadIkA badhUrupameM pAMca pANDavoMke khAndAnameM praveza karanA, jIvana (Life ) aura zAna indriyoM ke saMbaMdhase inanIsadvazatA rakhatA hai ki usako mahAbhAratake racayitA ko atyAta tAtra buddhi dhyAnameM lAye bagaira nahIM raha saktI thI, aura upane umakA arthAt dropadIkA turanta apane yuddha ke bar3e nATakameM jo AtmAkI svAmAvika aura karma zaktiyoMke antima

Page #88
( 76 ) yuddha aura karma zaktiyoMkI pUrNa parAjayakA mahAn alaGkAra hai, prayoga kiyA (dekho 'di pamanyanTa hisTI auphabhAratavarSa ke0 pana0 Aiyara kRta bhAga 2) / isa prakAra jaya ki aitihAsika dropadIko yudhiSThira aura bhIma jo usake patike jeSTha bhrAtA the apanI putrI ke samAna aura arjunase choTe nakula aura nAdeva apanI mAnAke samAna mAnate the, to usakI (louble) arthAt kAlpanika dropadI paJcajJAna indriya aura jIvana sattAke sambandhako darzAne hetu pA~coMkI strI viNyAta huii| eka aura kathAke anusAra jo usane sambaMdhita hai sUyya (zuddhAtmAke cinha ) ne usako eka adbhuta mAjana (ghaTaloI ) diyA thA, jisameM se saba prakArake bhojana aura aura padArtha pacchAnusAra milate the| isa icchita vastuko denevAlI lAIkI vyAkhyA isa bhAMti hai ki yAtmA svamAvase paripUrNa hai aura bAMdha sahAyatAle svatatra hai| duSTa dussAsanakA dropadAko sundagnAko janatAke samakSa, usake vastrako jo alokika DhaMga se bar3hatA gayA utArakara pratyakSa kara, dene meM asamartha rahanA eka aisI bAta hai jisa se jIvake svabhAva para prakAza par3atA hai, kyoMki baMdha (dropadI kI rajasvalA)-avasthAmeM jIva sadaiva mAhekI tahoM meM itanA lapeTA humA hai ki kisI prakAra bhI usakI nagna chavikA darzana karanA sambhava nahIM hai! jIva sanAphA eka aura sundara alaMkAra zrImatI phagoiyAkI jApAnI kathAmeM pAyA jAtA hai usake pAMca cAhanevAle pAMca __ indriyoM ke sUcaka haiM jo sabake saba usako una asalo cIjoM

Page #89
(80) sthAnameM jinako vaha cAhatI va mAMgatI hai nakalI aura burI vastuH bheMTa karake dhokhA dete haiM; mora maikADo bahirAtmA (zArIrika vyakti) hai jisako chor3akara vaha candraloka (pitRloka )ko vahA~ke nivAsiyoM ke sAtha prasthAna kara jAtI hai| - magara dropadIko indra se jo jAvAtmAkA eka aura alaMkAra hai pRthak samajhanA caahiye| ina donoM rUpoMmeM bheda yaha hai ki jaba ki dropadI jIvana sattA aura jJAna indriyoM ke sambaMdhako jAhira karatI hai, indrakA bhAvakSetra usako apekSA adhika vizAla hai| indrakA jIvana yadi usako eka aitihAsika vyakti yA jIvita devatA mAnA jAve to vaha hinduoke sadAvAra sabhyatA aura deva tAmoMke guNoM se ghRNA utpanna karane ke liye yatheSTa hai kyoMki sirpha yahI bAta nahIM hai ki usane apane guru gautamako strole bhoga kiyA va pitAmaha ( brahmAjI) ne bhI use daNDa denekI vajAyA usake pApake cinha phor3e phunsiyoMko kevala usakI prArthanA para netroM meM parivartana karake use aura bhI sundara banA diyA, parantu isa kathAke yathArtha arthakA koI saMbaMdha itihAsase nahI hai aura usase pratIta hotA hai ki usake racayitAko AtmajJAnakA bahuta kucha bodha thA, aura alaMkAroMkI kavi-racanAko anupAta yogyatA prApta thI / usa alaMkArika bhASAkA jo isa rUpake sambandhame vyavahRta huI hai pUrNa gatise rasa lene ke liye yaha Avazyaka hai ki hinduoMke sRSTi racanA sambaMdhI vicAroMko jo sAMyamatAnusAra puruSa aura prakRti ke saMyogase utpanna hotI hai dhyAna meM rakhA jaave|

Page #90
( 81 ) lekina yahA~ para hamArA abhiprAya sAMkhyadarzanoM ke sRSTi-vikAza saMbaMdhI vicAroMse nahIM hai varana isIse hai ki puruSa se jIvAtmAoM kI utpatti kisa prakAra hotI hai jisakA varNana hinduoM ke pramANita zAstra yogavAziSTameM nimna prakAra diyA gayA hai| "u ra 'hmaNake samAna jo apane ucca padase cyuta ho kara zUdra ho jAtA hai, IsA (Izvara) bhI jIyameM patita ho jAtA hai / sahastroM jIva pratyeka sRSTi camakate rheNge| usa utpanna karanevAle vicArake Andolana se jIvika Izvara pratyeka vikAza meM utpanna hoNge| parantu isakA kAraNa yahAM " isameM ) nahIM hai / jo jona ki Izvarane nikalate haiM aura unI ahAnAse unnati karate haiM bharane karmoM dvArA vArakavAra janma maraNako zAma hote haiM / he rAma ! yaha kArya kAraNa saMbaMdha hai jo ki jIvoMgI utpattike liye koI kAraNa nahIM hai to bhI sattA aura karma Apasa meM eka dUsare ke liye kAraNa haiM / samasta jIva ghagairaha kAraNake IzvarIya padase nikalate haiM, magara unako utpatti ke bAda unake karma -unake duHkha aura sukhake kAraNa hote haiN| aura saMkalpa mo AtmodhakI ajJAnatAko mAyAse utpanna hotA hai saba karmokA kAraNa hai|" hinduoM kA aisA vicAra ekase aneka ho jAneke dhAremeM hai, aura yadyapi yaha vicAra sadoSa hai aura una kaThinAiyoMse jo sAdhAraNa mAnasika vicAroM arthAt guNoMko padArthoMse jinameM

Page #91
( 82 ) vaha pAye jAte haiM prathaka samajhane ke kAraNa paidA hote hai, bacaneke liye vAharI upAyake naura para hai, to bhI isa vicArakA manameM rakhanA usa marmake jAnaneke liye jo hinduoMke handrAdi devatAoM saMbaMdhI kalpanAoMmeM pAyA jAtA hai Avazyaka hai| indra ke apanI gurukI patI ahilapAse bhAMga karanevAlI kathAkI vyAkhyA karate huye yaha bAta jAnane yogya hai ki AtmA kA pudgalase samAgama nitAnta manA hai, kyoki mokSakA ayahI ekakA dUsarese pRthaka honA hai| isase AtmAkA pudgala meM praveza karanA eka varjita kiyA hai, aura isa kAraNa use vyabhicAra kahA gayA hai| ava cUMki pudgala buddhike jJAnakA, jo jIvakA zikSaka hai, mukhya viSaya hai, isaliye zrAtmA aura pudgalakA samA. gama gurukI patnIke sAtha vyabhicAra karma ho jAtA hai / AtmAke pudgalame prakhaNDa ekatAke rupame praveza karanekA phala ananta jIvoMkI utpatti hai (jaise yogavAziSTake ullekhameM varNana hai) jinameM se pratyeka jIva paudgalika paramANuoMme zarIradhArI ho jAtA hai aura mAikA aMdhakAramayI prabhAvake kAraNa phor3e phurasI ke sadRza hotA hai| parantu yaha jIva phira zIghra hI AtmAke jJAna aura vizvAsa dvArA ( jisako alaMkArakI bhASAmeM brahmAjI arthAt IzvarakI upAsanA kahA gayA hai ) Atmavodha prApta kara lete haiM, aura phira pUrNatA aura sarvazatAko pA lete haiM, isaliye 'vaha netroM meM pariNata huye kaheM gaye haiN|

Page #92
( 3 ) indrakI bAbata kahA jAtA hai ki usako soma rasakA bhI cahuta zauka hai jo musajamAno ke matako zarAba tarAse sahatA rakhatA hai| yaha eka prakArakI madirA hai jo magana karatI hai magara massa nahIM karanI, aura jo AtmA ke svAbhAvika Ananda kA cinha hai| indrakA vAhana hAthI hai jo vistAra, aura vajamavAlA hai, isaliye pudgalakA cinha hai| isa vicArakA sAra yaha hai ki AtmA svayam caja phira nahIM sakatI hai parantu pudugalakI mahAyatAse cala phira sakatI hai| isa vicArakI aura bhI vyAkhyA svayama hAtho vana meM pAI jAtI hai jisake eka sirase tIna sUMDa nikale huye mAne gaye haiM aura yaha eka vilakSaNa cinha hai jo akAraka bhAvako siddha karane ke liye nimsandeha gar3hA gayA hai kyoki tIna supudgatake tIna guNoke cAtraka hai arthAt sat rajana va tamaske jo sAMrUyamanake anusAra prakRtike tIna mukhya guNa haiM / soca aura vistArako zakti jo jIvakA mukhya gugA hai isTInA karane para bar3hane aura zatrI ( pavitratA yA puNya ) se pRthaka hone para atyanta laghu rUpa dhAragA kara kamaja ( mahasrAra cakra ) daNDa ( anumAnata: meru daNDa ) ke bhItara chipa jAne se darzAyI gaI hai /

Page #93
( 64 ) phuTa noTa naM 5 kevala thor3e se vicAraneme yaha vidita ho jAyagA ki yaha darzana zAstra na to harSadAyaka taura para nirmANa kiye gaye haiM aura na vaha vaijJAnika athavA saiddhAntika zuddhatA se lakSita haiM / prArambha meM hI vaha saiddhAntika dRSTi (naya) vAdako bhulA dete haiM aura bahuta karake pramANakI kismoM aura z2arAyoMse apanI anabhijJatAko pragaTa karate haiM / unakI tattva- gaNanA bhI avaijJAnisa aura bhramapUrNa hai| saiddhAntika dRSTise dekhate huye vidvAna hindU bhI isa bAta ko mAnane para vAdhya huye hai ki unake hoM darzanoM meM se koI bhI siddhAntAnukUla ThIka nahIM hai / nimna lekha, jo ki ' sakraDa vuksa aupha di hindUja' kI navIM pustakakI bhUmikAse uddhRta kiyA gayA hai, hindU bhAvoMkA eka acchA namUnA hai: / "vaha (vijJAna bhikSu jo sAkhyadarzana para eka prasiddha TippaNI TIkAkAra hai) isa vAtako jAnatA thA ki chaha darzanoM meM se kAI bhI... jaise ki kaI bAra hama pahile anusAra pUrvIya ..... kaha cuke haiM pazcimIya vicAra ke saddhAntika DhaMgakA darzana na thA balki ve kevala eka prazno-tarIke sadRza haiM, jinameM ki sRSTi utpatti saMvadhameM hI vedoM aura upaniSadoMke kisI 2 siddhAntako tarka vitarka rUpameM eka vizeSa prakAra ke ziSyoMkA batAyA hai unako saMsArake gUr3ha viSayoMko samajhAye vinA ho, ki jinako ve apanI mAnasika aura prAdhyAtmika kamiyoke kAraNa samajhane kI yogyatA nahIM rakhate the / " .......

Page #94
(6) missandeha bhUmikAkAra hindU siddhAntake doSoko, usake ziSyoMkI apakva buddhi ke AdhAra para chipAnekA prayatna karatA hai, parantu guruke pUrNa jJAnako siddha karanevAle hetuoMkI anupasthitimeM. baha vyAkhyA buddhi nahIM varana vizvAsa dvArA prerita kI huI hI mAnI jA saktI hai / imako pratipAdanakI yathArthatA se koI sambandha nahIM hai, kintu mUla siddhAntakI yogyatAse hai,. aura unake yatheSTa na honeke vAgmeM to sApha 2 savAla hai| 'pramANa'ke upAyoM (jarAyo) ke viSayame bhI ina dImi ekamattA nahIM hai / vaizepikoMke matAnusAra pratyakSa aura anumAna (Observation and inference ) hI kevala mAnanIya pramANa hai, naiyAyika loga ina donoke atirimata zabda (Agama ) va upamA ko aura bar3hAte hai, aura mImAMsaka loga 'pardhApatti' (Coro-- Ilary or inference by implication) aura kabhI 2 'anu. upalabdhi' (Inference by negation ) ko bhI zAmila karate hai / parantu TapamAna ( analogy ) vAstavameM sivAya eka prakAra ke 'anumAnAmAma' ( fallacy of inference ) ke aura kucha nahIM hai, aura 'arthApatti' ( corollary) anaupalandhi sace nyAya saMgata anumAnameM garmita hai| zeSake tIna prAMta pratyakSa ( direct observation ) 999ra (inferenc' ) SI TITA ( relrable testimony ) sAdhAraNatayA matyamAneke mukhya upAya haiM, bAvajUda isake nicazeSika yAgamako nahIM mAnate haiM, kyoMki vizvasanIya zAtI hI una vastuoM ke zAna prAlikA dvAra hai jo

Page #95
'pratyakSa aura anumAna ( perception and inference ) donoMse pare hai| vilA zubahA sAMkhyadarzanameM aha tImo pramANa mAne hai magara vaha vedoMkI abhrAntiko sAdhAraNa hI mAna letA hai aura usakI anumAna saMbaMdhI vidhiyoM meM upamAna bhI garmita hai jaise isa udAharaNameM ki saba Amake vRkSoMme vaura avazya lagA hogA kyoki eka vRttame vora lagA huA dikhAI detA hai (dekho mi0 TIkArAma tAtiyAkA agarejI anuvAda prakAza kiyA huAsAMkhya kArikA aMgarejI anuvAda pRSTha 30) / isa hisAvale to eka kutteko duma kaTI dekha kara yaha pariNAma bhI nikala sakatA hai ki saba kutte dumoko paTanAte hoNge| ___ atha hama tatvAMke viSayako lete haiM jinakA Thoka nirNaya liye 'binA siddhAnta yA dharmameM saphalatA nahIM ho skii| tatvoMkA bhAva unho mukhya bAtoM yA niyamose hai jinake dvArA anusaMdhAna ke viSayakA adhyayana kiyA jAtA hai, aura usakA nirNaya buddhimattAnusAra karanA Avazyakoya hai arthAt veDhaMge torase nahIM paraMtu vaijJAnika DhaMgake phAyadA karonAke mutAvika, kyoMki dharmakA uddeza aura abhiprAya jIvoMkI umati aura AtataH mukti meM hai isaliye usakI khoja bhAtmAke guNoM aura una kAraNoke, jo usakI svAbhAvika svatantratA ora zaktiko ghaTA dete haiM aura jo usako siddhi prAptike yogya kara dete haiM, nirNaya karaneke liye hotI hai| sacce tatva isa kAraNa vahI haiM jo jaina siddhAnta -meM varNita haiM arthAta jIva ajIva ityAdi zeSa to tatvAbhAsa

Page #96
( 87 ) haiM jo vAstavame asatya haiM magara tatvakA vastra pahine hue haiN| ina bAtoMko manameM rakha kara hama isa bAtakA mirNaya kareMge ki paT darzanoM ko kahAM taka sacce tatyoMkA patA lgaa| prathama hI sAMkhya darzana meM nimna 25 tatvoMkA varNana hai (1) puruSa (jIva ) (2) prakRti, jisameM tona prakArakA guNa, satva (buddhi) rajas, (kriyA) namas (sthUla ) sammilita haiM / ( 3 ) madata, jo puruSa aura prakRti ke saMyogale utpanna. honA hai ( 4 ) ahaMkAra / ( 5-6 ) paJca jJAna-indriyAM / ( 10-14 ) paJca karma indriyAM - hAtha, pAMca, vacana, liGga, gudA / (14-16) pAca prakArakI indriya uttejanA - sparza, rasa Adi jo pAca indriyoMse sambandha rakhatI haiM / ( 20 ) mana / ( 21-05 ) pAMca prakArake sthUla bhUta-AkAza, vAyu, agni, apa, pRthvI / " inameM se pahile dona to sadaiva haiM zeSa 23 unake saMyo gase vikAza pAte haiN| isa tatya-gaNanAkI yogyatA isa kAvila nahI hai ki jisakI buddhi prazaMsA kara sake kyoMki tatvapana una

Page #97
( 88 ) jaise pahile ho. do meM kucha thor3AsA jhalakatA hai / kAla gaura AkAza jaise bar3e mukhya padArthoMko yaha vicArameM nahIM lAtI jaba - ki sAdhAraNa vastuoM jaise karma-indriyoMko inameM alaga sthAna diye gaye haiN| isa bAtakA bhI patA nahI calatA ki unakA cunAva kisa AdhAra para kiyA gayA hai kyoMki isI prakAra ke bahutase bhAvazyakIya kArya jaise pAcana kriyA, rudhiHkA saMcAlana ityAdi - bilkula choDa diye gaye haiN| yaha pUrNa darzana dharma, AvAgamana aura, mukikI vaijJAnika aura pUrNatayA vRddhi anusAra vyAkhyA samajhI jAtI hai to bhI isa viSaya meM kisI bAnake samajhAnekA prayatna nahIM kiyA gayA hai; aura AdhyAtmika vidyAkA yaha sampUrNa vibhAga tatvoMme hone ke kAraNa vilakSaNa pratIta hotA hai / naiyAyika loga misna 16 tatvoM ko mAnate haiM / ( 6 ) nirNaya (10) vAda (11) jalpa ( 12 ) vitaNDA (13) hetvAbhAsa (14) chala (15) jAti ( 1 ) pramANa (2) prameya ( 3 ) saMzaya ( 4 ) prazA (5) draSTAnta ( 6 ). siddhAnta ( 7 ) avayava (8) sarka (16) nigrahasthAna - vahAM bhI eka dRSTi isa bAta ke bodha ke liye yatheha hai ki J yaha tatva kevala nyAyakA jJAna karA sakate haiN| parantu nyAya

Page #98
(89) nissandeha dharma nahIM hai, yadyapi vaha vyAkaraNa, gaNamA aura anya sAinsejakI bhAMti zAnakA eka upayogI vibhAga hai| agara nyAyake niyamoM ko tatva kahA jA sakA hai to hamako vyAkaraNake bhaGgoM-saMzA, kriyA ityAdi-aura gaNita vidyAke niyamoMko bhI tatva kahanA par3egA parantu yaha spaSTatayA vAhiyAta hai| naiyAyika loga isa kaThinAIse apane dUsare tatvake abhiprAyameM bAraha prakAra ke padArthoMko zAmila karanese yavanekI koziza karate haiM arthAt (1) AtmA (2) zarAra (3) zAnaindriya (4) artha ( jisameM rUpa, rasa, gandha, sparza, zabda, garbhita haiM) (5) buddhi (6) mana (7) pravRtti (racana, mana, yA zarIra dvArA upayoga) (8) doSa (jisakA bhAva rAga depa, mithyA jJAna yA mUr3hatA hai) (8) pratyeka bhAva (punarjanma ) (10) phala ( natIjA yA pariNAma ) (19) duHkha ( 12) aparage ( duHkhase chuTakArA ) / parantu pariNAma par3I gar3abaDa hai kyoMki dUsarA natva prameya se sambaMdha rakhanA hai jisameM samasta reya padArtha aura isaliye samasta astitva padArtha antargata haiM aura isa kAraNa vaha bAraha hI padArthoM para sImita nahIM ho sakA hai| isa mAga (kirama) caMdImA niyama viruddha honA, isameM spaSTa hai ki isameM atyaMta AvazyakIya bAtoM jaile prAva, baMdha, saMpara aura nijagapara vilkula dhyAna nahI diyA gayA hai aura aisI apanAnazyakIya yAtoM para jaise sparza rasa ityAdi para AvazyakAse adhika jora diyA gayA hai| jalpa, vitaNDA aura chalakA (jAtiko zubhArameM

Page #99
( 6 ), na lene para bhI ) alaga alaga tayoMke taura para kAyama kiyA jAnA sana mAnasika phUhaDapanakI misAla hai / vaizeSika loga nimna padArthoMkA ullekha karate haiM (5) vizeSa (6) samavAya ( 7 ) asAva " " sAmAnya parantu yaha bhAga bandI tatva-gaNanA nahIM hai valki arastU aura milake tarIkoMke sadRza eka prakArakI vibhAga bandI hai cunAMce mejara pI0 DI0 vAluke prakAza kiye hue kaNADake vaizeSika sUtroM kI bhUmikA ke yogya lekhakane isa bAta ko apanA saccA kartavya samajhA ki isa darzana ke doSoMke liye pAThakale kSamA mAMge / vaha likhatA hai : (1) dravya (2) guNa karma ( 3 ) ( 4 ) 1 7 "vaizeSika darzana padArthoMko eka vizeSa aura pUrNa nizcita dRSTise dekhatA hai / yaha una logoMkI vicAra dRSTi hai jinake * liye kaNADake upadeza banAye gaye the| isa kAraNa vaha eka ( utanA pUrNa va svatantra vicAroMkA darzana nahIM hai jitanA ki vaha vaidika aura anya prAcAna RSiyoMkI jo kaNADake samaya ke pUrva gujare haiM zikSAkI, usakI utpattike upakaraNoM ke lihAz2a se vRddhi yA prayoga hai / " vaizeSikoMkI tatvagaNanAkA Arambha vAstava meM aura karmako bhAgabaMdI se honA kahA jA saktA hai / dravya, guNa, dravya nau ha

Page #100
(61) prakArake kahe jAte haiN| (1-4) cAra prakArake arthAt pRthvI, apa, agmi va vAyuke paramANu (5) AkAza (6) kAla (7) dika (8) jIvAtmA (8) mana / guNa ninna prakArake haiM arthAt rUpa, rasa, gaMdha, sparza saMkhyA, nApa, prathakanA, saMyoga, vibhAga, pUrvakatA, pazcAn, samajha, sukha, duHkha, icchA, deSa, aura prytn| paraMtu zabda AkAzakA guNa kahA gayA hai| karma pAMca prakArakA hai, arthAt ukSepana ( UparaphI ora pheMkanA) avakSepana (nIcekI ora pheMkanA) AkuJcana ( sikuDanA) prasAgnam (phailAnA ) aura gamanam (calanA) isa prakArako saMkhyA dravya, guNa aura kmakI hai jo vaizeSikoM ne dI hai, parantu vahAM bhI hamako sacce tatvoMke varNanako kSoM koziza nahI milatI hai| kula vidhi atyanta anizcita aura vehaMgI hai| sAmAnya pariNAma doSapUrNa hai / karmokI bhAgavandI mathaDIna aura guNoM kA varNana mahA aura aniyamita hai| ghAyu, apa agni aura pRthvI cAra bhinna dranya nahIM haiM. varan ekahI dravya prathAt pudgalake cAra bhinna rUpa hai, aura zabda ItharakA guNa nahIM hai caran eka prakArakA Andolana hai jo paudgalika paTAgauke hilane julanase paidA hotA hai| manako eka naye prakArakA dravya mAnanA bhI spaSTa rItise yuktisaMgata nahIM hai, kyoki jIva maura pudagalale prathaka mana koI anya padArtha nahIM hai| isa prakAra hindU middhAnake tIna aniprasiddha darzana saMdhAna hIna ki rahina vicArako pragaTa karate hai aura pUrNa ronise

Page #101
( 12 ) nyAyayukta kahalAne ke adhikArI nahIM haiN| zeSake tIna arthAt yoga, vedAnta aura jaimimanIke mImAMsAkI bhI dazA isa sambandhameM kucha inase acchI nahIM hai| vaha tatva AdhAra para nirdhArita nahIM haiM aura isaliye una para dhyAna denekI yahAM hameM AvazyakatA nahIM hai 1 nikaTastha kAlameM kucha logoMne advaita vedAntako jisako zikSA yaha hai ki brahma paddakI prAptike liye kevala brahmakA jAnanA ho AvazyakIya hai, atizaya mahatvapUrNa mAnA hai / magara vedAntI yaha nahIM batA saktA hai ki brahmake jAnane parabhI vaha ava taka brahma kyoM nahIM ho gayA / yadi yaha siddhAnta vaijJAnika vicArake AdhAra para analambita hotA to yaha samajhA liyA gayA hotA ki jJAna aura siddhi do bhinna bAteM haiM, bAvajUda isake ki AtmA ke ucca AdarzakI siddhike prArambhake liye jJAna atyanta Avazyakoya hai / yahAM bhI hamako jainamata zikSA detA hai ki satya-mArga sampa gdarzana, samyagjJAna, samyakcAritra rUpa hai parantu inameM se koI bhI prathaka taura para mArga nahIM hai / pataJjali bhI apanI zakti ko sAmAnya bAtoMke varNanameM vyaya kara dete hai aura AtmA ke svarUpa aura bandhanako nahIM batalA sakte haiM aura na vaha apane hI mArgako jisako vaha zrAtmA aura pugdula ke aniSTa saMyoga ko dUra karane ke liye sikhalAte hai kA kAraNa rUpase darzA sakke hai / 1

Page #102
_