Page #1
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ kevali paNNatto dhammo maMgalam dharmamaMgala. samyak samyaktva carcA vizeSAMka (Agama-adhyAtma ke Aloka meM) prastuti -bra. hemacaMda jaina 'hema' (bhopAla) dvitIya AvRtti - dhuvadhAma - bA~savADA ke saujanya se
Page #2
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ pa. pU. zrI 108 adhyAtma yogI vIra sAgarajI mahArAz2a janma 5 maI 1940 - akalUja, yama sallekhanA - 10 mArca 1993-kuMthalagiri
Page #3
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ 20 vIM sadI ke prathamAcArya kevali paNNatto dhammo maMgalam dharmamagala. ATE samyak samyaktva carcA vizeSAMka (Agama-adhyAtma ke Aloka meM) prastotA bra. hemacaMda jaina 'hema' kahAna nagara, lAma roDa devalAlI (nAsika) mahArASTra pa.pU.cAritra cakravartI AcArya 108zrI zAMtisAgarajI mahArAja parama saMrakSaka. dvitIya AvRtti - dhruvadhAma - bA~savADA ke sahayoga se 1000 pratiyA~ sva. bra. hIrAlAla khuzAlacaMda dozI mAMDave, solApura. jaina dhArmika va sAmAjika prabodhana kA nirmIka marAThI aura hiMdI mAsika di. 2 navaMbara 2009 saMpAdikA- prA. sau. lIlAvatI jaina 1, salIla apArTa., 57 sAnevADI, auMdha-puNe (mahArASTra) 411007 phona- 020- 2588 7793
Page #4
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ mAno yA na mAnI / prA. sau.lIlAvatI maina. jaina dhArmika samAja meM jitanI upajAtiyA~,usase adhika paMtha bhedoM kI bharamAra ho gayI hai| isase AgamapraNIta vacanoM meM,arthoM meM bhI heraphera hone lage haiN| eka tarapha nAre lagAye jAte haiM, 'siddhAMtoM se koI samajhautA nahIM ! sarvajJa praNIta vacanoM ke Age kucha nhiiN| Agama hI satya hai| Agama meM bhUla nahIM honI caahie| ...' i. i. ....jI hA~! hameM bhI yahI saba kucha maMjUra hai| patA nahIM kauna sahI hai,kauna galata?AgamapraNIta vacanoM kA artha lagAnA eka kaThina kAma hai| marmajJa hI usakA marma jAna sakatA hai| Akhira Agama ko jAnane kA sAdhana graMtha hI haiM / aba . graMthoM ke bAre meM bhI bar3e vivAda mace hue haiN| phalA~ graMtha AgamapraNIta hai hI nahIM ! kahakara kucha graMtha bahiSkRta bhI ho jAte hai| a kahatA hai ba AgamapraNIta nahIM hai, galata hai| ba kahatA hai- maiM hI sahI hU~ a galata hai| becArA Ama AdamI ulajhana meM par3a jAtA hai|aagm ko samajhanA bhI eka samasyA hai| kyoM ki graMthoM-zabdoM kA hI sahArA lenA par3atA hai aura zabda to pudgala kI paryAya hai| vaktA/lekhaka ke,jIva ke sAre bhAva zabdoM meM kahA~ vyakta ho pAte hai? phira hama saMsArI jIvoM ke jJAna ke ughAr3a kI bhI pAmaratA hai| kucha puruSArtha kI bhI kamI hai| jisane jitanA samajhA, jisa dRSTi se, jisa naya se samajhA, usakI najara meM vahI sahI hotA hai| kahIM hama sAre sAta aMdhe to nahIM hai?eka eka hI avayava pakar3akara usI ko hAthI samajha rahe haiM? kyA anekAMta se aisA mAne leM ki yaha bhI sahI ho sakatA hai aura vaha (sahI)bhI ho sakatA hai? samasyA yaha hai ki,avirata samyagdRSTi ko-caturtha guNasthAna meM-zuddhopayoga/zuddhAtmA - nubhUti hotI hai yA nahIM?koI kahatA haiM, hoto hai, unhoMne anekoM pramANa Agama graMthoM se nikAlakara dikhaaye| ve bhI to pUrvAcAryoM ke graMthoM se hI uddhRta haiM na ? koI use nahIM maantaa| ve bhI apane pramANa batAte haiN|.. aba samasyA yaha hai ki kyA Agama meM donoM bAteM haiM? aisA kaise ho sakatA haiM? satya to ekahI hai aura vahI Agama hai| to kaunasA sahI mAnA jAye? ___ koI kahatA hai ki inake pahale pUrvAcAryoM ne aisA-aisA likhA thaa| ye to bAdameM hue haiN|'....to kyA itihAsa ke paravartI kAla meM likhA graMtha prAmANika nahIM ho sakatA? kevala itihAsa kI prAcInatA hI prAmANika mAna lI jAye? pUrvakAla meM aura paravartI kAla meM jo graMtha likhe gaye ve bhI to una saMsArI jIvoM ne hI likhe haiM, inake yA unake jJAna ke ughAr3a ke pUrNatA kI kyA koI kasauTI hai? ve bhI to bhASA ke mAdhyama se bhAvAnuvAdaka mAtra the / kyA sAre bhAva unakI pakar3a meM Aye hoMge?agara unase mUla meM kahIM bhAva pakar3ane meM bhUla ho gayI ho to vahI bhUla paraMparA ke pravAha meM cala par3I? kadAcit bar3hatI gayI? to phira kasauTI bhAva pakar3ane kI honI cAhie yA prAcInatA kI? kyA vastu satsvarUpa kA, satyatA kA nirNaya kevala kAla ke AdhAra para ho sakatA hai? taba yaha, socane para majabUra honA par3egA ki kiso
Page #5
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ bhI kAla meM , kisI ke jJAna kA ughAr3a kitanA hai? hA~ ! kAla kI kasauTI vahA~ lI jA sakatI hai jahA~ mUla zuddha ugama-pravAha meM milAvaTa kahA~ se AyI? prathama kisane kI? yaha jaba khojanA ho taba vahA~ itihAsa kI,kAla kI kasauTI upayukta siddha ho sakatI hai| bhASAe~ bhI to kaI prakAra se badalatI gayI, jo anekoM saMdarbho meM kabhI isa pakSa meM to kabhI usa pakSa meM buddhi ko lagAne meM nimitta banatI rahatI hai| saMskRta, prAkRta aura Aja kI kaI bhASAe~ ! unake artha lagAnA bhI kitanA muzkila ho jAtA hai? prAcIna bhASAoM ke vidvAnoM meM bhI artha lagAne kI samasyA para ekamata nahIM hotA / Aja bhI kucha vidvAna agara yaha mAnate haiM ki vyavahAra pahale hotA hai, nizcaya bAda meM hotA hai| kareM to kyA kareM? aisI samasyA jaba nirmANa ho jAtI hai taba yaha soca liyA jAtA hai ki jo sarvajJa praNIta/kathita hai usapara zraddhA/ vizvAsa kara lenA caahie| paraMtu kucha graMthoM meM sarvajJa kathana ke nAma para jo mata prakAzita kiye gaye haiM unameM bhI kahI-kahIM aMtara dikhAyI detA hai / taba aprayojanabhUta tattvoM ke bAre meM bhale hI sarvajJa kathita vacana ko pramANa mAna leM, paraMtu prayojanabhUta tattvoM ke mata-matAMtaroM para to sarvajJa kathita ke nAma-AdhAra para A~kheM mUMdakara zraddhA yA vizvAsa nahIM kiyA jA sktaa| kyoM ki ve kuMdakuMda jaise pUrvAcArya bhI kahate haiM ki sarvajJoM ne jo kahA hai vahI maiM kahatA hU~ paraMtu usakA bhI svIkAra tuma parIkSA karake, svayaM anubhUti karake hI kro| jaba jJAnI janoM ko parIkSApradhAnI hokara prAmANya yA anumAnoM para hI dRSTi jamAnI par3atI hai aura jaba graMtha ke pramANa yA artha ke anumAna bhI kAma nahIM Ate aura prazna anuttarita raha jAte ho to anubhava ko pramANa mAnanA hI eka mAtra sAdhana baca jAtA hai| arthAt yaha anubhava sarvajJa praNIta vacanoM ke AdhAra para parIkSA pradhAnatA se karane meM hI vastusvarUpa ke satyatA kA nirNaya ho sakatA hai| taba jinako anubhava huA ve apane anubhavoM kA AdhAra leM, jinake kevala sarvajJa praNIta vacanoM kA yA graMthoM kA hI Azraya ho, aura apane anubhavoM meM bAta na utareM, unakA samAdhAna anubhava prAptoM ke sAtha kyA kabhI ho sakatA hai? taba to ve kaheMge ki kyA pramANa hai ki Apako * anubhava ho gayA hai? to usakA javAba yaha hai ki caturtha guNasthAna meM atyalpa, aMzamAtra kyoM na ho, zuddhopayoga/zuddhAtmAnubhUti hoto hai jo jAti apekSA se usI pUrNa anubhUti ke samAna hai| 'nahIM hoto' kahane vAle bhale hI kucha kahe, para hoto hai' kahane vAloM ke pAsa bhI anekoM pramANa hai| mokSamArga prakAzaka 7 ve adhikAra meM kahA gayA hai ki-jo Apta bhAsita zAstra(pramANa) haiM unameM koI bhI kathana pramANa virUddha nahIM hotaa| kyoM ki yA to jAnapanA hI na ho yA rAga-dveSa ho taba asatya kheN| so Apta aise hote nahIM hai| tUne bhalI prakAra parIkSA nahIM kI isalie bhrama ... aba savAla yaha hai ki bhrama-kisa ko hai? hamAre alpamatI ke anusAra isa vivAda meM saba se mahatvapUrNa nirNAyaka sAdhana bhASA-zabda na hokara bhAva hai| anubhUti-bhAva-kA viSaya hai| zabdoM ke-bhASA ke saMdarbha pakar3akara artha nikAlane meM ulajhanA hotA hai, zabdoM ko
Page #6
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ tor3Amaror3A jAtA hai| manacAhe artha nikAle jAte haiN| donoM mata apanI haThadharmitA ko pakar3a- kara baiThate haiN| isase to ucita yahI hai ki anubhUti kI, bhAva kI bAta pakar3akara dekha liijie| jinako hotI hai, hotI hai basa, ve hAthapara rakhe A~vale kI bhA~ti nikAlakara to nahIM batA sakate, na hI usakA zabdoM meM varNana kara sakate hai| pariNAmoM se prApta zAMti cehare para phailI dikhAyI detI hai| bolacAla, khAna pAna meM, vyavahAra meM samatA, zAMti jhalakatI hai| kaSAya meM maMdatA baratatI hai| isapara se jAno, mAno to mAno, na mAno to ApakI marjI !anubhUti kA viSaya to aisA hai jisako anubhUti hotI hai,vaha usake hI anubhUti kA viSaya hai| jisake hRdaya meM jo bhAva basate haiM,vahI unako jAna sakate haiM ,yA sarvajJa jAna sakate hai ! kisIke hA~ yA nA kahane se vaha satya yA asatya nahIM ho sktaa| yaha to eka ananubhUta AnaMda kI upalabdhi hai| 'jina DhU~DhA tina pAIyA gahare pAnI paiTha ! aura paiTha ke lie parizrama,sAdhanA kI jarUrata hai| eka maMdirajI meM eka mahArAja Aye / unhoMne jo artha batAye, dusare mahArAja Aye to unhoMne una sabhI saMdarbho ko galata karAra diyaa| koI kahane lagA,zAstrasabhA karAie, tattvacarcA se apane Apa nirNaya ho jAtA hai| Ajakala pahale jaisI dharmasabhAe~ bhI to nahIM hotI, khaMDana-maMDana nahIM hotaa| agara hotA bhI hai to nirNaya laganA kaThina ho jAtA hai| nirNaya laga bhI gayA to bhI hama nahIM maaneNge|'vaalii haThadharmitA kA bhI bolabAlA hai hI! ___koI kahate haiM, caturtha guNasthAna meM zuddhopayoga nahIM hotA' aisA mAnane vAloM kA bahumata hai| para kyA bahumata kisI siddhAMta ke nirNaya kI kasauTI ho sakatA hai? koI isa nirNaya para pahu~cate haiM ki 'jisako jo ThIka lage,karo, para jhagaDe bar3hAkara phUTa to mata pADo / hA~,unheM samajhAyA jA sakatA hai| apane haka meM manavAyA nahIM jA sktaa|' ___ koI kahatA hai, samAja meM aura bhI kaI samasyAe~ hai| jinake lie hame eka, saMgaThita hokara rahane kI mahati AvazyakatA hai| kAla bar3A kaThina cala rahA hai| aise meM mithyAtva, maMtrataMtra,anAcAra,zithilAcAra,bhraSTAcAra kaI prakAra ke AcAra ! maMdiroM ke jhagar3e, lobha, svArtha ke zikArI ! mAnava ne mAnava ko aura mAnava ko prakRti ne bhI khUba satAyA hai| kyA sAdhu kyA zrAvaka, u~galI para ginane jitane cAritra bace haiM jinake sAmane natamastaka hone ko mana karatA hai| ataH jhagar3e miTAo !... yaha bAta to samAja hita kI apekSA kahIM ThIka lagatI bhI hai| ___ hama socate haiM, ina viSama sthitiyoM meM hameM bhraSTAcAra miTAne ke lie aura sadAcAra ke utthAna/sudhAra ke lie eka zuddhopayoga hI Azraya hai| tAki ina viSama paristhitiyoM meM hama apane Apako apane dharmAdhAra se sambhAla skeN| AtmakalyANa kA dUsarA koI mArga nahIM hai| kama se kama koI zuddhopayoga se apane Apa ko durusta karatA hai to avazya karane dIjie na! Aja cAroM tarapha mithyAtva kA jo pradUSaNa phailA hai usase zuddhopayoga kA bhAva to kahIM adhika U~cAI para hI le jAne vAlA hai na? pahale mithyAtva, bhraSTAcAra, anAcAra, terA-merA paMtha ke jhagar3e, arthalipsA, svArtha ke Sar3ayaMtroM se to nibaTie na! zuddhopayoga hotA hai yA nahIM isa viSaya meM ulajhane se kahIM adhika apanI zaktiyA~ bhraSTAcAra se nibaTane meM lagAnA jarUrI
Page #7
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ hai| zuddha Atmadharma jAnane-mAnane vAloM ko aba ApasI matabheda bhulAkara aba azuddha kA / mithyAtva kA iMTakara mukAbalA karanA hogaa| hamArA siddhAMta bho aMta meM AtmA kI anubhUti para jAkara pahuMcatA hai| agara Apa kI najara meM anubhUti hotI hI nahIM to kevala AtmA kI bAta karanA bhI to AgamapraNIta hai na? to karane dIjie na ! AtmAnubhUti kA citra dekhakara hI kyoM na ho, usa nimitta se bhAva to AyeMge hI na ! pariNAma to badaleMge na ! Ara zuddhAtmAnubhUti hotI hai vaisA kahie, yA vaisA kahane dIjie ki apUrva avasara evo kyAre Avaze?' yoM samajha lIjie ki chaha dravya,sAta tattvoM kI samajhapUrvaka mithyA pariNAmoM se ve baca hI rahe haiM na ! yaha bhI kyA kama hai? vItarAgasvarUpa zuddhopayogako prApta karane ke lie yaha saMsArI jIva dharma,mokSa kA udyama kareM to kama se kama mithyA udyama to chUTegA na?kama se kama yaha socakara dekheM ki Apasa meM vivAda karane ke sthAna para Aja kama se kama zuddha AtmA kI bAta karane vAloM ko eka hokara mithyAtva,anAcAra kA u~Takara mukAbalA karanA atyaMta Avazyaka hai| kama se kama tattva matabhedoM ke nAma para hama eka dUsare kA virodha to na kreN|uske lie pahale hameM ApasI ina matabhedoM ko alaga rakhanA hogaa| ataH pU. A. vidyAnaMdajI ko nIti ThukarAvo mata gale lgaao|'ke svIkAra karane kI Aja atyAdhika AvazyakatA hai| ___ isI AtmAnubhUti ke saMdarbha meM anekoM pramANa peza kiye gaye haiN| phira bhI isa viSaya para anekoM zaMkAe~ bhI upasthita kI gayI hai| Agama kahatA hai ki ajJAna bhrama kI jananI hai| ataH hama jAnate haiM ki aba isa viSayapara kucha kahane kA koI upayoga nahIM hogA phira bhI itanA socakara bhI hama eka bAra prayAsa aura karanA cAheMge avazya ! kyoM ki Age javAba aura bhI hai| dekhie, itanA Apane bhI socA hai, aura thoDA soca liijie| agara ucita lage to mAnane se mata cuukie| hamArI galatI hai to hama bhI mAnane se nahIM cuukeNge| ____ muni vizuddhasAgarajI (ziSya virAMgasAgarajI)solApura meM isa viSaya para apane mata rakha rahe haiN|ek bAra bhAI paM.bra.hemacaMdajI jaina (bhopAla)hamase milane aaye| unase isa viSaya para kAphI carcA huii| paM.zrI ratanalAlajI bainAr3A se unakI jo patravyavahArAtmaka carcA huI unhoMne batAyI, hamane bhI pddh'ii| unhoMne jo bhI kucha saMdarbha diye jo sabake par3hane yogya lge| ataH isa pustikA ke mAdhyama se sabake sAmane rakhane kA bhAva huaa| AzA hai sabhI adhyAtma ke marmajJa, rasika ina vicAroM kA vItarAga bhAva se svAgata kreNge|aapke isa viSaya para abhiprAya se avazya avagata karAyeMge tAki hama bhI apane bhAva adhika nirmala banA skeN| hama kisI bhI AcArya yA munirAjoM kA, vidvAnoM, paMDitoM kA avamAna nahIM karanA caahte| unake prati pUrNa Adara, bhAva hai| na hi apane matoM kI sthApanA kA Agraha hai, hamAre vicAra meM zuddha dharma ko mAnanevAle saba eka To, basa, itanA kahanA cAhate haiN| pramANaaura bhI bahuta haiM: jarA inheM bhI dekha lenA cAhie / ho sakatA hai ki Apake bhAva badala jAyeM yA agara hamArI dRSTi meM kahIM kamiyA~ hai to hama sudhAra leMge,Aie, ApakA svAgata hai eka svastha/vItarAga carcA ke lie,Atmadharma ke viSaya para ekamata hone ke lie ! phira mAno yA na mAno,marjI ApakI!
Page #8
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ satyameva jayate nAnRtam bra. hemacaMda jaina, 'hema',bhopAla samaya evaM satya donoM mahAkImatI hai| Aja Apa samaya ko barbAda kara rahe haiM, kala samaya Apako barbAda kare degaa| isalie he baMdhu ! Apa apane samaya kA sadupayoga evaM prabaMdhana apane dhana kI taraha kreN| samaya ke sadupayoga se samayasAra kI prApti hotI hai| tathA samaya ke durupayoga se zuddha saMsAra kI prApti hotI hai| ___ satya-asatya kahA~ hotA hai? kisameM hotA hai? vicAra kIjie-dhArmika dRSTikoNa se yA vastusvabhAva se dekheM to koI bhI vastu sat yA asat nahIM hotii| isa udA. se samajheM ki-'yaha ghaTa hai| isameM tIna prakAra kI sattA hai| ghaTa'nAmaka padArtha kI sattA hai| ghaTa ko jAnane vAle 'jJAna' kI sattA hai aura ghaTa 'zabda' kI bhI sattA hai| isI prakAra 'paTa' nAmaka padArtha,usako jAnane vAle jJAna evaM paTa zabda kI bhI jagata meM sattA hai| jinakI sattA hai, ve sabhI satya hai, ina tInoM kA sumela ho to jJAna bhI satya, vANI bhI satya, aura vastu to satya hai hI ! kiMtu jaba vastu, jJAna aura vANI kA sumela na ho-mu~ha se bole 'paTa',aura izArA kareM ghaTa' kI ora, to vANI asatya ho jaayegii| isI prakAra sAmane to ho 'ghaTa' aura hama use jAne paTa,to jJAna asatya (mithyA) ho jaayegaa| vastu to asatya hone se rhii| vaha to kabhI asatya ho nahIM sktii| vaha to sadA hI sva-svarUpa se hai ,pararUpa se nahIM hai| ____ ataH siddha huA ki asatya vastu meM nahIM hotaa| balki use jAnane vAle jJAna meM,yA kahane vAlI vANI meM hotA hai| ataH maiM to kahatA hU~ ki ajJAniyoM ke jJAna, zraddhAna aura vANI ke atirikta loka meM asatya kI sattA hI nahIM hai| sarvatra satya kA hI sAmrAjya hai| vastutaH jagata pIlA nahIM hai, kiMtu hameM pIliyA ho gayA hai, ataH jagata pIlA dikhAyI detA hai| isIprakAra jagata meM to asatya kI sattA hI nahIM hai,para asatya hamArI dRSTi meM aisA samA gayA hai ki vahI jagata meM dikhAyI detA hai| sudhAra bhI jagata kA nahIM, apanI dRSTi kA, apane jJAna kA karanA hai| satya kA utpAdana nahIM karanA hai| satya to hai hii| jo jaisA hai vahI satya hai| use sahI jAnanA hai, mAnanA hai| sahI jAnanA-mAnanA hI satya prApta karanA hai aura Atma satya ko prApta kara moha-rAga-dveSa kA abhAva kara vItarAgatA rUpa pariNati honA hI +satya dharma hai| . yadi maiM paTa ko paTa kahU~ to satya, kiMtu paTa ko ghaTa kahU~ to asatya hai, jhUTha hai| mere kahane se paTa-ghaTa to nahIM ho jaayegaa| vaha to paTa hI rhegaa| vastu meM jhUTha ne kahA~ praveza kiyA? jhUTha kA praveza to vANI meM huaa| isIprakAra yadi paTa ko ghaTa jAne to jJAna jhUThA huA,vastu to nhiiN| maiMne.. paTa ko ghaTa jAnA-mAnA yA kahA, isameM paTa kA kyA aparAdha hai? galatI to mere jJAna yA vANI..' meM huI hai| galatI to sadA jJAna yA vANI meM hotI hai| vastu meM nhiiN| isaprakAra yathArtha ko samajhate hue isa udA. se apane satya rUpa kA darzana kreN|
Page #9
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ aba AtmA evaM zarIra para ghaTAkara dekhie| arUpI AtmA eka padArtha hai, vastu ha,vAstavika sattAtmaka dravya hai| rUpI zarIra bhI eka padArtha hai,vastu hai,vAstavika sattAtmaka dravya hai| inako jAnane vAle jJAna kI bhI sattA hai aura unako kahane vAle zabdoM kI bhI sattA hai| inakI sattA hai ataH ye sattAtmaka padArtha satya haiN| aba jo yadi padArtha kA, padArtha ke jJAna kA evaM padArtha ko kahane vAle zabda kA sumela ho jAye to jJAna bhI satya,vANI bhI satya aura vastu/padArtha to satya hai hI ! yahI sva-pA kA vibhedaka jJAna hI bhedajJAna kahalAtA hai aura isa bhedajJAna pUrvaka hI nija , zuddhAtmA kA anubhava pragaTa ho jAtA hai| mukti kA mArga mila jAtA hai, atIndriya AnaMda kI kaNikA pragaTa ho jAtI hai| isI meM lIna rahate-rahate kaivalya sUrya pragaTa ho jAtA hai| sahaja cidAnaMda / | dharmyadhyAna- Agama ke Aloka meM 5 (1)zlokavArtika- jo jo jJAna vaha dhyAna hai|(2) bArasaNupekkhA - (A. kuMdakuMda deva) - suddhava jogeNa puNo dhamma sukkhaM ca hodi jiivss| tahyA saMvarahedU jhANo tti viMcatie NiccaM // 14 // (3)bRhadadravyasaMgraha- gAthA 57- atrAha ziSyaH / adya kAle dhyAnaM naasti| kasmAditi cet uttama sahananAbhAvAddazacaturdaza-pUrvagata shrutjnyaanaabhaavaacc| atra parihAraH - zukladhyAnaM nAsti dhrmydhyaanmstiiti| tathAcoktaM mokSaprAbhRte zrI kuMdakuMdacArya daive:- 'bharahe dussamakAle dhammajjhArNa havei NANissa / taM appasahAvaThie Na hu maNNai so duannnnaanni||1|| ajjAvi tirayaNasuddhA appA jhAUNa lahai iNdttN| loyatiyadevattaM tattha cudA Nivbudi jaMti // 2 // artha-yahA~ ziSya kahatA hai, -isa paMcama kAla meM dhyAna nahIM hai, kyoM ki isa kAla meM uttama saMhanana / kA abhAva hai aura daza tathA caudaha pUrva kA zrutajJAna bhI nahIM hai| samAdhAna-isa kAla meM zukladhyAna nahIM hai, paraMtu dharmyadhyAna hai| zrI kuMdakuMdAcArya deva ne mokSaprAbhRta meM (gAthA 76-77)meM kahA hai ki bharatakSetra meM duHSama nAmaka paMcama kAla meM jJAnI jIva ko dharmyadhyAna hotA hai| vaha dharmyadhyAna AtmasvabhAva meM sthita hone vAle ko hotA hai| jo aisA nahIM mAnatA vaha ajJAnI hai| aba bhI samyagdarzana-jJAna-cAritrarUpa tIna ratnoM se zuddha jIva AtmA kA dhyAnakarake iMdrapada athavA lokAMtika devapada prApta karate haiM aura vahA~ se cayakara (manuSya hokara) mokSa ko prApta karate haiN| (4)kArtikeyAnuprekSA-gAthA 471-472 kI TIkA-dharmo vastusvarUpaM dharmAdanapetaM dharmyadhyAnaM tRtaaym||471|| .......dharmya dharme svasvarUpe bhavaM dharmyaM dhyAnam / / 2 / / artha- dharma yAne vastusvarUpa(vastu kA svabhAva), vastu svarUpa se rahita na ho aisA jo dhyAna usako dharmyadhyAna kahate haiN| dharma ke binA isa dhyAna kA astitva nahIM pAyA jaataa| dharmya yAne nijAtmA ke sva-svabhAvamaya dharma meM hone vAlA vaha dharmyadhyAna hai|
Page #10
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ jijJAsA -samAdhAna -jinabhASita maI 2005 samAdhAna kartA- paM. ratanalAla jI bainAr3A praznakartA- zrImatI jyoti luhAr3e, koparagA~va jijJAsA-kyA caturtha guNasthAna meM AtmAnubhUti hotI hai? samAdhAna - isa prazna kA uttara AcArya jJAnasAgarajI mahArAja ne 'samyaktvasArazatakam' nAmaka graMtha meM bahuta suMdara diyA hai| usI ke anusAra yahA~ likhA jAtA hai| jaba saMjvalana kaSAya kA tIvra udaya na hokara maMda udaya hotA hai,taba yaha jIva apane puruSArtha se usa maMda udaya ko dabAkara yA naSTa karake apane Apa meM lIna ho jAtA hai, usa lIna hone ko AtmAnubhava yA AtmAnubhUti kahate haiN| yahI svarUpAcaraNa cAritra hai| caturtha guNasthAnavartI ko AtmAnubhUti to nahIM hotI magara Atmatattva kA vizvAsa jarUra hotA hai| jaise-kisI vyakti ke tIna putra haiN| jinhoMne namaka kI DelI ko uThAkara khAyA vaha namakIna lgii| phira jaba unako mizrI kI Dele diye to unhoMne unako bhI namaka mAnakara dUra pheMka diyaa| taba pitA ne kahA, yaha namaka nahIM mizrI hai ,evaM namakIna nahIM, mIThI hai| paraMtu putroM ne nahIM maanaa| bAda meM jaba mizrI ke Dele para makkhiyA~ bhinabhinAne lagI namaka ke Dele para makkhiyA~ nahIM gayIM taba pitA ne phira smjhaayaa| tIna putroM meM se eka putra ko phira bhI vizvAsa nahIM huaa| anya do putroM meM se eka putra ne kahA ki pitAjI kaha rahe haiM ataH yaha mizrI hI hogI,mIThI hI hogii| paraMtu tIsare putra ne turaMta mizrI kI DelI ko uThAkara cakhA, aura kahA, ahA, sacamuca mizrI hai, mIThI hai| isI prakAra mithyAdRSTi ko to Atmatattva para vizvAsa hI nahIM hotaa| avirata samyagdRSTi ko AtmavizvAsa mAtra hI hotA hai| paraMtu zukladhyAnI jIva ko AtmAnubhUti athavA AtmAnubhava rUpa AnaMda kI prApti hotI hai| yadi koI gRhastha hote hue bhI apane AtmasvarUpa kA ciMtavana kara rahA ho, jaise maiM zuddha-buddha saccidAnaMda hU~, mere aMdara rAga dveSa vagaireha kucha bhI nahIM hai, to usa samaya bhI usa jIva ke AtmAnubhava nahIM kahA jA sktaa| yaha AdamI to usa bhikhArI kI taraha pAgala hai jo janma se daridra hote hue bhI apane Apa ko cakravartI mAnatA ho| isase to vaha mithyAdRSTi acchA hai jo apane Apako dukhI anubhava karatA huA yaha socatA hai ki yaha dukha mujhe kyoM ho rahA hai? aura yaha kaise naSTa ho sakatA hai? itanA avazya hai ki jo tattvazraddhAnI kabhI gRhasthocita bAtoM kI tarapha se mana ko mor3akara ekasA vicAra kara rahA ho ki maiM svabhAva kI apekSA to siddhoM ke samAna nirvikAra huuN|vrtmaan meM karma saMyoga ke kAraNa bAhya padArthoM meM iSTa-aniSTa kalpanA rUpa vikAra mujha meM ho rahA hai, jise mujhe chor3anA cAhie, ityaadi| to usakA yaha vicAra sadvicAra hai, dharmabhAvanArUpa hai aura maMda lezyA ke hone se hone vAlA yaha pariNAma svarUpAcaraNa yA AtmAnubhUti yA AtmAnubhava meM kAraNa mAnA gayA hai| A. jJAnasAgarajI mahArAja ke uparokta prakaraNa ke anusAra caturtha guNasthAna meM AtmavizvAsa to hotA hai, paraMtu AtmAnubhUti athavA svarUpAcaraNa rUpa cAritra kadApi nahIM hotaa|
Page #11
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ bhopAla di. 24.05.2005 maMgalamaya maMgala karaNa vItarAga vijnyaan| namoM tAhi jAteM bhaye, arahaMtAdi mhaan| AgamaniSTha, AgamavettA, zrIyut paM. ratanalAlajI bainAr3A ko jijJAsu bra. hemacaMdra jaina kA sAdara yathAyogya abhivAdana saha jayajineMdra, darzana vishuddhi| atra svAdhyAyAmRtapAnabalena kuzalaM ttraapystu| maiM jinabhASita kA niyamita pAThaka huuN| isa maI 2005 mAha ke jijJAsA-samAdhAna meM Apa ne avirata samyagdRSTi caturtha guNasthAnavartI ko AtmAnubhUti se rahita AtmavizvAsI mAtra mAnya kiyA hai| vaha bhI pa.pU. jJAna sAgarajI AcArya ke zabdoM meM, na ki pUrvavartI AcAryoM ke zabdoM meN| kAraNa kyA hai? munivara pa.pU.vIrasAgarajI mahArAja (akalUja-solApura) dvArA likhita cAroM anuyogoM ke AdhAra para saMkalita 'avirata samyaktvI ke zuddhAtmAnubhUti kI saMpramANa siddhi' pustikA Apane par3hI hI hogii| tathA unake dvArA likhita 'adhyAtma nyAya dIpikA' bhI par3hI hogii| tathA 'samayasAra tAtparyavRtti TIkA' kA unhIM ke dvArA kRta hiMdI anuvAda bhI par3hA hI hogaa| tatsaMbaMdha meM ApakA kyA kahanA hai? aba mujha jijJAsu kI nimnalikhita jijJAsAoM kA Agama pramANa pUrvaka jo ApakI zailI hai, samAdhAna karane kI kRpA kreN| bhavadIya- bra. hemacaMdra jaina hema', bhopAla dharmyadhyAna-Agama ke Aloka meM (1)mahApurANa- parva 21, zloka 75 - dehAvasthA punaryava na syaaddhyaanoprodhinii| tadavasthA muniAyet sthitvAsitvAdhizayya vA // 75 / / - kisI bhI avasthA meM (baiThe hue, leTe hue, athavA ardhapadmAsana, padmAsana, khaDgAsana) Adi meM dhyAna ho sakatA hai| jaba kabhI upayoga ko aMtaraMga svabhAva ko jAnane meM lagAyeMge | taba AtmAnubhava ho sakatA hai| (2)pravacanasAra gAthA 181 suhapariNAmo puNNaM asuho pAvaM ti bhnnidmnnnnesu| pariNAmo NaNNagado dukkhakkhayakAraNaM smye||181|| artha-para ke prati zubhapariNAma puNya hai aura para ke prati azubha pariNAma pApa hai| para jopariNAmAma dUsaroM ke prati jAtA nahIM aisA (ananya) pariNAma usI samaya duHkhakSaya kA (saMvarapUrvaka nirjarA | kA zuddhAtmAnubhUti kA -paramAnaMda kA- nirAkulatA kA) kAraNa hai aisA kahate haiN|
Page #12
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ . paM. bra.hemacaMdajI jaina dvArA upasthita 19 jijJAsAe~ - jijJAsA 1 - nizcaya-vyavahAra samyagdarzana kA kyA lakSaNa hai? paribhASA batAie / jijJAsA 2 - nizcaya-vyavahAra samyagdarzana eka sAtha hote haiM yA Age pIche? jijJAsA 3 - kyA samyagdarzana kI paryAya nizcaya-vyavahAra do rUpa hotI hai ? jijJAsA 4 - kSAyika samyagdRSTi (zreNika rAjA kA jIva jo vartamAna meM prathama naraka meM haiN|) ko nizcaya samyagdarzana hai yA vyavahAra yA donoM? jijJAsA 5 - aupazamika kSAyopazamika, kSAyika-ina tInoM prakAra ke samyagdRSTiyoM ko kyA (AtmAnubhUti rahita?) AtmavizvAsa eka sadRza hotA hai? yA tInoM ke AtmavizvAsa meM kucha aMtara rahatA hai? jijJAsA 6 - pravacanasAra gAthA 80 (jo jANadi arahataM....)evaM samayasAra gAthA 320 (diTThi jaheva NANaM....) kI zrImad pa.pU.jayasenAcArya viracita tAtparyavRtti TIkAoM meM kramazaH karaNalabdhipUrvaka 'avikalpasvarUpa kI prApti' tathA 'bhavyatva zakti kI vyaktatA' kA svarUpa batalAyA hai| kyA isakA artha mAtra AtmavizvAsa honA hI samyagdarzana mAnA gayA hai? jijJAsA 7 -(a) pravacanasAra gAthA 80 tA.vR. TIkA ke prAraMbha meM likhita 'atha cattA pAvAraMbha (gAthA 79) ityAdi sUtreNa yaduktaM zuddhopayogAbhAve mohAdivinAzo na bhavati, mohAdi vinAzAbhAve zuddhAtma lAbho na bhvti|'...kaa kyA artha hai? jijJAsA 7 - (ba)pravacanasAra gAthA 248 (dasaNaNANuvadeso ...) kara tA.vR. TIkA meM kathita nanu zubhopayoginAmapi kvApikAle...zrAvakANAmapi sAmAyikAdi kAle . zuddha bhAvanA dRzyate, teSAM kathaM vizeSo bhedo jJAyata iti |....bhupdsyprdhaantvaa dAmravana nimbvnvditi|' kA artha khulAsA kreN| jijJAsA 8 - prAyogya labdhi meM, karaNalabdhi meM, tathA anivRttikaraNoparAMta hone vAle AtmA ke vizvAsa meM kyA aMtara hai? jijJAsA 9 - dezavratI zrAvaka evaM avirata samyagdRSTi ke AtmavizvAsa meM kyA kucha pharka hotA hai? kyoM ki Apake anusAra AtmAnubhUti muni/ saMyamI ko hI hotI hai? jijJAsA 10 - Apake hisAba se munirAjoM ko hI AtmAnubhUti hotI hai to gRhavirata zrAvakoM (kSullaka, ailaka, AryikA)ko bhI svAtmAnubhUti nahIM hotI hogI? jijJAsA 11 - jainoM evaM jainetara matAvalambiyoM ke AtmA ke vizvAsa meM kyA kucha aMtara hotA hai? kyoM ki anya matAvalaMbI bhI AtmA ke hone meM vizvAsa rakhate haiN| jijJAsA 12 - vaha AtmA jisakA ki jainoM(samyagdRSTiyoM) ko vizvAsa hotA hai kyA vaha dravyakarma, nokarma (zarIra), bhAvakarma, (moha-rAga-dveSa) se rahita AtmA hotA hai yA inake sahita hotA hai?
Page #13
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ jijJAsA 13 - avirata samyagdRSTi mokSamArgI hai yA nahIM? yadi hai to usake cAritra kaunasA pragaTa huA kahalAyegA? mithyA cAritra bhI usake nahIM hai| jijJAsA 14 - samyaktvAcaraNa (mokSapAhuDa gAthA 5 se 10) evaM svarUpAcaraNa cAritra meM kyA aMtara hai? jijJAsA 15 - mokSamArga meM pragaTa hone vAlA saMvara-nirjarA tattva kyA zubha bhAva rUpa hai yA vItarAgabhAva/zuddha bhAva rUpa hI hai? jijJAsA 16- mithyAdRSTi dravyaliMgI muni jo navaveM graiveyaka taka jAte haiM tathA jinheM 11 aMgoM taka kA jJAna pragaTa ho jAtA hai, kyA unako AtmA kA vizvAsa nahIM hotA? kyA unake saMvara-nirjarA tattva pragaTa hote haiM yA nahIM? jijJAsA 17 - dharmyadhyAna ke svAmI cauthe se sAtaveM guNasthAnavI jIva kahe haiN| taba asaMyamI samyagdRSTi ke bhI cAritra kA aMza pragaTa huA honA cAhie,anyathA (16+25=41) prakRtiyoM kA baMdha nahIM rUkatA?anaMtAnubaMdhI cAritramoha kI prakRti kA anudaya /aprazasta upazama/ kSaya hI kAraNa hai| isa cAritra ke aMza kA nAma Agama meM kahIM kucha AyA ho to spaSTa kreN| jijJAsA 18 - samayasAra gAthA -13 (bhUdattheNAbhigadA...)kI AtmakhyAti TIkA meM.. aMta meM 'evamasAvekatvena dyotamAna shuddhnytvenaanubhuuytev| yA tvanubhUtiH sAtmakhyAtirevAtmakhyAtistu smygdrshnmev| iti samastameva nirvdym|' isakA artha spaSTa kreN| jijJAsA 19 - tattvArthazlokavArtikAlaMkAra prathama khaMDa pRSTha 555 para 'nahi cAritra - mohodayamAtrAdabhavaccAritraM darzanacAritramohodaya janitAdacAritrAdabhinnameveti'sAdhayituM zakyaM sarvatra kAraNa bhedasya phlaabhedktvprskteH| ......siddhAMta virodhaat| ....isake hiMdI artha meM paM. zrI mANakacaMdajI kauMdeya nyAyAcAryajI ne caturtha guNasthAnavartI ko svarUpAcaraNa cAritraM (acAritra meM)kahA hai tathA jaina siddhAMta pravezikA meM paM. gopAladAsajI baraiyA ne prazna 111/112 meM svarUpAcaraNa cAritra kahA hai| kyA Apako yaha mAnya hai? . dhabadhyAna- Agama ke Aloka meM (1)samAdhi zataka -zloka 73-AcArya pUjyapAda - grAmo'raNyamiti dvedhA, nivAso'nAtmadarzinAm / dRSTAtmanAM nivAsastu, viviktAtmaiva nishclH|| artha-mithyAdRSTi kA nivAsa yaha nagara hai aura yaha araNya hai, aisA do prakAra kA hai| samyagdRSTi kA nivAsa eka nizcala sabase bhinna AtmA hai| isa para se siddha hai ki dhyAna vana meM hotA hai, nagara meM yA samudAya meM nahIM hotA aisA durAgraha mithyA hai| aMtardRSTi vAle ko to sirpha nijasvabhAva hI pratIti meM AtA hai, cAhe vaha kahIM bhI ho|
Page #14
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ paM.ratanalAlajI bainAr3A kA patra- paM.hemacaMdajI ke nAma bra. hemacaMdra jI sasneha jayajineMdra, ApakA patra di.24 maI 2005 prApta huaa| vyastatA ke kAraNa javAba kucha derI se de rahA huuN| vAstavikatA to yaha hai ki Agama ko ThIka DhaMga se na samajha pAne ke kAraNa aisI bhrAMtiyA~ svAbhAvika haiN| do varSa pUrva bhI paM. bAbulAlajI iMjiniyara koTA vAle, pU. munizrI sudhAsAgarajI mahArAja ke koTA cAturmAsa meM unake nikaTa Aye the| pU. munizrI ne lagAtAra kaI saptAha taka unakI galata mAnyatAoM kA nirAkaraNa kara unakI bhrAMtiyoM ko, AgamavirUddha mAnyatAoM ko ThIka kiyA thaa| ToDaramala smAraka ke saMbaMdhita vidvAnoM kI saba kI, lagabhaga ve hI eka sI galata dhAraNAe~ haiN| Apane bhI apane patra meM bhI unhIM mAnyatAoM ko jijJAsA ke rUpa meM likhA hai| maiMne yadyapi samasta jijJAsAoM kA saMkSipta samAdhAna saMlagna patra meM diyA hai,paraMtu ina sabhI jijJAsAoM para to khulakara spaSTa vivecanA honI caahie| mujhe atyaMta Azcarya hai ki jinavANI ke saMbaMdha meM apanI mAnyatAoM ke samakSa, pU. AcAryoM ke zAstrIya pramANoM kA apalApa kyoM kiyA jA rahA hai? jinavANI bhakta evaM dharmapipAsu mumukSu kA to kartavya yaha honA cAhie ki Agama meM apanI galata mAnyatA sAbita hone para turaMta hI usa mAnyatA ko jinavANI ke anurUpa banA leN| merI bhAvanA to yaha hai ki hama saba evaM Apa saba vidvAt gaNa, cAturmAsa ke ina dinoM meM pU.A.vidyAsAgarajI mahArAja ke samakSa yA pU. munizrI sudhAsAgarajI ke yA pU. munizrI pramANa sAgarajI ke samakSa uparokta sabhI jijJAsAoM ke vistRta samAdhAna hetu sapramANa upasthita ho| aura apanI mAnyatAoM ko AgamAnusAra parivartana karane kA abhinava prayAsa kreN| yadi pakSa chor3akara aisA kiyA gayA to sabhI saiddhAMtika bhUloM kA nirAkaraNa ho jAyegA tathA sAmAjika ekatA ko bhI aitihAsika saMbala prApta hogaa| __maiM Apase kabhI milA to nahIM hU~, paraMtu Apake jJAna kI carcAe~ aksara sunatA rahatA huuN| Apa jijJAsu haiM, aisA kahA jAtA hai| mujhe pUrNa AzA hai ki Apa mere uparokta sujhAva ko ucita mAnate hue isI cAturmAsa meM pU. AcAryazrI Adi ke nikaTa baiThane ko tithiyA~ nizcita kara mujhe sUcita kreNge| - yaha bhI nivedana hai ki patra kA uttara biMduvAra tathA ArSa Agama pramANa sahita dene kA kaSTa kreN| maMgala bhAvanAoM sahitaratanalAla bainAr3A, 1/205, prophesara kAlonI, AgarA - 282 002
Page #15
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ 15 paM. zrI ratanalAlajI bainAr3A (AgarA) dvArA ukta 19 jijJAsAoM kA samAdhAna jijJAsA 1 - nizcaya vyavahAra samyagdarzana kA kyA lakSaNa hai? paribhASA batAie / samAdhAna - 1. zrI bRhadravyasaMgraha - gAthA 41 kI TIkA meM kahA hai 'evamuktaprakAreNa mUDhatrayamadASTaka SaDayAtana zaGkAdyaSTamalarahitaM zuddhajIvAditattvazraddhAnalakSaNaM sarAga samyaktvAbhidhAnaM vyavahAra samyaktvaM vijJeyam / tathaiva tenaiva vyavahArasamyaktvena pAramparyeNa sAdhyaM zuddhopayogalakSaNa nizcayaratnatrayabhAvanotpanna paramAhlAdekarUpasukhAmRtarasAsvAdanamevopAdeyamindriyasukhAdikaM ca heyamitiM rucirUpaM vItarAga cAritrAvinAbhUtaM vItarAgasamyaktvAbhidhAnaM nizcayasamyaktvaM ca jJAtavyamiti / ' aise isa pUrvokta prakAra se tIna mUr3hatA, ATha mada, chaha anAyatana aura zaMkA Adi ATha doSarUpa se paccIsa mala haiM unase rahita tathA zuddha jIva Adi tattvArthoM ke zraddhAnarUpa lakSaNa kA dhAraka, sarAga samyaktva hai dUsarA nAma jisakA aisA vyavahAra samyaktva jAnanA cAhie aura isIprakAra usI vyavahAra samyaktva dvArA paraMparA se sAdhane yogya, zuddha upayogarUpa nizcaya ratnatraya kI bhAvanA se utpanna jo parama AhlAdarUpa sukhAmRta rasa kI AsvAdana hai vahI upAdeya haiM aura iMdriyajanya sukha Adika heya hai aisI rucirUpa tathA vItarAga cAritra ke binA nahIM utpanna hone vAlA aisA vItarAga samyaktva nAma kA dhAraka nizcaya samyaktva jAnanA caahie| 2. paramAtma prakAza 2/18 kI TIkA meM pR. 132 para isa prakAra kahA haidvidhA samyaktaM bhaNyate, sarAga- vItarAg2a bhedena / sarAgasamyaktvalakSaNaM kathyate / prazama saMvegAnukampAstikyAbhivyakti-lakSaNaM sarAgasamyuktvaMlakSaNaM bhaNyate, tadeva vyavahAra smyktvmiti| tasya viSayabhUtAni SadravyANIti / vItarAga samyaktvaM nijazuddhAtmAnubhUti lakSaNaM vItarAga cAritrAvinAbhUtaM tadeva nizcayasamyaktvamiti / atrAha prabhAkarabhaTTaH / nijazuddhAtmaivopAdeya iti rucirUpaM nizcayasamyaktvaM bhavatItibahudhA vyAkhyAtaM pUrva bhavadbhiH, idAnIM punaH vItarAga cAritrAvinAbhUtaM nizcayasamyaktvaM vyAkhyAtamiti pUrvApAravirodha: kasmAditi cet| nijazuddhAtmaivopAdeya iti rucirUpaM nizcayasamyaktvaM gRhasthAvasthAyAM tIrthaMkaraparamadeva bharatasagararAmapANDavAdInAM vidyate, naca teSAM vItarAga cAritramastIti parasparavirodhaH, asti cettarhiteSAsaMyatattvaM kathamiti pUrvapakSa: / tatra parihAramAha / teSAM zuddhAtmopAdeyabhAvanArUpaM nizcayasamyaktvaM vidyate / paraM kintu cAritramohodayena sthiratA nAsti vratapratijJAbhaGgo bhavatIti tena kAraNenAsaMyatA vA bhnnyte| zuddhAtma bhAvanAcyutaH santaH bharatAdayonirdoSiparamAtmanAmarhatsiddhAnAM guNastavavastustavarUpa stavanAdika kurvanti taccaritapurANAdikaM ca samAkarNayanti tadArAdhakapuruSANAmAcAryopAdhyAyasAdhunAM viSaya -
Page #16
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ kaSAyadurdhyAnavaJcanArthasaMsArasthiticchedanArthaM ca dAnapUjAdikaM kurvanti tena kAraNena zubharAgayogAt sarAgasamyagdRSTayo bhvnti| yA punasteSAM samyaktvasya nizcayasamyaktvasaMjJA vItarAgacAritrAvinAbhUtasya nizcayasamyaktvasya paraMparayA saadhkaatvaaditi| vastuvRttyA tu tatsamyaktvaM sarAgasamyaktvAkhyaM vyavahArasamyaktvameveti bhaavaarthH| samyaktva do prakAra kA hai, eka sarAga samyaktva aura dUsarA vItarAga smyktv| sarAga samyaktva kA lakSaNa kahate haiN| prazama arthAt zAMtipanA, saMvega arthAt jinadharma kI ruci tathA jagata se aruci, anukaMpA arthAt parajIvoM ko duHkhI dekhakara dayAbhAva aura Astikya arthAt deva guru dharma kI tathA chaha dravyoM kI zraddhA ina cAroM kA honA vaha vyavahArasamyaktvarUpa sarAga samyaktva hai| usake viSayabhUta chaha dravya haiN| jo vItarAga samyaktva nijazuddhAtmAnubhUti lakSaNa vAlA aura nizcaya cAritra ke sAtha hotA hai, vahI nizcaya samyaktva hai| yahA~ prabhAkara bhaTTa kahate haiM-nijazuddhAtmA hI upAdeya hai| aisI rUcirUpa nizcaya samyaktva kA kathana pahale tumane aneka bAra kiyA, phira aba vItarAga cAritra se tanmayI nizcayasamyaktva hai, yaha vyAkhyAna karate haiM, so yaha to pUrvApAra virodha hai| kyoM ki jo nija zuddhAtmA hI upAdeya hai aisI rucirUpa nizcaya samyaktva to gRhastha meM tIrthaMkara paramadeva bharata cakravartI aura rAma pANDavAdi bar3e-bar3e puruSoM ke rahatA hai| lekina unake vItarAga cAritra nahIM hai| yahI paraspara virodha hai| yadi unake vItarAga cAritra mAnA jAve to asaMyatapanA kyoM kahA? yaha prazna kiyaa| usakA uttara zrI guru dete haiN| una mahAna bar3e puruSoM ke zuddhAtmA upAdeya hai, aisI bhAvanA rUpa nizcaya samyaktva to hai parantu cAritramoha ke udaya se sthiratA nahIM hai| vrata pratijJA bhaMga hotI hai isa kAraNa se ve taba taka asaMyamI kahalAte haiN| zuddhAtmA kI akhaMDa bhAvanA se rahita hue bharata, sagara, rAghava, pANDavAdika nirdoSa paramAtmA arahaMta siddhoM ke guNastavana vastustavanarUpa stotrAdi karate haiM aura unake cAritra purANAdika sunate haiM tathA unakI AjJA ke ArAdhaka jo mahAna puruSa AcArya,upAdhyAya,sAdhu unako bhakti se AhAra dAnAdi karate haiM ,pUjA karate haiN| viSayakaSAya rUpa khoTe dhyAna ke rokane ke lie tathA saMsAra kI sthiti ke nAza karane ke lie aisI zubha kriyA karate haiN| isalie zubharAga ke saMbaMdha se sarAga samyagdRSTi hai aura inake samyaktva ko nizcayasamyaktva bhI kahA jA sakatA hai, kyoM ki vItarAga cAritra se tanmayI nizcayasamyaktva ke paraMparayA sAdhakapanA hai| vAstava meM vicArA jAveM to gRhastha avasthA meM inake vaha sarAgasamyaktva kahA jAne vAlA vyavahArasamyaktva vyavahAra vyavahAra hI hai aisA jaano| 3. samayasAra gAthA kI TIkA pR. 158 meM isaprakAra kahA haijIvAdinavapadArthAnAM viparitAnibhivezarahitatatvena zraddhAnaM samyagdarzanaM / (tesimadhigamo NANa) teSAmeva saMzayavimohavibhramarahitatatvenAdhigamo nizcayaH parijJAnaM samyagjJAnaM / rAgAdIpariharaNaM caraNaM)teSAmeva sambandhitvena rAgAdi prihaarshcritrN| (eso du mokkhpho|) ityeSa vyvhaarmokssmaargH| athavA teSAmeva bhUtArthenAdhigatAnAM padArthAnAM zuddhAtmanaH
Page #17
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ sakAzAt bhinnatvena samyagavalokanaM nishcysmyktvm| teSAmeva samyakaparicchittirUpeNa zuddhAtmano bhinnatvena nizcayaH smygjnyaanm| teSAmeva zuddhAtmano bhinnatvena nizcayaM kRtvA rAgAdivikalparahitatvena svazuddhAtmanyavasthAnaM nizcayacAritramiti nishcymokssmaargH| ___ jIvAdi navapadArthoM kA viparIta abhiprAya se rahita jo sahI zraddhAna hai vahI samyagdarzana hai| unhIM jIvAdi padArthoM kA saMzaya, vimoha, vibhrama ina tInoM se rahita jo yathArtha adhigama hotA hai nirNaya kara liyA jAtA hai, jAna liyA jAtA hai vaha samyagjJAna kahalAtA hai aura unhIM ke saMbaMdha se hone vAle jo rAgAdika-vibhAva hote haiM unako dUra haTA denA so samyak-cAritra kahalAtA hai| yaha vyavahAra mokSamArga hai| hA~, bhUtArthanaya ke dvArA jAne hue jIvAdi padArthoM ko apanI zuddhAtmA se pRthak rUpa meM ThIka-ThIka avalokana karanA, nizcaya samyagdarzana kahalAtA hai aura unhIM jIvAdi padArthoM ko apanI zuddhAtmA se pRthak rUpa meM jAnanA so nizcayasamyagjJAna hai aura unako zuddhAtmA se bhinna jAnakara rAgAdirUpa vikalpa se rahita hote hue apanI zuddhAtmA meM avasthita hokara rahanA nizcayasamyakcAritra hai| isaprakAra yaha nizcaya mokSamArga huaa| jijJAsA 2 - nizcaya vyavahAra samyagdarzana eka sAtha hote haiM yA Age-pIche? samAdhAna - prazna kra. 1 ke samAdhAna meM yaha spaSTa hai ki vyavahAra samyagdarzana sAdhana hai aura nizcayasamyagdarzana sAdhya hai| isase yaha siddha hai ki vyavahAra samyagdarzana pahale hotA hai aura nizcaya samyagdarzana bAda meN| 1.bRhadrvya saMgraha gAthA 41 kI TIkA meM pR.140 meM isaprakAra kahA hai'atra vyavahArasamyaktvamadhye nizcayasamyaktvaM kimarthaM vyAkhyAtamiti ced-vyavahArasamyaktvena nizcaya samyaktvaM sAdhyata iti saadhysaadhkNbhaavjnyaapnaarthmiti|' / artha-yahA~ isa vyavahAra samyaktva ke vyAkhyAna meM nizcayasamyaktva kA varNana kyoM kiyA jAtA hai? vyavahAra samyaktva se nizcaya samyaktva siddha kiyA jAtA hai| isa sAdhya-sAdhaka bhAva ko batalAne ke lie kiyA gayA hai| 2.-paMcAstikAya gAthA 107 kI TIkA meM A. jayasena ne kahA hai-. 'idaMtu navapadArtha viSayabhUtaM vyavahArasamyaktvaM / kiM viziSTam / zuddhajIvasti-kAyarucirUpasya nizcayasamyaktvasya chadmasthAvasthAyAmAtmAviSayasvasaMvedanajJAnasya paramparayA biijm|' artha-yaha jo navapadArtha kA viSayabhUta vyavahArasamyaktva hai vaha zuddhajIvAstikAya kI rucirUpa jo nizcayasamyaktva hai usakA tathA chadmastha avasthA meM AtmaviSayaka svasaMvedana jJAna kA paraMparA se bIja hai| 3.-zrI pravacanasAra cAritrAdhikAra gAthA-2 kI TIkA meM AcArya amRtacandrasvAmI na isaprakAra kahA hai
Page #18
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ 18 'aho niHzaGkitatvaniHkAMkSitatvanirvicikitsatvanirmUDhadRSTitvopabRMhaNa sthitikaraNa vAtsalyaprabhAvanAlakSaNadarzanAcAra, na zuddhasyAtmanastvamasIti nizcayena jAnAmi tathApi tvAM tAvadAsImiMdAmi yAvat tvatprasAdAt shuddhmaatmaanmuplbhe| artha-aho niHzaGkitatva,niHkAMkSitatva,nirvicikitsatva,nirmUDhadRSTitva,upabRMhaNa,sthiti - karaNa, vAtsalya, prabhAvanA svarUpa darzanAcAra, tU zuddhAtmA kA svarUpa nahIM hai| aisA maiM nizcaya se jAnatA hU~ to bhI tujhako taba taka svIkAra karatA hU~, jaba taka tere prasAda se zuddha AtmA ko prApta ho jaauuN| __ uparokta pramANoM se spaSTa hai ki vyavahAra samyagdarzana pahale hotA hai| taduparAMta vItarAga cAritra kA avinAbhAvI nizcaya samyagdarzana bAda meM hotA hai| jijJAsA 3.- kyA samyagdarzana kI paryAya nizcaya vyavahAra do rUpa hotI hai? . samAdhAna - AcAryoM ne samyagdarzana kI paryAya do rUpa hI mAnI hai| 1.paMcAstikAya gAthA 107 kI TIkA zrI jayasenAcArya ne kahA hai'yadyapi kvApi nirvikalpasamAdhikAle nirvikAra zuddhAtmarucirUpaM nizcayasamyaktvaM spRzati tathApi pracureNa bahiraMgapadArtharucirUpaM yadvyavahAra samyaktva tatsyeva tantra mukhytaa|' isa prakaraNa se spaSTa hai ki nizcaya samyaktva to kabhI-kabhI hotA hai jaba ki vyavahAra pracuratA se rahatA hai| AcAryoM ne vyavahAra samyaktva ko sarAga samyaktva aura nizcaya samyaktva ko vItarAga samyaktva kahA hai| 2. samayasAra gAthA - 211-212 kI TIkA meM (jayasenAcArya jI ne)kahA hai- . 'kiMca-rAgI samyagdRSTi na bhavatIti bhaNitaM bhvdbhiH| tarhi caturtha paMcama guNa sthAnavartinaH tIrthaMkara-kumAra-bharata-sagara-rAma-pANDavAdayaH samyagdRSTayo na bhavanti ? iti / tatra mithyAdRSTyApekSayA tricatvArizaprakRtInAM bandhAbhAvAt sarAgasamyagdRSTayo bhvnti|' . ___Apane kahA ki rAgI samyagdRSTi nahIM hotaa| taba to caturtha paMcamaguNasthAnavartI kumAra avasthA ke tIrthaMkara, bharata, sagara, cakravartI, rAmacaMdra, pANDava, Adi samyagdRSTi nahIM hotA . caahie| samAdhAna- nahIM, yaha bAta nahIM hai| mithyAdRSTi kI apekSA 43 prakAra ke baMdha kA abhAva hone se ve sarAga samyagdRSTi hote haiN| 3.prazna 1 ke samAdhAna meM paramAtma prakAza kA jo udA. diyA hai vaha yahA~ bhI par3hane yogya hai| 4. rayaNasAra gAthA 4 meM kahA hai- 'sammattarayaNasAraM mokkhamahArukkhamUlamidi bhnniyN| * taM.jANijjar3a NicchayAhArasarUvado bhedN|' artha-samyagdarzana samasta ratnoM meM sArabhUta ratna hai aura mokSarUpo vRkSa kA mUla hai, isake nizcaya aura vyavahAra aise do bheda jAnane caahie|
Page #19
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ 5. bRhadravyasaMgraha kI TIkA gAthA 41 meM pR. 140 para isaprakAra kahA hai'zuddhajIvAditattvArtha zraddhAnalakSaNaM sarAgasamyaktvAbhidhAnaM vyavahArasamyaktvaM vijnyeym|... vItarAgacAritrAvinAbhUtaM vItarAgasamyaktvAbhidhAnaM nizcayasamyaktvaM ca jnyaatvymiti|' artha-zuddha jIva Adi tattvArthoM kA zraddhAnarUpa sarAgasamyaktva vyavahAra samyaktva jAnanA cAhie aura vItarAga cAritra ke binA nahIM hone vAlA vItarAga samyaktva nAmaka nizcaya samyaktva jAnanA caahie| 6. bhagavatI ArAdhanA meM kahA hai'iha dvividha samyaktvaM sarAgasamyaktvaM vItarAga samyaktvaM ceti|....ttr prazasta- rAgasahitAnAM zraddhAnaM sarAga smygdrshnN| rAgadvayarahitAnAM kSINamohAvaraNAnAM vItarAga smygdrshn| . . artha-samyaktva do prakAra kA hai| sarAgasamyaktva aura vItarAga samyaktva / tahA~ prazastarAga sahita jIvoM kA sarAga samyaktva hai aura prazasta va aprazasta donoM prakAra ke rAga se rahita kSINamoha vItarAgiyoM kA samyaktva vItarAga samyaktva hai| uparokta pramANa ke anusAra samyagdarzana kI paryAya do rUpa honA siddha hai| jijJAsA 4.- kSAyika samyagdRSTi zreNika ke jIva ko naraka meM nizcaya samyagdarzana hai yA vyavahAra, yA donoM? samAdhAna- naraka meM zreNika rAjA ke jIva ko mAtra vyavahArasamyagdarzana hai, nizcayasamyagdarzana nhiiN| kyoM ki nizcaya samyagdarzana to nizcaya cAritra kA avinAbhAvI hai| naraka meM nizcaya cAritra nahIM hotaa| isalie nizcaya samyaktva bhI nahIM hai| jaisA ki samayasAra gAthA 13 kI TIkA meM zrI jayasenAcArya ne kahA hai - 'ArtaraudraparityAgalakSaNanirvikalpasAmAyikasthitanAMyacchuddhAtmarUpasyadarzanamanubhavanamava lokanamupalabdhiH saMvittiH pratItiH khyAtiranubhUtistadeva nizcayanayena. nizcayacAritrAvinAbhAvi nizcayasamyaktvaM vItarAgasamyaktvaM bhnnyte|' artha-Artaraudra pariNAmoM ke tyAgarUpa lakSaNa hai jisakA, aisI nirvikalpa sAmAyika meM sthita jIva ke jo zuddhAtmarUpa kA darzana anubhavana, avalokana, upalabdhi, saMvitti, pratIti, khyAti,anubhUti hotI hai vahI nizcayanaya ke nizcayacAritra kA avinAbhAvI nizcayasamyaktva vItarAgasamyaktva kahA hai| bRhadravyasaMgraha meM to mahArAjA bharata ke kSAyika samyagdarzana ko vyavahAra samyagdarzana kahA gayA hai| - 'eSAM bharatAdInAM yat samyagdarzanaM tattuM vyavahAra smygdrshnN|' jijJAsA 5.- aupazamika, kSAyopazamika, kSAyika ina tInoM prakAra ke samyagdRSTiyoM ko kyA (AtmAnubhUti rahita) AtmavizvAsa eka sadRza hotA hai?
Page #20
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ 20 samAdhAna-samayasAra gAthA 13 kI TIkA jo upara prazna kra. 4 ke uttara meM likhI gayI hai, usake anusAra zuddha AtmasvarUpa kI anubhUti ko nizcaya samyaktva yA vItarAga samyaktva kahA hai| tInoM prakAra ke samyagdRSTiyoM ko savikalpa avasthA meM zuddhAtmA kI anubhUti rahita Atma vizvAsa to hotA hai jo kSAyika aura upazama samyagdRSTiyoM ke nirdoSarUpa hotA hai| jaba ki kSAyopazamika samyagdRSTiyoM ke sadoSarUpa hotA hai| tadanusAra aupazamika aura kSAyika samyagdRSTi ke AtmavizvAsa eka sadRza kahA gayA hai aura kSAyopazamika samyagdRSTi ke samyaktva prakRti ke udaya hone ke kAraNa bhinna rUpa se kahA gayA hai| yaha vizvAsa nirvikalpa samAdhikAla meM zuddha AtmAnubhUti sahita hotA hai aura savikalpa avasthA meM zuddha AtmAnubhUti rahita hotA hai| jijJAsA 6- pravacanasAra gAthA 80 - jo jANadi arihaMta evaM samayasAra gAthA 320 -diTThI jaheva NANaM kI zrImad pa. pU. jayasenAcArya viracita tAtparyavRtti TIkAoM meM kramazaH karaNalabdhipUrvaka avikalpa svarUpa kI prApti tathA bhavyaktva zakti kI vyaktatA kA svarUpa batalAyA hai| kyA isakA artha mAtra AtmavizvAsa honA hI samyagdarzana mAnA gayA hai ? samAdhAna- uparokta donoM gAthAoM kI TIkA meM avikalpa svarUpa kI prApti tathA bhavyatva zakti kI vyaktatA kA jo ullekha AyA hai usakA tAtparya mAtra AtmavizvAsa- rUpa samyagdarzana hI hai| kyoM ki uparokta samAdhAnoM se yaha spaSTa ho cukA hai ki zuddha AtmasvarUpa kI anubhUti to nizcaya cAritra ke avinAbhAvI, nizcaya samyaktva hone para hI hotI hai / --- * --- jijJAsA 7. - pravacanasAra gAthA 80 kI tAtparyavRtti ke prAraMbha meM likhita'atha cattApAvAraMbha---(gAthA 79) ityAdi sUtreNa yaduktaM zuddhopayogAbhAve mohAdivinAzo na bhavati, mohAdivinAzAbhAve zuddhAtmalAbho na bhavati '... kA kyA artha hai ? . samAdhAnaM- isakA artha bahuta spaSTa hai ki mohanIya karma kA nAza isake binA nahIM ho sakatA aura mohAdi ke nAza ke binA zuddhAtmA kA lAbha nahIM hotA arthAt vItarAgatA prApta nahIM hotI / gAthA 79 tAtparyavRtti meM spaSTa kahA gayA hai ki jo sAdhaka zubhopayoga kI pariNatiyoM meM pariNamana karake aMtaraMga meM mohI hokara yadi nirvikalpa samAdhi lakSaNa pUrva meM kahe hue moha rahita zuddha Atmatattva ke virodhI moha Adi ko nahIM chor3atA / to vaha jina yA siddha ke samAna apane AtmasvarUpa ko nahIM jAna pAtA / arthAt zuddha AtmasvarUpa kI prApti ke lie mohAdi kA vinAza honA Avazyaka hotA hai aura mohAdi ke vinAza ke lie zuddhopayoga Avazyaka hai / 7 yahA~ moha kA abhAva zuddhopayoga se hI hotA hai yaha jo avadhAraNA dI gayI hai isakA artha darzanamoha nahIM, cAritramoha lagAnA caahie|
Page #21
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ jijJAsA 8.- prAyogyalabdhi meM, karaNalabdhi meM tathA anivRttikaraNoparAMta hone vAle AtmA ke vizvAsa meM kyA aMtara hai? samAdhAna-uparokta donoM dazAoM meM hone vAle AtmA ke vizvAsa meM aMtara mAnanA caahie| 1. prAyogyalabdhi meM AtmavizvAsa nahIM hotaa| yahA~ AtmavizvAsa vacana taka sImita hai| bhAvarUpa nahIM hotaa| 2. karaNalabdhi meM AtmavizvAsa honA prAraMbha ho jAtA hai paraMtu mithyAtva kA sadbhAva hone ke kAraNa pUrNa AtmavizvAsa nahIM ho paataa| 3. anivRttikaraNa ke uparAMta mithyAtva kA upazama ho jAne ke kAraNa AtmavizyAsa pUrNa pragaTa ho jAtA hai| . saca to yaha hai ki jaba taka mithyAtva kA udaya hai taba taka tattvazraddhAnamUlaka AtmavizvAsa bilakUla saMbhava nahIM hai| jijJAsA 9. - dezavratI zrAvaka evaM avirata samyagdRSTi ke AtmavizvAsa meM kyA kucha pharka hotA hai? kyoM ki Apake anusAra AtmAnubhUti muni/saMyamI ko hI hotI hai? samAdhAna-yadi samyaktva samAna hai to dezavratI zrAvaka aura avirata samyagdRSTi ke AtmavizvAsa meM koI aMtara nahIM hotA haikyoM ki apratyAkhyAnAvaraNa kaSAya kA anudaya AtmavizvAsa meM koI vizeSatA lAne meM samartha nahIM hai| zuddha Atmatattva kI anubhUti to vItarAga cAritra ke avinAbhAvI vItarAga samyaktva ke kAla meM hI saMbhava hai| jo mAtra zuddhopayogI muniyoM ko hI hotI hai| jijJAsA 10.- Apake hisAba se munirAjoM ko hI AtmAnubhUti hotI hai to gRhavirata zrAvakoM (kSullaka,ailaka,AryikA)ko bhI svAtmAnubhUti nahIM hotI hogI? samAdhAna-caturtha,paMcama evaM chaThe guNasthAnavartI zubhopayogI jIvoM ko AtmavizvAsa mAtra hotA hai, AtmAnubhUti athavA AtmAnubhavalpa AnaMda nahIM hotaa| kyoM ki saMjvalana kaSAya ke maMda udaya meM AtmalIna hone para hI AtmAnubhUti hotI hai| jaisA ki upara ke sabhI Agama pramANoMdvArA spaSTa kiyA gayA hai| AtmAnubhUti, abheda ratnatraya, paramopekSA saMyama, zuddhopayoga ye saba ekArthavAcI haiN| zubhopayoga meM sthita munirAja ko bhI zuddhAtmAnubhUti nahIM hotii| - zrI paramAtma prakAza gAthA 144 kI TIkA meM kahA hai ki - 'manaH zuddhyabhAve gRhasthAnAM tapodhanavat zuddhAtmabhAvanA krtunaayaatiiti| tathA coktaMkaSAyairindriyarduSTaiH: vyAkulIkriyate manaH yataH yataH kartuM na zakyate bhAvanA gRhmedhibhiH| artha-mana kI zuddhi ke binA gRhasthoM ko yati ke samAna zuddhAtmA kI bhavavanAkaranA nahIM banatA hai| kahA bhI hai-kaSAyoM aura duSTa indriyoM se mana vyAkula rahatA hai| isalie gRhasthoM ko AtmabhAvanA karanA zakya nahIM hai|
Page #22
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ 22 jijJAsA 11.- jainoM aura jainetara matAvalaMbiyoM ke AtmA ke vizvAsa meM kyA kucha aMtara hotA hai ? kyoM ki anya matAvalaMbI bhI AtmA ke hone meM vizvAsa rakhate haiM? samAdhAna- jainoM aura jainetaroM ke AtmavizvAsa meM jamIna AsamAna kA aMtara hai| jaise bauddha tathA vaizeSika AtmA kA abhAva hone ko mokSa mAnate haiM, jo jainamata meM bilakula galata hai| yogamata vAle AtmA ke buddhi, sukha Adi guNoM kA nAza hone ko mokSa mAnate haiM jo bilakula galata hai| cArvAka mata vAle AtmA ko padArtharUpa se svIkAra hI nahIM karate, punarjanma ko nahIM mAnate / sAMkhya mata vAle AtmA ko sadA zuddha mAnate haiN| AtmA ko karmoM kA kartA aura bhoktA nahIM mAnate, sarva vyApaka mAnate haiM jo nitAMta galata hai| ___ . jainoM ke alAvA jainetara kucha mata AtmA kA astitva to mAnate haiM paraMtu AtmA ke vAstavika svarUpa kA paricaya na hone ke kAraNa usakI karmabaddha, azuddha avasthA tathA usake zuddha hone ke upAyoM kA sahI jJAna na hone ke kAraNa ajJAnI haiM, mithyAdRSTi haiM, unake AtmavizvAsa raMcamAtra bhI nahIM hai| unakA AtmavizvAsa gRhita mithyAtva sahita hai jaba ki jainiyoM kA usase rahita hai| jijJAsA 12.-vaha AtmA jisakA ki jainoM samyagdRSTiyoM ko vizvAsa hotA hai vaha dravyakarma,nokarma,(zarIra),bhAvakarma(moha,rAga,dveSa) se rahita AtmA hotA hai yA inake sahita hotA hai? samAdhAna- samyagdRSTi to dravyakarma,bhAvakarma,nokarma rahita zuddha AtmA kA hI zraddhAna karatA hai para usa zuddha AtmA kI anubhUti vItarAga pariNati meM hI hotI hai jo ki vItarAga cAritra ke hone para hI saMbhava hai| jijJAsA 13.-avirata samyagdRSTi mokSamArgI hai yA nahIM? yadi hai to usake cAritra kaunasA prakaTa huA kahalAyegA? mithyAcAritra bhI usake nahIM hai? . samAdhAna- tattvArthasUtra ke prAraMbha meM A. umAsvAmI mahArAja ne yaha sUtra likhA hai - . ___ - smygdrshnjnyaancaaritraannimokssmaargH| artha- samyagdarzana samyagjJAna samyakcAritra kI ekatA hI mokSamArga hai / isakI TIkA meM A. pUjyapAda svAmI ne likhA hai kisamyagdarzanaM samyagjJAnaM samyakcAritramityetat tritayaM samuditaM mokSasya sAkSAnmArgo veditvyH| artha - samyagdarzana,samyagjJAna aura samyakcAritra ye tInoM milakara sAkSAt mokSa kA mArga hai aisA jAnanA caahie| isa Agama pramANa ke anusAra avirata samyagdRSTi mokSamArgI nahIM hai| usake kaunasA cAritra huA isa saMbaMdha meM gommaTasAra jIvakANDa gAthA 12 meM spaSTa kahA hai ki - 'cArittaM NatthiM jado avirada antesu tthaannesu|' artha - avirata samyaktva guNasthAna taka cAritra nahIM hotA hai|
Page #23
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ . - mokSamArga prakAzaka meM paM. ToDaramalajI ne 9 veM adhikAra meM spaSTa likhA ha ki 'tAtai anaMtAnubaMdhI ke gaye kichu kaSAyAni kI maMdatA to ho hai paraMtu aisI maMdatA na ho haiM, jAkari koU cAritra nAma pAvai .....jahA~ aisA kaSAyAni kA ghaTanA hoya jAkari zrAvakadharma va munidharma kA aMgIkAra hoya tahA~ hI cAritra nAma pAvai haiN| ...mithyAtvAdi asaMyataparyaMta guNasthAnAni viSai asaMyama nAma pAvai hai|' yadi caturtha guNasthAna meM cAritra kA aMza mAnA jAya to vahA~ cAritra kI apekSA kSAyopazamika bhAva honA caahie| paraMtu zrI SaTkhaNDAgama meM spaSTa kahA hai - 'asaMjadaM sammAiTThitti ko bhAvo, uvasamiovA khaiyo vA khaovasamio vA bhaavo||5|| odaieNa bhAveNa puNo asNjdo|' artha-asaMyatasamyagdRSTi ke kaunasA bhAva hai? aupazamika bhAva bhI hai,kSAyika bhAva bhI hai, aura kSAyopazamika bhAva bhI hai||5|| asaMyata samyagdRSTi kA asaMyata bhAva audayika hai| - rAjavArtika-1-1 meM isaprakAra kahA hai samyagdarzanasya samyagjJAnasya vA anyatarasvAtmalAbhe cAritramuttaraM bhjniiy|' artha-samyagdarzana, samyagjJAna ina donoM meM se eka kA AtmalAbha hote, uttara jo cAritra hai vaha bhajanIya hai| arthAt samyagdarzana hone para samyak cAritra honA avazyaMbhAvI nahIM hai| -AcArya guNabhadra ne uttara purANa meM kahA hai 'sametameva samyaktva jJAnAbhyAM caritaM mtm| syAtAM binApitetena guNasthAne cturthke| 74-543 artha- samyak cAritra to samyagdarzana va samyajJAna sahita hotA hai kintu caturtha guNasthAna meM samyagdarzana aura samyagjJAna samyak cAritra ke binA hote haiN| uparokta pramANoM se spaSTa hotA hai ki avirata samyagdRSTi ke samyakcAritra nahIM hotaa| aura jaba taka samyakcAritra nahIM taba taka mokSamArgI bhI nahIM hai| . - jaisA ki pravacanasAra gAthA 236 kI TIkA meM amRtacaMdrAcArya ne kahA hai 'atha Agama jJAna tattvArtha zraddhAna saMyatatvAnAmayogapadyasya mokSamArgatvaM vighttyti||' artha-isase AgamajJAna, tattvArtha zraddhAna tathA saMyatatva ke ayugapatatva vAle ke mokSamArga ghaTita nahIM hotaa| - mokSamArga prakAzaka meM paM. ToDaramalajI ne kahA hai 'yahA~ prazna jo asaMyata samyagdRSTi ke to cAritra nAhIM, vAkai mokSamArga bhayA hai ki na bhayA hai? tAkA samAdhAna-mokSa yAkai hosI, yaha to niyama bhyaa| tAtai upacArateM yAke mokSamArga bhayA bhI khie| paramArtha teM samyakcAritra bhaye hI mokSamArga ho hai| ---- laise asaMyata samyagdRSTi ke vItarAgabhAva rUpa mokSamArga kA zraddhAna bhayA tAtai vAko upacArate mokSamArgI khie| paramArtha teM vItarAgabhAvarUpa pariName hI mokSamArga hosii|'
Page #24
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ 24 jijJAsA - 14. - samyaktvAcaraNa (mokSapAhuDa gAthA 5 se 10) evaM svarUpAcaraNa cAritra meM kyA aMtara hai? samAdhAna- svarUpAcaraNa cAritra nAmaka cAritra kA varNana kisI bhI AcArya ne nahIM kiyA / yaha to paMcAdhyAyIkAra pANDe rAjamalajI kI kalpanA mAtra hai / A. kuMdakuMda ne cAritrapAhuDa gAthA 5 se 10 taka jo samyaktvAcaraNa cAritra kA varNana kiyA hai| usakA saMbaMdha samyak cAritra se bilakula nahIM hai / A. kuMdakuMda ne 25 doSoM se rahita aura aSTa aMga se sahita samyagdarzana ko dhAraNa karanA samyaktvAcaraNa cAritra kahA hai| samyak cAritra ko saMyamAcaraNa cAritra nAma se alaga kahA hai| isa saMyamAcaraNa cAritra ko dhAraNa karane vAlA hI mokSamArgI kahalAtA hai / jisake pAsa samyaktvAcaraNa cAritra nahIM hai, usake pAsa samyagdarzana bhI nahIM hai aisA samajhanA cAhie / zAstroM meM svarUpAcaraNa cAritra nAmaka cAritra to nahIM kahA para paramAtmaprakAza gAthA - 2- 39 kI TIkA meM aisA jarUra kahA hai - 6 dveSamaM yathAkhyAtarUpaM svarUpecaraNaM nizcayacAritraM bhaNati / idAnIM tadabhAve'nyaccAritramAcarantu tapodhanAH // ' artha - rAgadveSa kA abhAva jisakA lakSaNa hai aisA parama yathAkhyAtarUpa svarUpa meM AcaraNa nizcayacAritra hai| vartamAna meM usakA abhAva hone se munigaNa anya cAritra kA AcaraNa kreN| samyaktvAcaraNa to caturtha guNasthAna meM hotA hai paraMtu svarUpaM meM AcaraNa rUpa cAritra to gyArahaveM guNasthAna meM kahA gayA hai, jaisA Upara pramANa hai / samyagdarzana utpanna hone ke sAthasAtha usake anukUla AcaraNa bhI hone lagatA hai| vahI samyaktvAcaraNa kahA gayA hai| jijJAsA 15.- mokSamArga meM pragaTa hone vAlA saMvara- nirjarA tattva kyA zubhabhAva rUpa bhI hai yA vItarAga bhAva / zuddhabhAva rUpa ho hai ? samAdhAna- mokSamArga meM pragaTa hone vAlA saMvara, nirjarA tattva zubhabhAva rUpa bhI hai aura rAgabhAva rUpa bhI hai| zrI jaya dhavalA pustaka 1 pRSTha 6 para isaprakAra kahA hai'suhasuddha pariNAmehiM kammakhayA bhAve tkkhyaannuvvttiido|' artha- yadi zubha pariNAmoM aura zuddha pariNAmoM se karmoM kA kSaya na mAnA jAya to phira karmoM kA kSaya ho hI nahIM sakatA / A. vIrasena mahArAja to dhavalA pustaka 13 pRSTha 81 para isataraha ghoSaNA kara rahe haiM'mohaNIyaviNAste puNa dhammajjhANaMphalaM, suhumasAmparAyacarimasamae tassa viNAsuvalaMbhAdo // artha- mohanIya kA nAza karanA dharmyadhyAna kA phala haiM, kyoM ki sUkSmasAmparAya guNasthAna ke aMtima samaya meM usakA vinAza dekhA jAtA hai| - zrI rAjavArtika 1-4-18 meM kahA hai'pUrvoktAnAmAzrava dvArANAM zubhapariNAmavazAnnirodhaH saMvarAH // ' artha - pUrvokta mithyAdarzanAdi Asrava dvAroM kA zubha pariNAmoM ke vaza se nirodha honA saMvara
Page #25
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ 25 hai| dharmyadhyAna zubhabhAva hai, ataH zubhabhAva ko bhI mokSamArga meM prakaTa hone vAle saMvara nirjarA tattva rUpa mAnanA caahie| jijJAsA 16.- mithyAdRSTi dravyaliMgI muni jo navameM praiveyaka taka jAte haiM tathA unheM 11 aMgoM taka kA jJAna prakaTa ho jAtA hai kyA unako AtmA kA vizvAsa nahIM hotA? kyA unake saMvara-nirjarA tattva prakaTa hote haiM yA nahIM? samAdhAna nahIM hote / kyoM ki unheM viparitAbhiniveza rUpa mithyAtva kA udaya rahatA hai| mithyAtva rahate hue vyavahAra samyaktva rUpa Atma vizvAsa saMbhava nhiiN| jijJAsA 17.-dharmyadhyAna ke svAmI cauthe se sAtaveM guNasthAnavI jIva kahe haiN| taba asaMyamI samyagdRSTi ke bhI cAritra kA aMza prakaTa huA honA caahie| anyathA 16+25=41 prakRtiyA kA badha nahIM rukatA? anatAnabadho cAritramAha ko prakati kA anadaya/aprazasta upazama/kSaya hI kAraNa hai| isa cAritra ke aMza kA nAma Agama meM kahIM kucha AyA ho to spaSTa kareM? samAdhAna-caturtha guNasthAna meM kaSAya kI eka caukar3I kA abhAva hotA hai,paraMtu use saMyama rUpa cAritra nAma nahIM milatA hai| zrI jayadhavalA 16/40 ke anusAra cAritra ke viSaya meM anaMtAnubaMdhI kA kArya yaha hai ki vaha apratyAkhyAnAvaraNa Adi ke kaSAyoM ke udaya pravAha ko anaMta kara detI hai| isalie cAritra meM anaMtAnubaMdhI catuSka kA vyApAra niSphala nahIM hai, paraMtu vaha kisI cAritra kA ghAta nahIM krtii| ata: usake jAne para koI cAritra prakaTa nahIM hotaa| ApakI yaha dhAraNA ThIka nahIM hai ki binA cAritra kA aMza prakaTa hue karmaprakRtiyoM kA baMdha nahIM rukanA cAhie, kyoM ki abhavya jIva ke bhI prAyogyalabdhi meM 34 baMdhApasaraNoM meM 46 prakRtiyoM kA baMdha ruka jAtA hai| jaba ki vahA~ sArI kaSAyeM haiM aura cAritra kA aMza bhI nahIM hai| sAsAdana guNasthAna meM bhI anaMtAnubaMdhI Adi samasta kaSAyoM kA sadbhAva rahate hue bhI 16 prakRtiyoM kA baMdha ruka jAtA hai, taba vahA~ kaunasA cAritra pragaTa honA maaneNge| isalie yaha dhAraNA ucita nahIM hai ki binA cAritra kA aMza prakaTa hue karmaprakRtiyoM kA baMdha nahIM ruktaa| anaMtAnubaMdhI ke jAne se itane aMzoM meM vahA~ kaSAya aMza to ghaTatA hai para use zAstroM meM koI bhI nAma nahIM diyA hai| kyoM ki caturtha guNasthAna taka cAritra kA aMza bhI nahIM hotaa| jijJAsA 18. -samayasAra gAthA 13- 'bhUTattheNAbhigadA...kI AtmakhyAti TIkA-aMta meM- 'evamasAvekatvenadyotamAnaH zuddhanayojanAnubhUyata eva / yA tvanubhUtiH sAtmakhyAtirevAtmakhyAtistu samyagdarzanameva / iti samastameva nirvdym|'- isakA artha spaSTa kreN| samAdhAna - uparAkta paktiyA kA khalAsA isaprakAra ha ki jA zaddhanaya ka dvArA apana
Page #26
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ 26 AtmA ke zuddha svarUpa kA bhAna kara lete haiM, azuddha dazA ko azuddhi ke rUpa meM jAna lete haiM unakA yaha vAstavika jJAna hI AtmakhyAti nAma se kahA jAtA hai aura AtmA kI isa zuddhanaya se jAnI gayI avasthA kA vizvAsa hI samyagdarzana hai| zuddhanaya se jIva ko jAnane se hI samyagdRSTi prApta ho sakatI hai aura jaba taka isaprakAra AtmA ko nahIM jAnatA hai taba taka paryAyabuddhi vAlA hotA huA mithyAdRSTi hI hai| anAdikAla se isa jIva ne naimittika bhAvoM meM chipI huI isa Atmajyoti ko nahIM pahacAnA thaa| usa Atmajyoti ko zuddha naya ke dvArA hI prakAzamAna kiyA jA sakatA hai| yaha prasaMga samayasAra kA hai| isa graMtha meM vItarAga samyagdRSTi kI hI pradhAnatA hai| jaisA ki A. jayasena ne vibhinna sthAnoM para svayaM TIkA meM kahA hai ki isa graMtha meM mukhya rUpa se nirvikalpa samAdhi meM sthita samyagdRSTi kA hI grahaNa kiyA gayA hai, anya kA gauNa vRtti se kiyA hai| ataH ise ukta Aloka meM hI dekhiegA / jijJAsA 19.- tattvArtha zlokavArtikAlaMkAra prathama khaNDa pRSTha 555 para - 'na hi cAritra mohodaya maatraadbhvccaaritrN| darzana cAritra mohodayajanitAdacAritra dabhibhameveti sAdhayituM zakya; sarvatra kAraNa bhedasya phlaabhedktvprskteH| siddhaaNtvirodhaat|| artha-isake hiMdI artha meM paM.mANikacaMda jI kauMdeya nyAyAcArya jI ne caturtha guNasthAnavartI kA svarUpAcaraNa cAritra acAritra meM kahA hai tathA jaina siddhAMta pravezikA meM paM. gopAladAsa jI baraiyA ne prazna 111/112 meM svarUpAcaraNa cAritra kahA hai| kyA Apako yaha mAnya hai? samAdhAna-maiMne Upara pra.naM. 14 ke uttara meM spaSTa kahA hai ki kisI bhI AcArya ne apane dvArA racita kisI bhI graMtha meM svarUpAcaraNa cAritra nAma kA koI cAritra ullakhita nahIM kiyA hai / paM. mANikacaMda jI kauMdeya ne svarUpAcaraNa cAritra ko acAritra mAnA hai aura paM. gopAladAsajI baraiyA ne svarUpAcaraNa cAritra kA kathana kiyA hai| use mAtra samyaktvAcaraNa cAritra kA paryAyavAcI kahA jA sakatA hai paraMtu samyak cAritra meM garbhita nahIM kiyA jA sktaa| yaha bhI likhanA ucita hogA ki A.kuMdakuMda ne anaMtAnubaMdhI ke abhAva se samyaktvAcaraNa cAritra nahIM mAnA hai| anyathA tRtIya guNasthAna meM bhI samyaktvAcaraNa mAnanA par3egA jo galata hogaa| dharmyadhyAna - Agama ke Aloka meM jo jIvo bhAvaMto jIvasahAvaM subhaavsNjutto| so jaramaraNaviNAsaM kuNai phuDaM lahai nnivvaannN||.....bhaavpaahudd 61 // kevalaNANasahAvo kevaladasaNasahAvo suhmio| kaMvalasattisahAvo so haM idi ciMtae nnaannii|| ..... niyamasAra 96 //
Page #27
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ 27 paM.bra. hemacaMdra jaina 'hema' (bhopAla) dvArA likhita javAba - di. 30-09-2005/01.11.2005 . AdaraNIya AgamavettA vidvadvara zrI paM. ratanalAlajI bainAr3A, jaina, sAdara jAyajineMdra | ApakA 24.8.05 kA patra mere bhopAla pate se riDAirekTa hokara yahA~ devalAlI (nAsikamahArASTra) pate para prApta huA / maiM 1 mAha se bAhara ( cainnaI, ponnUra ) gA~va meM thA / vahA~ paryuSaNa parva meM ekAMta sthAna - zrI kuMdakuMdAcArya deva kI tapobhUmi meM dasama pratimAdhArI mere mitra bra. AdinAthana ke sAtha tattvacarcA kA lAbha letA thA / kSamAvANI parva para uttama kSamA cAhatA huuN| maiMne apanI jijJAsAoM kA samAdhAna jinabhASita patrikA meM agasta-sitaMbara ke aMka meM bhI nahIM pAyA to socA zAyada zAyada samAdhAna nahIM AyegA / paraMtu Apane bhArI zrama kara samAdhAna karane kA prayAsa isa patra meM kiyA hai / tadartha bahuta bahuta dhanyavAda / sAtha hI Apane AcAryazrI ke maMgala sAnnidhya meM jijJAsA samAdhAnArtha upasthita hone kA sujhAva diyA hai| svAsthya anukUlatA rahI to avazya hI Agama-adhyAtma kI gahana tattvacarcA samAdhAna hetu, saMta samAgama hetu samaya nikAla kara sUcita karU~gA / AdaraNIya bainAr3A jI ! Apa AgamavettA hai| jJAna kI nirmalatA ke lie Agama ke Aloka meM jijJAsAoM kA samAdhAna khojanA bhrAMtiyoM meM sthita honA to nahIM mAnA jA sakatA?Agama agAdha hai / ' ko na vimuhyati zAstra samudre / ' Apa A. ka. paM. ToDaramalajI ke mokSamArgaprakAzaka ke AdhAra se bhI samAdhAna prastuta karate haiM, phira bhI unake sarva kathanoM ko kyoM nahIM mAnya karate? Apa AtmavizvAsa / AtmA ke vizvAsa ko evaM AtmAnubhUti ko eka nahIM maante| kSAyika samyagdRSTi ko bhI nizcayasamyaktvI nahIM mAnate, sarAga vyavahAra samyaktvI hI mAnate ho? jaba ki kSAyika navalabdhiyoM meM prathama labdhi kSAyika samyaktva hI hai / mithyAtvI evaM samyagdRSTi jIvoM ke hone vAlI karmodayajanya sukha - duHkhAnubhUti meM Apa avazya hI aMtara to mAnate hoMge ? samyaktvI ko mithyAtvaM va anaMtAnubaMdhI catuSkaM ke abhAva meM nizcita hI nirAkulatva lakSaNa Atmopalabdhi rUpa sukhAnubhUti kA AMzika pragaTapanA hI na mAnA jAye to samyaktvopalabdhi kA kyA phAyadA? phira zrAvaka (dezasaMyamI) ke do kaSAya caukar3I ke abhAvarUpa nirAkulatvalakSaNa sukhAnubhUti nahIM mAnI jAye to phira sakala saMyamI (munirAja ) ke tIna kaSAyoM ke abhAvarUpa pracura sva-saMvedanarUpa Atmika nirAkulatvalakSaNa AnaMdAnubhUti bhI nahIM mAnI jA sakegI! aura phira cAroM kaSAyoM ke abhAva meM kSINamohajina meM bhI pUrNa nirAkulatvalakSaNa sukha AnaMdAnubhUti kA udbhava bhI nahIM mAnA jA skegaa| ataH nyAya saMgata yahI hai ki mithyAtva evaM krodhAdi kaSAyoM kA abhAva hI sukha hai, svAtmAnubhUti hai / A. ka. paM. ToDaramalajI ne mokSamArga prakAzaka adhyAya 9 vA~ - (hindI) pR. 337 meM likhA hai
Page #28
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ 28 'paramArthataH kaSAyoM ke asaMkhyAta loka pramANa sthAna haiN| unameM sarvatra pUrvasthAna se uttarasthAna meM maMdatA pAyI jAtI hai, paraMtu vyavahAra se una sthAnoM meM tIna maryAdAe~ kiiN| Adi ke bahuta sthAna to asaMyama rUpa kahe, phira kitane hI deza saMyama rUpa kahe, phira kitane hI sakala saMyama rUpa khe| unameM pradhama guNasthAna se caturtha guNasthAna taka jo kaSAya ke sthAna hote haiM ve sarva asaMyama hI ke hote haiN| isalie kaSAyoM kI maMdatA hone para bhI cAritra nAma nahIM paate| yadyapi paramArtha se kaSAya kA ghaTanA cAritra kA aMza hai, tathApi vyavahAra se jahA~ aisA kaSAyoM kA ghaTanA ho, jisase zrAvakadharma yA munidharma kA aMgIkAra ho,vahIM cAritra nAma pAtA hai, so asaMyata meM aise kaSAya ghaTatI nahIM hai, isalie yahA~ asaMyama kahA hai| kaSAyoM ko adhika-hInapanA hone para bhI jisa prakAra pramattAdi guNasthAnoM meM sarvatra sakala saMyama hi nAma pAtA hai, usI prakAra mithyAtvAdi asaMyata paryaMta guNasthAnoM meM asaMyata nAma pAtA hai| sarvatra asaMyama kI samAnatA nahIM jaannaa|' ___ AdaraNIya bainAr3A jI ! Apane pa.pU. jJAnasAgarajI dvArA kathita caturtha guNasthAna meM mAtra AtmA kA vizvAsa hone kI bAta mAnya kI hai aura maiMne pa.pU. munivara vIrasAgarajI mahArAja (solApura)dvArA likhita jaina adhyAtma nyAyadIpikA kA evaM samayasAra(tA.vR. TIkA)kA adhyayana karake unake pAsa 5 varSoM taka 1-1 mAha jA-jAkara caturtha guNa sthAna meM mAtra AtmAnubhUti hone kI bAta mAnya kI hai| Apa va maiM donoM AgamapramANa prastuta kara rahe haiM, phira bhI visaMgati dUra kyoM nahIM ho rahI hai? isake alAvA maiMne kSu.dvaya (pU.kSu.suzIlamatI mAtAjI,evaM pU.kSu.suvratA mAtAjI-suziSyA pa.pU.vIrasAgarajI mahArAja), zrI manaharalAlajI varNI evaM zrI jineMdra jI varNI ke sAnnidhya kA lAbha liyA hai, aura AcAryazrI vidyAsAgarajI ke pAsa bilakula samIpa baiThakara 9 sAloM taka anekoM jagaha tattvacarcAe~ kI hai aura unhoMne mujhe bharapUra lAbha bhI diyA hai,AzIrvAda bhI milA hai| kiMtu unake dvArA kucha tattvoM kI vivecanA aisI pratIta hone lagI ki ye vivecanA Agama-adhyAtma se mela nahIM khAtI pratIta hotI aura Agama-adhyAtma ke vettA 4-5 vidvAnoM, sarvazrI paM. phUlacaMdajI siddhAMta zAstrI,paMkailAzacaMdajI si.zAstrI,paM.jaganmohanalAlajI si.zA.,paM.pannAlAlajI sAhityAcArya, paM.deveMdrakumArajI zAstrI Adi se bhI tattvacarcAe~ kii| ina vidvAnoM ke sAnnidhya meM AcAryazrI ke sasaMgha dhavalA vAcanAoM meM bhI thoDA-thoDA bhAga liyA paraMtu nimnalikhita ciMtanoM ne mujhe jhakajhora diyA,kyoM ki inake Agama pramANa nahIM hai........| (1)karmabaMdha prakriyA meM mithyAtva akiMcitkara hai| (2)anaMtAnubaMdhI kaSAya se mithyAtva kA(darzanamoha)kA baMdha hotA hai| (3)visaMyojita anaMtAnubaMdhI kaSAya (cAritramoha) kA baMdha prathama guNasthAna meM Ane para apratyAkhyAnAvaraNa, pratyAkhyAnAvaraNa kaSAyoM se hotA hai| bhale jaya dhavalA (kaSAya pAhucubhAga 4 peja 24) meM mUla meM mithyAtva se baMdha honA likhA ho| (4) 'dasaNa mUlo dhmmo|' kA artha dharma kA mUla samyagdarzana nahIM, varan munimudrA hai|
Page #29
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ 29 manimadrA sa rahita ko vadanA mata kraa| (5)prazasta kaSAya (zubha rAga ) se saMvara, nirjarA evaM puNyabaMdha donoM hote haiN| ____paramArthataH pApa (asAtA)kI saMvara-nirjarA arthAt aghAtikarmoM kA AnA, rUka jAnA evaM sattA meM unakA saMkramaNa ho sAtA rUpa ho jAnA to mAnya hI hai, paraMtu AtmaguNa ghAtaka ghAtikarma kI saMvara-nirjarA mAnanA kaise saMbhava ho? kAraNa aMtima graiveyaka taka jAne vAle bAhya se nigraMtha mahAvratI dravyaliMgI sAdhu ko bhI saMvara-nirjarA tattva pragaTa mAnanA par3egA jo ThIka nahIM hai? usake to zubhayoga se aghAtiyA karmoM kI puNyaprakRtiyoM kA bandha hotA hai| vyavahAra karate-karate nizcaya vItarAga dharma pragaTa ho jAtA hotA to phira zvetAmbara va digaMbara mAnyatA meM pharka hI kyA rahA? yadyapi yaha eka traikAlika satya hai ki mahAvratarUpa dravyaliMga dhAraNa kiye binA bhAvaliMga(tIna kaSAya ke abhAvarUpa) dazA pragaTa nahIM hotI, isI prakAra aNuvratAdi (vyavahAra deza saMyama)dhAraNa kiye binA do kaSAya ke abhAvarUpa paMcama guNasthAna (zrAvaka dazA)pragaTa hI nahIM hotii| isIprakAra sacce deva-zAstra-guru evaM unake dvArA upadiSTa prayojanabhUta tattvoM ke niNayabinA (jJAna binA) karaNalabdhirUpa vizaddhi ho nahIM pragaTa hAto tA nizcaya avikalpa dazA rUpa samyaktva kI bhI prApti nahIM hotii| ataH vyavahArapUrvacara evaM sahacara donoM rUpa sAdhaka avasthA meM hotA hai, athavA buddhipUrvaka grahaNa kiyA hI jAtA hai| paraMtu isa samIcIna vyavahAra (azubha se nivRtti evaM zubha meM pravRtti) mAtra se darzana moha-cAritra moha haTa jAyeMge aisI mAnyatA, vizvAsa banAye rakhanA prakArAntara se mithyAtva kA hI poSaNa hai| abhiprAya kI bhUla miTe binA samyagdarzanAdi pragaTa nahIM ho skte| pravacanasAra jI gAthA 77 evaM samayasAra gAthA 154 isa bAta kI sAkSI hai| ... A.ka.paM.ToDaramalajI ne abhiprAya kI bhUla sudhAre binA samyaktva kI upalabdhi saMbhava hI nahIM hotI-isake lie hI to unhoMne apanA jIvana balidAna kara mokSamArga prakAzaka graMtha kI racanA kI hai| unhoMne kahIM para bhI vyavahAra dharma pAlanA nahIM chuddaayaa.hai| merA apanA niSkarSa hai ki jaina dharma jo ki sampradAyAtIta hai, vastu ke svabhAva ko darzAne vAlA hai, vaha kisI bhI prakAra se mithyAtva va kaSAyoM kA athavA hiMsAdi pApoM kA poSane vAlA nahIM hai| aura upacarita vyavahAra dharma ko nizcaya dharma kA mAtra sahacArI sAdhana nirUpita karane vAlA hai| saMkSepa meM kahU~ to jo pApa meM jAne nahIM detA aura puNya ko nizcaya vItarAga dharma mAnane nahIM detA, basa,yahI jaina dharma kA sAra hai| tabhI to samayasAra meM 12 vIM gAthA kI AtmakhyAti TIkA meM pa. pU. amRtacaMdrAcArya deva ne yaha gAthA dI hai| jaI jiNamayaM pavajjaha tA mA vavahAraNicchae muyaha / ekkeNa viNA chijjai tityaM aNNeNa uNa tacvaM / / astu / pApoM meM jAne kI evaM puNya ko nizcaya vItarAga dharma mAnane kI jinAjJA to nahIM hai paraMtu pApoM se bacane ke lie evaM nizcaya vItarAga dharma (akaSAyabhAva)kI prApti ke lie
Page #30
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ 30 jJAnI zubhAcaraNa ( bhUmikAnusAra vyavahAradharmAcaraNa, prazastarAga rUpa AcaraNa ko hanta ! hastAvalaMbana jAnate hue) kA AlaMbana lete haiM paraMtu use sAdhya jo nizcaya dharma nahIM mAnate / paramArthataH nizcaya yA vyavahAra rUpa do prakAra kA mokSamArga yA do prakAra kA samyagdarzanajJAna cAritra nahIM hotA hai| usakA nirUpaNa do prakAra kA hotA hai| sacce mokSamArga ko / samyagdarzana - jJAna - cAritra ko mokSamArga nirUpita karanA saccA mokSamArga / samyagdarzana-jJAnacAritra hai| aura jo svayaM mokSamArga yA samyagdarzana - jJAna - cAritra nahIM hai, paraMtu usa sacce mokSamArga/samyagdarzana- jJAna - cAritra kA nimitta hai, sahacArI hai yA pUrvacara rUpa se bhI pAyA jAtA hai, use upacAra se mokSamArga / samyagdarzana - jJAna-cAritra kahanA so vyavahAra hai vyavahAra mokSamArga hai, vyavahAra samyagdarzanaM -3 -jJAna-cAritra hai / svazrito nizcayaH, parAzrito vyavahAraH isa Agama vacana se svAzrita / saccA nirUpaNa so nizcaya aura parAzrita / upacAra nirUpaNa so vyavahAra, kiMtu aisA na mAnakara do mokSamArga mAnanA mithyA hai| paramArthataH sAdhaka avasthA meM donoM ekasAtha pragaTa hote haiM / arthAt upacarita (vyavahAra) evaM anupacarita (nizcaya ) / upacarita (vyavahAra) sahacArI nimitta hai anupacarita ( nizcaya ) yathArtha hai / darzana moha + anaMtAnubaMdhI kaSAya ke upazama-kSayopazama-kSaya ke nimitta se jo AtmAnubhUti / AtmA kA vizvAsarUpa nizcaya samyaktva pragaTa hotA hai usahI ko aupazamikakSAyopazamika kSAyika ke bheda se tIna prakAra kA kahA jAtA hai| usehI cAritraguNa kI sarAgavItarAga avasthA kA Aropa kara sarAga- vItarAga samyaktva kahA jAtA hai| use hI jJAnaguNa kI alpajJa - sarvajJa avasthA kA Aropa kara avagAr3ha - paramAvagAr3ha samyaktva kahA jAtA hai| tathA anya nimittAdi kI apekSA AjJA samyaktvAdi samyaktva ke dasa bheda bhI kiye haiM / (dekheMAtmAnuzAsana zloka-1 6-11) paramAtmaprakAza 2/18 kI TIkA jo Apane svayaM prathama jijJAsA samAdhAna meM prastuta kI hai usameM ati spaSTa rUpa meM yaha bAta kahI gayI hai ki- sarAga samyaktva ko vyavahAra samyaktva evaM vItarAga samyaktva ko nizcaya samyaktva kahA hai, vaha cAritramoha kI sthiratA-asthiratA kI apekSA se hI kahA hai| una tIrthaMkarAdi mahApuruSoM ke zuddhAtmA upAdeya hai aisI ruci rUpa nizcaya samyaktva to gRhasthAvasthA meM bhI hai, paraMtu cAritramoha ke udaya se sthiratA nahIM hai| ataH use sarAgAvasthA meM vyavahAra samyaktva kahA hai| sarAga- vItarAg2a samyagdarzana bAbada anya Agama pramANa . 1. sarvArthasiddhi (1/2) : tad dvividhaM sarAga- vItarAga viSaya bhedAt / prazama saMvegAnukampAstikyAdyabhivyaktilakSaNaM prathamam / AtmavizuddhimAtramitarat / 2. rAjavArtika (1/2): saptAnAM karmaprakRtinAM AtyaMtike'pagame satyAtma vizuddhimAtra mitarad / vItarAgasamyaktvamityacyate / 3. amitagatizrAvakAcA (2): vItarAga sarAgaM ca samyaktvaM kathitaM dvidhA / virAgaMkSAyikaM
Page #31
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ tatra sarAgamaparadvayam // 65 // .... isameM kSAyika ko vItarAga evaM zeSa do (aupazamika, kSAyopazamika)ko sarAgasamyaktva kahA hai| 4. paMcAstikAya (tA.vR.150-151) yadAyaM jIvAHAgamabhASayAkAlAdilabdhirUpamadhyAtmabhASayA zuddhAtmAbhimukha pariNAma rUpaM svasaMvedanajJAnaM labhate tadA prathamatastAvanmithyAtvAdi saptaprakRtinAmupazamena kSayopazamenaca sarAga samyagdRSTibhUtvA paMcaparameSThIbhaktyAdi rUpeNa parAzrita dharmyadhyAna bahiraMga sahakAritvenAnaMtajJAnAdi svarUpo' hamityAdi bhAvanA svarUpamAtmAzritadharmyadhyAnaM prApya AgamakathitakrameNAsaMyata samyagdRSTayAdi guNasthAnacatuSTaya madhye kvApi guNasthAne darzana moha kSayeNa kSAyika samyaktvaM kRtvA...... 5. mokSamArgaprakAzaka-(9/322). jaisA saptatattvoM kA zraddhAna chadmastha ke huA thA,vaisA hI kevalI bhagavAna ke pAyA jAtA hai isalie jJAnAdika kI hInatA-adhikatA hone para bhI tiryaMcAdika va kevalI-siddha bhagavAna ke samyaktva guNa samAna hI kahA hai| ....kevalI-siddha bhagavAna rAgAdirUpa pariNamita nahIM hote, saMsAra avasthA ko nahIM cAhate, so yaha isa zraddhAna kA bala jaannaa|' 6. paMcAstikAya(tA.3.160) ...... 'vItarAga sarvajJa praNIta jIvAdipadArtha viSaye samyak zraddhAnaM jJAnaM cetyubhayaM grahasthatapodhanayo samAnaM .....' 7. zlokavArtika (2/1/2) sarAge vItarAge ca tasya sNbhvto'nyjsaa| . prazamAderabhivyaktiH zuddhimAtrAca cetsH||12|| yathaiva hi viziSTAtmasvarUpaMzraddhAnaM sarAgeSu saMbhavati tathA vItarAgeSvapIti tasyAvyAptirapi doSo na shNkniiyH||.....etaani pratyekaM samuditAni vA svasmin svasaMviditAni paratrakAyAvAgvyavahAravizeSa liMgAnumitAni sarAga samyagdarzanaM jJApayaMti .....' artha- jaise hI darzanamohanIya ke udaya rahita viziSTa AtmA kA svAbhAvika svarUpa zraddhAna ThIka sarAga samyagdRSTiyoM meM saMbhavatA hai| isI prakAra vItarAga jIvoM meM bhI svAbhAvika pariNAma rUpa zraddhAna vidyamAna hai| isa kAraNa usa samyagdarzana ke lakSaNa meM avyApti doSa hone kI bhI zaMkA nahIM karanI caahie| (lakSya ke pUre bheda-prabhedoM meM jo lakSaNa vyAptA hai, vaha avyAptanAma kA lakSaNAbhAsa nahIM hai| prazama,saMvega,anukaMpA aura Astikya ina cAra svabhAvoM se rAgI jIvoM meM samyagdarzana kI jJapti ho jAtI hai aura vItarAga jIvoM meM kevala AtmA kI vizuddhi se hI samyagdarzana vyakta ho jAtA hai| zlokArtha-sarAga va vItarAga donoM meM hI samyagdarzana saMbhava hai| tahA~ sarAga meM to prazamAdilakSaNoM ke dvArA usakI abhivyakti hotI hai aura vItarAga meM vaha kevala citta vizuddhi dvArA lakSita hotA hai| prazamAdi guNa eka eka karake yA samudita rUpa se apanI AtmA meM to svasaMvedanagamya hai aura dUsaroM meM kAya ca vacana vyavahAra rUpa vizeSa jJApaka liMgoM dvArA anumAna gamya hai| ina prazamAdi guNoM para se samyagdarzana jAna liyA jAtA hai| upasahAra-1.paramArthataH samyaktva (viparitAbhinivezarahita nija zuddhAtmA kA zraddhAna
Page #32
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ 32 rUpa pariNAma)eka hI prakAra kA hotA hai, use zraddhA/samyaktva guNa kI anaimittika nirmala paryAya kahA hai| isako hI nisargaja-adhigamaja bheda se do prakAra kA, aMtaraMga nimittApekSA se aupazamika,kSAyopazamika,kSAyika ke bheda se tIna prakAra kA, bahiraMga nimittApekSA se AjJA,mArga,upadeza,sUtra,bIja,saMkSepa,vistAra,artha,avagAr3ha,paramAvagAr3ha ke bheda se dasa prakAra kA kahA hai| punazca,nirUpaNa kI apekSA se nizcaya(vItarAga/svAzrita)evaM vyavahAra (sarAga/ parAzrita)ye do prakAra kA tathA sahacArI zubha,zuddha cAritrApekSA sarAga-vItarAga bheda se do prakAra kA tathA jJAnApekSA avagAr3ha-paramAvagAr3ha bheda se do prakAra kA kahA hai| 2. paramArthataH sarva samyagdarzana sAkSAt yA paraMparA se adhigamaja hI hote haiN| jaba ki cAritra to adhigamaja hI hotA hai| (dekho.- zlokavArtika 3 re sUtra kI TIkA) ... 3. nizcaya samyagdRSTi ko (jisako darzanamoha + anaMtAnubaMdhI catuSka kA upazama, kSayopazama, kSaya huA hai|) niyama se 1) deva-guru-dharma/deva-zAstra-guru kA, 2) tattvArthoM kA, 3)sva-para kA,4)nija zuddhAtmA kA (dravyakarma-nokarma-bhAvakarma rahita nija dhruvacidAnaMdAtmA kA) zraddhAna hotA hI hotA hai| nizcaya samyagdRSTi ke ye cAroM lakSaNa yugapat pAye jAte haiN| (dekho-mokSamArga prakAzaka-9/328) 4. samyaktvaprApti ke lie bahiraMga nimittoM meM 1) jAtismaraNa 2)vedanA 3) dharmazravaNa (dezanA) 4)jinabiMba darzana 5)samavazaraNAdi vibhUti yukta jina mahimA darzana 6)devarddhi darzana Adi jo kaheM haiM una saba meM dezanA pradhAna hai| niyamasAra gAthA 53 meM kahA hai-'sammatasyaNimitaM jiNasutaM tassa jANayA purisaa| .. antaraheU bhaNidA daMsaNa mohassa khaya paahudii||53|| 5. pravacanasAra gAthA 80- 'jo jANadi arahataM davvatta gunnttpjjytehi|| so jANadi appANaM moho khalu jAdi tassa layaM // 8 // isa gAthA meM moho zabda darzanamoha ke artha meM prayukta huA hai - aisA spaSTArtha tAtparyavRtti TIkA meM pU.jayasenAcArya deva ne kiyA hai tathA karaNalabdhi meM savikalpa svasaMvedana evaM anivRttikaraNoparAnta avikalpa svarUpa kI prApti honA likhA hai| -aba maiM mUla viSaya para jijJAsAkrama se carcA karatA huuN| jijJAsA 1-nizcaya-vyavahAra samyagdarzana kA kyA lakSaNa hai?paribhASA rUpa btaaie| nizcaya-vyavahAra samyagdarzana kI jo paribhASAe~ Apane dI hai ve sarva mAnya hI hai| paraMtu usa para se Apane kyA artha nikAlA? yahI na ki gRhastha avasthA meM bhI nizcayasamyaktva (nija zuddhAtmA hI upAdeya)hotA hai tathApi cAritra mohodaya se hone vAlI asthiratA vaza vaha samyagdRSTi jIva 'viSaya-kaSAyavaMcanArtha saMsAra sthiti chedanA vA paMcaparameSThISu guNastavanAdi bhakti kroti| taba vaha sarAga samyagdRSTi kahalAtA hai| kyoM ki darzanamoha+ anaMtAnubaMdhI kaSAya ke upazama, kSayopazama, kSaya se hone vAlA viparitAbhiniveza rahita zraddhAnarUpa AtmA kA pariNAma hI nizcaya samyaktva hai / aisA nizcaya samyaktvI jaba
Page #33
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ azubharAgAdi se bacane ke lie prazasta zubha rAga ke nimittabhUta deva-zAstra-guru Adi kA avalaMbana le pravartatA hai taba vaha sarAga samyagdRSTi kahalAtA hai aura jaba zubhAzubha donoM prakAra ke rAga ke avalaMbanoM ko chor3akara nijazuddhAtmA kA Azraya-avalaMbana letA hai taba vahI jIva vItarAga samyagdRSTi kahalAtA hai| aisA viziSTa puruSArtha mukhyarUpa se nigraMtha munirAja ke hI hotA pramANaH paMcAstikAya gAthA-165 tA.vR. TIkA evaM tattvapradIpikA TIkA donoM dekheN| aNNANAdo NANI jadi maNNadi zuddha sNpogaado| havaditti dukkhamokkhaM parasamayarado havadi jiivo||165|| tattvapradIpikAH sUkSma para samaya vyAkhyAnametat / arhadAdiSu bhagavatsu siddhisAdhanIbhUteSu . bhaktibalAnuraJjitA cittavRttiratra shuddhsNpryogH|athkhlvjnyaanlvaaveshaadydiyaavjjnyaanvaanpi tatAH zuddhasaMprayogAnmokSo bhavatIti abhiprAyeNa khidyamAnastatra pravartate tadA tAvatso'pi rAga lavasadbhAvAtparasamayarata ityupgiiyte| atha na kiMpunarniraMkuza rAgakalikalaMkitAntaraMgavRttiritaro jana iti||165|| tAtparyavRtti..... tadAkAle rasamayarato bhavati jIvo sa pUrvokto jJAnI jIva iti| tadyathA kazcitpuruSonirvikAra zuddhAtmabhAvanAlakSaNe paramopekSA saMyame sthaatumiihte| tatrAzakta san kAmakrodhAdyazuddha pariNAma vaMcanArtha saMsArasthiti chedanArthaM vA yadA paMcapImeSThiSu guNastavanAdi bhaktiM karoti tadA sUkSma para samaya pariNataH san sarAga-samyagdRSTirbhavati iti, yadi punaH zuddhAtmabhAvanA samartho'pi tAM tyaktvA zubhopayogAdeva mokSo bhavatItekAntena manyate tadA sthUla parasamaya pariNAmenAjJAnI mithyaadRssttirbhvti|ttH sthitaM ajJAnena jiivonshtiiti| tathA coktaM - kecidajJAnatAnaSTAH kecinnaSTAH prmaadtH| kecijjJAnAvalepena,kecin naSTazca naashitaaH||165||.. pravacanasAra gAthA 181 taa.vR.| tattvapradIpikA bhI dekheN| ... zubhAzubha zuddha dravyAvalambanamupayoga lakSaNaM ceti .... artha- prazasta zubha dravyoM (navadevatA)kA avalaMbana zubhopayoga kahalAtA hai, puNyabaMdha hotA hai| aprazasta-azubha dravyoM (paMceMdriya viSayoM) kA avalaMbana azubhopayoga kahalAtA hai| pApabaMdha hotA hai| zuddha Atmadravya ke avalaMbana se zuddhopayoga hotA hai| nijazuddhAtma(kAraNa paramAtmA,kAraNa samayasAra) zuddhadhyeya rUpa dravya kA avalaMbana zuddhopayoga kahalAtA hai| yaha caturtha guNasthAna meM nagaNya hai, paMcama guNasthAna meM sAmAyikAdi kAla meM hotA hai| (pravacanasAra gAthA 248 tA.vR. TIkA)tathA chaThaveM-sAtaveM guNasthAna meM pramattaapramattavasthArUpa munirAja ke zubha va zuddhopayoga pracuratA se hotA hI rahatA hai| " dekho-pravacanasAra gAthA 248 kI tA.vR. TIkA 'nanu zubhopayoginAmapi kvApi kAle zuddhopayoga bhAvanA dRzyate / zuddhopayoginAmapi
Page #34
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ 34 kvApi kAle zubhopayoga bhAvanA dRzyate / zrAvakANAmapi sAmAyikAdikAle zuddha bhAvanA dRzyate, teSAM kathaM vizeSo bhedo jJAyata iti / parihAramAha-yuktamuktaM bhavatA, paraM kintu ye pracureNa zubhopayogena vartante, te yadyapi kvApi kAle zuddhopayoga bhAvanAM kurvanti tathApi zubhopayogina evaM bhaNyante / ye'pi zuddhopayoginaste yadyapi kvApi kAle zubhopayogena vartante tatha zuddhopayogina eva / kasmAt bahupadasya pradhAnatvAdAmravananimbavanavaditi // 248 // jijJAsA 2 - nizcaya-vyavahAra samyagdarzana eka sAtha hote haiM yA Age pIche ? mahodaya ! Apane jo niSkarSa nikAlA hai ki vyavahAra samyagdarzana pahale hotA hai tathA nizcayasamyagdarzana bAda meM hotA hai yaha sarvathA galata hI hai| kyoM ki jo samyagdarzana darzanamohanIya + anaMtAnubaMdhIkaSAya ke upazama-kSayopazama, kSaya se ( viparItAbhiniveza rahita zraddhAnarUpa AtmA kA pariNAma rUpa) pragaTa hotA hai vahI nizcayasamyagdarzana hai| jaba taka Apako yaha karaNAnuyoga sammata samyaktva kA lakSaNa svIkArya nahIM hogA taba taka citta meM aisI bhrAMti banI rahegI / jaba bhI samyagdRSTi kA upayoga / vicAra zubhAzubha rUpa ho azuddhopayogarUpa pariNamatA hai taba bhI usakA zraddhAna yathArtha pratItirUpa banA hI rahatA hai| - jaba vaha mithyAtva anaMtAnubaMdhI yA mizra mohanIya ke udaya se nizcaya samyaktvarUpa pariNAma se gira jAyegA, tabhI vaha mithyAdRSTi, sAsAdana mizra pariNAma vAlA ho jAyegA / isalie caturtha, paMcama, SaSThama guNasthAnavartI jIva cAritrika asthiratAvaza zubhAcaraNarUpa sarAga avasthA meM Ane para bhI caturtha - paMcama guNasthAnavartI jIvoM ke viSayakaSAya rUpa azubharAga meM jA par3ane para bhI ve saba sarAga samyagdRSTi kahe jAne para bhI nizcaya samyagdRSTi hI bane rahate haiM / isalie paMcAstikAya (tA.vR. 160) meM gRhastha va munirAja ke samyagdarzana - jJAna samAna kahA hai / (kRpayA sarAMga- vItarAga samyagdarzana bAbada anya Agama pramANa 6 kA vistAra dekheM / ) astu / A.ka. paM. ToDaramalajI ne mo.mA.pra. (hindI) pR. 330 - 331 para isakA ati suMdara samAdhAna prastuta kiyA hai| unhoMne pUrvacara evaM sahacara vyavahAra ko spaSTa karate hue pUrvacara vyavahAra ko vyavahArAbhAsa siddha kiyA hai aura nizcaya ke sAtha pAye jAne vAle vyavahAra ko samIcIna vyavahAra kahA hai tathA eka hI kAla meM donoM kA honA mAnya kiyA hai| samyaktva ke bheda aura unakA svarUpa isa zIrSaka ke aMtargata unhoMne likhA hai| - aba isa samyaktva ke bheda batalAte haiM - 'vahA~ prathama nizcaya - vyavahAra kA bheda batalAte haiN| - viparItAbhiniveza rahita zraddhAna rUpa AtmA kA pariNAma vaha to nizcayasamyaktva hai kyoM ki yaha satyArtha samyaktva kA rUpa hai| satyArtha kA nAma nizcaya hai tathA viparItAbhinivezarahita zraddhAna ko kAraNabhUta zraddhAna so vyavahAra samyaktva hai, kyoM ki kAraNa meM kArya kA upacAra kiyA hai, so upacAra kA hI nAma vyavahAra hai / ' vahA~ samyagdRSTi jIva ke deva-guru-dharmAdika ko saccA zraddhAna hai, usI nimitta se isake zraddhAna meM viparItAbhiniveza kA abhAva hai| yahA~ viparItAbhiniveza rahita zraddhAna so to nizcaya samyaktva hai aura deva-gurudharmAdika kA
Page #35
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ 35 zraddhA hai so vyavahAra samyaktva hai| isaprakAra eka hI kAla meM donoM samyaktva pAye jAte haiM / tathA mithyAdRSTi jIva ke deva-guru-dharmAdika kA zraddhAna AbhAsa mAtra hotA hai / aura isake zraddhAna meM viparItAbhiniveza kA abhAva nahIM hotaa| isalie yahA~ nizcaya samyaktva to hai nahIM aura vyavahAra samyaktva bhI AbhAsamAtra hai. kyoM ki isake deva-guru-dharmAdika kA zraddhAna hai so viparItAbhiniveza ke abhAva ko sAkSAt kAraNa nahIM huaa| kAraNa hue binA upacAra saMbhava nahIM hai / isalie sAkSAt kAraNa apekSA vyavahAra samyaktva bhI isake saMbhava nahIM hai / athavA isake deva-guru-dharmAdika kA zraddhAna niyamarUpa hotA hai so viparItAbhiniveza rahita zraddhAna ko paraMparA kAraNabhUta hai / yadyapi niyamarUpa kAraNa nahIM hai tathApi mukhyarUpa se kAraNa hai| tathA kAraNa meM kArya kA upacAra saMbhava hai, isalie mukhya rUpa paraMparA kAraNa apekSA. mithyAdRSTi bhI vyavahAra samyaktva kahA jAtA hai| (mo.mA.pra. - pR. 331 ) uparokta vivecana se tathA ( kRpayA sarAga- vItarAga samyagdarzana bAbada anya Agama pramANa6 kA vistAra dekheM / ) isa meM uddhRta AgamapramANoM se ki vItarAga samyagdarzana ko. kSAyika samyagdarzana tathA aupazamika, kSAyopazamika ko sarAga samyagdarzana kahA hai yaha bhI bhalIbhA~ti siddha huA ki nizcaya - vyavahAra samyagdarzana Age-pIche nahIM varan eka hI kAla meM pragaTa hote haiN| paMcAstikAya tA.vR. 160 TIkA meM to spaSTa hI likhA hai ki- vItarAga sarvajJa praNIta jIvAdipadArtha viSaye samyak zraddhAnaM jJAnaM cetyubhayaM gRhasthatapodhanayoH samAnaM / .... ' ) sAdhya-sAdhana kI apekSA se vicAra kiyA jAya to avazya hI yahI kahA jAyegA ki vyavahAra sAdhana hai aura nizcaya sAdhya hai| jaise ki vyavahAra ratnatraya sAdhana aura nizcaya ratnatraya sAdhya hai| vyavahAra AcaraNa pUrvacara bhI hotA hai aura sahacara bhii| jaba nizcaya sAdhya pragaTa ho taba sahacara vyavahAra sAdhana yathArtha vyavahAra sAdhana kahalAtA hai| vyavahAra mokSamArga evaM nizcaya mokSamArga kI evaM unake avayava samyagdarzanajJAna - cAritra kI vyavahAra - nizcayarUpa paribhASA Apane svayaM jijJAsA 1 ke samAdhAna meM samayasAra gAthA - 155 tA.vR. TIkA udghRta kara de hI dI hai| jo yathArtha hI hai / nizcaya - vyavahAra ye donoM pariNAma sAdhaka avasthA meM (caturtha paMcama - SaSThama guNasthAnoM meM jahA~ buddhipUrvaka grahaNa -tyAga kA vicAra vikalpa vartatA hai) paraspara sApekSa hI hote haiM, arthAt yugapat hI hote haiM / nirapekSa ho to mithyA hote haiN| paMcAstikAya - gAthA 172 tA.vR. TIkA meM spaSTa likhA hai - athaivaM pUrvoktaM prakAreNAsya prAbhRtasya zAstrasya vItarAgatvameva tAtparya jJAtavyaM tacca vItarAgatvaM nizcaya vyavahAra nayAbhyAM: sAdhyasAdhakarUpeNa parasparasApekSAbhyAmeva bhavati, muktisiddhaye na ca punarnirapekSAbhyAmitivArtikaM / tadyathA-ye kecana vizuddha jJAnadarzanasvabhAvazuddhAtmatattvasamyak zraddhAnajJAnAnuSThAnarUpa nizcaya mokSamArga nirapekSa kevala zubhAnuSThAna rUpaM vyavahAranayameva mokSamArga manyate tena tu suralokAdikleza paraMparayA saMsAraM paribhramaMtIti, yadi zuddhAtmAnubhUtilakSaNam nizcayamokSamArgaM manyate nizcayamokSamArgAnuSThAMna zaktyabhAvAtrizcayasAdhakaM 'zubhAnuSThAnaM ca kurvanti tarhi sarAgasamyagdRSTayo bhavanti paraMparayA
Page #36
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ mokSaM labhate iMti vyavahAraikAnta nirAkAraNa mukhyatvena vAkya dvayaM gtN| ye pi kevala nizcaya nayAvalaMbinaH saMtopi rAgAdi vikalpa rahitaM parama samAdhirUpaM zuddhAtmAnamalabhamAnA api tapodhanAcaraNa yogyaM SaDAvazyakAdi anuSThAna zrAvakAcaraNa yogyaM dAnapUjAdyanuSThAnaM ca dUSayate tepyubhaya bhraSTAH saMto nizcaya vyavahArAnuSThAna yogyAvasthAntaramajAnantaH pApameva bdhnnti| yadi punaH / zuddhAtmAnuSThAna rUpaM mokSamArga tatsAdhakaMvyavahAra mokSamArga manyate tarhi cAritramohodayAt zaktyabhAvena zubhAzubhAnuSThAna rahitA api yadyapi zuddhAtmabhAvanAsApekSa zubhAnuSThAnarata puruSasadRzA na bhavanti tathApi sarAga-samyaktvAdidAna vyavahAra samyagdaSTayo bhavanti, paraMparayA mokSaM ca labhante-iti nizcayaikAnta nirAkaraNaM mukhyatvena vAkya dvayaM gatam / tataH sthitametannizcaya vyavahAra paraspara sAdhyasAdhaka bhAvena rAgAdi vikalparahita paramasamAdhibalenaiva mokSaM labhate // 172 / / phalitArtha (jijJAsA 2 ke bAre meM ) (mo.mA.pra.pR.325) -- jaise aNuvrata, mahAvrata hone para to dezacAritra, sakalacAritra ho yA na ho, paraMtu aNuvratamahAvrata hue binA dezacAritra, sakalacAritra kadAcit nahIM hotA, isalie ina vratoM ko anvaya rUpa kAraNa jAnakara kAraNa meM kArya kA upacAra karake inako cAritra kahA hai| usI prakAra arahaMta devAdika kA zraddhAna hone para to samyaktva ho yA na ho, paraMtu arahaMtAdika kA zraddhAna hue binA tattvArthazraddhAna rUpa samyaktva kadAcit nahIM hotA, isalie arahaMtAdika ke zraddhAna ko anvayarUpa kAraNa jAnakara kAraNa meM kArya kA upacAra karake isa zraddhAna ko samyaktva kahA hai| isIse isakA nAma vyavahAra samyaktva hai| 'arahaMta devAdika ke zraddhAna se kudevAdika kA zraddhAna dUra hone ke kAraNa gRhita mithyAtva kA abhAva hotA hai, usa apekSA isako samyaktva kahA hai| sarvathA samyaktva kA lakSaNa yaha nahIM hai, kyoM ki dravyaliMgI muni Adi vyavahAra dharma ke dhAraka mithyAdRSTiyoM ke bhI aisA zraddhAna hotA hai|' - (mo.mA.pra.pR.325) . isaprakAra vyavahAra samyaktva pUrvacara rUpa se (samyaktva ke sanmukha mithyAdRSTi jIvake) pAyA jAne para hI use karaNalabdhi pUrvaka avikalpasvarUpopalabdhi rUpa nizcaya samyaktva kI prApti ho jAtI hai, isI hetu se vyavahAra ko pahale hotA hai kahA hai, paraMtu niyAmakatA nahIM hai ki ho hI jaayegaa| isIprakAra aNuvrata/pratimAdhArI vratI zrAvaka hone para do kaSAyoM ke abhAva rUpa nizcaya zrAvakapanA rUpa paMcama guNasthAna ho jAtA hai, paraMtu niyAmakatA rUpa nahIM hai ki ho hI jaayegaa| isIprakAra mahAvrata dhAraNa karane(jinadIkSA grahaNa kara lene)para hI sAmAyikAdi zuddhopayoga ke kAla meM tIna kaSAyoM kA abhAva hokara apramatta-pramattaguNasthAna pragaTa ho jAtA hai paraMtu niyAmakatA rUpa nahIM hai ki ho hI jaayegaa| jina jIvoM ke mithyAtvakarma ke upazamAdi hone para caturtha avirata samyagdRSTi guNasthAna,apratyAkhyAnAvaraNa kaSAya kA abhAva hone jamyo para paMcama saMyamAsaMyama guNasthAnaM aura pratyAkhyAnAvaraNa kaSAya kA bhI abhAva ho jAne para sakala saMyama(apramattAdi)saptama-SaSThama guNasthAna kI prApti ho jAtI
Page #37
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ 37 hai| ve hI kramazaH nizcaya samyaktvI zrAvaka va muni hote haiN| tabhI vyavahAra samyaktva, aNuvrata va mahAvrata ko pUrvacarApekSA sAdhana saMjJA hotI hai| taba ve sahacararUpa, kAraNa rUpa-sAdhana rUpa vidyamAna rahate haiN| jijJAsA 3 - kyA samyagdarzana kI paryAya nizcaya-vyavahAra do rUpa hotI hai? . mahodaya, Apane yaha jo niSkarSa nikAlA hai ki nizcaya samyaktva to kabhI-kabhI hotA hai jaba ki vyavahAra samyaktva pracuratA se rahatA hai, yaha nitAnta bhramapUrNa hai| isakA khulAsA maiM jijJAsA 1 va 2 meM kara hI AyA huuN| paramArthataH nizcaya-vyavahAra do rUpa se nirUpaNa kiyA jAtA hai| nizcaya to anirvacanIya hI hotA hai aura usakI bAhya vyavahAra lakSaNoM se pahacAna karAyI jAtI hai| vastutaH sarAga/vyavahAra samyaktva to nizcaya/vItarAga samyaktva kA jJApaka nimitta hai jo sAdhaka avasthA meM pAyA jAtA hai| arahaMtAvasthA meM to sarAga samyaktva va sarAga cAritra (mahAvratAdirUpa vyavahAra cAritra)kA abhAva hI ho jAtA hai| jaba ki kSAyika samyaktva va kSAyika cAritra Adi anaMtakAla (AtmA meM)pragaTa banA rahatA hai| ataH Apako yathArtha kA nAma nizcaya evaM upacAra kA nAma vyavahAra aisA hI nirNaya karanA caahie| jo upacAra/vyavahAra ko paramArtha/nizcaya mAnate haiM ve to mithyAdRSTi hI haiM tathA ve bhIjo sAdhaka avasthA meM upacAra/vyavahAra sAdhana kA sarvathA niSedha karate haiM mithyAdRSTi hI haiM aura jo zubhopayoga karate-karate zuddhopayoga ho jAtA hai aisA mAnate haiM, ve bhI mithyAdRSTipane ko prApta ho jAte haiN| kyoM ki yadi aisA hI mAnA jAye to zubhopayoga se pahale hone vAle/rahane vAle azubhopayoga ko zubhopayoga kA kAraNa mAnanA par3egA-jo saMbhava nahIM hai| isakA bhI khulAsA bhI A.ka.paM.ToDaramalajI ne mo.mA.pra.pR.256 para kiyA hai| - 'dravyaliMgI ke zubhopayoga to utkRSTa hotA hai, zuddhopayoga hotA hI nahIM, isalie paramArtha se inake kAraNakAryapanA nahIM hai| itanA hai ki zubhopayoga hone para zuddhopayoga kA yatla kareM to ho jAye, paraMtu yadi zubhopayoga ko hI bhalA jAnakara usakA sAdhana kiyA kare to zuddhopayoga kaise ho? . . - . isalie mithyAdRSTi kA zubhopayoga to zuddhopayoga kA kAraNa hai hI nahIM, samyagdRSTi ko zubhopayoga hone para nikaTa zuddhopayoga prApta ho-aisI mukhyatA se kahIM zubhopayoga ko zuddhopayoga kA kAraNa bhI kahate haiN| __ Apane jo-jo AgamapramANa diye haiM ve mujhe pUrNataH mAnya haiN| jo pracuratA se prazastarAga sahita vartana karane vAle caturtha-paMcama-SaSThama guNasthAnavI jIva hai,unake viparItAbhiniveza rahita nizcaya samyaktva ko hI sarAga samyaktva saMjJA hai aura jo mahAmunirAja pracuratA se zuddhopayoga meM vartana kara rahe haiM unake usa nizcaya samyaktva ko hI vItarAga samyaktva kahA hai| sarAgatAvItarAgatA yaha cAritraguNa kA pariNamana hai, na ki zraddhA-samyaktva guNa kA ! samyaktva kI ghAtaka to darNanamoha meM anaMtAnubaMdhI prakRti hai, usakA abhAva hone para (udayasta rahane para)jo nirmala pratIti pAyI jAtI hai vahI nizcaya samyaktva hai, tathA jo sarAga :
Page #38
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ 38 samyaktva ke bAhya lakSaNa pravRtti rUpa to nArakiyoM va tiryaMcoM meM pAye hI nahIM jAte to bhI unake nizcaya samyaktva vidyamAna rahatA hai| isalie abhiprAya/mAnyatA samyak hue binA jJAnacAritra bhI samyakpane ko prApta nahIM hote haiN| jijJAsA 4 - kSAyika samyagdRSTi zreNika kejIva ko naraka meM nizcaya samyagdarzana hai yA vyavahAra yA donoM ? mahodaya ! Apane to isakA samAdhAna aise likhakara kiyA hai ki naraka meM rAjA zreNika ke jIva ko mAtra vyavahAra samyagdarzana hai, nizcaya samyagdarzana nahIM hai-gajaba hI kara diyA ? Apane jaba yaha dhAraNA hI banA lI ho ki nizcaya samyaktva to nizcaya cAritra kA hI avinAbhAvI hai taba to Apa aisA hI likheNge| kSAyika samyagdRSTi ko vyavahAra / sarAga samyagdRSTi kahanA atisAhasa kI bAta hai| kRpayA maiMne sarvArthasiddhi, rAjavArtika, amitagati zrAvakAcArAdi ke udA. pramANa diye haiM, unakA avalokana kreN| vahA~ para spaSTa rUpa se kSAyika samyaktva ko vItarAga evaM zeSa do ( aupazamika kSAyopazamika) ko sarAga samyaktva kahA hai / ( kyoM ki ye donoM chUTa jAte haiM, sAdi anaMtakAla nahIM rahate haiN|) tathA jo Apane bRhad dravyasaMgraha meM mahArAjA bharata ke kSAyika samyagdarzana ko vyavahAra samyagdarzana likhA hone kA pramANa diyA so sarAga avasthA meM nizcaya samyaktva to hai paraMtu jo paramAtma prakAza 2- 18 TIkA kA uddharaNa Apa svayaM jijJAsA 1 ke samAdhAna meM de Aye haiN| usase bhI milAna kara dekhnaa| unake gRhasthAvasthA meM nizcaya samyaktva to hai, paraMtu cAritramoha ke udaya se sthiratA nahIM hai / tathA ve azubha se bacane ke lie zubha kriyA karate haiM, isalie zubharAga ke saMbaMdha se sarAga samyagdRSTi hai aura inake samyaktva ko nizcaya samyaktva saMjJA bhI hai kyoM ki vItarAga cAritra se tanmayI nizcaya samyaktva ke paraMparayA sAdhakapanA hai| vAstava meM vicAra kiyA jAveM to gRhasthAvasthA meM inake vaha sarAga samyaktva kahA jAne vAlA vyavahAra samyaktva hI hai, aisA jAno / yahA~ para maiM Apa se jAnanA cAhatA hU~ ki nizcaya cAritra kA avinAbhAvI jo nizcaya vItarAga samyaktva hai - hotA hai, usa samaya darzanamoha kI kaunasI prakRti kA abhAva ho jAtA hai? are, vahA~ to usI nizcaya kSAyika samyaktva kI paryAya hai aura usameM aba kyA nirmalatA AnI bAkI hai? mAtra cAritra kI sarAga/azuddhAvasthA miTane se usa kSAyika samyaktva ko hI vItarAga samyaktva nAma diyA hai| Agama meM mAtra anaMtAnubaMdhI kaSAya ko hI dvisvabhAvI arthAt samyaktva evaM cAritra kI ghAtaka (darzanamoha ke sAtha) kahI hai na ki apratyAkhyAnAvaraNa yA pratyAkhyAnAvaraNa ko ! ataH Apa Agama ke Aloka meM avazya hI isa biMdu para vicAra kreN| vijJeSu kimdhikam / jijJAsA 5 - aupazamika kSAyopazamika, kSAyika-ina tInoM prakAra ke samyagdRSTiyoM ko 'kyA (AtmAnubhUti rahita) AtmavizvAsa eka sadRza hotA hai? yA tInoM ke AtmavizvAsa meM kucha aMtara rahatA hai?
Page #39
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ 39 mahodaya ! Apane tInoM prakAra ke samyagdRSTiyoM ko savikalpAvasthA meM zuddhAtmA kI anubhUti rahita AtmavizvAsa honA svIkArA, kSAyika va aupazamika ko nirdoSa aura kSAyopazamika vAle ko sadoSa ( kyoM ki usake samyaktva mohanIya kA udaya hai / ) mAnya kiyA hai aura yaha vizvAsa Apake anusAra nirvikalpa samAdhi kAla meM zuddha AtmAnubhUti sahita tathA savikalpa avasthA meM zuddha AtmAnubhUti rahita hotA hai| paraMtu Apane samyagdRSTi jIva ko jo AtmAnubhUti rahita AtmA kA vizvAsa honA mAtra batalAyA / likhA hai, usakA Agama pramANa nahIM diyA ? Atma vizvAsa - AtmA kA vizvAsa kauna se Agama-adhyAtma graMthoM meM AyA hai? isa zabda kI khoja Apane kI hai yA kahIM para labdhisArAdi meM likhA ho ki anivRttikaraNoparAMta Atma vizvAsa / AtmA kA vizvAsa mithyAtva kA upazama ho jAne para pUrNa pragaTa ho jAtA hai| jaisA ki Apane jijJAsA 8 ke samAdhAna meM likhA hai tathA jijJAsA 6 ke samAdhAna meM bhI Apane TIkA meM Aye mUla zabdoM ko gauNakaraapane mana mutAbika artha kara DAlA hai ! AtmAnubhUti ki guNa kI paryAya mAnate haiM? aura savikalpa nirvikalpa paryAya kisa guNa kI paryAya mAnakara artha kara rahe haiM? anubhava, anubhUti, vedanA saMvedana yaha mati zrutajJAna meM hI hotA hai aura sAkAra upayoga savikalpa hI hotA hai| paraMtu mokSamArga meM rAga-dveSa-moha se upayoga ko bAraMbAra bhramAnA ( eka jJeya se dUsare, dUsare jJeya se tIsare jJeya para le jAnA) caMcala karane ko hI vikalpa kahA hai / isakI spaSTatA mo.mA.pra. pRSTha 210-211 para paM. ToDaramalajI ne kI hai| yadi Apa aisA hI artha * kara rahe haiM taba phira prazna hai ki pravacanasAra gAthA 80 kI tA.vR. TIkA meM karaNalabdhi praviSTa jIva ko 'savikalpa svasaMvedanajJAnena' tathA karaNalabdhi (anivRttikaraNa) ke anaMtara samaya meM 'avikalpa svarUparUpe prApte' ina zabdoM kA artha AtmAnubhUtiparaka hI hotA hai yA kore AtmavizvAsa rUpa? vastutaH yaha AtmAnubhUtisvarUpa hI hai| isase caturtha guNasthAna meM avirata samyagdRSTi ko tathA pra.sA.mAthA 248 tA.vR. TIkAnusAra zrAvaka paMcamaguNasthAnavartI ko ( 'sAmAyikAdi kvApi kAle ' ) nirvikalpa AtmAnubhUti kI siddhi ho jAtI hai| itanA hI nahIM, pra.sA. gAthA 201 meM ( evaM paNamiya siddhe... ) tAtparyavRtti TIkA meM to A. jayasena deva ne 'jiNavaravasahe' zabda kI vyAkhyA meM 'sAsAdanAdi kSINa kaSAyAntA ekadeza jinA ucyante, zeSAzcAnAgAra kevalinoM jinavarAbhaNyante, tIrthaMkara parama devAzca jinavara vRSabhA iti tAn jinavara vRssbhaan| ... ') dUsare guNasthAna se bArahaveM guNasthAnavartI jIvoM ko ekadeza jina taka kahA hai / isa bAta ko Apa kisa prakAra mAnya karate haiM? mAtra AtmavizvAsa hone se ? yA jAtyaMtara jJAnAnubhava / AtmAnubhava / sukhAnubhava hone se ? yahI bAta samayasAra gAthA 13 kI TIkA meM kahI hai| niSpakSa hokara vicAra karane para yaha bAta ja~cegI / bhAsita hogI, anyathA nahIM / yaha jIva ajJAnI kala taka rahatA hai? yaha pUche jAne para A. jayasenadeva ne samayasAra gAthA19 (kamme Nokammahi... ) tA. kR. TIkA meM bahirAtmA ko svasaMvitti zUnya evaM svayaMbuddha yA
Page #40
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ 40 bodhitabuddha jJAnI jIvoM ko bhedajJAna mUlaka zuddhAtmAnubhUti kI prApti honA likhA hai| ... 'apratibuddhaH svasaMvittizUnyo bahirAtmAbhavati taavtkaalmiti| atra bhedavijJAna mUlAM zuddhAtmAnubhUtiM svataH svayaMbuddhayApekSA parato vA bodhitabuddhayApekSayA ye labhaMte te puruSAH zubhAzubha bahirdravyeSu vidyamAneSvapi mukurandavadavikArA bhavaMtIti bhaavaarthH|' __ arthAt samyagdRSTi jJAnI jIva saMsAra avasthA meM zubhAzubha bahirdravyoM ke vidyamAna hote hue bhI darpaNa ke samAna nirvikAra rahate haiM, aisA bhAvArtha hai| Apa samayasAra jI meM vItarAga nirvikalpa samAdhirata jJAnI samyagdRSTi kI mukhyatA kA kathana mAnate haiM aura anya samyagdRSTiyoM kA gauNa rUpa se / aba yadi hama aisA hI mAnakara caleM taba bhI samayasAra gAthA 35 (jahaNAma ko vi puriso...) tA.vR.TIkA meM pratyAkhyAna bAbad dhobI kA dRSTAMta dekara apratibuddha 'svasaMvedana jJAnabala'se mithyAtvarAgAdi parabhAvoM kI paryAyoM ko ye parakIya haiM (apane svabhAva meM nahIM hai) aisA jAnakara una saba parabhAvoM ko tatkAla chor3a detA hai aura zuddhAtmAnubhUti ko anubhavatA hai, aisA spaSTarUpa se likhA hai|arthaat pratibuddhatA svAnubhUtipUrvaka hI hotI hai yaha siddha huaa| aura bhI dekhie / zrI jayasenAcArya deva samayasAra gAthA 38 (ahamikko khalu zuddho...)kI utthanikA meM likhate haiM'atha zuddhotmaivopAdeya iti zraddhAnaM samyaktvaM tasminneva zuddhAtmani svasaMvedanaM samyagjJAnaM, tatraiva nijAtmani vItarAga svasaMvedanaM nizcala rUpaMcAritramiti nizcaya ratnatraya pariNata jIvasya kIdRzaM svarUpaM bhavatItyAvedayansan jiivaadhikaarmupsNhrti|' isameM 'svasaMvedana' samyagjJAna hai, kahA hI hai aura caturtha guNasthAnavartI se upara ke sabhI guNasthAnAnuvartI jIva samyagjJAnI hI hote haiN| binA svasaMvedana jJAna ke koI bhI jIva samyagjJAnI nahIM ho sktaa| yaha bAta sarva graMthoM meM likhI huI hai| punazca samayasAra gAthA 50 se 55 (jIvassa Natthi vaNNo....)kI TIkA meM aneka bAra 'zuddhAtmAnubhUte bhinnatvAt ' zabda likhA hai ki ye varNAdika se guNasthAna taka ke bhAva jIva ke.nahIM hai| kisa kAraNa se nahIM hai? kyoM ki ye sabhI pudgala dravya ke pariNAma hone se 'zuddhAtmAnubhUti se bhinna haiN|' aba jo yadi samyagdRSTi jJAnI jIva ke zuddhAtmAnubhUti sarvathA hI na mAnI jAye to usane mAtra parokSa AgamasApekSa jJAna se ina varNAdi bhAvoM ko apane se bhinna jAnA kahalAyegA, nizcaya anubhUti (svAda)pUrvakajAnA nahIM kahalAyegA? paraMtu aisA mAnane se sarvatattvaviplava ho jaayegaa| gyAraha aMgoM Adi kA kSayopazama vAle mithyAdRSTi jIvoM ko bhI pratyakSa jJAnI mAnane kA prasaMga AyegA, jo kabhI kisI prakAra sahI nahIM kahA jA sktaa| sabhI samyagdRSTi svAnubhava pratyakSa se jJAnI hai, na ki bAhya tyAga tapasyA yA bAhya kSAyopazamika jJAna kI adhikatA se| punazca, samayasAra gAthA-70 (kohAdisu vaTuMta sa...)tA.vR.TIkA meM likhA hai'....kiMca yAvat krodhodyAsaMvebhyo bhinnaM zuddhAtma svarUpa svasaMvedanajJAnabalena na jAnAti tAvatkAlamajJAnI bhavati / ajJAnI san ajJAnajAMkartRkarmapravRttiM na muJcati tasmAbaMdho /
Page #41
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ 41 bhvti| baMdhAtsaMsAraM pribhrmtiitybhipraayH|' punazca, samayasAra gAthA-177,178 tA.vR. TIkA (rAgo doso moho ya AsavANatthi smmdihiss| tamhA AsavabhAveNa viNAhedUNa pccyaahoNti|| hedu jadubviyappo....) - TIkA-rAgadveSamohAH samyagdRSTena bhavaMti samyagdRSTatvAnyathAnupapatteriti hetu: tathAhianaMtAnubaMdhikrodhamAnamAyAlobha mithyAtvodayajanitA rAgadveSamohAH samyagdRSTerna- saMtIti pkssH| kasmAt? iticet kevalajJAnAdi anaMtaguNasahita paramAtmopAdeyatve sati vItarAga sarvajJa praNIta SadravyapaMcAstikAyasaptatatva nava padArtha rucirUpasya mUDhatrayAdi paMcaviMzati doSa rahitasya.....tathA coktaM AdyA samyaktvAcAritre dvitIyA dhvanatyaNuvrataM / tRtIyAsaMyamaMtu-yathAkhyAtaM kudhAdayaH / artha-caturthaguNasthAna vAle samyagdRSTi jIva ko rAga-dveSa-moha nahIM hote haiN| kyoM ki ina bhAvoM ke hone para samyagdRSTipana bana hI nahIM sakatA hai| ise spaSTa kara batalA rahe haiM kicaturthaguNasthAnavartI sarAga samyagdRSTi jIva ke anaMtAnubaMdhI krodha,mAna,mAyA,lobha evaM mithyAtva ke udaya meM hone vAle rAga-dveSa-moha ke bhAva nahIM hote|...(isiiprkaar paMcamaguNasthAna-vartI zrAvaka ke anaMtAnubaMdhI evaM apratyAkhyAnAvaraNa do kaSAya tathA chaThaveM guNasthAna vartI muni ke anaMtAnubaMdhI,apratyAkhyAnAvaraNa aura pratyAkhyAnAvaraNa ye tIna kaSAyarUpa krodha-mAna-mAyA-lobha rUpa rAga-dveSa-moha nahIM hote haiM tathA saptama guNasthAnavartI munirAja vItarAga(vItarAgasamyagdRSTi) ke inhIM kaSAyoM ke tIvra udaya janita pramAdotpAdaka rAga-dveSa-moha nahIM hote| ___ aura isI prakAra anya graMtha meM bhI kahA hai ki prathama mithyAtva aura anaMtAnubaMdhI vAle krodha-mAna-mAyA-lobhasamyaktva aura cAritra ina donoMkonahIM honedete haiN| dUsareapratyAkhyAnAvaraNa kaSAya samyaktva aura svAnubhUti/svasaMvedanarUpa samyagjJAna ko nahIM rokate haiM, lekina aNuvrata nahIM hone dete haiN| tIsare pratyAkhyAnAvaraNa kaSAya samyaktva aura dezavrata ko nahIM rokate haiM, lekina sakala saMyama nahIM hone dete haiN| uparokta kathana kA tAtparya yahI hai ki caturtha guNasthAna meM anaMtAnubaMdhI ke abhAva meM tajjanya krodhAdi nahIM hote haiM aura jo vizuddhi pragaTatI hai, use samyaktvAcaraNa cAritra nAma diyA hai| isa guNasthAnavartI jIva ke pragaTa dikhAyI de aisA dezavrata/sakalavrata kA pariNama rUpa cAritra nahIM hotA aura na koI AgamI adhyAtmI mAnatA hai ki aisA cAritra hotA hai| jijJAsA 6 - pra. sA. gAthA 80 evaM samayasAra gAthA 320 kI tAtparyavRtti TIkAoM meM kramazaH karaNalandhipUrvaka avikalpasvarUpa kI prApti' tathA bhavyatva zakti kI vyaktatA' kA svarUpa batalAyA hai| kyA isakA artha mAtra AtmavizvAsa honA hI samyagdarzana mAnA gayA hai?
Page #42
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ 42 isakA samAdhAna ApakA sahI isalie nahIM hai ki Apako nizcaya-samyaktva ke rUpa -svarUpa meM pUrA viparyAsa hai| isakI sapramANa vistRta carcA maiM jijJAsA 3,4 evaM 5 meM Upara kara AyA hN|vhaaNyh siddha kiyAjAcukA hai ki pratibaddhatA (AtmajJAna/samyagdarzana) svAtmAnubhUtipUrvaka hI hotI hai| jijJAsA 7-(a)pravacanasAragAthA 80 tA.vR. TIkAke prAraMbha meM ullikhita 'atha cattApAvAraMma(gAthA 79)ityAdi sUtreNa yaduktaM zuddhopayogAbhAve mohAdivinAzo na bhavati, mohAdi vinAzAbhAve zuddhAtma lAmo na bhvti|'...kaa kyA artha hai? mahodaya ! Apane isakA artha bhI galata kara diyaa| Apane 79 gAthA kA artha kara diyA jaba ki 80 vIM gAthA kI tA.va. TIkA kA artha karanA thA / Apane moha zabda kA artha cAritramoha kara diyA jaba ki aneka jagaha tathA isI gAthA kI TIkA meM moha zabda kA artha darzanamoha kiyA hai, likhA hai svayaM AcAryadeva ne ! jinAgama meM sarvatra moha kA artha darzana moha tathA rAgadveSa (kSobha) kA artha cAritramoha kiyA hai| pramANa ke lie Apa pravacanasAra kI gAthA80,81,83,85,86,88,89,92, 180, 188, 194,195,196 tA.vR.TIkA dekheM / samayasAra gAthA 281 bhI dekheN| yaha to Apa bhI mAnya kara rahe haiM,karanA bhI cAhie ki zuddha AtmasvarUpa kI prApti ke lie mohAdi kevinAza ke lie zuddhopayoga Avazyaka hai| phira bhI moha zabda kA Apa yahA~ 80 vIM gAthA meM cAritramoha kareM yahI Azcarya hai| isake alAvA Apane pravacanasAra gAthA 248 (dasaNaNANuvadeso.....) kI tA.vR.TIkA kA artha likhanA kyoM chor3a diyA? kyoM ki usameM spaSTa rUpa se zrAvakoM ke sAmAyikAdidhyAna kAla meM zuddhopayoga hotA hai yaha siddha kiyA hai| kRpayA punarvicAra kreN| jijJAsA 8 - prAyogyalandhi meM, karaNalandhi meM tathA anivRttikaraNoparAMta hone vAle AtmA ke vizvAsa meM kyA aMtara hai? . ' mahodaya ! Apane prAyogyalabdhistha jIva ko AtmA kA vizvAsa nahIM honA, karaNalabdhi meM AtmavizvAsa kA honA prArambha honA(pUrNa AtmavizvAsa nahIM ho pAnA, kyoM ki pratibaMdhaka darzanamoha/mithyAtva kA sadbhAva hai) tathA anivRttikaraNa ke uparAMta mithyAtva kA upazama ho jAne se AtmavizvAsa pUrNa prakaTa ho jAtA hai-mAnya kiyA hai| Apa hI ke anusAra isI AtmavizvAsa hI kA nAma samyagdarzana hai| kyoM ki jaba taka mithyAtva kA udaya hai taba taka tattva zraddhAnamUlaka AtmavizvAsa bilkula saMbhava nahIM hai| .. samyagdarzana-(zuddhAtmA kI ruci, pratIti svasaMvedana, AtmakhyAti) ko AtmA kA vizvAsa zabda diyA jAnA vicAraNIya hai kyoM ki samayasAra gAthA - 13 kI TIkA meM isa zabda kA prayoga donoM hI AcAryoM ne nahIM kiyA hai, mAtra Apake sivAya? Apa aisA kyoM kara rahe haiM, ApakA maMtavya/ abhiprAya samajha pAnA kaThina hai|
Page #43
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ 43 samyaktvopalabdhi se pUrva jinopadiSTa tattvoM kA zravaNa, grahaNa, dhAraNa, nirdhAraNa hotA hai| dhAraNA jJAna taka yaha jIva anekoM bAra A jAtA hai, paraMtu nirdhAraNa nahIM karatA ki yaha upadeza mere bhava roga janma maraNa miTAne kI auSadhi hai tathA jo prAyogyalabdhistha jIva ko 'yaha aise hI hai' aisI savikalpa jJAna meM nirNayAtmaka ruci ho jAye to hI vaha zuddhAtmAbhimukha pariNAma rUpa karaNalabdhi meM praveza kara sakatA hai,anyathA nhiiN| arthAt jo yadi use AtmA kA vizvAsa hI na Aye to kyA vaha prAyogyalabdhi taka AyA kahalAyegA?phira vaha apane mati zruta jJAnopayoga ko svarUpa sanmukha kyoM kara karegA? (dekho-sa.sA.-144-AtmakhyAti TIkA) yaha bAta to Apane svIkAra hI lI hai ki 'samyaktva samAna to AtmA kA vizvAsa bhI samAna / kyoM ki apratyAkhyAnAvaraNa kaSAya kA anudaya AtmavizvAsa meM koI vizeSatA lAne meM samartha nahIM hai| taba phira bandhuvara ! pratyAkhyAnAvaraNa kA anudaya usa AtmA ko vizvAsa meM kyoM kaise koI vizeSatA DAla sakatA hai? kyoM ki AtmavizvAsa kA saMbaMdha to mAtra darzana mohanIya + anaMtAnubaMdhI catuSka se hai, na ki apratyAkhyAnavaraNAdi kaSAyoM se ! ata: yaha bAta hI ki 'nizcaya samyaktva to caturtha guNasthAna meM hI ho jAtA hai|'- svIkArane meM Agama kA apalApa nahIM hai varan aisA nahIM svIkArane meM Agama kA apalApa hai| isa saccI AtmapratIti rUpa nizcaya samyaktva ko hI cAritrika asthiratA ke kAraNa sarAgatA ke sadbhAva ke kAraNa sarAga samyaktva evaM saMyamI munirAja ko cAritrika sthiratA ke kAraNa vItarAga samyaktva saMjJA milatI hai| kSAyika samyaktva to caturtha guNasthAna se lekara guNasthAnAtIta siddhAvasthA meM (sAdianaMtakAla paryaMta) yathAvasthita rUpa se aparivartanIya hI rahatA hai| Agama-adhyAtma kA sumela baiThAne se hI yaha bAta baiThegI, anyathA nhiiN| jijJAsA 10 - Apake hisAba se munirAjoM ko hI AtmAnubhUti hotI hai to gRhavirata zrAvakoM / (kSullaka,ailaka,AryikA) ko bhI svAtmAnubhUti nahIM hotI hogI? . bandhuvara ! samAdhAna Upara kiyA jA cukA hai| svAtmAnubhUti = AnaMdAnubhUti kA hI nAma hai| aisI tyAga tapasyA se kyA phAyadA jisameM AnaMdAnubhUti vikalpoM ke bhAra-bojha se mukti, nirbhAratA, zAMta rasa kA svAda, tRpti hI na prakaTa ho| jisakI jitanI kaSAyeM miTatI jAtI haiM, vaha vaha utanA hI nirbhAra, halakApana mahasUsa karane laga jAtA hai| yadi caturtha-paMcama guNasthAnavartI jIvoM ko nirAkulatva lakSaNa atIMdriya sukha kI kaNi kA hI prakaTa na hotI ho, to phira dravyaliMgI muni ko pravacanasAra gAthA 271 meM saMsAra tattva kyoM kahA? kyoM ki na to use AtmA kI zraddhA, (samyaktva)hai aura na svAnubhUti (aanNdaanubhuuti)| aviratasamyagdRSTi va dezavratI ko dravyaliMgI muni se zreSTha kyoM kahA ? bhaiyA ! vicAra karo, mAtra zabda ke jAla
Page #44
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ 44 meM mata uljho| dhyAnAbhyAsadvArA dharmyadhyAna / samyagdarzana pragaTa kro| vijJeSu kimadhikam / yaha bAta to satya hI hai ki gRhasthoM ke yati/muni ke samAna zuddhAtmA kI bhAvanA, lInatA karanA nahIM banatA, paraMtu isakA artha aisA bhI nahIM hai ki vaha zuddhAtmA kI bhAvanA bhUmikAnusAra bilkula hI nahIM kara sktaa| isIlie kahA hai - jaM sakkaI taM kIraI, jaMNa sakkaI taM ca saddahaI / saddahamANo jIvo pAvaI ajarAmaraM ThANaM / / paramArthataH jisakI jitanI kaSAyeM utanA hI duHkha AkulatA yaha jIva bhogatA hai / jisakI jitanI kaSAyeM miTa jAtI hai, ghaTa jAtI hai, vaha utanA hI sukha, nirAkulatA kA vedana karatA hai| nirgrathatA to parigraha pApa kA prAyazcitta hai aura kucha bhI nahIM / svAtmAnubhUti to aMtaraMga sAdhanA kA phala hai| dharmyadhyAna cauthe, pA~caveM, chaThe guNasthAnoM meM savikalpaka mAtra hI nahIM hotA hai| pravacanasAra gAthA 196 (jo khavida kaluso...) tA.vR. TIkA meM dhyAna, dhyAna-saMtAna, dhyAnaciMtA, dhyAnAnvayasUcanam aise 4 bheda darzAye haiN| una para vicAra krnaa| kyoM ki savikalpa se hI nirvikalpa hone kA vidhAna hai| jo AcAryakalpa paM. ToDaramalajI ne rahasyapUrNa ciTThI meM sarala bhASA meM diyA hai / jijJAsA 11 - jainoM evaM jainetara matAvalambiyoM ke AtmA ke vizvAsa meM kyA kucha aMtara hotA hai? kyoM ki anya matAvalaMbI bhI AtmA ke hone meM vizvAsa rakhate haiM / mahodaya ! isakA samAdhAna Apane ThIka hI kiyA hai ki jainetara kucha mata AtmA kA astitva to mAnate haiM, paraMtu AtmA ke vAstavika svarUpa kA paricaya na hone ke kAraNa usako karmabaddha azuddha avasthA tathA usake zuddha hone ke upAyoM kA sahI jJAna na hone ke kAraNa ajJAnI haiM, mithyAdRSTi haiM, unake AtmavizvAsa raJcamAtra bhI nahIM hai| unakA AtmavizvAsa gRhita mithyAtva sahita hai, jaba ki jainiyoM kA usase rahita hai| phira prazna hotA hai ki vartamAna ke kitane jaina gRhastha, paMDita, sAdhu gRhita mithyAtva se rahita haiM? balki ulaTe gRhita mithyAtva kA hI poSaNa kara rahe haiM aura abhI pharavarI 2006 meM zravaNabelagolA meM jo mahAmastakAbhiSeka hogA, kyA vaha jaina saMskRti kA pratIka hai ? vicAraNIya hai| ho sakatA hai, use dekhane hama, Apa bhI jaayeN| eka bAra ApakI jinabhASita patrikA donoM terA - bIsa paMthI AmnAyoM ko sahI ThaharA cukI hai, aura usakA niSedhaM vayovRddha vidvAna paM. zrI nAthulAla jI zAstrI -iMdaura ne kiyA thA / vartamAna meM yadi anekoM jaina paMDita, sAdhu zithilAcArI haiM, to anekoM utsUtrabhASI bhI haiM / paMcama kAla kI balihArI hI samajhanA cAhie ? , Wang jijJAsA 12 - vaha AtmA jisakA ki jainoM (samyagdRSTiyoM) ko vizvAsa hotA hai ki vaha dravyakarma, nokarma (zarIra ), bhAvakarma, (moha - rAga-dveSa ) se rahita AtmA hotA hai yA inake sahita hotA hai?
Page #45
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ 45 mahodaya ! Apane itanA to ThIka hI likhA ki samyagdRSTi to dravyakarma, bhAvakarma tathA nokarma rahita zuddha AtmA kA hI zraddhAna karatA hai| (paraMtu jo yaha likhA ki para usa AtmA kI anubhUti vItarAga pariNati meM hI hotI hI hai, jo ki vItarAga cAritra ke hone para hI saMbhava hai| arthAt muni ko hI hotI hai, eka laMgoTI dhArI ailaka ko bhI nahIM?.maiM phira jAnanA/pUchanA cAhatA hU~, ki usa eka laMgoTI dhArI tapasvI sacce samyagdRSTi paMcama guNasthAnavartI ko raJcamAtra bhI AtmAnubhUti (AnaMdAnubhUti)nahIM hai/nahIM hotI hai, to laMgoTI chor3ate hI, munidIkSA lete hI, vaha AtmAnubhUti-atIMdriya AnaMdAnubhUti pragaTa ho jAtI hogI? jarA vicAra karo ki kisa apekSA se vItarAga cAritradhArI muni ko vaha AtmAnubhUti kisa stara kI hotI hai jo Agama meM likhI gayI hai / aho ! munirAja ke atIMdriya AnaMda kI to kyA bAta karanA? ve to tIna kaSAya caukar3I ke . abhAva se niraMtara pracura svasaMvedana rUpa nirAkulatA kA pratyakSa vedana karate haiN| jijJAsA 13 - avirata samyagdRSTi mokSamArgI hai yA nahIM? yadi hai to usake cAritra kaunasA pragaTa huA kahalAyegA? mithyA cAritra bhI usake nahIM hai| . .. AdaraNIya bainAr3A jI ! isa jijJAsA ke samAdhAna meM Apane jo bhI Agama pramANa diye haiM, ve sarva hI mujhe pUrNarItyA mAnya haiN| merA to mAtra itanA hI kahanA hai ki samyagdarzana jJAna ke sAtha jo samyaktvAcaraNa hai vaha avirata samyagdRSTi ko mokSamArgI siddha karatA hai| use jaghanya aMtarAtmA kahA hai| mithyA zraddhAna, mithyAjJAna, mithyAcAritra - ina tInoM kI ekatA saMsAramArga hai , baMdhamArga hai aura samyakzraddhAna, samyakjJAna, samyakcAritra ina tInoM kI ekatA mokSamArga hai| aviratasamyagdRSTi ke mithyAzraddhAna-jJAna-cAritra tInoM hI nahIM hai, to pratipakSI samyakzraddhAna-jJAnacAritra usake pragaTa hue honA cAhie, kyoM ki usa tattvajJAnI ke duHkha phala ko paidA karane vAle mithyAzraddhAna-mithyAjJAna-mithyAcAritra nahIM hai| phira bhI use jo asaMyamI kahA hai usakA kAraNa apratyAkhyAnAvaraNAdi kaSAyoM kA udaya hai| isI bAta kI vizada carcA zlokavArtika prathama bhAga pRSTha 553 se pRSTha 556 taka meM haiN| tadanusAra - ___ 'mithyA darzanAdyapakSaye kSIyamANazca na syAt, iti saMdigdha vipakSavyAvRttikatvamapi na sAdhanasya zaMkanIyaM samyagdarzanotpattAvasaMyata samyagdRSTe mithyAdarzanasyApakSaye mithyAjJAnAnu. tpattestatpUrvaka mithyAcAritrabhAvAttannibaMdhana saMsArasyApakSayaprasiddhaH, anyathA mithyAdarzanAdi trayApakSayepi tadapakSayAghaTanAt / ' (sArAMza-kyoM ki samyagdarzana utpanna ho jAne para caturthaguNasthAna vAle asaMyata samyagdRSTi jIva ke mithyAdarzana kA -hAsa ho jAne para mithyAjJAna kI utpatti nahIM ho pAtI hai / ataH una mithyAdarzana aura mithyAjJAna ko pUrvavartI kAraNa mAnakara hone vAle mithyAcAritra kA bhI abhAva ho gayA hai| isa kAraNa una tIna kAraNoM se utpanna hue saMsAra kA bhI -hAsa honA prasiddha
Page #46
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ hai| jaba kAraNa hI na rahA, to kArya kahA~ se hogA?) 'naca samyagdRSTermithyAcAritrAbhAvAtsaMyatatvameva syAnna punaH kadAcit asaMyatatvAtmityArekA yuktA, cAritramohodaye sati samyak caaritrsyaanuppttersNyttvoppteH| kAtya'to dezato - nasaMyamonApi mithyAsaMyama iti vyAhatamapinabhavati, mithyAgamapUrvakasya saMyamasya pancAgnisAdhanAde mithyAsaMyamatvAt samyagAgama pUrvakasya samyak sNymtvaat| tato'nyasya mithyAtvodayA sattvepi pravartamAnasya hiMsAderasaMyamatvAt / ' (sArAMza-koI zaMkA kare to phira samyagdRSTi jIva ke caturtha guNasthAna meM mithyAcAritra ke na rahane se saMyamIpanA ho bhI jAve? phira kabhI bhI use asaMyatapanA nahIM honA cAhie? paraMtu aisI zaMkA karanA ThIka nahIM hai, kyoMki cauthe-pA~caveM guNasthAna meM cAritra guNa kA ghAtaka-apratyAkhyAnAvaraNapratyAkhyAnAvaraNa kaSAyoM kA udaya ho rahA hai| aisA hone para samyak cAritra guNa nahIM bana sktaa| vastutaH caturtha guNasthAna meM na to saMyama(munipanA)hai, na dezasaMyamavratI(zrAvakapanA) hai aura na hi mithyAsaMyama (prathama guNasthAnavat mithyAcAritra) hai| isaprakAra usake asaMyamapanA hai jo ki pUrNa saMyama, deza saMyama aura mithyAsaMyama se bhinna hai| 'na cAsaMyamAdabhedena mithyAsaMyamasyopadezAbhAvabheda evaMti yuktaM tasya bAlatapaH zabdenopadiSTatvAt tata kathaMcit bhedsiddhe|' artha-kisI kA AkSepa hai ki jIva ke pA~ca bhAvoM meM audayika asaMyatabhAva se bhinna mithyAsaMyama kA kahIM upadeza nahIM hai| isakAraNa mithyAcAritra aura asaMyama kA abheda hI mAnanA caahie| phira cauthe meM yA to mithyA cAritra mAno yA saMyamIpana svIkAra kro| graMthakAra kahate haiM-aisA kahanA ThIka nahIM hai| kyoM ki ye asaMyama se bhinna mAne gaye usa mithyA cAritra kA tattvArthasUtra chaThaveM adhyAya meM 'bAlatapa' zabda se upadeza kiyA hai| usa kAraNa mithyA cAritra aura asaMyama meM kisI apekSA se bheda hI siddha hai| 'na hi cAritramohodayamAtrAd bhvcaaritrN| darzanacAritra mohodayajanitAdacAritrAdabhinnameveti sAdhayituM zakyaM, sarvatra kAraNa bhedasya phalAbhedaqatvaprasakteH mithyAdRSTyasaMyamasya niyamena mithyAjJAna pUrvakatvaprasiddhaH, samyagdRSTyasaMyamasya mithyAdarzanajJAnapUrvakatva virodhAt virUddha-kAraNapUrvakatayApi bhedAbhAve siddhAnta virodhaat|' artha-caturtha guNasthAna meM darzanamohanIya ke saMbaMdha se rahita hokara kevala cAritramohanIya ke udaya se hone vAlA jo cAritra hai vaha pahale guNasthAna meM darzanamohanIya aura cAritramohanIya ke udaya se hone vAle mithyAcAritra se abhinna hI hai (sadRza hai )-isa bAta ko siddha karanA zakya nahIM hai| zakya na ho to bhI mAna liyA to sarvatra kAraNabheda hone para bhI kAryaphala meM abheda mAnane kA prasaMga A jaayegaa|(isse kyA anartha ho jAyegA) jisa caturtha guNasthAna ke acAritra bhAva meM kevala cAritramohanIya kA udaya hai aura pahale guNasthAna ke acAritra (mithyAcAritra)meM darzanamohanIya sahita cAritramohanIya kA udaya hai| ye donoM eka kaise ho sakate haiM? mithyAdRSTi kA asaMyama niyama se mithyAjJAnapUrvaka prasiddha ho rahA hai aura samyagdRSTi ke asaMyama ko
Page #47
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ 47 mithyAdarzana va mithyAjJAna ko kAraNa mAnakara utpanna hone kA virodha hai| ye donoM doSa caturthaguNasthAna meM nahIM haiN| virUddha kAraNoM ke pUrvavartI hone para bhI uttama samaya meM utpanna hue kAryoM kA yadi bheda honA na mAnA jAyegA to sabhI vAdiyoM ko apane siddhAMtoM se virodha ho jaayegaa| kyoM ki sabhI parIkSakoM ne bhinna-bhinna kAraNoM kedvArA bhinna-bhinna kAryoM kI utpatti honA mAnya kiyA hai|atH prathama va caturtha guNasthAna ke asaMyama nyAre-nyAre hI haiN| bhAvArtha-samyak cAritra na hone kI apekSA se donoM asaMyama eka haiM kintu naJ kA artha paryudAsa aura prasajya karane para darzana mohanIya ke udaya se sahita acAritra ko mithyA cAritra kahate haiM aura darzana mohanIya ke udaya na rahane para(+anaMtAnubaMdhI ke bhI na rahane para)kevala apratyAkhyAnAvaraNa aura pratyAkhyAnAvaraNa ke udaya se hone vAle asaMyama ko acAritra kaha dete haiN| paramArthata: anaMtAnubaMdhI cAritramoha kI prakRti hai| vaha cAritra kA hI ghAta karatI hai| samyaktva kA ghAta nahIM karatI paraMtu usakA udaya samyaktva ke nAza kA kAraNa avazya hai| use hI samyaktva kA virodhaka sAsAdana khaa| samyaktva kA abhAva mithyAtva kA udaya hone para hI hotA hai, vaha sAsAdana meM nahIM huaa| vahA~ 2 re guNasthAna meM upazama samyaktva kA hI kAla hai, isIlie use sAsAdana samyagdRSTi kahA hai, sAsAdana mithyAdRSTi nahIM khaa| A.ka.paM.ToDaramalajI ne mo.mA.pra.meM pR.92 para isIlie satya hI likhA hai ki- 'mithyAcAritra meM svarUpAcaraNa cAritra kA abhAva hai isIlie isakA nAma acAritra bhI kahA jAtA hai| paraMtu avirata samyagdRSTi ke mithyAcAritra hotA hI nahIM to usake acAritra ko samyaktvAcaraNa cAritra kahA tathA use hI AtmajJAnI vidvAnoM ne svarUpAcaraNa cAritra kahA hai| ataH yaha jIva mokSamArgI hai| jaghanya aMtarAtmA hai|(-dekho-kaartikeyaanuprekssaa- gAthA 197 tathA vArasANuvekkhA gA.18) jijJAsA14-samyaktvAcaraNaM (mokSapAhuDa gAthA 5 se 10) evaM svarUpAcaraNacAritra meM kyA aMtara hai? ___ samAdhAna yaha hai ki zaMkAdi 25 mala doSoM se rahita aSTAMga sahita samyagdarzana ko dhAraNa karanA samyaktvAcaraNa cAritra hai(vyavahAra hai)aura darzanamoha ke sAtha jo anaMtAnubaMdhI kaSAyoM kA abhAva huA tatphala svarUpa AtmA (cAritra) meM jo vizuddhi pragaTa huI, zAnti-samatA kA vedana-pariNamana huA vahI svarUpAcaraNa cAritra hai| bAhya vratAdi na hone se ise hI asaMyama khaa| mithyAtva ke abhAva meM Astikya evaM anaMtAnubaMdhI ke abhAva meM prazama, saMvega, anukaMpA, AtmaniMdA-garhAdi guNa pragaTa hote haiN| aisA kahanA bhI galata nahIM hogaa| jijJAsA 15-mokSamArga meM pramaTa hone vAlA saMvara-nirjarA tattva kyA zubha bhAva rUpa bhI hai yA vItarAgabhAva(zuddha bhAva)rUpa hI hai? mokSamArga arthAt sAdhaka avasthA (caturtha se bArahaveM guNasthAna taka) athavA buddhipUrvaka
Page #48
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ 48 sarAgatA heya vItarAgatA upAdeya kara vartana (AcaraNa) karane kI avasthA / tadanusAra caturtha, paMcama, SaSThama, guNasthAnavartI jJAnI kA jIvana / sabhI jJAnI jIva yaha mAnate haiM ki kAraNa bhinnatA se kArya bhinnatA hotI hI hai| jo-jo baMdha ke kAraNa hai unase viparIta abaMdha ( saMvaranirjarA) ke kAraNa hote haiN| baMdha ke 5 pratyaya haiN| mithyAdarzana, avirati, pramAda, kaSAya, yoga | ye krama se hI Ate haiN| mithyAtva ke jAne para hI jIva ko mokSamArgI huA kahA hai| usa samyagdRSTi 1 zraddhA meM sarva prakAra kA rAga heya hI hotA hai| pUrNa vItarAgatA hI upAdeya rahatI hai / tathApi jaise mithyAtva eka kSaNa meM calA jAtA hai aura samyaktva, saccI zraddhA pragaTa ho jAtI hai, arthAt prathama se caturtha guNasthAna meM A jAtA hai paraMtu cAritramoha krama-krama se hI jAtA hai| isa kAraNa samyagdRSTi jIva azubha ko prathama chor3atA hai, zubha ko grahaNa karatA hai, lakSya zuddha kA hI rahatA hai| isalie samyagdRSTi jJAnI ke sarAMga cAritra ko jo ki zubhopayoga rUpa zubhabhAvarUpa hai, puNyabaMdha kA kAraNa hai, pApa kA saMvara karane vAlA hai, use upacAra se saMvara- nirjarA rUpa kahA hai, jAnanA / nizcaya se vItarAgabhAva (zuddhabhAva) hI saMvara-nirjarA rUpa hai| dekho - bR. dravya saMgrahagAthA 45 kI TIkA - evaM pravacanasAra gAthA - 181,79, 199 kI TIkA ) svazuddhAtmA kA anubhava rUpa zuddhopayoga rUpa vItarAga cAritra ( svarUpa sthiratA ) hI saMvara - nirjarA hai aura sarAga cAritra ( azubha pApa se bacane ke lie, saMsAra sthiti chedane ke lie) zubha bhAva rUpa pariNAma upacAra se saMvara-nirjarA rUpa haiN| sarAga cAritra ko apahRta saMyama kahA hai| jo bAhya meM paMceMdriya viSayoM kA tyAga hai / vaha upacarita asadbhUta vyavahAra naya se cAritra hai aura aMtaraMga meM jo rAgAdi kA tyAga hai, vaha azuddha nizcayanaya se cAritra hai / vyavahAra ( sarAga ) cAritra se sAdhya nizcaya cAritra (vItarAgatA / saMvara-nirjarA) kA varNana bR. dravya saMgraha gAthA 46 meM hai aura ina donoM prakAra ke mokSamArgoM ko prApta karane kA upAya dhyAnyAbhyAsa hai / tadartha bra. dravyasaMgraha kI gAthAe~ 47,48,49;50 dekheM / Apane jo bhI pramANa Agama se likhe ve saba mAnya hIM hai| paraMtu upacAra- anupacAra, vyavahAra - nizcaya rUpa saMvara-nirjarA kA svarUpa samajhanA jarUrI hai| anyathA upacAra ( sarAga cAritra) ko hI paramArtha ( nizcaya vItarAga cAritra ) samajhane se zraddhAmUlaka abhiprAya kI bhUla banI rahatI hai / (puruSArtha siddhayupAya kI gAthAe~ - 211, 212 - 214 bhI isa artha meM dekheM / ) jijJAsA 16 - mithyAdRSTi dravyaliMgI muni jo navameM graiveyaka taka jAte haiM tathA jinheM 11 aMgoM taka kA jJAna pragaTa ho jAtA hai, kyA unako AtmA kA vizvAsa nahIM hotA? kyA unake saMvara-nirjarA tattva pragaTa hote haiM yA nahIM? Apane jo samAdhAna likhA vaha yogya hI hai ki use viparItAbhinivezarUpa mithyAtva kA udaya rahatA hai / mithyAtva rahate hue vyavahAra samyaktvarUpa AtmavizvAsa saMbhava nahIM / yaha jarA vicAraNIya biMdu hai / kRpayA mo.mA.pra. pRSTha 245, 246, 247, 311 avazya
Page #49
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ avalokana kreN| jijJAsA 17 - dharmyadhyAna ke svAmI cauthe se sAtaveM guNasthAnavI jIva kahe haiN| taba asaMyamI samyagdRSTi ke bhI cAritra kA aMza pragaTa huA honA cAhie, anyathA (16+25-41)prakRtiyoM kA baMdha nahIM rUkatA? anaMtAnubaMdhI cAritra-moha kI prakRti kA anudaya/aprazasta upazama/kSaya hI kAraNa hai| isa cAritra ke aMza kA nAma Agama meM kahIM kucha AyA ho to spaSTa kreN| ApakA yaha samAdhAna ki anaMtAnubaMdhI kA kArya apratyAkhyAnAvaraNAdi kaSAyoM ke udaya ke pravAha ko anaMta kara denA hai, isalie cAritra meM anaMtAnubaMdhI catuSka kA vyApAra niSphala nahIM hai, paraMtu vaha kisI cAritra kA ghAta nahIM krtii| ataH usake jAne para koI cAritra prakaTa nahIM hotaa| - yaha biMdu vicAraNIya hai| isa viSaya kI hama-Apa Upara carcA kara hI Aye haiM ki anaMtAnubaMdhI ke jAne para samyaktvAcaraNa cAritra pragaTa hotA hai aura yaha bhI Agama hai ki anaMtAnubaMdhI kaSAyoM se baMdhane vAlI 25 prakRtiyA~ haiN| jo usake jAne para nahIM baMdhatI tathA usakA udaya Ate hI sAsAdana guNasthAna meM baMdhana lagatI hai| sAsAdana meM jo 16 prakRtiyoM kA baMdha rUkA rahatA hai, nahIM hotA hai| usakA kAraNa vahA~ mithyAtva kA abhAva hI hai| kyoM ki mithyAtva se baMdhane vAlI 16 prakRtiyA~ alaga hai| anaMtAnubaMdhI ke jAne se jo cAritrika vizuddhatA pragaTatI hai (bhale usakA kucha bhI nAma zAstroM meM na diyA ho, acAritra hI kahA ho|) usase 25 prakRtiyoM kA Asrava baMdha nahIM hotaa| jijJAsA 18- samayasAra gAthA-13 (bhUdatyeNAbhigadA...)kI AtmakhyAti-TIkA meM aMta meM 'evamasAvekatvena dyotamAna zuddhanayetvanAnubhUyataeva / yA tvanubhUtiH sAtmakhyAtirevAtmakhyAtistu samyagdarzanameva / iti samastameva nirvdym|' isakA artha spaSTa kreN| mahodaya ! Apane isa paMktiyoM kA artha anuvAda sahI nahIM kiyaa| Apane apanI dhAraNAnusAra hI kara diyA ki....AtmA kI isa zuddhanaya se jAnI gayI avasthA kA vizvAsa (?) hI samyagdarzana hai| Age Apa yaha bhI likha rahe haiM ki yaha prasaMga samayasAra kA hai aura vaha vItarAga samyagdRSTi kI hI pradhAnatA kA hai|.....any kA gauNa rUpa se grahaNa kiyA hai| AcArya parameSThI zAstroM kI racanA apane zuddhopayoga se cyuta ho zubha vikalpa meM Ane para apane ko azubha se bacAte hue ajJAnI jIvoM ko sacce mokSamArga kA nirUpaNa kara sanmArga para lAne hetu hI karate haiN| aura A. jayasena jI ne jo vItarAga samyagdRSTi kI mukhyatA kI so ucita hI hai, paraMtu lakSaNa dRSTi se hI pUrvApara virodha rahita tattvoM kI prarUpaNA karate haiN| lakSya samyagdarzana kA hai to usakA lakSyaNa jo trikAla abAdhita hai vahI zrImad amRta
Page #50
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ 50 caMdrAcAryadeva ne isa gAthA TIkA meM likhA hai| vaha isa prakAra hai-. . (isalie ina 9 tattvoM meM bhUtArtha naya se eka jIva hI prakAzamAna hai / ) isa prakAra yaha ekatvarUpa se prakAzita hota huA zuddha rUpa se anubhava kiyA jAtA hai aura jo yaha anubhUti hai so AtmakhyAti (AtmA kI pahicAna) hai aura jo AtmakhyAti hai so samyagdarzana hI hai| isaprakAra yaha sarva kathana nirdoSa haiM, ' bAdhArahita hai| jijJAsA 19 - tattvArtha zloka vArtikAlaMkAra prathama khaMDa pRSTha 555 para 'nahi cAritramohodayamAtrAdabhavaccAritra darzana cAritra mohodayajanitAda- cAritrAda bhinnameveti sAdhayituM zakyaM sarvatra kAraNa bhedasya phalAbhedakatva prasakteH / siddhAMtavirodhAt / .. isake hiMdI artha meM paM. zrI mANakacaMdajI kaudeya nyAyAcAryajI ne caturtha guNasthAnavartI ko svarUpAcaraNa cAritra (acAritra meM) kahA hai tathA jaina siddhAMta pravezikA meM paM. gopAladAsajI baraiyA ne prazna 111 / 112 meM svarUpAcaraNa cAritra kahA hai / kyA Apako yaha mAnya hai? Apane kisI ArSagraMtha meM svarUpAcaraNa zabda kA prayoga nahIM pAyA ataH amAnya kiyA, paraMtu paM. gopAladAsa jI baraiyA ne jo svarUpAcaraNa cAritra kA kathana kiyA hai use use mAtra samyaktvAcaraNa cAritra kA paryAyavAcI kahA jA sakatA hai, mAnya kiyA, paraMtu samyak cAritra meM garbhita nahIM kiyA / sktaa| isa bAbada pUrva meM kAphI kucha likhA jA cukA hai| isameM mujhe kucha vizeSa nahIM kahanA hai| sAtha meM Apane yaha jo likhA hai ki yaha bhI likhanA ucita hogA ki A, kuMdakuMda ne anaMtAnubaMdhI ke abhAva se samyaktvA caraNa cAritra nahIM mAnA hai| anyathA tRtIya guNasthAna meM bhI samyaktvAcaraNa mAnanA par3egA, jo galata hogaa| to kRpayA vidita karAyeM ki samyaktvAcaraNa kisake abhAva meM pragaTa hotA hai ? -tathA nimnalikhita ATha anya jijJAsAoM kA bhI samAdhAna karane kA kaSTa kreN| jijJAsA 20- pravacanasAra gAthA 201 tA.vR. ( evaM paNamiya siddhe) TIkA meM 'jiNavaravasahe' zabda kI TIkA / vyAkhyA meM 'sAsAdanAdikSINakaSAyAntA ekadeza jinA ucyante 'yaha kisa apekSA se likhA hai? kRpayA khulAsA kreN| jijJAsA 21 - Apake anusAra caturtha guNasthAnavartI avirata samyagdRSTi samyak cAritra ke na hone se mokSamArgI hI nahIM hai, taba phira use jaghanya aMtarAtmA kyoM kahA hai? -dvividha saMgabina zuddha upayogI muni uttama nija dhyAnI / madhyama aMtara Atama hai je dezavratI anagArI / nara .... jaghana kahe avirata samadRSTi, tInoM zivamagacArI / - yaha chahaDhAlA meM paM. daulatarAma jI ne kyA galata likha diyA hai ? pramANa ke lie kRpayA
Page #51
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ kArtikeyAnuprekSA gAthA 197 evaM vArasANuvekkhA gAthA 18 dekheM-jisa meM avirata samyagdRSTi ko jaghanya aMtarAtmA evaM jaghanya pAtra kahA hai| aba yadi aMtarAtmA hI mokSamArgI nahIM hogA to phira kauna hogA? jijJAsA 22-kyA digaMbara munirAja svAdhyAya evaM saMyama pAlanArtha caSmA dhAraNa kara sakate haiM? yadi kara sakate haiM to caSme rakhane kA ghara(kesa) tathA kA~ca sApha karane ke lie vastra kA Tukar3A bhI rakhanA pdd'egaa| to kyA ve parigraha kI paridhi meM AyeMge yA nahIM? jijJAsA 23 - pravacanasAra gAthA 239 (paramANupamANaM vA mucchA....)-tattvapradIpikA TIkA kI utthanikA (athAtmajJAnazUnyasya sarvAMgamaz2Ana tattvArtha zraddhAnasaMyatatvAnAM yoga - pdympykiNcitkrmitynushaasti|.....)meN AtmajJAnazUnya zabda kA prayoga bhAvaliMgI yA dravyaliMgI muni-kisake lie kiyA gayA hai? jijJAsA 24- pravacanasAra gAthA 238 (jaM aNNANI kamma khavedi......)-tattvapradIpikA TIkA meM evaM utthanikA (athAtmajJAna tattvArtha zraddhAna saMyatatvAnAM yaugapo'pyAtma jJAnasya mokSamArgasAdhakatamatvaM dyotayati) meM AtmajJAna kA kyA artha hai? jise mokSamArga kA sAdhakatama kahA hai ! tathA AtmajJAnazUnya ko ajJAnI kahA hai ! jijJAsA 25 - kyA di. munirAja rAtri meM bola sakate haiM? upadeza de sakate haiM? isa bAre meM Agama kyA kahatA hai? jijJAsA 26 - kyA vartamAna kAla meM di. munirAja ekalavihArI ho sakate haiM? kyA ekalavihArI honA sarvathA niSiddha hai? jijJAsA 27 - uddiSTAhAra tyAgI vratiyoM ko kina-kina sAvadhAniyoM ko rakhanA cAhie jisase uddiSTAhAra kA grahaNa na ho| kyA AhAradAtA zrAvaka ko vratI/do pratimAdhArI zrAvaka honA anivArya hai? kyA avratI pAkSika zrAvaka se uddiSTAhAra tyAgI AhAra grahaNa kara sakate haiM yA nahIM? (uparokta tattvacarcA meM kucha Agama ke abhiprAya se virUddha likhA gayA ho to he jinavANI. mA~, evaM jJAnI jana mujha abodha bAlaka ko kSamA kara sadbuddhi pradAna krnaa| bha. mahAvIra nirvANa divasa (dIpAvalI parva) para mithyAtva aMdhakAra kA nirvANa ho jagata meM samyaktva kA ujAlA phaile isa pavitra bhAvanA ke saath| ApakA zivAkAMkSI , bra. hemacaMda jaina, hema' dharmyadhyAna-Agama ke Aloka meM 0 kiM bahaNA bhaNieNaM je siddhA NaravarA gae kaale| sijjhihahi je vi bhaviyA taM jANaha sammamAhAdha // 48 // mokSapAhuDa artha-bahuta kahane se kyA sAdhya hai?jo narapradhAna atIta kAla meM siddha hue haiM aura AgAmI kAla meM siddha hoMge, vaha samyaktva kA mAhAtmya jaano|
Page #52
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ ratanalAla bainADA paMcazIla 1/ 205 bI, prophesarsa kaoNlonI di. 01.11 . 2005 harIparvata, AgarAphona - (0562)235 1428 - 285 2278 A. hemacaMdrajI sA. jayajineMdra, ApakA patra prApta huaa| sAre viSaya dekhe| socatA hU~ ki yadi Apako vartamAna kAla ke sarvazreSTha jJAna evaM cAritra ke dhanI pU. A. zrI ke ciMtana bhI Agama virUddha lagate haiM to merI carcA se kucha bhI phala nikalanA saMbhava nahIM hai| phira bhI Apa se anurodha hai ki nIce likhe viSayoM para Agama pramANa zIghra bhejane kA kaSTa kreN| tAki maiM unako dRSTigata rakhate hue Apake patra kA uttara de skuuN| - 1. pahale, dUsare, tIsare guNasthAna meM vyavahAra samyaktva hotA hai| 2. nizcaya samyaktva, caturtha guNasthAna yA gRhastha avasthA meM hotA hai| 3. nizcaya samyaktva pahale hotA hai, vyavahAra samyaktva bAda meM / yA donoM eka sAtha hI utpanna hote haiN| 4. rAjA zreNika ke nizcaya samyaktva hai (maiMne pramANa diyA thA ki mahArAjA bharata ke vyavahAra sarAga smyktv-thaa.| Apa bhI koI pramANa dIjie ki rAjA zreNika ke nizcaya samyaktva hai| 5. anaMtAnubaMdhI ke abhAva meM svarUpAcaraNa caritra hotA hai| 6. svarUpAcaraNa kI pribhaassaa| 7. caturtha guNasthAna meM zuddhopayoga hotA hai| (maiMne pramANa diye haiM ki saptama guNasthAna se zuddhopayoga hotA hai,Apa bhI pramANa bhejeM ki caturtha se hotA hai|) 8. caturtha guNasthAna meM zuddhAtmAnubhUti hotI hai| 9. avirata samyagdRSTi mokSamArgI haiN| 10. zubha bhAva se saMvara-nirjarA nahIM hotii| 11. Apane AdyA samyaktva caaritre|'(pR.14 kA artha-prathama mithyAtva aura anaMtAnubaMdhI vAle krodha-mAna-mAyA-lobha samyaktva aura cAritra ina donoM ko nahIM hone dete haiN| yaha likhA hai| yaha galata hai| kRpayA do bArA vicAra kara sahI artha graMtha meM dekha kara likhiegaa| nivedana-Apa manamAnI carcA karate haiN| jaba ki mujhe Agama vAkya caahie| mujhe Apa bhAvArtha yA apanA maMtavya na likheN| mujhe to AcAryoM ke zloka yA TIkA Adi mAtra hI likhe| hamArI ApakI carcA kA AdhAra Agama hai| sAtha hI paMDitoM ke pramANa na deN| (cAheM paM. ToDaramalajI ho, yA paM. gopAladAsa jI ho, paMcAdhyAyIkAra ho yA any|)aagm-likhit AcAryoM ke pramANa se hI carcA kareM to zreSTha rhegaa| mujhe to bArahavIM zatAbdi taka ke likhe AcArya hI pramANa rahate haiN| AzA hai Apa zIghra uttara bhejane kA kaSTa kareMge / zubhecchu - ratanalAla bainAr3A
Page #53
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ 53 bra.paM. hemacaMdra jaina di. 28.11.2005 * bhopAla AdaraNIya AgamavettA vidvadvara paM.zrI ratanalAla jI bainADA jaina sAdara darzana vizuddhi saha jyjinedr| ApakA 01.11.05 kA likhA patra maisUra(kanakagiri) yAtrA se vApisa lauTane para prApta huaa| patra par3hakara mana ko kiMcit kheda huA ki Apane mujhe AgamAdhAra binA manamAnI carcA karane vAlA samajha liyA,jaba ki merA jIvana Agama pramANa se vItarAgI vANI ko vItarAga bhAva se sAdharmI vAtsalyabhAva se grahaNa karane kA rahA hai| jo bhI maiMne apane pUrva patra meM likhA, binA Agama pramANa ke kucha nahIM likhA, phira mujhe apane alpa kSayopazama jJAna meM Agama vihita kathanoM jaisA bhAva bhAsita huA, vahI Apake vicArArtha prastuta kiyA hai| maiM eka maikenikala iMjiniyara/vaijJAnika hU~,ataH parIkSA pradhAnI vizeSa hU~ evaM nimna likhita zloka meM vizvAsa rakhatA huuN| sUkSma jinodita tattvaM, hetubhirnaiva hnyte| AjJAsiddhaM tu tadgrAhyaM, nAnyathAvAdino jinaH / Apane aba mere dvArA likhita patra ko, abhiprAya ko, dhairya se niSpakSa bhAva se par3ha liyA hogA, tathA jo kucha navIna jijJAsAe~ likhI thI, unakA bhI samAdhAna avazya bhejeM, maiM punaH punaH vicAra kruuNgaa| maiM raMcamAtra bhI haThAgrahI,pUrvAgrahI,durAgrahI nahIM hU~, mAtra isa paryAya ko satyagrAhI kiMvA satyAgrahI(?)banakara vItarAga deva-zAstra-gurU kI ananya zraddhApUrvaka samarpita kiyA hai| jaisA ki nimna zloka meM kahA hai pakSapAto na me vIre, na ca dveSa: kpilaadissu| - yuktimadvacanaM yasya, tasya kAryaH prigrhH|| astu , Apane mujhase kucheka bAtoM ke Agama pramANa dene ko kahA hai| tathA paMDitoM (paM. ToDaramala jI, paM. gopAladAsa jI baraiyA, paMcAdhyAyIkAra kavi paM. rAjamalajI pAMDe Adi) ke pramANa nahIM dene ko kahA hai| mAtra 12 vIM zatAbdi taka ke hI AcArya bhagavaMtoM ke kathanoM ko prAmANika svIkAra kiyA hai / to kyA Apa 12 vIM zatAbdi se Aja taka 21 vIM zatAbdi meM yA aba Age paMcama kAla ke aMta taka satya sanAtana digaMbara jaina dharma kI/kuMdakuMda AmnAya kI mUladhArA kA viccheda ho gayA mAnate haiM? yaha nizcita hI gaMbhIra vicAraNIya biMdu hai| paramapUjya zrImad jayasenAcArya deva kI samayasAra, pravacanasAra, paMcAstikAya graMthoM para likhita athavA paramAtmaprakAza, bRhadravya saMgraha para zrI brahmadevasUri viracita saMskRta TIkAoM ko Apa prAmANika nahIM mAnate haiM? aisA duHsAhasa maiM nahIM kara sakatA huuN| maiM na to Agama virodhI hU~, aura na hI kisI vyakti vizeSa kA ! hA~, maiM Agama-adhyAtma virodhI kathanoM kA avazya virodhI huuN| aura Agama pramANa kathanoM kA yathAtathya
Page #54
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ svarUpa pragaTa karane vAle AcAryakalpa paM. ToDaramala jI, paM.daulatarAma jI Adi kA anaMta upakAra mAnatA huuN| saMkSepa meM kahU~ to anaMta jJAniyoM (4, 5, 6 guNasthAnavartI jJAniyoM dvArA likhita, vartamAna meM upalabdha jinAgama)kA ekasA abhiprAya rUpa mata/ekamata hotA hai tathA anAtmajJa az2AnI ke anaMta (paraspara virUddha)mata yA aneka mata-pakSa hote haiM-mAnatA huuN| vartamAna meM jo bhI bhagavat kuMdakuMdAcArya kI mUlAnmAya ke poSaka zAstra haiM, ve sarva hI mujhe mAnya haiN| jaba Apane mujhe pratibaMdhita kara diyA ki 12 vIM zatAbdi taka ke likhe AcArya hI pramANa rahate haiM to phira maiM itanI prabala dhAraNA vAlA vyakti nahIM hU~ ki Apake dvArA vAMchita Agama pramANa de sakU~ jo 12 vIM zatAbdi taka ke AcAryoM dvArA hI likhe gaye hoN| tathApi kiMcita prayAsa kara rahA hU~, pakSAtikrAMta hokara nirNaya karanA hogaa| 1. koI bhI AgamajJa yaha nahIM kahatA ki prathama, dvitIya, tRtIya guNasthAnoM meM vyavahAra samyaktva hotA hai| prathama guNasthAna meM to tattvavicAra, deva-gurU-dharma kI sAmAnya pratIti hotI hai| usake bala para hI yaha jIva sva-para bheda vijJAna karatA huA yathArtha tattva pratIti karatA hai aura zuddhAtmAbhimukha ho savikalpa sva-saMvedanapUrvaka nirvikalpa svarUpopalabdhi rUpa viparItAbhiniveza rahita zraddhAna rUpa, nizcaya samyaktva rUpa AtmAnubhUti ko prApta kara caturtha guNasthAnavartI avirata samyagdRSTi ho jAtA hai| etadartha ajJAnI-jJAnI kA lakSaNa samayasAra AtmakhyAti gAthA-19 evaM 75 meM TIkA meM likhA hI hai| samyagdarzana kI paribhASAe~ prathamAnuyoga evaM caraNAnuyoga ke anusAra - | zraddhAnaM prmaarthaanaamaaptaagmtpobhRtaam| trimUDhApoDhamaSTAMga smygdrshnmsmym|| tathA dravyAnuyogAnusAra - 'tatvArtha zraddhAnaM smygdrshnm|' tathA karaNAnuyogAnusAra- 'mithyAtvIdayAbhAvAt darzanamohodayAbhAvAt 'hone para hI samyagdarzana kA lakSaNa kahA hai| . samayasAra jI AtmakhyAti gAthA 276-277 meM abhavya ko tattvazraddhAna hone para bhI mithyA zraddhAna rahatA hai - likhA hai tathA pravacanasAra jI tattva.pradIpikA gAthA - 239 meM AtmajJAna zUnya ko AgamajJAna, tattvazraddhAna evaM saMyama tInoM kI yugapatatA hone para bhI akiMcitkara kahA hai| isase siddha hotA hai ki mAtra vyavahAra dRSTi se sAmAnya jainI janoM ko jinako bAhya jainIpanA (gRhita mithyAtva se rahitapane rUpa)pragaTa ho unako vyavahArAbhAsarUpa vyavahAra samyaktva hotA hai, kahA jA sakatA hai, nimittoM kI ora se dvitIya guNasthAnavartI jIva ko sAsAdana samyagdRSTi kahA hai| usake samyagdarzana ghAtaka anaMtAnubaMdhI kaSAya kA udaya ho Ane se sAsAdana (virAdhanA sahita) samyagdRSTi kahA hai| paramArthata. aupazamika samyaktva kA hI kAla hai| isIlie pravacanasAra gAthA-201 tA.vR. TIkA meM dUsare guNasthauna se bArahaveM guNasthAnavI jIvoM ko ekadeza jina taka kahA hai|
Page #55
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ 55 isakA kAla jaghanya eka samaya, utkRSTa chaha AvalI pramANa hI hai aura chadmastha asaMkhyAta samayoparAMta hI apane kaSAya bhAvoM ko jAna pAtA hai| isa guNasthAnavartI jIva ke pariNAma to kevalajJAna gamya hI hote haiN| mizra mohanIyodaya ke nimitta se mizra tRtIya guNasthAna (madhyapa aMtarmuhUrta kAlapramANa) hotA hai aura isake bhI pariNAma kevalajJAna gamya haiN| tattvoM kA satya-asatya rUpa zraddhAnaazraddhAna eka hI kAla meM vartatA hai| mithyAdRSTi kA jJAna hI tattvanirNaya kara saccA banatA hai| isIlie dhavalA 1/39 pR. para use maMgalakArI siddha kiyA hai| 2. nizcayasamyaktva gRhasthAvasthA/ caturtha guNasthAna meM hotA hai| isakA pramANa Apa svayaM ne paramAtma prakAza 2/18 kI TIkA se isaprakAra diyA hai| - 'nijazuddhAtmaivopAdeya iti rucirUpaM nizcayasamyaktvaM gRhasthAvasthAyAM tIrthaMkaraparamadeva bharatasagararAmapANDavAdInAM vidyate,naca teSAM vItarAga cAritramastIti parasparavirodhaH asti, cetarhiteSAsaMyatattvaM kathamiti puurvpkssH| tatra prihaarmaah| teSAM zuddhAtmaivopAdeyabhAvanArUpaM nizcayasamyaktvaM vidyte| paraM kintu cAritramohodayena sthiratA nAsti vratapratijJAbhaGgo bhavatIti tena kAraNenAsaMyatA vA bhnnynte| ...... 3. paramArthataH nizcaya-vyavahAra samyaktva donoM eka sAtha hI utpanna hote haiN| tathApi kudevAdika kI mAnyatA se rahita evaM aSTamUlaguNa sahita vyakti ko hI jinadharma kI dezanA grahaNa kara sakane yogya pAtra kahA hai, aisI nirmala buddhivAle jIva ke jo vizuddhi pragaTa hai vahI vItarAgI deva-zAstra-gurU-dharma kI mAnyatA vAlA pUrvacara vyavahAradharma dhAraka pAtra jIva hai| tadartha puruSArthasiddhyupAya zlo.74dekheM jisameM mUlaguNa rahitako dezanA kA apAtra kahA hai avirata samyagde'STi kA svarUpa bR.dravyasaMgraha gAthA 45 kI TIkA meM isaprakAra likhA haimithyAtvAdi sAta prakRtiyoM ke upazama, kSayopazama athavA kSaya hone para athavA adhyAtmabhASA se nijazuddhAtmAbhimukha pariNAma hone para zuddhAtmabhAvanA se utpanna, nirvikAra .. vAstavika sukhAmRta ko upAdeya karake saMsAra-zarIra aura bhogoM meM jo heyabuddhiyukta samyagdarzana se zuddha hai vaha caturthaguNasthAna vratarahita dArzanika kahalAtA hai| isa paribhASA meM samyaktva kI paribhASA karaNAnuyoga, dravyAnuyoga evaM caraNAnuyoga tInoM anuyogoM se samanvita hai| yahI nizcaya-vyavahAra samyaktva kA eka hI kAla meM utpanna honA hai| jaise putrAdi saMtAna utpanna hone para janmadAtA strI-puruSa ko mAtA-pitA kI saMjJA milatI hai, kiMtu vivAhAdi pUrvacara vyavahAra binA saccA nizcaya vyavahAra lAgU nahIM pdd'taa| punazca, zrI ratnakaraNDa zrAvakAcAra zloka 33 meM gRhastha samyagdRSTi ko mokSamArgastha kahA hI hai, jaba ki samyaktva rahita muni ko mokSamArgastha nahIM khaa| . tathA bR.dravyasaMgraha gAthA - 47 mUla meM hI kahA hai ki - duvihaMpi mokkhaheuM jhANe pAuNadi jaM muNI nniymaa| tamhA payattacittA jUyaM jhANaM samanbhasaha // 47 //
Page #56
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ 56 artha-(Atma)dhyAna karane se munirAja niyama se nizcaya aura vyavahAra rUpa kSamArgako prApta karate haiN| ataH tuma citta ko ekAgra karake dhyAna kA samyak prakAra se abhyAsa kro| hamako bhI isI prakAra se dhyAna karane kI preraNA gAthA -48 meM dI hai| 4. rAjA zreNika ke kSAyika samyaktva/vItarAga samyaktva hai vaha nizcaya samyaktva hI hai| isake Agama pramANa maiMne apane 1. 11. 05 ke patra meM diye haiN| sarvArthasiddhi, rAjavArtika, amitagati zrAvakAcAra, paMcAstikAya, zlokavArtika, mo.mA.prakAzaka ke pramANoM se sarAga-vItarAga samyagdarzana bAba spaSTatA ho jAtI hai tathA paMcAstikAya gAthA 160 meM to gRhastha va munirAja ke samyagdarzana ko spaSTatayA samAna hote haiM - kahA hai| . 5. anaMtAnubaMdhI ke abhAva meM svarUpAcaraNa cAritra hotA hai-aisA sIdhA Agama vAkya dekhane meM nahIM aayaa| samyaktvAcaraNa cAritra hotA hai, aisA to AyA hI hai tathA zuddhopayoga ke binA darzanamoha kA kSaya nahIM hotA - aisA pravacanasAra gAthA- 80 (jo jANadi arahaMta)kI tA.vR.TIkA meM spaSTa jayasenAcArya deva ne likhA hai| arthAt kSAyika samyagdarzana zuddhopayoga rUpa nirvikAra svasaMvedana binA nahIM hotA-yaha spaSTa hai aura aupazamika samyaktva kSAyikavat nirmala hotA hI hai| ataH isase nizcaya hotA hai ki svAtmAnubhUti/zuddhopayoga binA(bhale bijalI kI camakAravat atyalpa ho)aupazamika samyaktvopalabdhi saMbhava nahIM hai| 6. svarUpAcaraNa cAritra kI paribhASA-jaisA ki pUrva vidvAna paraMparA ne svIkAra kiyA hai vahI dekhane meM AtI hai-jo ki anaMtAnubaMdhI kaSAya ke abhAva meM pragaTa hotA hai| phira bhI jaba anaMtAnubaMdhI cAritramoha kI prakRti hai ataH usake jAne para jo bhI zuddhi aMza pragaTa hotA hai, use kucha na kucha to nAma denA hI pdd'egaa| tabhI to dhavalA bhAga 1-pR.165 dasaveM sUtra (sAsaNa sammAiTThI....) kI TIkA meM AcArya vIrasena svAmIne yaha likhA hai ki - ....iti cet,na samyagdarzanacAritra pratibandhyAnantAnubaMdhI udayotpAditaviparItAbhinivezasyaM tatra satvAd bhavati mithyAdRSTirapitu mithyAtvakarmodayajanita viparItAbhinivezAbhAvAt na tasya mithyAdRSTi vyapadezaH kintu sAsAdana iti vypdishyte| kimiti mithyAdRSTi riti navyapadizyate cenna, anaMtAnubaMdhinAM dvisvabhAvatva pratipAdana phalatvAt / na ca darzanamohanIya syodayAdupazamAtkSayAtkSayopazamAdvAsAsAdana pariNAmaH.....prANinAmupajAyate tena mithyAdRSTiH samyagdRSTiH smygmithyaadRssttiriticocyet| yasmAcca viparItAbhinivezo' bhUdanantAnubaMdhino,na tadarzanamohanIyaM,tasya caaritraavrnntvaat| tasyobhayapratibaMdhakatvA dubhaya- vyapadezo nyAyya iticenna, isstttvaat| artha-zaMkA-yadi aisA hai to ise (sAsAdana samyagdRSTi ko) mithyAdRSTi hI kahanA cAhie, sAsAdana saMjJA denA ucita nahIM hai.? samAdhAna-nahIM, kyoM ki samyagdarzana aura (svarUpAcaraNa)cAritra kA pratibaMdha karana vAle anaMtAnubaMdhI kaSAya ke udaya se utpanna huA viparItAbhiniveza dUsare guNasthAna meM pAyA jAtA hai| isalie dvitIya guNasthAnavI jIva mithyAdRSTi hai kiMtu mithyAtvakarma ke udaya meM utpanna
Page #57
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ 57 huA viparItAbhiniveza vahA~ nahIM pAyA jAtA hai, isalie use mithyAdRSTi nahIM kahate haiM, kiMtu sAsAdana samyagdRSTi kahate haiN| zaMkA-pUrva kathana ke anusAra jaba vaha mithyAdRSTi hI hai to phira use mithyAdRSTi saMjJA kyoM nahIM dI gayI hai? samAdhAna-aisA nahIM hai, kyoM ki sAsAdana guNasthAna ko svataMtra kahane se anaMtAnubaMdhI prakRtiyoM kI dvisvabhAvatA kA kathana siddha ho jAtA hai| __darzana mohanIya ke udaya, upazama, kSaya aura kSayopazama se jIvoM ke sAsAdanarUpa pariNAma to utpanna hotA nahIM hai, jisase ki sAsAdana guNasthAna ko mithyAdRSTi, samyagdRSTi athavA samyagmithyAdRSTi kahA jAtA, tathA jisa anaMtAnubaMdhI ke udaya se dUsare guNasthAna meM viparItAbhiniveza hotA hai, vaha anaMtAnubaMdhI darzanamohanIya kA bheda na hokara cAritra kA AvaraNa karane vAlA hone se cAritramohanIya kA bheda hai| isalie dUsare guNasthAna ko mithyAdRSTi na kahakara sAsAdana samyagdRSTi kahA hai| zaMkA-anaMtAnubaMdhI samyaktva aura cAritra ina donoM kA pratibaMdha hone se use ubhayarUpa (samyaktva cAritramohanIya)saMjJA denA nyAyya saMgata hai ? samAdhAna-yaha Aropa ThIka nahIM, kyoM ki yaha to hameM iSTa hI hai| arthAt anaMtAnubaMdhI ko samyaktva aura cAritra ina donoM kA pratibaMdhaka mAnA hI hai| vastutaH viparItAbhiniveza do prakAra kA hotA hai, anaMtAnubaMdhI janita aura mithyAtvajanita! dUsare guNasthAna meM anaMtAnubaMdhIjanita viparItAbhiniveza hI pAyA jAtA hai| isalie mithyAtva guNasthAna se bhinna ise svataMtra sAsAdana guNasthAna. mAnA gayA hai| 7. caturtha guNasthAna meM zuddhopayoga hotA hai| Upara biMdu kra.3 bRhad dravyasaMgraha kI TIkA ke AdhAra se avirata samyagdRSTi caturthaguNasthAnavartI kA svarUpa/ paribhASA dI gayI hai| usI prakAra pravacanasAra gAthA 80 tA.vR. TIkA meM AyA hai| jise maiM pUrva patroM meM bhI uddhRta karatA A rahA huuN| usameM isa prakAra kathana hai-..... . ......atha cattA pAvArambha ityAdi sUtreNa yaduktaM zuddhopayogAbhAve mohAdivinAzo na bhavati, mohAdi vinAzAbhAve zuddhAtmalAbho na bhvti|..... tat AtmaparijJAnAt tasya moho darzanamoho layaM vinAzaM kSayaM yAtIti |......itthNbhuutN dravyaguNaparyAyasvarUyaM pUrvamarhadabhidhAneparamAtmanijJAtvApazcAnnizcayanayena tadevAgamasArapadabhUtayA'dhyAtma bhASayA nijazuddhAtmabhAvanAbhimukharUpeNa savikalpa svasaMvedana jJAnena tathaivAgama bhASayAdhaHpravRtti karaNApUrva - karaNAnivRttikaraNa saMjJa darzanamohakSapaNa samartha pariNAma vizeSabalena pazcAdAtmani yojyti| tadanaMtaramavikalpasvarUpa rUpe prApte...... darzanamohAndhakAraH pralIyate itibhAvArthaH // 80 // 8. caturthaguNasthAna meM zuddhAtmAnubhUti hotI hai| samayasAra gAthA 13 AtmakhyAti TIkA meM - 'evamasAvakatvena dyotamAnaH zuddhanayatvenAnubhUyata eva / yA tu anubhUtiH sAtmakhyAti - revAtmakhyAtistusamyagdarzanameva / iti samastameva nirvdym|'.... aisA spaSTa ullekha hai|
Page #58
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ 58 punaH samayasAra gAthA 19 tAtparyavRtti TIkA meM - 'apratibuddhaH svasaMvittizUnyo bahirAtmAbhavati taavtkaalmiti| atra bhedavijJAnamUlAMzuddhAtmAnubhUti svataH svayaMbuddhayApekSayA ye labhaMte te puruSAH zubhAzubha bahirdravyeSu vidyamAneSvapi mukurandavadavikArA bhavantIti bhaavaarthH|'.. samayasAra gAthA 50 se 55 taka AtmakhyAti TIkA meM aneka bAra 'zuddhAtmAnubhUtebhinnatvAt' zabda AyA hai, jo dhyAna dene lAyaka hai| 9. aviratasamyagdRSTi mokSamArgI hai| ratnakaraNDa zrAvakAcAra zloka 33 meM spaSTa likhA hai gRhastho mokSamArgasthonirmohonaiva mohavAn / anagAro gRhI zreyAn nirmoho mohino muneH||33|| . 10. zubhabhAva se saMvara-nirjarA nahIM hotI, prakRta meM puNyabaMdha hotA hai aura aghAtiyA karmoM ko pApa prakRtiyoM kA Asrava kiMcit ruka jAnA(saMvara?)saMkramaNa ho jAnA-puNyarUpa pariNama jAnA hotA hai paraMtu AtmaguNa ghAtaka dhAtikarmo kA AnA nahIM ruktaa| dekho-pravacanasAra gAthA 180-181 kI TIkA suhapariNAmo puNNaM asuho pAvaM ti bhnnidmnnnnesu| pariNAmo NaNNagado dukkhakkhaya kAraNaM samaye // 181 // 11. 'AdyA. samyaktvacAritre dvitIyA dhnanatyaNuvrataM / tRtIyA saMyama turyA yathAkhyAtaM krudhaadyH|' isakA artha maiMne bikkula sahI likhA hai| kyoM ki mUla meM 'samyaktvacAritre' zabda hai| Apa mUla artha meM bhI bhUla nikAla rahe haiM? vicAraNIya hai| astu ! Apa punarvicAra kreN| Agama-adhyAtma virUddha kucha likhA ho to kSamA kreN| zeSa zubha, kRpAdRSTi banAye rkheN| patrottara deveN| bhavadIya zivAkAMkSI- bra. hemacaMda jaina 'hema' vizeSa-11-12 disaMbara 06 ke pazcAt maMgalAyatana-alIgar3ha jAne kA vicAra hai| saMbhava ho to pdhaareN| milakara khuzI hogii| - bra. hemacaMda jaina 'hema' . dharmyadhyAna-Agama ke Aloka meM paramAnaMdasaMyuktaM, nirvikAraM niraamym| dhyAnahInA na pazyanti, nijadehe vyvsthitm|| ..... paramAnaMda stotram 1 // AnaMda brahmaNo rUpam , nijadehe vyvsthitm|| dhyAnahInA na pazyanti , jAtyaMdhA iva bhAskaram ||.....prmaanNd stotram 9 // sadhyAnaM kriyate bhavyaiH mano yena viliiyte| tatkSaNaM dRzyate zuddhaM, ciccmtkaartnkssnnm||......prmaanNd stotram 10 / / nirvikalpasamutpannaM jnyaanmevsudhaarsm| viveka maMjuliM kRtvA, tatpibanti tapasvinaH // ...paramAnaMda stotram
Page #59
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ 59 di. 15.01.06. AdaraNIya AgamavettA vidvadvara zrI paM.ratanalAla jI bainAr3A jaina-AgarA, sAdara jayajineMdra, drshnvishuddhi| Apake 01.11.2005 ke patra meM vAMchita Agama pramANa maiMne apane 28.11.05 ke patrottara meM bheje the| jo Apako disaMbara ke prathama saptAha meM mila gayA hogaa| aba Apane mere dvArA pUrva do patroM meM di.30.09.05/01.11.05 evaM 28.11.05)uddhRta Agama pramANoM kA sarva pUrvAgraha chor3akara niSpakSa bhAva se ciMtana manana kara, vyakti niSThatA ko chor3akara Agama niSThatA ko zirodhArya kara samIcIna nirNaya/samAdhAna prApta kara liyA hogA tathA jo uttara/ vicAraNIya biMdu puna : Apake jJAna meM Aye hoM(jo Apa mujhe vicArArtha bhejane vAle the) zIghra bhejane kI kRpA kreN| mere aura Apake bIca hue upArokta patrAcAra se, maiM AzA karatA hU~ ki aba Apako nimnalikhita tathyoM/ siddhAMtoM kA nizcaya/nirNaya ho gayA hogaa| 1.moha kA artha mithyAtva/ darzanamoha hai na ki caaritrmoh| darzanamoha hai to cAritramoha to hai hii| 2. mithyAtva va anaMtAnubaMdhI catuSka ke abhAva meM pragaTa hone vAlA viparItAbhiniveza rahita zraddhAna rUpa pariNAma hI nizcaya samyagdarzana hai, jo yadi kSAyika rUpa ho to caturtha guNasthAna se lekara arihaMta-siddhAvasthA taka (sAdi anaMtakAla paryaMta) eka sA hI rahatA hai| deva-zAstraguru evaM prayAjanabhUta tattvoM ke zraddhAna ko vyavahAra samyagdarzana kahate haiN| 3. 'kSAyika'ko vItarAga evaM aupazamika/kSAyopazamika'ko sarAga samyagdarzana bhI kahate haiN| 4. zrAvakAvasthA meM kSAyika samyagdarzana ko sarAga samyagdarzana tathA munidazA meM use hI vIta- rAga samyagdarzana kahate haiN| sarAgAvasthA meM sarAga evaM vItarAgAvasthA meM vItarAga nAma paataahai| 5. sarAga samyagdarzana ko vyavahAra evaM vItarAga samyagdarzana ko nizcaya samyagdarzana bhI kahate haiN| paramArtha se nijazuddhAtmA kI ruci/pratItirUpa nizcayasamyagdarzana to caturtha guNasthAna meM hI pragaTa pUrNa ho jAtA hai| nizcaya samyagdarzana bhedarahita eka hI prakAra kA hai| 6. anaMtAnubaMdhI nizcaya se cAritramoha kI prakRti hone para bhI samyaktva evaM cAritra donoM kA ghAta karatI hone se dvisvabhAvI hai| jaise kainsara roga manuSya paryAya ke nAza kA kAraNa hai, vaise hI anaMtAnubaMdhI kA udaya samyaktva ke nAza kA kAraNa hai| 7.sAsAdana guNasthAna meM mithyAtva (darzanamoha) kA anudaya hone se mithyAtva karma ke udaya se utpanna hone vAlA viparItAbhiniveza vahA~ nahIM pAyA jAtA isalie use mithyAdRSTi nahIM kahate, kiMtu samyagdarzana aura cAritra kA pratibaMdha karane vAlI anaMtAnubaMdhI kaSAya ke udaya se utpanna huA viparItAbhiniveza vahA~ pAyA jAtA hai, isI se isako sAsAdana samyagdRSTi kahate haiN|| AsAdanA sahita jisakI samIcIna dRSTi hotI hai vaha sAsAdana samyagdRSTi kahAlAtA hai| .
Page #60
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ 8. viparItAbhiniveza do prakAra kA hotA hai-eka azraddhAna rUpa aura eka asthiratArUpa ! dravyakarmanokarma-bhAvakarma rahita nijazuddhAtmA kI zraddhA nahIM honA,mithyAtvodayajanita viparItA- bhiniveza hai aura svarUpa meM sthiratA (lInatA)nahIM honA cAritramohodayajanita viparItAbhiniveza hai| atattvazraddhA (prayojanabhUta tattvoM kI zraddhA nahIM hone)kA kAraNa mithyAtva (darzanamoha)hai aura asthiratA (rAga-dveSa rahita nirvikalpatA kA nahIM honA)kA kAraNa kaSAya (cAritramoha) hai| 9. pa.pU.A.vIrasena mahArAja ne (dhavala pu.1/163) yahI bAta siddha kI hai ki dUsare guNasthAna- vartI jIva ko sAsAdana samyagdRSTi kyoM kahA? mithyAdRSTi kyoM nahIM kahA?kyoM ki viparItAbhiniveza mithyAtva janya aura anaMtAnubaMdhI janya do prakAra kA hotA hai| so dUsare guNasthAna meM anaMtAnubaMdhI janya viparItAbhiniveza huA hai ,jo kainsara roga kI taraha samyaktva kA ghAtaka hai| yahA~ mithyAtvodaya janya viparItAbhiniveza nahIM huA hone se dUsare guNasthAnavartI ko AsAdanA sahita samyagdRSTi kahA hai| mithyAdRSTi nahIM khaa| yahI bAta A.ka.paM.ToDaramala jI ne siddha kI hai| 10. anaMtAnubaMdhI yadyapi cAritramohanIya hI hai, tathApi vaha svakSetra tathA parakSetra kA ghAta karane kI zakti se saMyukta hai| arthAt cAritra(svakSetra)evaM samyaktva(parakSetra)ko ghAtane kI zakti se saMyukta hai| anaMtAnubaMdhI darzanamohanIya kA bheda na hokara cAritra kA AvaraNa karane vAlA hone se cAritramohanIya kA hI bheda hai| isalie dUsare guNasthAna ko mithyAdRSTi na kahakara sAsAdana samyagdRSTi kahA hai tathA anaMtAnubaMdhI ko samyaktva va cAritra ina donoM kA pratibaMdhaka mAnA hI hai| (dekho-dhavala 1/165 va 6/42) 11. A.ka.paM.ToDaramala jI kA jJAna tarka/vicAraNA sahita agAdha gaMbhIratA lie hue thA, isIse unake sAmane dhavala graMtha upalabdha na hone para bhI yaha niSkarSa nikAlakara mo.mA.pra.9veM adhyAya meM yaha likhA hai- . 'anaMtAnubaMdhI ke udaya se krodhAdi pariNAma hote haiM, kucha atattvazraddhAna nahIM hotaa| isalie anaMtAnubaMdhI cAritra hI kA ghAta karatI hai ,samyaktva kA ghAta nahIM krtii| so paramArtha se hai to aisA hI, paraMtu anaMtAnubaMdhI ke udaya se jaise krodhAdika hote haiM, vaise krodhAdika samyaktva hone para nahIM hote| aisA nimitta-naimittika pAyA jAtA hai| .......isalie upacAra se anaMtAnubaMdhI ke bhI samyaktva kA ghAtakapanA kahA jAye to doSa nahIM hai / arthAt paM. ToDaramala jI ne anaMtAnubaMdhI kI dvisvabhAvatA mAnya kI hai| bhavadIya- hemacaMda jaina -(vidvatjanoM se vizeSa prArthanA hai ki ukta carcA ke viSaya meM apane abhiprAya nimna pate para avazya avagata kraaveN|) bra. hemacaMda jaina 'hema' ema. Aya. jI.,10, sekTara e, sonAgiri , bhela -bhopAla (ma.pra.) 462002, (phona-0755 - 2681 049)
Page #61
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ jijJAsA samAdhAna-jinabhASita (aMka disaMbara- 2005, pR.26) samAdhAna kartA - paM. zrI ratanalAlajI bainAr3A, AgarA praznakartA -bra. hemacaMda jaina, 'hema' , bhopAla jijJAsA-kRpayA ina mAnyatAoM ke bAre meM apane vicAra likheM 1. paramArthataH anaMtAnubaMdhI cAritra kI prakRti hai, vaha cAritra hI kA ghAta karatI hai| samyaktva kA ghAta nahIM karatI hai| 2. dUsare guNasthAna meM upazama samyaktva kA hI kAla hai, isalie use sAsAdana samyagdRSTi kahA, sAsAdana mithyAdRSTi nahIM khaa| samAdhAna - uparokta jijJAsA 1. (a) ke samAdhAna meMdhavala pustaka 1 pRSTha 163 kA kRpayA avalokana kreN| vahA~ isaprakAra kahA hai, prazna-sAsAdana guNasthAna vAlA jIva mithyAtva kA udaya hone se mithyAdRSTi nahIM hai| samIcIna ruci kA abhAva hone se samyagdRSTi bhI nahIM hai| donoM ko viSaya karane vAlI samyagmithyAtva rUpa ruci kA abhAva hone se samyagdRSTi bhI nahIM hai| inake atirikta aura koI cauthI dRSTi hai nahIM ,kyoM ki samIcIna -asamIcIna aura ubhayarUpa dRSTi ke Alambana bhUta vastu ke atirikta dUsarI koI vastu pAyI nahIM jAtI hai| isalie sAsAdana guNasthAna asatsvarUpa hai| uttara- aisA nahIM hai| kyoM ki sAsAdana guNasthAna meM viparIta abhiprAya rahatA hai| isalie use asadRSTi hI samajhanA caahie| prazna-yadi aisA hai to ise mithyAdRSTi hI kahanA caahie| sAsAdana saMjJA denA ucita nahIM hai? uttara-nahIM, kyoM ki samyagdarzana aura cAritra kA pratibaMdha karane vAlI anaMtAnubaMdhI kaSAya ke udaya se utpanna huA viparItAbhiniveza dUsare guNasthAna meM pAyA jAtA hai| isalie dvitIya guNasthAnavI jIva mithyAdRSTi hai kintu mithyAtva karma ke udayaM se utpanna huA viparItAbhiniveza vahA~ nahIM pAyA jAtA hai, isalie use mithyAdRSTi nahIM kahate haiM / kevala sAsAdana samyagdRSTi kahate haiN| prazna-upara ke kathanAnusAra jaba vaha mithyAdRSTi hai to phira use mithyAdRSTi saMjJA kyoM nahIM dI gayI? uttara-aisA nahIM hai ,kyoM ki sAsAdana guNasthAna ko svataMtra kahane se anaMtAnubaMdhI prakRtiyoM kI dvisvabhAva kA kathana siddha ho jAtA hai| (A) gommaTasAra karmakAMDa TIkA 546/71/ 12 meM isaprakAra kahA hai, .. 'mithyAtvena sahodIyamAnAH kaSAyAH samyastvaMdhnanti / anantAnubaMdhinA ca smyktvsNymau|' artha-mithyAtva ke sAtha udaya hone vAlI kaSAya samyaktva ko ghAtatI hai aura anaMtAnubaMdhI
Page #62
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ 62 ke dvArA samyaktva ke dvArA samyaktva aura saMyama ghAtA jAtA hai| (i)zrI dhavalA pu.1, pRSTha 361 para isaprakAra kahA hai- 'mithyAdRSTi jIvoM ke bhalehI donoM (mati va zruta) ajJAna hoveM, kyoM ki vahA~ para ve donoM jJAna ajJAnarUpa nahIM honA cAhie? uttara-nahI, kyoM ki viparItAbhiniveza ko mithyAtva kahate haiN| aura vaha viparItAbhiniveza mithyAtva aura anaMtAnubaMdhI ina donoM ke nimitta se utpanna hotA hai| (I) paMcasaMgraha prAkRta- 1/115 meM isaprakAra kahA hai, 'paDhamo daMsaNaghAI vidio taha ghAr3a desavira tti taio saMjamaghAr3a cauttho jaharavAya ghaaiyaa| prathama anaMtAnubaMdhI kaSAya samyagdarzana kA ghAta karatI hai , dvitIya apratyAkhyAnA- varaNa kaSAya dezavirati kA ghAtaka hai|, tRtIya pratyAkhyAnAvaraNa kaSAya sakala saMyama kI ghAtaka hai aura caturtha saMjvalana kaSAya yathAkhyAta cAritra kI ghAtaka hai| (u)anaMtAnubaMdhI yadyapi cAritramohanIya hI hai tathApi vaha svakSetra tathA parakSetra meM ghAta karane kI zakti se yukta hai| zrI dhavala pu. 6, pRSTha 42-43 meM kahA hai ki 'aNatANubaMdhiNo----- sammattacANittANaM virohiNI / duvihsttisNjudttaado| --------- edesiM------siddha dasaNamohaNIyattaM carittamohaNIyattaM c|' artha-guruupadeza tathA yukti se jAnA jAtA hai ki anaMtAnubaMdhI kaSAyoM kI zakti se do prakAra kI hai| isalie samyaktva va cAritra ina donoM ko ghAtane vAlI do prakAra kI zakti se saMyukta anaMtAnubaMdhI hai| ------ isaprakAra siddha hotA hai ki anaMtAnubaMdhI darzanamohanIya bhI hai,cAritra mohanIya bhI hai| arthAt samyaktva tathA cAritra ko ghAtane kI zakti se saMyukta hai| isaprakAra anaMtAnubaMdhI kI donoM zaktiyoM ko svIkAra karanA caahie| . (U) zrI dhavalA pR.1, pRSTha 165 para isa prakAra kahA hai - _ 'anaMtAnubaMdhI kI dvisvabhAvatA kA kathana siddha ho jAtA hai tathA jisa anaMtAnubaMdhI ke udaya se dUsare guNasthAna meM viparItAbhiniveza hotA hai, vaha anaMtAnubaMdhI darzanamohanIya kA bheda nahIM hokara cAritra kA AvaraNa karane vAlA hone se cAritramohanIya kA bheda hai|' prazna-anaMtAnubaMdhI samyaktva aura cAritra ina donoM kA pratibaMdhaka hone se use ubhayarUpa saMjJA denA nyAya saMgata hai? uttara- yaha Aropa ThIka nahIM hai| kyoM ki yaha to hameM iSTa hI hai, arthAt anaMtAnubaMdhI ko samyaktva aura cAritra ina donoM kA pratibaMdhaka mAnA hI hai| (e)zrI dhavala pu. 6, pRSTha 42 para isaprakAra kahA haiprazna-anaMtAnubaMdhI kaSAyoM kI zakti do prakAra kI hai| isa viSaya meM kyA yukti hai? uttara-ye catuSka darzanamohanIya svarUpa nahIM ganejA sakate kyoM ki samyaktva prakRti, mithyAtva aura samyagmithyAtva ke dvArA hI AvaraNa kiye jAne vAle darzanamohanIya ke phala kA abhAva hai aura na inheM cAritra mohanIya svarUpa hI mAnA jA sakatA hai , kyoM ki apratyAkhyAnAvaraNAdi
Page #63
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ 63 kaSAyoM ke dvArA AvaraNa kiye gaye cAritra ke AvaraNa karane meM phala kA abhAva hai| isalie uparyukta anaMtAnubaMdhI kaSAyoM kA abhAva hI siddha hotA hai| kintu unakA abhAva nahIM hai kyoM ki sUtra meM inakA astitva pAyA jAtA hai| isalie anaMtAnubaMdhI kaSAyoM ke udaya se sAsAdana bhAva kI utpatti anyathA ho nahIM sakatI hai| isahI anyathAnupatti se inake darzanamohanIyatA aura cAritramohanIyatA arthAt samyaktva aura cAritra ko ghAta karane kI zakti kA honA siddha hotA hai| ___ pU. AcArya vIrasena mahArAja Adi ke uparokta pramANoM se yaha bilakula spaSTa hai ki anaMtAnubaMdhI samyaktva kA bhI ghAta karatI hai / itanA aura bhI vizeSa hai ki mokSamArga prakAzaka 9 veM adhikAra paM. ToDaramalajI ne isaprakAra kahA hai, yahA~prazna-jo anaMtAnubaMdhI to cAritramoha kI prakRti hai| so cAritra ko ghAtai, yA kari samyaktva kA ghAta kaise sambhavai? tAkA samAdhAna-anaMtAnubaMdhI ke udayatai krodhAdirUpa pariNAma ho haiN| kichu atattva zraddhAna hotA naahiiN| tA" anaMtAnubaMdhI cAritra hI ko ghAtai hai| samyaktva ko nahIM ghAtai hai|' mokSamArga kA yaha kathana uparokta AgamapramANa ke anusAra na hone se Agama sammata nahIM hai| jijJAsA-2 isake samAdhAna meM 'sAsAdana meM upazama samyaktva kA kAla hai|'- isakA artha yaha nahIM samajhanA cAhie ki dUsare guNasthAna meM upazama samyaktva hai| kyoM ki dUsare guNasthAna meM upazama samyaktva hai| kyoM ki dUsare guNasthAna vAlA NAsiyammotto(go.jI.20, prA.paM.saM.1/ 9; zrI dhavala 1/66) arthAt nAzita samyaktva(jisakA samyaktva ratna naSTa ho cukA aisA jIva)kahalAtA hai| sAsAdana guNI asaddRSTi hai|(dhvl 1/165) vaha upazama samyaktva ke kAla ke aMta meM patita-nAzita samyaktva hokara hI sAsAdana ko prApta hotA hai, sthitibhUta upazama samyaktva ke sAtha sAsAdana meM nahIM jAtA yaha abhiprAya hai| 'sAsAdana meM upazama samyaktva kA kAla hai ' - isakA abhiprAya yaha hai ki upazama samyaktva kAla ko aMtima 6AvalI kI avadhi meM koI jIva pariNAma hAnivaza samyaktva ratna ko khokara(la.sA.pRSTha 83,mukhtArI) sAsAdana (nAzita samyaktva va mithyAtva guNa ke abhimukha) ho jAtA hai| (jayadhavala 12, labdhisAra gA. 99 se 109, dhavala 4/339-343 Adi) caubIsa ThANA meM upazama samyaktva kI prarUpaNA karate hue upazama samktva ko cauthe the se gyArahaveM guNasthAna taka kahA jAtA hai, dUsare guNasthAna meM nahIM kahA jAtA hai / dUsare sAsAdana guNasthAna meM tiryaMcAyu Adi 25 azubha prakRtiyoM kA baMdha hotA hai, jo upazama samyagdRSTi ko bilakula saMbhava nahIM hai| ataH uparokta samAdhAna ke anusAra sAsAdana guNasthAna meM upazama samyaktva kA kAla na mAnakara usakA sahI abhiprAya samajhanA caahie| isa dvitii| guNasthAna, ko sAsAdana samyagdRSTi kahane kA vAstavika abhiprAya kyA hai? isa saMbaMdha meM dhavalA pustaka 1, pRSTha 166 kA nimna kathana dhyAna dene yogya hai|
Page #64
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ 64 prazna-sAsAdana guNasthAna viparIta abhiprAya se dUSita hai| isalie isameM samyagdRSTipanA kaise banatA hai? uttara-nahIM, kyoM ki pahale vaha samyagdRSTi thA isalie bhUtapUrva nyAya kI apekSA usake samyagdRSTi saMjJA bana jAtI hai| vAstava meM sAsAdana dRSTi kA sahI artha hai, AsAdanA sahita jisakI samIcIna dRSTi hotI hai,vaha sAsAdana samyagdRSTi kahalAtA hai|' yahA~ bhI itanA vizeSa hai ki paM. ToDaramalajI ke samakSa zrI dhavalA Adi graMthoM kA prakAzana na hone ke kAraNa, mokSamArga prakAzaka tathA unake dvArA racita anya graMthoM meM bahuta se aise prasaMga par3hane meM Ate haiM jo sUkSma vivecana karane vAle zrI dhavalA Adi graMthoM ke anusAra Agama sammata nahIM hai| kucha pakSapAtI loga zrI dhavalA Adi graMthoM ke artha ko mokSamArga prakAzaka ke anusAra tor3a maror3akara apanI sthUla buddhi kA paricaya dete haiN| jabaki unako dhavalA Adi graMthoM ke anusAra mokSamArga prakAzaka meM Avazyaka sudhAra kara apanI buddhi kA parimArjana karanA mokSamArga meM zreyaskara hai| - 1/205, prophesara kAlonI, AgarA- 280002 dharmyadhyAna-Agama ke Aloka meM edamhi rado NiccaM saMtuTTho hohi nniccmedmhi| edeNa hohi titto hohadi tuha uttama sokkhaM ||.....smysaar 206 // mokkhapahe appANaM Thavehi taM ceva jhAhi taM cey| tattheva vihara NiccaM mA viharasu annnnkssdvvsu||.....smysaar 412 // jo savvasaMgamukko jhAyadi appANamappaNo appaa| Na vi kammaNokammaM cedA ciMtedi eyttN|| ..... samayasAra 188 // appANaM jhAyaMto daMsaNaNANamao annnnnnmo| lahadi acireNa appANameva so kmmpvimukkN|| .....samayasAra 189 // ahamekko khalu suddho Nimmamao nnaanndNsnnsmggo| tamhi Thido taccitto savve ede khayaM nnemi||.....smysaar 73 // . NAhaM homi paresiMNa me pare saMti NANamahamekko / (191) idi jo jhAyadi jhANe appANaM havadi jhaadaa||......prvcnsaar 204 // jo evaM jANittA jhAdi para appagaM visuddhppaa| (194) sAgAro'aNagAro khavedi so mohduggNtthiN| ..... pravacanasAra 207 // jo icchai Nissari, saMsAramahaNavAu ruNdaao| kammiMdhaNANa DahaNaM so jhAyai appayaM suddh|..... mokSapAhuDa 26 //
Page #65
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ di. 15.1.2006 paM. hemacaMda jI jaina dvArA paM. zrI ratanalAlajI bainAr3A ko patra Aja abhI jinabhASita disaMbara 05 kA aMka milaa| mere nAma se jijJAsA chapI? mahAzcarya huaa| mAnyavara bainAr3A jI ! disaMbara 2005 ke jinabhASita aMka meM jijJAsA samAdhAna meM mere nAma se jijJAsA chApa kara (usakA samAdhAna bhI mere patra 29.11.2005)meM uddhRta dhavalA(1/165) ke samAdhAnAnusAra tathA kucha vistRta kara)Apane lagatA hai, mere sAtha yaha kyA kiyA hai ? mere dvArA pUchI gayI jijJAsAoM kA samAdhAna to nahIM chApA aura jo maiMne pUchA hI nahIM use kaise chApa diyA? Apane A.ka.paM.ToDaramalajI ko dhavalA zAstra upalabdha na hone se unake dvArA racita mokSamArgaprakAzaka tathA anya graMthoM ke bahuta se prasaMgoM ko Agama-sammata nahIM ThaharAyA hai| isa ApakIdRSTi ke bAre meM kyA kaheM? paM. ToDaramala jI ko to vidvat jagata ne AcAryakalpa kI upAdhi se vibhUSita kiyA thaa| jisako Agama-adhyAtma ke kathanoM kA yA cAroM anuyogoM kA satyArtha svarUpa bhAsita ho gayA hai to use 'chalaM na gRhitavyam' (samayasAra gA.5)ko nahIM bhulA denA caahie| A.ka. paM. ToDaramala jI ne to dUdha kA dUdha pAnI kA pAnI kara dikhAyA hai| bhale unake sAmane dhavalA zAstra nahIM thA, tathApi unhoMne mokSamArga prakAzaka meM anaMtAnubaMdhI kaSAyoM ko samyaktva ghAtaka to mAnya kiyA hI hai, kiMtu Apa to mAtra samyaktva vighAtaka hI mAnate haiM ! cAritra vighAtaka nahIM mAnate haiM? Apa kahate jarUra haiM ki anaMtAnubaMdhI dvisvabhAvI hai, paraMtu mAnate -manavAte eka svabhAvI haiM ! aisA anyAya kyoM? jaba ki zrImadvIrasenAcArya ne use darzanamohanIya kA bheda na ginAkara cAritramohanIya kA hI bheda siddha kara rahe haiM? to yaha Agama kA apalApa huA mAnA jAyegA yA nahIM? Apa patrAcAra se hamArA samAdhAna kara dete to yogya hotA! paraMtu merI AzaMkA nahIM hone para bhI jo hamane pUchA hI nahIM, use hamAre nAma se jinabhASita . meM chApa diyA? * mAnyavara mahodaya, merI-ApakI tattvacarcA kA AdhAra eka mAtra Agama hI hai| agara koI paM.ToDaramala jI, paM.jayacaMda jI chAbar3A,paM.gopAladAsa jI baraiyA, paM.dIpacaMdajI zahA, kAsalIvAla, Adi vidvAnoM ko(jinhoMne tana-mana-dhana saba kucha arpaNa kara mUla kuMdakuMdamnAya ko, jinavANI ke hArda ko/marma ko jIvita rakhA hai!) mAnya nahIM karate haiM,to kyA koI unase bar3e vidvAna mAne jAyeM? maiMne to apane pUrva patroM meM binA AgamAdhAra ke kucha nahIM likhA phira bhI Apako merI bAteM vivecana/bhAvArtha nirAdhAra lagate haiM to kyA kiyA jA sakatA hai? vAstava meM to AtmA ke vizvAsa hone ko samyagdarzana, kSAyika samyagdRSTi ko vyavahAra samyagdRSTi mAnanAnizcaya samyagdRSTi nahIM mAnanA, gRhastha/avirata samyagdRSTi ko mokSamArgI nahIM mAnanAAtmAnubhUti rahita mAnanA Adi bAteM manavAte Aye haiN| Apane likhA hai ki Apako 12 vIM zatAbdi taka ke hI AcArya pramANa lagate haiN| to kyA Apa zrImad
Page #66
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ amRtacaMdrAcArya,zrImadjayasenAcArya kI AtmakhyAti/tAtparyavRtti TIkAoM ko mAnya to karate hue bhI amAnya karate haiM?yaha kahakara ki yaha samyagdarzana kI paribhASA muniyoM ke lie haiM aura gRhasthoM ke lie alaga hai? / kSamasva ! Apa mujhe kSamA kareM, ki mujhe isa patra meM Apako yaha likhanA par3a rahA hai| phira bhI maiM ApakI sahRdayatA evaM jinavANI ke prati prema-samarpaNa bhAva kI prazaMsA hI karatA hU~ ki Apase preraNA pAkara maiMne Agama-adhyAtma graMthoM kA aura bhI adhika gaharAI se , niSpakSa bhAva se svAdhyAya prAraMbha kara diyA hai| Apa bhI aisA hI kareMge aura kiMcita mujha para kRpAdRSTi banAye rakheMge aura mere pUrva meM diye gaye samAdhAnoM aura jijJAsAoM ke saMdarbha meM apanA sapramANa nirNaya | samAdhAna bhejane kI kRpA kareMge to AbhArI huuNgaa| bahuta kahane se kyA lAbha? . kiM bahuNA bhaNieNaM je siddhA NaravarA gae kaale| . sijjhihahi je vi bhaviyA taM jANaha samAmAhappaM / / 88 / / mokSapAhuDa . artha-bahuta kahane se kyA sAdhya hai? jo narapradhAna atIta kAla meM siddha hue haiM aura AgAmI kAla meM siddha hoMge, vaha samyaktva kA mAhAtmya jaano| bhavadIya - bra. hemacaMdra jaina 'hema' dharmyadhyAna-Agama ke Aloka meM darzanaM jJAnacAritrAt sAdhimAnamupAznute / darzanaM karNadhAraM tanmokSamArge prckssyte||31|| ratnakaraNDa zrAvakAcAra na samyaktva samaM kiJcit traikAlye trijgtypi| zreyo'zreyazca mithyAtvasamaM naanyttnuubhRtaam|| 34 / / ratnakaraNDa zrAvakAcAra gRhastho mokSamArgastho, nirmoho naiva mohvaan| anagAro gRhIzreyAna, nirmoho molino muneH|| 33 / / ratnakaraNDa zrAvakAcAra anyUnamanatiriktaM yAthAtathyaM binA ca vipriitaat| niHsandehaM veda ydaahustjjnyaanmaagminH|| 42 // ratnakaraNDa zrAvakAcAra . kSamAyAcanA isa pustaka kI chapAI meM agara kahIM azuddha gAthA yA zloka Adi likhe gaye hoM to vaha hamArI bhUla hai / kRpayA pAThaka gaNa mUla pratiyoM meM dekhakara sudhAra kara leveM aura hameM bhI avagata karA zodhana meM rahI ina bhUloM ke lie hama kSamAprArthI haiN| - saMpAdikA
Page #67
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ 67 nijadhruvazuddhAtmAnubhava pratyakSa prAmANyasahita-aviratasamyaktvI ke zuddhAtmAnubhUti kI sapramANa siddhi-cAroM anuyogoM ke AdhAra para-saMkalana pa.pU.adhyAtmayogI zrI 108 vIrasAgarajI mahArAja(kRpayA nimnalikhita saMkalana kA vistRta vivecana aura bhI anekoM saMdarbho sahita uparokta pustikA meM par3hie / chapI pustakeM samApta ho gayI haiM / 64 pejesa kI pustikA kI jherAksa pratI 20 ru. DAkakharca sahita bhejane para upalabdha ho sakatI hai|) isa pustaka meM par3hie(1) kyA zuddhopayoga 4 the guNasthAna meM hotA hai? - saMdarbha- samayasAra TIkA -jayasenAcArya- gAthA 201, 202 (2)kyA aviratI gRhastha ko zuddhAtmakAnubhava hotA hai? saMdarbha-samayasAra TIkA-zrI jayasenAcArya gAthA-320,pravacanasAra TIkAzrI jayasenAcArya gAthA-20-33, (3) tattvAnuzAsana - zloka 46, 47 - nAgasena muni - (4)dharmyadhyAna kA artha-saMdarbha-kArtikeyAnuprekSA- svAmI kArtikeya, gAthA471,472, 473, (5) bhAvasaMgraha-A.devasAnAcArya-gAthA-381,382,383, (6) bhAvasaMgraha-A.devasAnAcArya-gAthA-383 kA artha saMdarbha-pravacanasAra-zrI jayasenAcArya-gAthA 80 (7) yadi samyaktvAdi 4,5,6 ve guNasthAnoM kA nirNaya bAhya lakSaNoM se kahe to? saMdarbha-dhavala pustaka 1/152 ,paMcAstikAya gAthA-166, niyamasAra gAthA144, pravacanasAra gAthA-79 ta.pra.,samayasAra gAthA-152, ratnakaraNDa - zrAvakAcAra- zloka 33, 102 (8) pratyeka aMtarmuhUrta meM zubha aura azubha upayoga hotA hai| - saMdarbha-pravacanasAra gAthA- 9,248, bRhad dravyasaMgraha-gAthA 34, kArtikeyaanuprekSA-gAthA 470, mahApurANa zloka-38,44/21 (9) zuddhabhAvanA kA kyA artha hai? saMdarbha-pravacanasAra gA.-248,bRhad dravyasaMgraha gAthA-28 (10) zuddhAtmAnubhava-saMdarbha- pravacanasAra gAthA-254-tAtparyavRtti (11) vItarAga svasaMvedana- saMdarbha-samayasAra tAtparyavRtti gAthA-96 (12) dharmyadhyAna-saMdarbha-jJAnArNava-4/17 (13) anubhUti kI samAnatA- saMdarbha-jJAnArNava- 29/45, 104, mahApurANa 21/11, pravacanasAra gAthA-181, sa.satyA-gAthA 186, sarvArtha siddhi-gAthA-9/29
Page #68
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ 68 (14) gRhastha ko anubhUti hotI hai| saMdarbha-mahApurANa 21/21, 75, samayasAra gAthA-11,tattvArthasUtra-6/1,2,3 (15) samyaktva devagati kA kAraNa kyoM kahA? ___ saMdarbha-tattvArthasUtra 6/21 (16) avirata samyaktvI ko saMvara hotA hai ___ saMdarbha- bR.dra.saMgraha gAthA 35 TIkA, pravacanasAra gAthA 9 TIkA tA.vR. (17) avirata ko AtmAnubhava kaisA hotA hai? - saMdarbha-tattvAnuzAsana zloka 54, 58, 63, 64, 65 (18).4 the, 5 veM, 7 veM guNasthAna ke anubhava meM kyA aMtara hotA hai? saMdarbha-tattvAnuzAsana zloka 49, prameya kamala mArtaMDa 2/12/245 (19) zuddhopayoga kaisA hai? saMdarbha-pravacanasAra gAthA 14 (20) 4 the guNasthAna meM AtmAnubhava mAneMge to koI vratI nahIM hogA? saMdarbha-iSTopadeza zloka 37 (21) dharmyadhyAna, zukladhyAna - tIna prakAra ke samyagdarzana meM kyA aMtara hai? saMdarbha-dhavalA pustaka 13/74 (22) sakalAdezI-vikalAdezI saMdarbha-aSTasahastrI 3/211, 212, paramAnaMda stotra 10, pravacanasAra gAthA 191, niyamasAra gAthA 96-kalaza 34, 25, 26, 58 (23) zuddhatva kA pakSa - saMdarbha-samayasAra 142, jaina siddhAMta koza 2/565, nayacakra devasenAcArya, samayasAra kalaza 122, samayasAra gAthA.173 se 176, samayasAra177, 178, * tAtparyavRtti (24) jaghanya AtmabhAvanA gRhastha ko hotI hai ? __saMdarbha- mokSapAhuDa 2/305 (25) gRhastha ko dhyAna hotA hai ____saMdarbha-bhAvasaMgraha 371,397,605 (26) dharmyadhyAna-zukladhyAna bhAvapAhuDa se 81/232/24, dravyasaMgraha gAthA 34, pravacanasAra gAthA 181 (27) saMdRSTi koSTaka -saMdarbha-AptamImAMsA 108 (28) svAtmAnubhava - saMdarbha - kSu. dharmadAra.... -saMdarbha-nijadhruvazuddhAtmAnubhava (pratyakSa prAmANyasahita)se sAbhAra-saMpAdikA
Page #69
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ vidvAnoM ke abhiprAya zrI jayakumAra kSIrasAgara, vAlacaMdanagara isa vizeSAMka meM Apane do vidvAnoM keeka hI viSaya para huI patra-carcA samAja ke sAmane rakhI hai| viSaya AsAna lagA phira bhI usakI vyApti, mahattA gaMbhIra hai| ApakA saMpAdakIya aura bra. hemacaMdajI ne AsAna bhASA meM batAyA hai ki 'vastu, jJAna aura vANI (kathana) ye tInoM sattAsvarUpa hote hue asatya jJAna meM aura usake dvArA kathana meM matalaba vyakti ke abhiprAya meM hotA hai| ciMtana apane abhiprAya ke anusAra calatA hai| anyoM ke abhiprAya ko samajhane ko taiyAra hI nahIM hote ataH kitanI bhI carcA kIjie uttara anirNita hI rahate haiM / ekamata bananA muzkila ho jAtA hai| usameM ahaM bhI rukAvaTa DAlatA hai| ataH samAja meM do bheda ho jAte haiN| hara koI dharma ke lie prayAsa karatA hai| paraMtu jo maiM kahatA hU~ vahI satya hai, ke sthAna para jo satya hai vahI merA hai...ApakI yahI bhUmikA bahuta prazaMsanIya hai| zrImAna bainAr3A jI kA kArya maiMne bArAmatI meM dekhA hai| bahuta samarpita vyakti hai| bra. hemacaMdajI ne nikAle prazna aura unake javAba unake gahana adhyayana ke paricAyaka hai| zrI paM. nirmala jI jaina, satanA - isa vizeSAMka meM ApakA puruSArtha sarAhanIya hai| ise sadA sarvadAM banAye rakhane kA prayatna karatI raheM / bas ! prathamAcArya mahArAja ke prati ApakI bhakti aura ApakI bhAvanAoM kA Adara karatA huuN| zrI zAMtilAla jI bainAr3A, AgarA - samyak samyaktva carcA vizeSAMka par3hA Apane isa vizeSAMka meM mere anuja bhrAtA zrI ratanA lAla jI ke prazna evaM uttaroM kA zAstrokta samAdhAna bahuta hI suMdara vyavasthita DhaMga se kiyA hai| zrI paM.bAbulAla jI jaina, azoka nagara - dharmamaMgala kA yaha vizeSAMka par3hakara prasannatA huii| hamAre svAdhyA maMDala ke loga bahuta rucipUrvaka ise par3ha rahe haiN| mahilA maMDala bhI par3a rahI haiN| maMdirajI meM rakha diyA hai| Apane bar3I kRpA kI jo yaha aMka nikaalaa|
Page #70
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ 70 zrI DaoN. vIrasAgarajI jaina,dillI - - dharmamaMgala kA yaha vizeSAMka par3hakara bahuta acchA lgaa| Aja patrikAoM ko Apake isa sArthaka aura racanAtmaka saMvAda ko bone ke prayAsa kA anukaraNa karanA caahie| zrI paM. suzIla kumAra jaina, indaura - dharmamaMgala ke isa vizeSAMka meM Apane jo patra -vyavahAra Apane Agama-adhyAtma ke Aloka ke udA. sahita jo prastuti pradAna kI hai, vaha atyaMta sarAhanIya hai| vastutaH samyak darzana svAnubhUtipUrvaka hI hotA hai| isakA khulAsA sabhI AcAryoM ne prAcIna zAstroM meM kiyA hai| usIkA anusaraNa paM. rAjamalajI pAMDe ne kalaza TIkA meM, lATI saMhitA meM, paMcAdhyAyI meM kiyA hai| isI paraMparA ko paM.banArasI dAsa ne nATaka samayasAra meM inake pazcAt paM. jayacaMdajI chAbar3A, paM. ToDaramalajI, paM. dIpacaMdajI zAha, paM. sadAsukhajI, paM. bhAgacaMdajI, paM. daulataramajI, paM. dyAnatarAyajI Adi sabhI ne yaha svIkAra kiyA hai ki caturtha guNasthAna meM svAnubhUti hotI hai| vartamAna yuga meM zrI kAnajI svAmI ne bhI yaha svIkAra kiyA thaa| tathA pU. munirAja jI zrI vIrasAgarajI ne bhI isI kA poSaNa kiyaa| yaha saba atyaMta spaSTa hone para bhI yadi koI nahIM mAnatA hai to Azcarya lagatA hai| phira bhI Apane mehanata to kI hai| jo itanA spaSTa vivecana kiyaa| bahuta-bahuta dhnyvaad| . zrI paM.rAjamala jI pavaiyA, bhopAla - dharmamaMgala kA vizeSAMka milA, adhyAtma carcA ke yogya yaha vizeSAMka bahutaMhI uttama hai| Apake sasa prakAzana ke lie hArdika badhAI svIkAra kreN| zrI paM. anupa caMdra jI jaina, eDavokeTa, phIrojAbAda - dharmamaMgala kA samyak samyaktva carcA ' yaha vizeSAMka milaa| Apa siddha hasta lekhikA evaM saMpAdikA hai, Apake isa prakAzana ke lie badhAI svIkAra kreN| zrI tulArAjI jaina, ambAha - dharmamaMgala kI yaha bahuta hI acchI patrikA hai| yahA~ Apake isa aMka kI khUba carcA huI hai aura prazaMsA bhI karate haiN| isa vizeSAMka meM ApakA sajaga, spaSTavAdI ra sahI lekhana sabako acchA lagatA hai|
Page #71
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ zrI DaoN. anila kumAra jI jaina, ahamadAbAda - ___ dharmamaMgala kA 'samyak samyaktva carcA' vizeSAMka milA / ina gUr3ha saiddhAtika carcAoM ko par3hakara prasannatA huii| prakAzana ke lie Apako sAdhuvAda / yadi Apasa meM mila baiThakara kisI aMtima nirNaya para vicAra kara kisI aMtima nirNaya para sabakI sahamati hogI to mujhe bar3I prasannatA hogii| bhAI zrI hemacaMda jI vijJAna ke vidyArthI rahe haiM aura vidvAna bhI haiN| bahuta-bahuta dhanyavAda, badhAI svIkAra kreN| zrI mANikacaMda jI pATanI, indaura - dharmamaMgala ke 'samyak samyaktva carcA' vizeSAMka do bAra pddh'aa| samyak darzana to Atma pratIti svarUpa hI hai| ataH zrI bainAr3A jI se adhika samAdhAna kI apekSA hai| jaba bhI isa viSaya meM jAnakArI prakAti ho to avazya bhejie| ina dinoM nizcita hI jo lekha, saMpAdakIya Apa kI patrikA meM par3hane ko mila rahe haiM, isase ApakI patrikA meM nikhAra AyA hai| isake lie Apako badhAI , tathA ApakI yaha patrikA dinoMdina pAThakoM ke lie AkarSaNa kA keMdra bane, inhIM zubha kAmanAoM ke saath| zrI manohara esa. gaurANNA, belagA~va - - dharmamaMgala ke 'samyak samyaktva carcA' isa vizeSAMka ko par3hakara pramudita huuN| aisI carcA Ajakala durmila ho gayI hai| Apake hAthoM aisI hI jinavANI kI nirmala sevA hotI rahe yahI zubhakAmanA hai| zrI ailaka cetana sAgara jI - manohara thAnA, jhAlAvAr3a - dharmamaMgala ke 'samyak samyaktva carcA' vizeSAMka prApta huaa| usakA adhyayana kiyaa| paM. ratanalAla jI bainAr3A vidvAna haiM, paraMtu adhyAtma graMtha ke rahasya ko kholanA caahie| Aja ke adhikAMza sAdhuoM meM bhI yahI bAta dekhane ko milatI hai / iMjiniyariMga meM thyorI aura praikTikala hote haiM, usI prakAra jaina dharma meM bhI thyorI aura praikTikala hote haiN| arthAt pahale cAroM anuyogoM dvArA unakI gaharAI samajhI jAtI hai, jaina darzana sUtroM kA , siddhAntoM kA jJAna va zraddhAna kiyA jAtA hai, tatpazcAt dIkSA lekara siddhAntoM para amala karate hue samatApUrvaka evaM zAMtipUrvaka AtmasAdhanA kI jAtI hai| zrI DaoN. pI.bI.panavelakara, vardhA - dharmamaMgala ke 'samyak ||myktvN carcA' isa pustikA ke rUpa meM eka aisI 5 . hai, jisase hama jaise alpajJAnI ke bhI jJAna kA aMzataH ughAr3a hotA hai| Apane niSpakSa bhAva se jo svastha vItarAga carcA prastuta kI hai, ApakA abhinaMdana ! donoM vidvAnoM ne Agama ke
Page #72
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ 72 aneka saMdarbha prastuta kiye haiN| paM. bainAr3A jI ne jisa vizvAsa kI bAta kI hai, maiM socatA hU~ ki vizvAsa to taba hotA hai jaba anubhava hotA hai| sAta karma prakRtiyoM ke abhAva se tathA dravya karma, nokarma, bhAvakarma virahita zuddhAtmA meM hI svabhAva ke Azraya se yaha pratIti hotI hai| A.samaMtabhadra ke anusAra sAmAyika karate samaya bhI zrAvaka ko vastroM kA upasarga hue muni jaisA hotA hai| kAraNa usa samaya bAyAbhyaMtara parigrahatyAga hotA hai| ataeva avirata samyagdRSTi kI pratIti hI AtmAnubhUti hai| 'nijazuddhAtmAnubhava' pustaka pU. vIrasAgarajI kI amola dena hai|aapne yaha pustaka bhejakara hama alpamatiyoM kA bar3A hI upakAra kiyA hai| zrImatI vimalA jaina, kaTanI - dharmamaMgala kA 'samyak samyaktva carcA' vizeSAMka prApta huaa| ApakI lekhanI pAThakoM ko prabhAvita karatI hai| sAtha hI zAstra sammata bAteM/prakaraNa suzrAvaka ko dRr3ha nizcayI bhI banAtI hai| Apake vicAra preraNAspada tathA jaina AsthA ko balavatI banAne meM ekadama sakSama haiN| yaha kRti nizcaya hI sAdhanA patha para agrasara hone meM sahayogI hogI aisA vizvAsa hai| zulka Adi bhejane hetu nivedana dharmamaMgala kA vArSika zulka ru.100/-, AjIvana DipaoNjhiTa ru.1100/-, saMrakSaka DipaoNjhiTa ru. 5001/- ma.oN.,DI.DI. yA koara akauMTa dvArA bheja sakate hai| dezabhara meM kahIM se bhI paMjAba naizanala baiMka dvArA hamAre koara akauMTa naMbara 450800 210000 2842 hai| kRpayA zulka rakama+20ru. baiMka kamizana sahita bhejie| yaha rakama Apa saMpAdikA,dharmamaMgala, lIlAvatI jaina ka nAma se bheja sakate haiM / rakama bhejane ke bAda hameM ApakA nAma-patA,(posTa pIna koDa sahita) rakama, bhejane kI tA., ApakA phona naM.evaM kisa hetu se rakama bhejI hai isakA khulAsA bhejanA atyAvazyaka hai| -lokala ceka ke alAvA bAhara gA~va ke ceka svIkAra nahIM kiye jAte / AjIvana evaM saMrakSaka DipaoNjhiTa ke vyAja para aMka milatA hai| aMka baMda.paTane para DipaoNjhiTa vApisa kiyA jAne kI gairaMTI hai| ___- saMpAdikA
Page #73
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ 73 * paramAnanda stotra * ___ akalaMkadeva svAmI paramAnanda saMyuktaM, nirvikAraM nirAmayam / dhyAnahInA na pazyanti, nijadehe vyavasthitam / / 1 / / anantasukha-sampanna, jJAnAmRta payodharam / anantavIrya sampannaM, darzanaM paramAtmanaH / / 2 / / nirvikAraM nirAbAdhaM, sarvasaMga vivarjitam / paramAnanda sampannaM, zuddha caitanyalakSaNam / / 3 / / uttamA svaatmcintaasyaanmohcintaacmdhymaa| adhamA kAmacintAsyAtparacintA'dhamAdhamA / / 4 / / nirvikalpasamutpannaM, jJAnamevasudhArasam / vivekamaJjali kRtvA, tatpibanti tapasvinaH / / 5 / / sadAnandamayaM jIvaM, yo jAnAti sa pnndditH| sa sevate nijAtmAnaM, paramAnanda kAraNam / / 6 / / nalinyAM ca yathA nIraM, bhinnaM tiSThati srvdaa| ayamAtmA svabhAvena, dehe tiSThati nirmalaH / / 7 / / dravyakarma malairmuktaM bhAvakarma vivarjitam / nokarma rahitaM biddhi, nizcayena cidAtmanaH / / 8 / / AnandaM brahmaNo rUpaM, nijadehe vyavathitam / dhyAnahInA na pazyanti, jAtyandhA iva bhAskaram / / 9 / / taddhyAnaM kriyate bhavyairmanoyena viliiyte| tatkSaNaM dRzyate zuddhaM, ciccamatkAra lakSaNam / / 10 / / ye dhyAnazIlA munayaH pradhAnAsne duHkhahInA niyamAd bhavanti / samprApya zIghraM paramAtmatattvaM, brajanti mokSaM kSaNamekameva / / 11 / / AnandarUpaM paramAtmatattvaM, samasta saMkalpavikalpamuktam / svabhAvalInA nivasanti nityaM, jAnAti yogI svayameva tattvam / / 12 / /
Page #74
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ 74 cidAnandamaya zuddhaM nirAkAraM nirAmayam / ... anantasukhasampannaM sarvasaGga vivarjitam / / 13 / / lokamAtra pramANo'yaM, nizcayena na sNshyH| vyavahAre tanUmAtraH kathitaH paramaizvaraiH / / 14 / / yatkSaNaM dRzyate zuddhaM, tatkSaNaM gata-vibhramaH / svastha cittaH sthiribhUtvA, nirvikalpa samAdhinA / / 15 / / sa eva paramaM brahma, sa eva jina puGgavaH / sa eva paramaM tattvaM, sa eva paramo gurUH / / 16 / / sa eva paramaM jyotiH sa eva paramaM tapaH / sa eva parama dhyAna, sa eva paramAtmanaH / / 17 / / sa eva sarva kalyANaM, sa eva sukha bhAjanam / sa eva zuddha cidrUpaM, sa eva paramaH zivaH / / 18 / / sa eva paramAnandaH, jyotiH sukhdaaykH| sa eva para caitanyaM, sa eva gunnsaagrH||19|| paramAhlAda-sampannaM, rAgadveSa vivrjitm|| arhantaM dehamadhyetu, yo jAnAti sa pnndditH||20|| AkAra rahitaM zuddhaM, sva-svarUpa vyavasthitam / siddhamaSTaguNopetaM, nirvikAraM niraMjanam / / 21 / / tatsadRzaM nijAtmAnaM, prakAzAya mhiiyse| sahajAnanda caitanyaM, yo jAnAti sa pnndditH||22|| pASANeSu yathA hema, dugdhamadhye yathA ghRtam / tilamadhye yathA tailaM, dehamadhye tathA zivaH / / 23 / / kASThamadhye yathA vahniH, zaktirUpeNa tisstthti| ayamAtmA zarIreSu yo jAnAti sa paNDitaH / / 24 / /
Page #75
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ Agama bhASA mAdhyAtmabhASA phala | dravya | paryAya | zuddhAtmAnubhUti ke lie Azraya karane | samIcIna | samyaktvI yogya 'svadravya' sakalAdezI dravya | paryAya zuddhAtmAnubhUti ke lie Azraya karane | asamIcIna mithyAtvI vA anyadravya athava kha vyavahArAbhAsa ga | dravya dravya / 0 zuddhAtmAnubhUti ke lie Azraya karana nizcayAbhAsI| mithyAtva yogya 'dravya' 0 | paryAya zuddhAtmAnubhUti ke lie Azraya karane vyavahArAbhAsI mithyAtvI yogya paryAya' dravya | | paryAya zuddhAtmAnubhUti ke lie Azraya karane| asamIcIna | mithyAtvI yogya nirapekSa 'dravya paryAya' / ubhayAbhAsI ba zuddhAtmAnubhUti ke lie Azraya karane| asamIcIna | mithyAtvI yogya 'dravya' (aMdhazraddhA 0 / 0 / zuddhAtmAnubhUti ke lie Azraya karane | asamIcIna mithyAtvI yogya paryAya' jhA dravya paryAya | zuddhAtmAnubhUti ke lie Azraya asamIcIna | mithyAtva yogya. 'svadravya' vikalAdezI paryAya dravya Ta nirapekSa nirapekSa zuddhAtmAnubhUti ke lie Azraya karane | asamIcIna | mithyAtvI dravya | paryAya ___ yogya 'svadravya' paryAya dravya zuddhAtmAnubhUti ke lie Azraya karane Tha nirapekSa nirapekSa yogya 'paryAya' athavA anyadravya | asamIcIna dravya / paryAya paryAya' dravya nirapekSA nirapekSa zuddhAtmAnubhUti ke lie Azraya karane | asamIcIna mithyAtvI dravya | paryAya yogya nirapekSa svadravya aura paryAya
Page #76
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ nijadhruvacidAnaMdAtmA ko jAnane kI paddhati (cArTa kra. 14) yaha maiM zuddhacidAnaMdAtmA huuN| yahA~ 'yaha' idantA' kI pratIti hai, isalie yaha 'pratyakSajJAna' hai| zuddhAtmAnubhava hai, nirvikalpa jJAna hai| ___ 'vaha' meM dhruva cidAnaMdAtmA thaa| yahA~ 'vaha' (tattA) kI pratIti hai, isalie yaha 'smaraNajJAna' hai, parokSajJAna hai, yaha zuddhAtmAnubhava nhiiN| jo maiM pUrva meM dhruvacidAnaMdAtmA thA, yahA~ yaha+vaha' ke saMkalana (idantA aura tattA ke saMkalana)kI pratIti hai isalie yaha 'pratyabhijJAna' hai| vaha yaha dhruvacidAnaMdAtmA hU~ parokSajJAna hai, zuddhAtmAnubhava nhiiN| jo jo jIva hai vaha vaha yahA~ 'jo jo + vaha vaha' rUpa vyApti kI pratIti hai, isalie yaha tarkajJAna' hai, yaha parokSajJAna hai| dhruvacidAnaMdAtmA hai| zuddhAtmAnubhava nhiiN| maiM dhruvacidAnaMdAtmA hU~,kyoM ki yaha paryAya hai| yahA~ 'sAdhana ke dvArA sAdhya kI pratIti hai', isalie 'anumAnajJAna' hai, yaha parokSajJAna hai, sAdhya ____ sAdhana zuddhAtmAnubhava nhiiN| maiM dhruvacidAnaMdAtmA huuN| yahA~ 'aMtarajalpa'rUpa pratIti hai, isalie yaha 'nayajJAna ' hai, parokSajJAna hai, zuddhAtmAnubhava nhiiN| paryAya ko jAnane kI paddhati / 'yaha' maiM duHkhI huuN| yahA~ 'yaha' idantA' kI pratIti hai, isalie yaha pratyakSajJAna' hai| 'vaha' maiM duHkhI thaa| yahA~ 'vaha' (tattA) kI pratIti hai, isalie yaha 'smaraNajJAna' hai, parokSajJAna hai| jo maiM pUrva meM duHkhI thA, yahA~ vaha+yaha' ke saMkalana (idantA aura tattA ke saMkalana kI) pratIti hai isalie yaha 'pratyabhijJAna' hai, vaha yaha duHkhI huuN| parokSajJAna hai| jo jo jIva zalyasahita hotA hai yahA~ 'jo jo + vaha vaha' rUpa vyApti kI pratIti hai, isalie yaha tarkajJAna' hai, yaha parokSajJAna hai| vaha vaha duHkhI hotA hai| maiM duHkhI hU~,kyoM ki mere hRdaya meM zalya hai| yahA~ 'sAdhana ke dvArA sAdhya kI pratIti hai', isalie 'anumAnajJAna' hai, yaha parokSajJAna hai| sAdhya . sAdhana maiM duHkhI huuN| yahA~ 'aMtarajalpa'rUpaM pratIti hai , isalie yaha 'nayajJAna' hai, parokSajJAna hai|